10 Ways A Brand Split Would Help WWE Right Now

"It's time to shake things up around here" - Vince McMahon, 2002.

By Kenny McIntosh /

One topic that divides wrestling fans in 2016 is whether WWE should go back to a brand split or keep the roster together. The first WWE brand split occurred in 2002 when WWF had hired a bunch of ex-WCW & ECW stars along with the contracts they adopted from the 2001 WCW purchase. Initially, the two rosters were positively stacked as RAW had Steve Austin, Booker T, The Undertaker and the nWo while SmackDown had Hulk Hogan, The Rock, Chris Benoit, Edge and Kurt Angle. The idea was for both shows to stay separate, except during pay-per-view events where there would be RAW matches and SmackDown matches and, in time, they could have inter-promotional 'dream matches'. Sadly, in the end it didn't quite work out and the rules of the brand split were adhered to less and less as the years went by. Eventually in 2012, the two brands merged and the two separate rosters were a distant memory. Even though the WWE roster has gone through a lot of injuries, I believe that a brand split would be the best thing for the company in the long run, so here are the ten reasons I have to convince you that RAW and SmackDown should go back to being separate entities with their own identities...

10. Separate Voices

Whether fans like it or not, Michael Cole is the voice of WWE and he's actually pretty good at it, when he's not forced to constantly plug things. In order to make the brands completely split, there cannot be any overlap on commentary. In the current WWE landscape you could have the current 3 man team on RAW - Michael Cole, JBL and Byron Saxton, meanwhile over on SmackDown all the action there would be called by Mauro Ranallo and Corey Graves. While it might not be a popular decision, my vote would be to move The King into a WWE Network role and bring him in for the pay-per view panels and have Corey Graves replace him on commentary. Graves and Ranallo would be a great contrast to the three men we currently hear on Monday nights. Ranallo can call the matches in more of a sports like way whereas Graves puts a modern twist on the classic 80s/90s heel colour commentator. Having split announce teams also works in that you might only ever hear Michael Cole call a Roman Reigns match whereas you'll only ever hear commentary to Bray Wyatt's bouts by Mauro Ranallo. Associating a voice with the performers will help to distinguish the brands. At pay-per-views, you can have both announce teams there to call their brands matches and, for one night a year, all five men could call the Royal Rumble match.

9. Give More Stars The Chance To Shine

Tyler Breeze is a perfect example of a superstar who would benefit from a brand split in 2016. Since moving up to the main roster, Breeze hasn't been in a meaningful feud except trading wins with Dolph Ziggler for the first month of his run. If Breeze was exclusively on SmackDown, he'd be able to move higher up the card, be more heavily featured and get more promo and ring time which would, in theory, help him connect with the TV audience and build up his stock in the company. A lot of mid card level stars would be better off in a brand split environment, because the rosters being split in half would allow more opportunities on both sides. When Cesaro returns from injury, he's automatically in the top 3 or 4 babyfaces of whichever roster he goes to, which means he can make more money and build his profile. The fans win because they get more of the Swiss Superman. It's well known within wrestling that there is less pressure on the SmackDown side as it's out of the sight of Vince McMahon, so when Triple H is pushing to get guys and girls from NXT called up, it allows him a political powerplay in that he could draft the people Vince isn't keen on to the SmackDown brand, and McMahon's favourites can go straight to RAW. It's win-win.

8. Shake Up The Product

The Authority storyline has been going on for two and a half years with no end point in sight. It's a creatively crippling storyline due to one of the main heels being Stephanie McMahon who rarely gets her comeuppance physically. With a roster split, it would likely mean the end of The Authority or, at worst, only have to put up with them on one show. The WWE's product has gotten increasingly stale in the last six months, due to 3 hour RAWs, questionable booking, injuries and other factors. In a time when WWE drastically needs to focus on the future, a brand split would force them to do just that. A lot of young performers would be the main stars on both shows and force the fanbase to take them seriously as the legitimate top stars of today. Having two rosters also allows you to experiment with ideas on each brand, whether it's bringing in an exclusive division, introducing tournaments or bringing back legends to work programs with some of the up and coming stars who could use the rub to advance their careers. As Vince McMahon has said before, "It's time to shake things up around here". It's time.

7. Quicker Call-Ups From NXT

With one roster, it's tough to find a place and a story for new names all the time but with two rosters, it opens up a lot more room for fresh talent. With NXT becoming such a massive success in the last 12 months, the brand has created more stars than it can feature on the one hour TV show, which means that if RAW and SmackDown operated with separate rosters, there can be more regular call-ups to the main TV shows with spaces to feature the talent. There's no reason why Finn Balor and The Balor Club (Anderson and Gallows) couldn't have debuted on RAW by SummerSlam, while Samoa Joe and Baron Corbin could have made their mark on SmackDown by the time WWE gets to Brooklyn in August. At the Performance Center, they have over 70 guys under contract, so whenever NXT stars graduate to one of the main rosters, it opens up more opportunity for the PC hopefuls to start getting featured on NXT. Gone will be the days of wondering why your favourite NXT star isn't on the USA Network challenging for a title or competing in the Royal Rumble - a brand split will allow these things to happen.

