10 Ways WWE's Current Product Mirrors That Which Killed WCW

The rise and fall of World Wrestling Entertainment.

By John Harty /

In recent years WWE€™s DVD sales and Network programming have been driven by nostalgia for its one time arch-nemesis WCW; at one time it was beating WWE handily in terms of the quality of its product, ratings, buy-rates and ticket and merchandise sales. But the company famously imploded in spectacular fashion; losing sixty-two million dollars in one year despite having never lost more than six million dollars in any year it had been in business (it lost seven million dollars in one month in 2000). Within three years of WWE fighting back and taking the lead in The Monday Night War it was sold to WWE for a figure rumored to be as low as four million dollars; a huge drop from the five hundred million dollars offered for it by SFX the year prior. It is a tale that anyone who wants to become a wrestling promoter should study in detail and learn from the multitudes of mistakes the company made to drive its audience away and ultimately put it out of business; as the saying goes, those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it. The scary thing is; the one company that should know the story and avoid the same pitfalls that killed a once noble promotion. WWE in 2014, seems oblivious to the view that it seems to be following suit with its current product. If you know the story; then surely you can see the parallels. Some are obvious and some are more obtuse; but once you see them you can€™t deny them.

10. A Three Hour Main Show & The Amount Of Product On TV

Nitro, WCW€™s flagship live Monday night show, was a breath of fresh air at first; in many ways it changed the industry. But as WCW became more successful Nitro extended to three hours; Thunder, a new two hour show, was added to Thursdays and the long established WCW Saturday Night brought the total of WCW television to six hours on a weekly basis. Unfortunately all this airtime eventually lead to repetition of matches, story lines and feuds and the overexposure of their talent roster; which stood at a whopping 260 wrestlers at one point. As the wheels became to come off of the company from a creative prospect; three hour Nitros became ponderous affairs, Thunder rarely had anything of note happen and was paid little attention by the creative team and Saturday Night was mostly filler. Fast forward to today and WWE currently runs eight hours of television across multiple platforms and its flagship show Raw runs in a three hour block that is often ponderous; Smackdown rarely has the top stars involved and little of note happens while, with the exception of NXT, the rest of WWE€™s weekly schedule is mostly filler. All this with only 103 active wrestlers across the main and NXT rosters. Raw is too often tedious with the same talents in the same spots having the same matches and feuds on a weekly basis; and, just like it did for WCW, it is driving their audience away.

9. Talent Under Contract That Never Make Appearances

As stated in the previous entry; WCW at one point had 260 wrestlers under contract. Some of these wrestlers, such as Lanny Poffo and Kevin Walcholz, never made an appearance for the company. In today€™s WWE; David Otunga, Rey Mysterio and Christian are all under contract (in the case of Rey against his will) but not making appearances for the company. It€™s a small thing but indicative of a pattern of historical repetition; but it makes even less sense today as WWE has no sizable competition as they did when WCW was still on the go. WCW clearly were holding onto these talents in case they could add something to their competitor€™s product; but with the reported WWE attitude being that TNA and other organizations are not genuine competition you have to question why they are doing this.

8. Repetitive Match Ups

A lot of fans grew tired of WCW because of the repetitive nature of the product they put out on television; because of the lack of mobility and the tampering of peoples careers by main event politicians guys were having the same matches against the same opponents often on a regular basis and familiarity breeds contempt which in turn drove away the audience base. The Cruiserweight division was particularly prone to this; with guys like Rey Mysterio Jr, Chris Jericho, Psicosis, Juventud Guerrera, Dean Malenko et all having faced each other so many times fans began to stop caring; and the amount of D.Q. finishes in their main events eventually drawing more distaste than the infamous Dusty Finishes of the late 80s and early 90s. And this was with a roster over twice the number of the current WWE roster and with two hours less television a week. Part of the reason for the launch of the WWE Network was that the Pay-Per-View buy-rates were on a steady decline and have been for the last few years. A big factor in this is that WWE presents the same match week in, week out, on television and then expects people to pay out for a PPV event to see the exact same match they€™ve seen over the last several weeks of television. This year alone from the February 10th edition of Raw to the March 3rd Edition; WWE presented matches featuring combinations of Fandango & Summer Rae vs Santino Marella and Emma for four consecutive episodes (then booked it again on the April 7th episode). Between April and July The Rhodes Brothers vs Rybaxel was presented no less than five times (in one form or another); and, lest we forget, there was a recent run of handicap tag-team main events pitting a combination of The Authority (usually Kane, Seth Rolins and Randy Orton) against John Cena and whoever his current partner was (first Dean Ambrose then Dolph Ziggler). Even veteran fans who refuse to abandon the product groan in frustration when they see the competitors come out for the n€™th week running for the same match up they€™ve had over and over again; many can€™t watch Raw live anymore because they have to be able to fast forward these segments. Other fans get fed up and abandon the product; just as they did with WCW.

