10 Ups & 8 Downs From AEW Fight For The Fallen
Growing pains emerge in AEW's weakest show to date.
All Elite Wrestling's third pay-per-view proper is in the books, and while Fight For The Fallen wasn't an event that'll feature on any 'Show of the Year' ballots, American wrestling's rising power came through with another appetite-whetting broadcast ahead of All Out on 31 August (though it was AEW's most problem-ridden night to date).
Like Fyter Fest before it, Fight For The Fallen was ostensibly a B-level show. That's not to discredit the talent involved (as this card featured some of AEW's biggest names), but a description of how it was marketed, with nobody suggesting it should be taken on the same level as Double Or Nothing or All Out. Regardless, AEW's men and women still brought it, and it's impossible to feel bad about a pay-per-view put together to raise funds for victims of gun violence.
Among the biggest matches was an extremely well-built tag pitting The Young Bucks against Cody and Dustin Rhodes, who sent the hype machine into overdrive with this week's outstanding Road To promo. Elsewhere, Kenny Omega clashed with Dragon Gate legend CIMA in a first-time singles match, the prodigious Adam 'Hangman' Page wrestled England's Kip Sabian, and the unlikely MJF/Shawn Spears/Sammy Guevara group met a trio of lunatics in Jimmy Havoc, Darby Allin, and Joey Janela.
Let's dive into it...
Downs...
8. Closed Caption Chaos
A minor Down but a Down nonetheless: look at the state of the screenshot above.
Closed captioning kicked in during the Buy In. It was unprompted and came completely out of nowhere, with hundreds of Twitter users noting the same problem on B/R Live, FITE.TV, and YouTube. What's worse is that the subtitles were at least 25% gibberish, spitting out slews of random, unrelated characters when it couldn't pick up what Excalibur and Alex Marvez were saying.
Production botches like this just won't do, particularly with cynics ready and waiting to dunk on AEW for any and all minor infractions. The captions stayed onscreen for a good 10-15 minutes, too. Surely somebody in the production truck should've been paying attention to this?
Not a good look at all.
7. Allie's Carry Job Doesn't Pay Off
Allie is a very, very good professional wrestler, and her performance vs. Brandi Rhodes was a highlight.
The former Impact Wrestling star sold everything from Awesome Kong's unexpected arrival to Brandi's constant heeling perfectly. Her facial expressions were on-point as she cycled through everything between "p*ssed off" and "fired up," and the rest of her work was similarly strong. Her ring IQ, movement, and execution are on a different level to those she's wrestled so far. Give her a promotion ASAP.
Unfortunately, Allie's work wasn't enough to save the bout form the Downs section. It wasn't awful; just below average, and perhaps we should have seen this coming. Brandi has less than 50 matches to her name. She's still very much a work in progress and it'll likely be a long, long time before she can keep up with someone like Allie.
Allie had Brandi tapping out while the referee had his back turned. This cost her in the end, as Rhodes took the victory with the Bionic Knee.
6. Return Of The Marv
Alex Marvez is probably a lovely guy, and he's definitely a good journalist, but a professional wrestling commentator he is not.
His return to the announce booth brought a big downturn following Goldenboy's strong performance at Fyter Fest. He doesn't emote well, lacks the knowledge to offer any kind of valuable insight, isn't engaging, and his inflexions are all over the place. None of these things are his fault as he's still learning, but can a promotion with mainstream aspirations afford to have a guy who's still learning sitting in the announce booth?
The answer, of course, is no. Marvez was better tonight than he was at Double Or Nothing, but still below standard. AEW must either lock him in a room with Excalibur and Jim Ross until TV starts in October or rethink the three-man team. It's hampering the broadcast's quality at the moment.
5. Brandi's Flip-Flopping
Brandi Rhodes' benefitted immensely from her heartfelt Road To promo in her match with Allie. It was the first time the Chief Brand Officer had felt like a genuinely sympathetic, relatable figure in AEW, particularly as she described "the demons in my head telling me I can't do this," thus making it easier to see beyond her inexperience between the ropes.
It was a strong babyface setup... until Awesome Kong showed up.
The former TNA standout came out just as Allie was looking to tie up with Brandi, and now, suddenly, Brand is a heel again? Just... why?
AEW need to work on how their player/executives are positioned on the alignment scale. The problem isn't limited to Brandi, but her flip-flopping from apparent face to heel so flippantly highlights the issue. Something to work on for sure, as cool as it was to see Kong again.
