10 Underwhelming Wrestlers Who Held Legendary Titles.

You can't polish a turd.

By M. Oliver /

One striking benefit that professional wrestling has over legitimate sports, is being able to decide its own champions.

Advertisement

In wrestling, unlike boxing or MMA, there should be no reason why a uninteresting competitor climbs the ladder to become champion and subsequently diminishes interest at the arenas and the box office.

A championship reign in wrestling is bestowed upon the wrestlers a booker believes will generate interest and ultimately revenue.

But as wrestling's past indicates, the man with the pencil isn't always infallible.

Over the years, countless hapless competitors have found themselves the holders of championships far greater than their own talents, from wrestlers who were intended for greatness but quickly faded into oblivion, to forgettable names who held titles before better performers arrived and put the championship on the map.

Here are ten of such instances of underwhelming performers holding legendary titles.

10. Butch Reed

In June of 1981 Peter Sutcliffe had just been revealed as the Yorkshire Ripper, AIDs was debuting in California and Bruce Reed was the NWA International Heavyweight Champion.

Advertisement

Bruce, the alter ego and government name of Butch Reed, captured the title from Dory Funk Jr. on a Florida show, and, for at least the space of 24 hours, held the biggest singles title in Japan.

There was no record of the date Reed won or lost the tile to and from Funk. Accordingly, no one knows exactly how long Reed held the championship, created for Lou Thesz - with a who's who of legendary holders including Rikidozan, Giant Baba and Gene Kiniski before him - but champion he was.

While Funk would take the title back with him to Japan, where he, Bruiser Brody, Stan Hansen and Jumbo Tsuruta would all exchange reigns over the course of the decade, Reed would never hold a more famed singles title for the rest of his 30-year career.

The NWA International Heavyweight Title was unified with the PWF Heavyweight Championship and the NWA United National Championship in 1989 to become the Triple Crown in All Japan Pro Wrestling.

Bruce Reed's title reign is still disregarded in Japan.

9. Johnny Hotbody

The ECW Heavyweight Championship had an illustrious history before ending up as a hubcap in WWE.

Advertisement

From the bloody triangle battle between Terry Funk, Shane Douglas and Sabu to the paralysis inducing wars between Masato Tanaka and Mike Awesome, the ECW Championship was a well earned trophy, reserved for the fearless.

However, back when the 'E' in extreme stood for Eastern, ECW champions were of a more ordinary ilk.

Building the promotion around former WWF stars such as Tito Santana, Don Muraco and Jimmy Snuka - who became the inaugural ECW Champion in 1992 - ECW was a North Eastern promotion in search of an identity - which it eventually founder under Paul Heyman.

An aberration in the company's early history, Johnny Hotbody was the second ever ECW champion, beating the legendary Snuka in April of 1992.

An unspectacular regular of North East indies since the late '80s, Hotbody's reign last less than eight weeks before Snuka regained the title.

The championship went on to new heights following Shane Douglas' reign in 1994, Hotbody however, went on to become the first and fastest Triple Crown champion in ECW's history, becoming the inaugural Television champion in August and a tag team champion with Chris Candido in April 1993.

8. Orlando Jordan

It's fair to say the former WCW United States Championship had lost most of its luster by the time WWE turned the title into its current postage stamp design in 2003, but it still had a history.

Advertisement

From the epic battles between Flair and Steamboat in the '70s, to Magnum TA's wars with Tully Blanchard, the US should be a championship worth reckoning for.

Orlando Jordan looked the part and was a functional professional wrestler - but that's about it.

Jordan debuted '03 and quickly turned heel to become JBL's Chief of Staff, his boss helping him steal the US Title from John Cena a year later.

While the switch was intended to free up Cena for a main event push, it was concurrently designed to give Jordan the rub. It failed.

An uninspiring performer with a standardised routine, Jordan was unable to draw any interest and WWE's jump-the-gun strategy of using a title win to push a prospect failed at the first hurdle.

