A world champion is supposed to be the cornerstone of a wrestling promotion - the face of the company, the most acclaimed talent it has, or at least one of them. As good as a champion may be in his physique, skill or charisma, they're still entirely dependent on the booker and the creative department to make them look good, through use of booking, promotion and creative decisions. In the wacky world of professional wrestling rules are made to broken, very rarely are champions given the treatment, push or persona they need to succeed, often they're condemned to mediocrity from the beginning in the modern era. For every title reign that feels prestigious, dominant and entertaining, there are several more that have horribly failed to get over for one reason or another. It could be that the creative department or management just didn't have enough faith in the wrestler, it could be a lack of ideas from the get go, or the choosing of bad ideas that never should have made it past the drawing board. You name it, WWE has done it at some point. In chronicle of these wrestlers who were never given a chance to live out their reign like they deserved, here's ten moments when WWE and WCW screwed over their world champions.
10. The Miz's Weak Opponents
A champion is reflected by the kind of opponents he faces in his title defenses - in the Miz's case he was given a variety of weak, fragile opponents which made it abundantly clear that he shouldn't be champion. After defeating Randy Orton, The Miz was thrown into an ongoing feud with Jerry Lawler, a 60-year-old man who is mostly a commentator at this point. It seemed interesting at the time, but in retrospect it was a moronic idea, particularly when The Miz relied on assistance from Alex Riley just to win the match. Alex Riley was also a major crutch to The Miz, as almost every big WWE Championship match finish had The Miz relying on interference to win, be it Riley, CM Punk or The Rock, at different points. People always cite The Miz's title reign as a huge flop, but it's worth questioning if he ever really had a chance given the awful, weak nature he was built up in, from the very beginning.
9. Sheamus Booked As A Massive Coward
When Sheamus won the WWE Championship for the second time, his run was anything but impressive. However, it's fair to say that he was basically screwed from the very beginning, barely given a chance to prove himself as an able, powerful or legitimate champion. The way he won the championship, his immediate reaction to threats afterwards, and his response to challenges all implied he was a weak coward, who would not hold the belt for long. WWE Champions should be booked strong upon winning the belt, seen as dominant, but they made Sheamus a coward from the very start. After winning the title at Fatal Four Way from interference from The Nexus, Sheamus instead of standing up to the aggressive band of rookies, ran away. This would be an ongoing trend in his reign, as when faced with pretty much any opponent, he'd run away, except Zack Ryder of course. It's natural progression for a top-tier heel to act weak, reliant and cowardly towards the end of their reign, but when it's literally after winning the title, it's a huge display of weakness and fans won't connect to a weakly booked champion.
8. Rey Mysterio Working Double Duty
During the 2011 angle often referred to as 'The Summer of Punk' in reference to CM Punk's past at Ring of Honor, Rey Mysterio became the WWE Champion in the conclusion of an eight man tournament in the absence of both CM Punk and John Cena. After defeating The Miz to earn his first WWE Championship, Rey Mysterio would be confronted by John Cena, who was absent from Raw for all of one week, before challenging Mysterio on that very same show. An already exhausted, weakened Mysterio would accept and lose, being robbed of his gold just as soon as he had claimed it. Rey Mysterio didn't necessarily deserve the title, but giving it to him and taking it away in one night gives the overt feeling that he was screwed in the storyline, one he arguably shouldn't have been a part of in the first place. Did Cena need to challenge Mysterio that night, Mysterio had already wrestled and the match only went to characterize Cena as praying on the weak. They could have delayed this match until the next pay-per-view, then had CM Punk come out after the match, with the stare down that happened on Raw, feeling more like a big, defining moment on pay-per-view.