7. Celebrity Segments

WCW tried different things to draw back the audience they had lost in the years before it went out of business; most of these things involved getting celebrities involved in their shows. While during the 80s WWE had proven that celebrities could add something and draw extra eyes to the product; WCW seemed to involve celebrities for the sake of having them there. From mini-concerts from Kiss and Megadeath (that drew some of the lowest quarter hour ratings of The Monday Night War) to Master P and his No Limits Soldiers taking on the West Texas Rednecks (the celebrity faction was meant to be the babyfaces in that angle; though the audience rallied behind the heels) to the travesty that was David Arquette€™s World Championship reign; WCW kept coming up with celebrity segments that seemed designed to do the opposite of what they were intended to do and draw higher audience numbers. While WWE pioneered celebrity usage; their recent involvement in the product has more often than not had the same effect as these spots did for WCW. Yes there is the odd moment that works such as Hugh Jackman€™s spot with Damien Sandow€™s Magneto; but it seems that for every one of those there are dozens of Larry The Cable Guy spots that just draw audience apathy while bringing little or no bump to the audience numbers. The recent Kathy Lee and Hoda segment stands out as the prime example of this; with WWE having to pump in Adam Rose€™s music to drown out the shower of boos from the live crowd due to the hatred this segment drew from them.

6. Popular Talent Stuck In The Mid-Card (AKA The Glass Ceiling)

In his recent interview on The Steve Austin Show; one of the more eyebrow raising comments by Vince McMahon was that nobody was grabbing the brass ring and moving up the card; he also said he listens to his audience. WCW was notorious for not elevating the talent in the middle of the card when they were over with the fans and it caused stagnation and contributed to the death of the company; many of the biggest stars of the last twenty years in professional wrestling (including the likes of Steve Austin, Mick Foley, Chris Jericho, The Big Show & Eddie Guerrero) had frustrating periods mired in the WCW mid card with no opportunity for upwards mobility and most of their creative ideas for matches and feuds shot down. Chris Jericho famously lobbied both backstage and on air for a program with Bill Goldberg; when nothing came of it his mind was made up to move on to WWE. The difference was that, back then, they had somewhere else to go; they jumped ship to WWE and became the stars that WCW should have made them. Nowadays there isn€™t a company of a close enough standing to WWE and talent don€™t want to lose their jobs despite their frustrations. Some talents, such as Kofi Kingston, have been so damaged by their lack of progress that, while they were once considered shoe ins to be the next main event star, it now seems that it would be impossible for fans to take them seriously in any situation above where they currently are. Even those that seem to have broken through often find it to be a false dawn; with five former World Champions that have headlined Pay-Per-Views as champion (Jack Swagger, The Miz, Dolph Ziggler, Sheamus & Mark Henry) mired in mid-card or lower feuds and, with the possible exception of Ziggler, not looking likely to reach those heights again. The number rises to ten if you chose to include names such as Kane, Rey Mysterio, Chris Jericho, Christian and The Big Show; and it's ultimately harmful to the product and devalues the achievement of becoming World Champion in the eyes of the fans. Your World Championship feud should ultimately be the main factor in driving buy rates, merchandise and ticket sales; the more damage you do to that scene the more damage you do to your company as a whole. Despite what Vince wants you to believe; there is a glass ceiling in today€™s WWE; just as there was in WCW.