Retaining his title by hook or by crook, Jordan's antics fueled the indifference to his matches and he finally dropped the title to Chris Benoit in 25 seconds at SummerSlam 2005.

Jordan was released from WWE in 2006, sending tumbleweeds through the wrestling world.

7. Scott Norton

Scott Norton is most fondly remembered as being the fridge freezer of a fella who did sweet f**k all as part of the nWo, after the stable expanded to include jabronis in 1997.

Advertisement

However, on the other side of the pacific, Norton was a veritable Godzilla.

After an entirely forgettable decade long career, that had seen him largely used as a tag-team wrestler toing and froing between New Japan and WCW throughout the '90s, Norton became NJPW's gaijin ace while part of nWo Japan.

After the IWGP Heavyweight Championship was vacated, following a neck injury to Masahiro Chono, Norton took on Yuji Nagata for the vacant title and defeated him to become champion in September 1998.

While the IWGP title of 1998 was a definite rung below All Japan's Triple Crown - and Norton a significant cut below Kenta Kobashi - it was still the second most prestigious title in Japan.

Although he wore the title on WCW TV, Norton received no push whatsoever following his win and dropped the title to Keiji Mutoh on the 4 January show of 1999, after a four month reign.

Departing WCW in 1999, Norton returned to Japan where he had a second, 23 day long reign with the IWGP title in 2001.

6. Gary Steele

Beginning the decade in the possession of Ric Flair, the NWA title was set on an irrevocable course to become a relic of a bygone era when WCW left the NWA in 1993.

Advertisement

By the time Shane Douglas rejected the title upon winning it in 1994, it was a dead brand.

Spending the next few years around the waist of UFC fighter Dan Severn, by the time he dropped it former Olympic judoka Naoya Ogawa in 1999, the attempts to recreate the travelling champion were finally abolished.

When Nagoya lost his title to unknown Englishman Gary Steele at the organisations 51st Anniversary show in Charlotte in September 1999 however, the title had reached an all time low.

A native of sunny Gravesend, Steele was only three years into his wrestling career when he became the first no-name champion in NWA history.

A blip on a legacy careering into oblivion, Steele dropped the strap back to Ogawa a week later in front of half-a-dozen fans in a school gym in Connecticut.

While Steele's career never saw him appear in a major company, disappearing from wrestling in 2001, his Wikipedia notes that he competed on Deal or No Deal in 2011 - so, swings and roundabouts.

5. Xavier

No one knew quite what to expect of Ring of Honor when it debuted in 2002.

Advertisement

As the offshoot of a VHS trading company, few could have anticipated that the promotion would quickly go on to define a new age of American professional wrestling.

Early ROH shows were a collection of jaw dropping matches that appeared light years removed from the recently defunct ECW - and John Jirus was an integral part of them.

Competing as Xavier, Jirus, a 7-year pro upon entering ROH in 2002, didn't appear at first to be out of place in the hybrid matches that featured the likes of Low Ki, Brian Kendrick, Amazing Red, and AJ Styles, and soon defeated the inaugural champion Low Ki to become the second ROH titleholder.

Xavier wasn't a bad wrestler at all, but compared to the company he was keeping as champion, it soon became clear that he was an evidently less dynamic performer. That apparently was good enough reason for ROH fans to turn on him.

Losing the championship to Samoa Joe after a forgettable six month reign, Xavier disappeared from ROH during 2004 and aside from a few sporadic appearances, the last of which came in 2007, was never seen again.

4. Rob Conway

The NWA Championship was cast a momentary reprieve when TNA struck an agreement with the alliance to use the title as its world championship in 2002.

Advertisement

After regaining a modicum of respect, TNA's decision to leave the NWA sent the title back to the school gyms in 2007 - the same year Rob Conway was released from WWE.

Spending most of 2008-10 hostage in Mexico in the possession of Blue Demon, the NWA title returned stateside and was the focal point of a feud between Colt Cabana and Adam Pearce from 2010 to 2012.

However, in 2013 Rob Conway returned from wrestling oblivion.