7. Goldberg
Goldberg was dominant for most of his reign in WCW, but creative seemed to only know what to do when building him up, once he'd reached the top, the ideas ran out rather quickly. Upon defeating Hulk Hogan on a fateful episode of Nitro in 1998, Goldberg became WCW World Heavyweight Champion. Question is, what do you with a dominant, unflinching monster when there's no competition left - any reasonable candidates left for him to feud with, had already been squashed on his way to the main event. One could argue that he gained the gold far too quickly, that Goldberg should have failed, before succeeding. Upon realizing that their monster babyface was better off chasing the title than wearing it, WCW desperately tried to come up with reasonable solutions for how he could lose the title, but still appear strong. What they came up with was Goldberg losing to Kevin Nash, after Scott Hall stunned him with a taser gun, when Nash didn't need the title at all. This match made a huge joke of Goldberg's win streak, when it would have made much more sense to just have Goldberg cheated out of his title by interference, or a bias referee. After Goldberg lost his title, fans quickly stopped caring about his streak, and WCW's last hottest star they had began to significantly cool off. It's fair to say that Goldberg was screwed booking-wise, as his entire rise to success had been wasted, with virtually no pay off for anyone.
6. RVD Losing Both World Championships
WWE's stance on drugs is taken very seriously these days, which is understandable given all the bad publicity wrestling as an industry has suffered due to the infamous nature of wrestling's involvement with steroids and other illegal substances. In Rob Van Dam's first stint with the WWE, he made one crucial mistake that ruined his entire success in the company, one he'd arguably worked years for. In May, 2006, RVD would cash in his Money in the Bank contract to face John Cena at One Night Stand, thus defeating him with assistance from Edge, gaining the WWE Championship. Paul Heyman then awarded Mr.Monday Night the revived ECW World Heavyweight Championship, as the franchise had just been reborn. However, A little over a month later, Van Dam would be arrested for being in possession of drugs. As punishment, RVD would lose to the WWE title to Edge on Raw, and the ECW Title to Big Show the very next nigh.There's no doubt he deserved the punishment, a company as big as World Wrestling Entertainment is can't be seen as taking a loose stance on narcotics. However, there's no doubt RVD was screwed as a champion just from sheer fulfillment of the criteria, he'd lost two world titles in no time at all, and went from the king of the mount to the very back of the pack.
5. Bob Backlund's Three Day Title Reign
The boundaries between the roles of 'heel' and 'face' in wrestling have gradually faded, wrestlers act less like clearly defined heroes and villains -f aces can act like heels, heels can act like faces, as long as the crowd support and reaction is appropriate, it doesn't really matter what a wrestler's alignment is most of the time. However, back in the mid 90's, wrestling promotions still cleanly followed the rules of heel vs face pretty religiously, especially when important titles were involved. In 1994, Vince McMahon wanted to put the WWF Championship on Diesel, but couldn't as Bret Hart currently had it, both competitors were face. Because of this, Backlund would instead go on to face Bret Hart at Survivor Series 94, eventually winning the 'throw in the towel' submission match, after performing the crossface chickenwing for a daunting eight minutes. Backlund then lost the WWF Title a mere 3 days later at a house show in Madison Square Garden to Diesel, in an eight second match. Clearly, Backlund was being used as a transition champion to carry the belt from one face to another, but this doesn't mean he wasn't screwed in his treatment. Would it have been so hard to delay the title loss to the next pay-per-view, if not a week or two later on Raw. Plus, there's not much justification to making Backlund look incredibly weak by squashing him, as that's the guy who just became champion and beat the incredible Bret Hart. There should be at least some believable aspect to it, but there wasn't, it made abundantly clear that Backlund's simply being used as a delivery boy. Either way, champions should seem stronger than how Backlund's second reign did.
4. Sid Vicious And WCW's Title Reboot
When WCW was in the midst of its downfall, several bad decisions were made which ultimately made the situation far worse, when a comeback wouldn't have been such an impossible prospect. By the middle of 2000, most of WCW's premiere talent had left the sinking ship for the considerably greener pastures of the WWF, mainstays like Jericho, Raven and The Giant (Big Show) had left in years prior, while in 2000 the WWF gained The Radicalz (Perry Saturn, Dean Malenko, Chris Benoit and Eddie Guerrero). At the same time, many wrestlers who WCW had previously relied on were absent from the world title picture - Hogan had been fired in January, Bret Hart was inactive due to injuries, Savage had left the company in May, Ric Flair was generally ignored over younger talent. Upon winning his first WCW World Heavyweight Championship, Chris Benoit left the company the very next day due to disputes. In response, WCW gave the belt to his former opponent in the tournament finals, Sid Vicious. WCW didn't have many other options, and Sid certainly wasn't a bad candidate championship candidate out of what remaining talent they had left. If Sid already looked weak, inheriting the title from the guy he lost to before, then Kevin Nash taking the title away for a stupid tag-team match stipulation didn't help. After that, Vicious reheld the belt, and looked to be on for a strong run (about 10 days was the average at this point) having held the title for 74 days. But of course, Russo and Bischoff couldn't have their WCW World Champion looking strong, competent or dominant, as they soon completely rebooted all title continuity. Vicious was then written off TV for several month, for some reason. In a year full of title vacancies, disqualifications and ridiculous booking, Vicious was just trying to do his job and bring back some notoriety to the company, as he has claimed himself in numerous interviews. Clearly, Vicious was passed up as a champion, so more qualified candidates such as Jeff Jarrett, Vince Russo and David Arquette could later win the belt. If that wasn't bad enough, WCW creative would later ruin his career, by forcing him to perform an aerial maneuver. What a waste.
