10 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dynamite (Jun 17)
AEW Dynamite: the greatest episodic wrestling TV programme in decades.
This week's episode promised a celebration of two quite incredible developments, post-Double Or Nothing: the expansion of AEW's Tag Team Division, which in terms of personnel at least is amongst if not the best ever amassed in pro wrestling history, and a refined cause-and-effect booking process.
We are no longer in the early phase of Dynamite which, while awesome in-ring, sometimes electrified without purpose. Kenny Omega Vs. Joey Janela, from the October 23 show, was a great wrestling match that functioned only to put Omega over ahead of his Full Gear match with Jon Moxley. It was fantastic, but pointless, even wasteful: they had a match on the lesser-seen Dark that better advanced the story, in which Omega entered Moxley's unhinged hardcore domain - and took the piss out of him once in it - by bantering off the Dean Ambrose wacky line. He proved he could hang in Moxley's match; the story of this more visible match was premised on Janela proving himself a capable pure wrestler ahead of his less significant PPV match with Shawn Spears. It was all backwards.
Everything moves forward and dovetails beautifully now. Relentlessly.
For example: Le Sex Gods - and they had the win/loss credentials to do it - aimed to steal a World Tag Team Title shot from Best Friends, a dynamic that also allowed AEW to build Jericho's conflict with Orange Cassidy and, maybe, Sammy Guevara's inner conflict.
One match.
A couple of segments.
Three compelling potential permutations.
Did AEW deliver upon that promise?
Downs...
3. That '90s Show
Why is Allie a "Jezebel"?
Is it because she's an attractive blonde woman with big t*ts, and thus automatically a bad person? Erections, suspicions: she's exclusively a form of arousal for Jim Ross.
It's a regressive portrayal that might yet be subverted - AEW has a tremendous knack of retroactively improving a puzzling story beat by orders of magnitude - but this is the same company that gave us non-consensual kissing at Revolution to punish a meddling woman. They've not earned that good faith benefit of the doubt with their treatment of women. The commentary team are usually better than this, too. They're smarter.
Can't they at least explicitly recall Allie's affiliation with the Butcher and the Blade to justify what comes off as latent misogyny?
Moreover, and the booking in the Women's division elsewhere was so good that this doesn't warrant that much in the way of complaint, especially since there is more time to build before Fyter Fest: why was Hikaru Shida Vs. Penelope Ford promoted only via match graphic?
2. Sequencing Issues
Though there was not inconsiderable storyline advancement and entertainment value at the midway point of Dynamite, the sequencing of the card between the two title matches developed a certain Dark vibe.
Across three segments, AEW presented - and again, the consecutive nature really didn't help in bringing this all into focus - a zombie character, an evil cult, and a WWF Attitude Era midcard act working comedy spots with a talent that, in terms of his canon win/loss record and incredible performance at Double Or Nothing, should be positioned with more gravitas than this.
This will all lead to something. These weren't dud segments that profoundly damaged characters, and one of them was really quite savvy, for reasons that will be covered imminently.
But there's a gang of bad faith mutants out there, licking the warts on their green lips, and a dish of "I thought AEW was meant to be like sports!" paired with a cry laugh emoji and "Haha AEW only uses old WWE guys!" is their sad, pathetic sustenance.
1. MJF Vs. Billy
AEW is attempting to protect the MJF character, draw attention to his pristine win/loss record, and keep him occupied, as Brian Cage completes the short-term AEW World Championship picture, with a diversionary subplot. This is all very noble and that, but it feels like a very midcard concern. Beyond last week's contrived set-up - with the greatest will in the world, why would Tony Schiavone interview Billy? - it was at least consistent with his "talent over tenure" MO to work him. The match was fine, with much of the ironic connotations that word holds.
The comedy spots were mostly funny, the manner in which MJF won made sense, and the defiantly story-driven match with a crystal clear babyface versus heel dynamic complemented the flow of the show, even if this match itself dragged at times. MJF right now occupies an uneasy space between pupil and prodigy.
This was more former than latter.
Ups...
10. It's The Small Things
AEW aims to create the atmosphere of a filmed event, not a performed show, to enable suspension of disbelief.
The prescribed, fully accounted for match card is the foundation to this sense of immersion. Nothing suddenly happens that asks unanswerable questions of the process. The viewer is going to ask them; it's the remit of the writer/showrunner/booker to anticipate these questions and hold an answer that does not shatter the illusion and make the audience feel stupid.
When Reba found Britt Baker in a dumpster after Big Swole's joyride, Baker immediately acknowledged the invisible camera expressly forbidden by AEW to achieve the above. The explanation was thin, but reassuring, and somehow so inspired as to be immaculately in character: Reba, fearful of a b*llocking, went to outrageous lengths to literally show Baker, splattered in litter, in a flattering light.