No more talented than six years prior, Conway captured the once legendary title in March of 2013 and quickly became part one of the worst angles in modern wrestling history.

Much like the ill-fated NWA invasion of the WWF in 1998, an absurdly inferior version of that NWA invaded New Japan in 2013.

NJPW was in rarefied era of professional wrestling, when Conway showed up to horribly defeat Satoshi Kojima, Manabu Nakanishi and Jushin Liger.

In late 2013 Conway won NWA tag-team titles with fellow j-brone Jax Dane, becoming the only man in history to simultaneously hold the NWA Championship and NWA Tag-Team Championship.

3. Joe Doering

Tribute acts have been a part of professional wrestling as long as institutionalised racism and sexism.

Advertisement

Wrestling fans in the UK are particularly familiar with cover versions of classic performances as Brian Dixon ferried fakes from the Ultimate Warrior to X-Pac through town halls across the country for years.

If Stan Hansen had been a WWF wrestler in the 1990s, Dixon surely would have got on the blower to Joe Doering.

After failing to raise eyebrows jobbing for TNA in 2005 and 2006, the 6'5" Doering moved on to All Japan in 2007 as the company's token oversized American gaijin.

After being signed by WWE to a developmental contract in 2010 and released after only six months, Doering returned to the once eminent AJPW and became a main event attraction as a piss-poor tribute act to Stan Hansen.

With All Japan now the 4th or 5th largest promotion in Japan and a shell of its former self, Doering's win for the Triple Crown almost went unnoticed outside of Japan.

Perhaps the most legendary of all Japanese championships, if match quality and feuds were the mark of a championship, there are few more prestigious titles than the Triple Crown.

Doering however, is to Stan Hansen what the Ascension are to the Road Warriors

2. Steve McMichael

In his career as an American Footballer, Steve McMichael was anything but underwhelming.

Advertisement

A defensive tackle for the New England Patriots, 'Mongo' won the 1985 SuperBowl as part of the Chicago Bears, before retiring in 1994 after a year with the Green Bay Packers.

Hired by WCW in 1995, McMichael was inexplicably deployed as a pro-babyface colour commentator on Nitro while he trained for his ring debut.

There is obvious competition for the worst colour commentator in wrestling history, but Mongo's weekly diatribe showed little to no awareness of wrestling maneuveres or WCW's performer - so naturally WCW put him in the ring.

Debuting and turning heel in the same match, Mongo joined the fabled Four Horseman in 1996 and went on to battle some of the NFL's top names such as Reggie White and Kevin Greene in one on one action - on WCW PPV.

However, when on 21 August 1997 he defeated Jeff Jarrett to become the United States champion, the title made famous by Harley Race and Ric Flair was sullied forever.

Racking up some of the most pitiful performances ever seen on paid television, to suggest that McMichael was the drizzling sh*ts would be doing a disservice to diarrhea.

1. Tommy Rich

Two questions have long surrounded the career of Tommy 'Wildfire' Rich.

Advertisement

Firstly, how Jim Barnett pulled off putting the most prestigious title in wrestling on Rich for less than a week. And secondly, how Tommy was considered a sex symbol in Georgia - or anywhere in the cosmos.

From 1979-1981, Tommy Rich was the hottest southern territory babyface in the business. A cross-state draw, 'Wildfire' was primed for a top national spot with the NWA.

Barnett, seeking to boost gates in his Georgia Championship Wrestling promotion, brokered an unlikely deal with the NWA to have champion Harley Race drop the title to Rich in Georgia and regain it four days later.

Rich's win was intended not only to increase attendance but to establish Rich as a headline attraction and burnish his popularity nationwide.

Despite being a significant draw in the immediate years following his victory, Rich was unable to build on his title win, nor maintain the popularity he once garnered.

Jumping from territory to territory throughout the '80s and '90s, Rich became a nostalgia act- an aging teeny bopper with a one hit wonder.

Years after dropping the 10lbs of gold, Rich finished up his national wrestling career in ECW as 10lbs of s**t in a 5lb bag.

Advertisement