4. Baker & Co. Underwhelm In Trios Action
The Buy In's second match saw Double Or Nothing winner Dr. Britt Baker DMD join forces with Riho to face the debuting Bea Priestley and Shoko Nakajima. A talented lineup in a bout seemingly put together to add new layers to the growing women's division, it was everything it needed to be.
Nakajima, 'The Big Kaiju,' indulged in drab grappling with Baker early on, before tagging Priestley in to a big pop. The match sped up slightly thereafter. The duo worked takedowns and suplexes before Bitt got disorientated, attempting to tag Nakajima rather than Riho. The course soon righted itself, though, and a speed vs. power battle broke out between Bea and Riho before Priestley summoned the spirit of Shayna Baszler, stomping on her young opponent's arm.
Baker looked a tad off the pace throughout, and that's worrying. Her disappointing performance contributed to a match that was merely okay. That isn't good enough for a division we were led to believe would become a cornerstone, so here's hoping they step it up next time.
3. Page's Ponderous Victory
Although Hangman Page vs. Kip Sabian was put together with little build, AEW successfully weaved a narrative around the bout on the night, with Sabian claiming his esteemed opponent had been handed everything since the promotion was formed. This gave him a real chip on his shoulder, and whoever came up with this angle deserves a pat on the back. It gave the clash the extra bit of juice it needed leading into it.
While primarily designed to boost Hangman's momentum ahead of his match with Chris Jericho, this handsome battle attempted to give Sabian his share of the shine too. He left a more valuable commodity than when he walked in, though there wasn't much spice to his work, and while he showed flashes of greatness, the space between his moves wasn't always compelling. Not the most encouraging showing in the biggest match of his career.
The match had its positives, but it was cumbrous as a whole. Sabian and Page weren't able to grip a crowd who'd been enraptured by Lucahsaurus and Jungle Boy minutes prior. Their work wasn't bad, it just didn't connect, resulting in a fundamentally sound but unexciting contest that, worryingly, was supposed to give AEW's next pay-per-view headliner a massive rub.
That Hangman doesn't feel like anything close to 'The Guy' heading into All Out is a huge, huge issue. AEW need to rectify this on Being the Elite and Road To.
2. "Thank You Jericho"
The Page vs. Sabian post-match angle saw what looked like one of the Dark Order's Creepers assault Hangman, with the dormant crowd not lulled from their slumber until the masked man hit a Codebreaker then removed his veil, revealing Chris Jericho as the perpetrator.
Page was left bloodied and beaten. Floored by a Judas Effect, he sold the beatdown like a pro, but 'Y2J' departed to chants of "thank you Jericho."
Again, worrying. Worrying as hell.
Is All Out's main event in full-on crisis mode? Saying so wouldn't even be knee-jerking at the moment. Page vs. Sabian and the Jericho angle were flubs that didn't resonate with the audience at all, thus delivering AEW's first piece of ineffective booking at a high level. Let's see how they respond to it - they've given themselves a lot to do.
1. The Worst Ending Imaginable
Fight For The Fallen's closing five minutes were embarrassing. Legitimately embarrassing.
The Young Bucks were on the microphone after their victory over the brothers Rhodes, paying tribute to Cody and Dustin's effort in defeat. They were clearly going for a big handshake/hug/coming together, but Kenny Omega's music hit when it wasn't supposed to, prompting Matt to say "we ran out of time."
Out came Omega with Brandi Rhodes, Luchasaurus, several other roster members, and Shahid Khan holding a big cheque. Having improved the "respect" angle while this was going on, Cody introduced Tony Khan Sr., then revealed that they'd raised $150,000 for their charitable cause. An excellent gesture, but an awkward, stunted angle.
Things got worse from there. Cody handed the microphone to Omega so he could close it out, with Kenny revealing that he couldn't use his old "goodbye and goodnight" catchphrase from NJPW. "Seeing as we're no longer on the air, let's have some fun with it," he said, while still on the air. In the background, Jim Ross could be heard asking "are we off?".
... and then Fight For The Fallen faded to black out of nowhere.
There's no way to dress this up: this was a complete and utter shambles. It was bush league stuff from a promotion that wants to be the big league, and there can be no excuse for it.
Ups...
10. An Improved Buy In
While Fight For The Fallen's Buy In pre-show certainly wasn't can't-miss viewing, it did feel like AEW had acted upon the critical feedback thrown their way following Double Or Nothing and Fyter Fest's lacklustre appetisers.