It's an hermetic presentation, AEW Dynamite, one that earns its ardent hardcore support by utilising virtually every second of the broadcast to reciprocate it.
9. Another Small, Great Touch
In another wonderful detail designed to reward those who care enough to pay strict attention - for all the early rhetoric of jobs and stars and the optics of who to push, this mentality is key to establishing a base - look at Colt Cabana.
He was shown on the babyface side of the crowd as the broadcast began. They were in high spirits, performing a Mexican wave, until the camera reached Cabana at the end of the line. The visual poetry was cute enough, but his expression continued his character development within a two second window. He looked despondent, unable to rouse himself into the trenches spirit.
Some time later, he was shown seated, mulling over the contract handed to him by Mr. Brodie Lee, in what amounted to the second row, further removed from his babyface peers.
It's also stunningly resourceful, incidentally, that AEW has turned the most crushing negative - the absence of the crowd, the lifeblood of a pro wrestling show - into this positive, effective storyline generator.
8. A Damn Fine Opener
Kenny Omega and Hangman Page Vs. The Natural Nightmares was a damn good opener unspoiled by the late appearance of Allie. QT Marshall didn't lose to Hangman Page because he was love-struck and distracted. He lost to Hangman Page because Hangman Page is the superior wrestler. This is the company that gives you satisfactory finishes.
This is also the company that gives you tremendous tag team wrestling with a ***1/2 minimum, and this (eventually) staggered beyond that by the pulsating finish. This company is quite incredible at finding a very neat way of laying out a match that doesn't transparently nor apathetically reach to make any dynamic work. They work to the dynamic.
After the wonderful, early novelty of the Kenny Omega Vs. Dustin Rhodes showdown, complete with Dustin levelling up to Omega's athleticism with a beautifully incongruous flying head scissors, there was a suggestion that Page had patronised Marshall somewhat.
He looked apologetic for out-smarting him and raking his back, and that small key moment right there was the way "in" to the believable, competitive match that followed. That lit the fire under Marshall and unlocked his hugely spirited and endearingly unrefined blitzkrieg sequence.
A very good and purpose-serving pro wrestling match.
7. Tremendous Booking In - Yes - The AEW Women's Division
Forgive the brief slip into the first person here, but the Abadon character is hard Not My Sh*t. The performer is admirably committed to a role that just isn't for me.
What follows isn't an automatic appraisal of a supernatural character purely because that supernatural character is promoted by AEW; what follows is an appraisal of a genuinely inspired spot of booking that solved, with remarkable inspiration, the significant issue that is an injury-plagued Women's division largely comprised also of travel-banned Japanese talent.
Anna Jay was given the Twitter match announcement and vignette treatment. She was framed as a big deal, and it was all earned by a fairly prodigious showing on Dynamite a few months ago, given her minimal experience level. Her opponent was subsequently announced on the night as the zombie-adjacent Abadon, who promptly destroyed her, and as goofy as I find this sort of thing, it was not cringe goofy. At all.
This was exponentially more effective than booking Abadon to squash Women's Wrestler X in an announced featured match. She beat somebody built as a somebody in sublime sucker-punch booking that created the illusion of depth.
Jim Ross deserves rare praise for his commentary work throughout a women's match; unlike with Kris Statlander, he sold in earnest sh*t-scared fright of the newcomer.
6. The Dr. Britt Baker, DMD Appreciation Slide
Britt Baker was absolutely phenomenal again after last week, in which she had the temerity to crack only one piss-funny joke. She has created an enormous expectation for herself and somehow contrived to smash it. Her obnoxious insistence on disrupting the show was as hilarious as it was in character.
She is a Role Model.
The show cannot do without the gift of her guidance, and she built a contraption to facilitate it. She used the contraption to hand notes to Tony Schiavone, one of which read, to put over Abadon, "This broad needs to find Jesus ASAP". That was as fantastic as her accompanying, unsettled facial expression, which sold the threat just subtly enough so as to not make a full cartoon of the presentation.
She was later interviewed by Tony Schiavone, who by displeasing her earned a "friendship time-out" Jesus Christ this woman is absolutely sensational at this. In a terrific moment - imagine not being weird robots and acknowledging the wider world - Big Swole did her best Undertaker impression and sent Baker on a joyride.
This division is actively and entertainingly building matches that it can't even promote. Shaken from its apathetic lull, the AEW Women's division is officially damn good now.
5. Midcard Storyline Progression
Where Dynamite stagnated on the night it still built towards a more exciting future, particularly in the post-match of MJF Vs. Billy.