3. Daniel Bryan's Match At Wrestlemania XXVIII
At Wrestlemania XXVIII, how did WWE treat their rising star Daniel Bryan? By making him lose his World Heavyweight Championship in a squash match against Sheamus, which was 18 seconds long. There was literally no reason behind this, other than WWE wanted to set a new record at Daniel Bryan's expense. Even the choice of opponent was a bad one, why bother giving Sheamus the World Heavyweight Championship, when both of his WWE Championship reigns were highly forgettable and went absolutely nowhere. The match was universally panned as a waste of our time, with critics commenting on both the match and the awful decision to make such a thing happen at such a high profile event. Many regarded it as a huge flaw in an otherwise fantastic Wrestlemania. Surprisingly, Bryan wasn't buried in the aftermath, although he certainly could have been. He was soon pushed towards the WWE title scene in an acclaimed feud with CM Punk. Regardless, that's no justification for making him look so weak, for virtually no reason, with no payoff or gain from that occurrence. There have been many huge mistakes made in the WWE career of Daniel Bryan, but none surpass this mammoth miscalculation which happened on the biggest stage of them all.
2. Ric Flair's Firing In 1991
Jim Herd is a highly criticized figure in wrestling, his tenure as Executive Vice President of WCW was particularly hated, as he attempted to dilute the serious wrestling product of the then NWA affiliated World Champion Wrestling into a cheap and blatant copy of the WWF. One gigantic blunder in particular was his decision to try and re-brand Ric Flair, which led to him talking down to the then-WCW World Heavyweight Champion. Herd had removed Flair as head booker and also wanted him to take a substantial pay cut. He even asserted that they needed to repackage Flair in order to stay relevant, asking him to drop the Nature Boy gimmick, shave his head, wear a diamond earring and bill himself as Spartacus. Herd was also quoted as wanting to reduce Flair's role in WCW drastically. Having had enough of Herd's ridiculous demands and lack of wrestling knowledge, Ric Flair refused. Jim Herd promptly fired him, leaving WCW without one of their best talents and their current world champion. While Ric Flair was slowly screwed out of his position in WCW as the number #1 player, he certainly landed on his feet in the WWF. Jim Herd was fired for his incompetence in 1992.
1. Bret Hart And The Montreal Screwjob
You probably knew this was coming - the only instance in which WWE literally screwed their champion without their prior knowledge of events at all. For those who don't those this infamous story of wrestling politics, Bret Hart was planning to defect to WCW after negotiating a much larger contract at an apparent 2.5 million dollars a year. Vince McMahon gave his consent, but obviously, Bret, still being WWF champion would have to drop the belt at some point before departing. Do to his ongoing beef with Shawn Michaels, Bret reportedly would not drop the title to him, The agreed upon course of events, was that the match at Survivor Series would end in disqualification, when Owen Hart, British Bulldog, Chyna and Triple H all interfere and start brawling. Bret then believed he'd drop the belt another day before his departure. Rumors had escalated leading many to know of The Hitman's departure, only heightening fan interest in the match. For what ever reason, McMahon made other plans as Michaels locked Hart in his own submission maneuver, as McMahon came to ringside and Hebner rang the bell. The event severely blended the lines of reality and fiction, instantly creating the villainous 'Mr. McMahon' character overnight that would revolutionize the WWF. Bret would go on to WCW, and didn't reconcile with the WWF until almost ten years later.