Previous Buy Ins did nothing to build anticipation for the main card, but this one at least aspired to. Promos from Dustin and Cody Rhodes and 'Superbad' Kip Sabian hyped two of the evening's biggest matches. As simple as they were, such things were sorely lacking on the previous shows. The lack of ineffective comedy represented another step forward as 'The Librarian' gimmick was minimised and nothing was played for laughs, a few spots aside, resulting in the first Buy In to truly feel like a serious wrestling presentation.
Quality is subjective and the women's trios match didn't quite hit the mark, but FFTF's pre-show was a step in the right direction. Here's to continued progression.
9. Daily's Place
It's always refreshing to watch a wrestling show that isn't held in an identikit American basketball arena, and Daily's Place looked fantastic last night, with the Shahid Khan-designed building calibrated perfectly for professional wrestling.
A minor Up, but an Up nonetheless. Aesthetics are important. Basketball buildings get tiresome and while Daily's Place is a smaller building than AEW will likely run in larger markets, it'd be great to see them host shows in other different venues when the opportunity arises. It'd certainly help differentiate them from WWE's homogenised main roster presentation.
8. Judas & The Hangman
"I'm looking at the blood of Hangman Page on my hand right now," was the line that opened Chris Jericho's much-hyped "live mic" segment, as 'Y2J' continued his search for the "thank you" he's been waiting for from AEW management since Double Or Nothing.
After riffing on the crowd, Jericho promised he'd get his "thank you" by "beating the crap out of everyone in All Elite Wrestling," starting with Hangman. He took credit for everything the company has achieved so far, including the TV deal, and claimed he "had to beat 'The Hangman,'" otherwise it'd be curtains for both him and the promotion, rounding his part of the segment off by promising to beat Page - that "little b*tch."
This drew Hangman out for a big ol' brawl, with streams of officials and other roster members pouring out to split things up. It came off markedly better than Jericho's post-match ambush earlier in the show and Chris' promo was solid. This marks it as an Up in isolation, though it did nothing to dispel the new concerns over All Out's main event.
7. No Silence In The Library
'The Librarian' gimmick is evolving. With "maintain silence in the library" plastered across the big screen, 'Pretty' Peter Avalon hit the ring with no entrance music, enhancing the jeers that poured from every corner of Daily's Place. He then cut a solid little promo before facing Sonny Kiss, claiming to have "something very important to tell you" before his opponent interrupted, putting on a show with the Jacksonville Jaguars' cheerleading team at the top of the ramp before hitting the ring.
The match itself was a considerable improvement on Leva Bates' tie-up with Allie at Fyter Fest, though it was never going to be difficult for Kiss and Avalon to outdo that drab affair. Regardless, the duo's strong clash of personalities and styles resulting in a sold Buy In battle laced with colour and character, concluding with Sonny Kiss scoring the victory from the top rope, handing the 'Librarians' their second consecutive loss.
Never designed to be a show-stealer, the bout will probably prove too shtick-heavy for some. Regardless, the crowd were into it, both guys go their personalities across, and there were no objective flaws. That's an Up.
6. MJF, Outdone
A supplemental Down for Shawn Spears calling himself 'The Chairman.' There's only room for one of those in this business, pal, and it ain't you.
Jokes aside, Fight For The Fallen's second trios bout was a hoot. The three maddest bastards in AEW (Joey Janela, Jimmy Havoc, and Darby Allin) faced off against Shawn Spears, MJF, and Sammy Guevara. The heel side was always going to be dicey and this manifested early on, as MJF (Cody's apparent "best friend") shouted "hey Spears, watch this!" at the Fyter Fest villain. Havoc, Janela, and Allin had no such issues. They kept their offence as fast and brutal as possible, with Havoc and Janela warming the crowd up before Allin came in to a big pop, the crowd firmly on his side as he faced off with Spears.
Solid stooging saw Shawn tag out before Darby could get his hands on the man who "upstaged" him at Fyter. Guevara, his substitute, stuck a middle finger in the daredevil's face. The evildoers worked well in bursts but the frosty MJF/Spears dynamic was a problem throughout, making for a fun, easy layout that concluded with Spears finally imposing his will, pinning Allin to upstage MJF.
Also, for the sadists, Janela death valley driver'd Guevara on the apron. He shouted "f*ck you Cornette" afterwards, too. Legend.
5. Kong Vs. Kong
Please, please make this mad kaiju boss battle happen immediately, AEW.
That is all.
4. Lucha Brothers Vs. SCU Recovers The Crowd
Fight For The Fallen came dangerously close to losing the crowd entirely until SoCal Uncensored vs. The Lucha Brothers happened, so thank god it went down the way it did.