6. A Real Women's Revolution

Back in the summer when Stephanie McMahon introduced three new women onto the main roster and branded it a Divas Revolution, it wasn't handled very well and in reality, it's only been the last month or two where we've had a gripping female storyline with Becky and Charlotte. If WWE opted to do a brand split, the Women's Champion would be able to appear on both shows, which means that there'd be two rosters of women all vying to compete for the Championship, while the champion becomes a marked woman who has to defend her title against all comers. With the amount of female talent on the independent scene today, there's no reason WWE couldn't try to hire more women to fill both rosters. Alternatively, the other option in the Brand Split world is that the Divas Championship, which would hopefully be re-christened the Women's title would be exclusive to one brand. Maybe the womens wrestling is on RAW whereas the female valets and the more 'Diva' type characters can be found on Thursday nights. It would mean one brand would get the chance to see Sasha Banks battle the likes of Charlotte while the other brand would have Lana, Eva Marie and others. No matter which option you went with, it would be nice to see more women featured on the main roster and having them on both brands opens up new spots for women from NXT as well as hiring talented women from across the world, getting them used to the company through NXT before bringing them up to their designated roster.

5. Two Shows With Different Identities

The key to a successful brand split is fostering different identities for each show. This encompasses everything from the theme music and the logos to the sets and colour schemes all the way to the announcers calling the show. Back in the 2002-2012 days of split rosters, the shows did look different and at times felt different, but there was more that could have been done to distinguish the two of them and make them feel like different companies. While it's OK to have recap videos for RAW, it would be better if the SmackDown announcers weren't plugging the upcoming RAW and the other way around, if they want it to feel like two different brands, there has to be a cut of ties between each. The only similarity should be the WWE logo and nothing more.

4. Annual WWE Draft

One of the most anticipated nights of the year was the WWE Draft, when any star could go from RAW to SmackDown and vice versa. Big moves in the past included Triple H and Jim Ross being drafted to SmackDown and Rey Mysterio and John Cena being drafted to RAW. In a 2016 brand split, it would be good to keep the annual tradition of a Draft alive but this time to stick to the rules a little more. Back in 2004, they had Triple H drafted to SmackDown only to be drafted back by the start of next week's show. It should be a straight forward switch for the ten competitors a year who switch between RAW and SmackDown. A fun twist to the Draft could be the trade option where the General Manager or on-screen Authority figure of each brand gets to make two or three trades a year, allowing for some storyline reasons to get certain people onto a roster. As long as it doesn't happen too frequently, the Draft and the switches could make for the most exciting part WWE's year.

3. Championships Exclusive To Each Show

The best way for WWE to handle the Championships today would be to make the Intercontinental Championship exclusive to SmackDown and the United States Championship exclusive to RAW, that way each brand has their own signature championship that makes the viewer tune into that show to see the champion or that title being defended. The US title remaining on RAW means the company can choose to bring back the extremely popular US Open Challenge that was a highlight of 2015 when John Cena would defend against different opponents every Monday night for almost six months. It resulted in some excellent matches with Cesaro, Seth Rollins, Neville, Sami Zayn and others. Keeping the strap on the Monday night flagship show allows them to bring it back when it suite a certain champion. The Intercontinental Championship has been floundering for the last few years and it needs something to give it some relevance again. Being exclusive to SmackDown means that most Thursday nights could feature a main event with the Intercontinental Title on the line allowing it to start to matter to fans again. Through long matches, gripping storylines and heated exchanges, the WWE Universe might begin to feel about the IC title how we felt about it back in the late 1980s or early 90s.

2. Floating WWE Champions

In 2002, WWE adopted the World Tag Team Titles for RAW and the WWE Tag Team Titles on SmackDown. If the 2016 brand split was a big success, then maybe in a couple of years that would be a good idea but given how limited the tag team division is, in terms of depth, it makes sense to have your Tag Team Champions able to appear on both shows and have to fend off multiple challengers at a time. It would add to the prestige of the Tag Team belts, in that the champions would be made to face all comers from both RAW and SmackDown. At the beginning of the original brand split in 2002, the WWE Champion would appear on both shows and defend the title against challengers from both brands. After about six months, they separated it into the WWE Title being on SmackDown and the World Title being on RAW. In a modern day roster split, I'd hope that the WWE World Heavyweight Champion would appear on both shows. I've always preferred there being one World Championship that is defended across both brands rather than two different World Champions. There should only be one top man in the company and having the champ on both shows can be a bit of a throwback to NWA Champ Ric Flair going to the different territories to defend his title. Whoever the World Champion is, should be saved for special occasions and shouldn't wrestle on both shows every week. With some good creative, the WWE World Champion could legitimately be the top guy in the whole company. What a world that would be.

1. Create 'Inter-Promotional Dream Matches'

My favourite part of the last brand split was how it gave us the inter promotional match between Shawn Michaels and Kurt Angle at WrestleMania 21. The story was simple and ,within the confines of a brand split world, it made perfect sense. Shawn Michaels eliminated Angle from the Royal Rumble, then Angle came back and took out HBK as revenge, this escalated into Angle beating Marty Jannetty and bringing Sensational Sherri in to sing "Sexy Kurt" on SmackDown, and even led to Michaels dressing up as a camera man to attack Angle on the blue brand's show. That's the power that an inter-promotional battle can have if the stars are kept apart. For the first twelve months of the new brand split, we should only see RAW guys and SmackDown guys interacting at the Royal Rumble or on the first Draft show. In order to make this a long term success, the current audience need to be taught that WWE are serious this time and the brands will be distinct, unique and separate. Then and only then can we get inter-promotional dream matches that the fanbase are dying to see.