This is where attentive booking yields convincing, compelling storylines. Two weeks ago, Jungle Boy and MJF argued at ringside during the former's challenge of Cody's TNT Championship. They didn't stop despising one another simply because their match ended. Weeks prior to that, Wardlow earned the ire of Luchasaurus by (hilariously) braining Marko Stunt against the barricade. This wasn't the first tease of this tantalising hoss fight, either, and this week, with Jurassic Express watching on, another melee - a very believable melee - broke out, leading to the announcement of a Wardlow Vs. Luchasaurus lumberjack match, the star rating for which, inevitably, will read "F*cking ruled".
Elsewhere, everything moved forward with purpose. Anna Jay's loss saw her preyed upon by the Dark Order. Abadon's victory upset Britt Baker. Match finishes created storylines and further matches in the short and long-term.
This company has mastered episodic wrestling storytelling even when the episode itself sags.
4. A Superbly Layered Segment Of Pro Wrestling Television
In his pre-match interview, Cody wondered aloud whether he remains aligned with either the Elite or the Nightmare family, accomplishing two things: retroactively making (some) sense of the booking in last week's wonky final segment, and further foreshadowing the formation of a new stable adjacent to the Four Horsemen alongside Shawn Spears and FTR.
Then, the open challenge itself was answered by Ricky Starks, a superb promo on NWA Powerrr with enormous breakout potential. The vignette heralding his debut very effectively put over both his style and his substance, and the mere fact that there was a vignette convinced the audience that he was a potentially major deal in the language of professional wrestling.
To cap off a multifarious triumph of a segment, the match was really, really good, put over both men in victory and defeat, and Starks showed tremendous fire, particularly in a high-quality blistering punch-up sequence.
Is Cody slowly turning heel, or is at a red herring that allows him to be that bit more of a desperate prick in these defences designed to get the undercard babyfaces over?
Either way, this is ace, ace stuff after a tentative start.
3. Another Superbly Layered Segment Of Pro Wrestling Television
Not since the days of dial-up internet has the world witnessed an image as goddamn sexy as the Young Bucks and FTR registering the moment just before they executed tandem spike piledrivers of beautifully contrasting origin.
This was every shade of f*cking fantastic. In using similar moves borrowed and named after the Brain Busters and Dave Meltzer, respectively, the Bucks and FTR highlighted their profound philosophical differences and that which unites them: brilliance.
The visual power of physical storytelling perfected, the mystery deepened exquisitely.
Why are FTR saying one thing - that they want to punch the Young Bucks in their mouths - and doing quite the opposite by saving them from harm?
AEW is crafting a rivalry based on respect and hatred simultaneously, and that tweet was prescient, all right. This is glorious before the match has even happened. Rejoice!
This segment did take its time to become as brilliant as it did - the picture got a bit busy with the Butcher, the Blade and FTR - but Bucks Vs. Superbad Squad built to an awesome finishing sequence in which the scintillating near-falls scored by the lower team were earned through the at-times overwhelming schmozz of it all.
2. Minimal Build, Maximum Effectiveness
The build towards Jon Moxley Vs. Brian Cage at Fyter Fest is unfussy, focused, and so effective that the prospect of it still being a fortnight off is a bummer.
Taz is fantastic in this role and was fantastic on the night, calling Moxley a rotten son of a bitch and a miserable son of a bitch plagiarist in that awesomely nasty New York brogue. Moxley's duelling promo was tremendous, too. He didn't play it for laughs, nor did he issue his trademark awesome '80s action movie threats; he revealed the sinister core of the real, troubled individual within ("I have demons...bad ones"), which was scarier than any quotable one-liner poetry. The subtext conveyed, quite brilliantly, that Cage is in trouble.
This match is going to rule. The build demands that it rules.
1. ANOTHER Superbly Layered Segment Of Pro Wrestling Television
Le Sex Gods Vs. Best Friends was a banger highlighted by some super stiff and exhilarating sequences crafted by Trent and Sammy Guevara, but it's Chris Jericho's genius that hauled this into 'great' territory.
The impeccable timing of Chris Jericho's saves created a sense of outrageously tense drama in the absence of the "Oh!" of a live crowd. He timed them with millisecond precision. This was an inspired match to book - Le Sex Gods hold such an impressive record that it cast doubt on the outcome - and the action put over the stakes. In a sublime sequence, Sammy Guevara flung himself out of the ring to lay out Chuck Taylor just as Jericho countered Trent's tornado DDT with the Liontamer. Since the barricade finally had an effect on Trent's ribs, this was built towards beautifully.
A lovely match that elevated Best Friends as credible threats, the inevitable Orange Cassidy interference materialised unexpectedly and wonderfully at the finish. He posed as the cameraman - and had done all night! - and tripped up Guevara so casually, in cunning character, that it worked to convince the referee of a mistake.
Deft, dovetailing brilliance that put over one Fyter Fest match and formalised another: this was maestro stuff from Mid South Tony.