Christopher Daniels, Frankie Kazarian, and Scorpio Sky's signature pre-match shtick chased with Rey Fenix and Pentagon doing insane, mental sh*t proved the perfect audience-reviving tonic. They were back on the show's side by the time referee Aubrey Edwards failed to catch Penta's glove (forcing a repeat).
The bout succeeded by highlight SCU's charisma and the Lucha Brothers' cocaine style of wrestling. We got posing and posting, chopping and kicking, big dives and big flips. Everything you'd expect from these teams, basically, and it delivered on both an athletic and character-based level, making it yet another success story in AEW's growing tag division.
A particularly close near-fall came when Fenix stomped Kazarian on the outside, allowing Penta to fly from the top rope, nailing Sky with a Destroyer on the way down. Scorp survived that one, but the stomp/Fear Factor combination that followed ended up putting him away.
3. A Boy And His Dinosaur Kill It... Then Lose For Some Reason
Look, your writer isn't saying that Justin Roberts called Luchasaurus and Jungle Boy "a boy and his dinosaur" made the three-way tag bout an automatic Up, but it definitely helped.
Fun moments were peppered throughout. Stu Grayson brought boatloads of fun offense despite his corny gimmick. Jack Evans and Angelico bickering over who'd have to face Luchasaurus was great, and the big bad dinosaur looked tremendous. Jungle Boy, meanwhile, is an instant jolt of adrenaline as soon as the hits the ring, and will almost certainly become a major star in this promotion. Evil Uno brought an impressive array of heel f*ckery to compliment his big beefy power moves.
It was laid out smartly, with the heels' extended control segment on Jungle Boy leaving the audience pining for a Luchasaurus tag. The hard-kicking dinosaur battered everyone in the match, bringing the whole building to its feet thereafter. He was cut off eventually, but the match succeeded in elevating his level of overness.
The only problem here is that the wrong team won. Luchasaurus and Jungle Boy were so over compared to everyone else that AEW should've called the audible rather than having the Dark Order prevail to a muted response. Regardless, a strong match, and one that at least pushed every character forward.
2. Best Bout Machines
Fight For The Fallen needed the real Kenny Omega. It needed 'The Best Bout Machine.' He performed well at both Double Or Nothing and Fyter Fest, but not at the level that brought him into the "best in the world" conversation a few years ago. For his sake and the show's, this was the night for him to come out like that state-of-the-art, cutting-edge pro-wrestler his supporters purport him to be.
Did he pull it off?
Yes. To an extent.
Omega vs. CIMA doesn't belong in either man's top five, but it was a great match, and the best thing on the show up to that point.
Fans knew it was going long when Justin Roberts announced it would have a 30-minute time limit, not the standard 20 that the show's other matches adhered to. That's exactly how it played out. The opening act was slow and methodical. It was very New Japan-like in its escalation of violence, and exploded to life as CIMA dived from the stage on the 15-minute mark, hitting Kenny with the Meteora.
Two springboard Meteoras followed. CIMA was in the ascendancy until Omega hit the V-Trigger, and the "fight forever" chants came soon after. Having been ignited by several awesome sequences, it became a bruising, pulse-racing encounter typical of Kenny's biggest bouts, until he finally "went for the nuclear option" (thanks, Excalibur) in the One Winged Angel, scoring the win.
1. Old School Rules
After stealing the show alongside brother Dustin Rhodes at Double Or Nothing, Cody got his first AEW main event at Fight For The Fallen, as the former 'Dusts joined forces against The Young Bucks.
Most previews had this down as a styles clash, with the Bucks flying all over the place while the more grounded Rhodes boys played bases. That's not what happened. While the opening stage brought flurries of the Jackson brothers' video-game movez, it played out as a smart, methodical southern-style tag, with Dustin playing a masterful face-in-peril.
The Bucks played heels for much of it. They continued their open trollery of Cody's "I need my older brother" spiel by embracing in the ring after taking their opponents out. Later, Nick Jackson spat at 'The American Nightmare' while working his sibling, then mockingly screamed "tag me, Dustin!" from the outside a few minutes later. It was as character-driven as it was old-school.
This is the kind of wrestling the Rhodes family love, much of AEW's audience want to miss, and the company will thrive on if they're able to keep delivering at this level. It was magnificent. Layered without being overly complicated and slow without ever coming close to being too slow, it favoured physicality and perfect psychology over highlight-reel moments, making it another devastating loss for those who still call the Jacksons "spot monkeys."
A bout of finisher theft preceded the finish - the Bucks putting Cody away with the Meltzer Driver. This will prove a divisive match. Some won't like its length and pacing, but those with patience and an eye for detail will be richly rewarded.