5. Creative Direction

While this had more to do with WCW existing within the Time Warner corporate structure; when the then WWF was setting ratings records off of the back of the raunchier Attitude Era product it was dictated to Eric Bischoff that WCW would revert to a cleaner, family friendly product. Despite the overwhelming evidence that the wrestling audience was clearly buying into the total opposite of that to the tune of the WWE€™s hundreds of millions of profit during that time period; WCW reverted to the product that had nearly driven the WWE out of business just a few years prior and it ultimately was one of the nails in their coffin because they had built their audience predominantly from the male 18-34 demographic . As Kevin Nash said during a recent episode of The Monday Night Wars: "We got a Standards and Practice guy in our creative room and they've got Val Venis with Jenna Jameson; wonder where that demographic's going to go?" Fast forward to now and, despite the displeasure of their core audience and ratings, buy-rates and ticket sales reflecting it€™s the wrong way to go, WWE is trying to provide a product for everyone with a decidedly family friendly tinge that is driving their audience away. Despite the overwhelming opinion online that things like Adam Roses Bunny and gimmicks like Los Matadores are ruining wrestling for the majority of long time fans; WWE continues to persist with them and other ideas like them. While I understand the reasoning; those who don€™t learn from their past are doomed to repeat it. If a regular TV show like The Walking Dead suddenly changed tact and it caused the ratings and merchandise sales to drop in the way WWE€™s have; then the show would be cancelled by the network. Just like WCW€™s TV shows eventually were.

4. A Stagnant Main Event Scene

This one€™s a no brainer to anyone outside of the WWE at the moment; but if the purpose of the main event is to drive Pay-Per-View buy-rates then the more you provide the same talents in that spot then the less willing people are to shell out their hard earned money to see it. WCW persevered with the likes of Hogan, Nash, Savage et all until they were past their prime and it drove their audience off; Hulk Hogan vs Ric Flair was presented to their audience, in one form or another (including tag-team and multiple participant matches), over twenty-five times between '94 & 2000 on both television and Pay-Per-View (of which ten occasions were on Pay-Per-View; five being one on one matches). No TV show with the same cast and plots, no matter how big it was at its peak, lasts forever. Audiences need new things to stave off their boredom; not endless rematches between John Cena and Randy Orton (despite swearing a few years back we€™d never have to watch that match again). Between 2005 and today this match has been presented, again in one form or another, a staggering seventy-four times with twenty-two of them being on a Pay-Per-View (of which ten were one on one matches). It killed WCW and now it€™s killing WWE.

3. Top Talent Having Creative Control

Hulk Hogan famously was given complete creative control over his character and how it was presented in his WCW contract and as a result it limited the bigger picture of what the company could do as a whole as they would have to rearrange things based on what Hogan wanted to do. The calamity that was the Hogan angle at 2000s Bash at the Beach Pay-Per-View, an infamous worked-shoot that became a legitimate shoot and marked the final appearance of Hogan for the company as well as his character defamation lawsuit against Vince Russo, happened due to Hogan's insistence he won the belt on that night (according to Russo at least). Another good example is that Sting had to be on standby to be the third guy on the night of Hogan's legendary heel turn at Bash at the Beach '96 because Hogan wasn't completely sold on the idea and contractually had every right to back out at the last minute; go back and watch the footage an you can see the hesitance in his eyes and demeanor just before he goes through with it. While no one in WWE has it written into their contract; creative control still exists in the current WWE product. John Cena has gone on record as saying he will never turn heel and that it is his decision; whatever his reasons are (many suspect they€™re monetary; heels don't shift as much merchandise) it€™s damaging the product as a whole and causes good ideas for scenarios to be abandoned because of one man. Large portions of the WWE audience have abandoned the product due to this; being put off by Cenas stale routine. They could be drawn back by a Cena heel turn & the new scenarios this would present; much in the same way those driven away by Hogan were when he turned heel. While not strictly the same situation; it is another piece of evidence that suggests WWE€™s ignorance to historical repetition.

2. All Hope Placed On One (Limited) New Star

Back when WWE began its fight back against WCW and started to pull ahead; one new star rose as the apparent savior of WCW. When the wheels really began to come off of the company; many executives in charge wanted to hitch the cart to this performer and build the company around him. He was anointed the man; his name was Bill Goldberg. Taking nothing away from Bill€™s popularity or achievements in professional wrestling; he was limited. The moment they stopped putting him in squash matches and gave him microphone time the cracks began to appear in his veneer; but he had been built in the right way over enough of a period of time that people still bought him as a true top star and he put butts in seats. Today; WWE is seemingly pitting its hopes on the next breakout star being Roman Reigns. The similarities to Bill Goldberg go beyond them sharing a finisher; but at least Goldberg had time to develop in the eyes of the fans as he rose up the card in a steady manner. Reigns, like Goldberg, is limited both in the ring and on the microphone; and, again like Goldberg, his best feature is his look. Reigns is being pushed into the top of the card far too soon; some of it smacks of desperation on WWE€™s part but the parallel is clear. Just like WCW with Goldberg; all of WWE€™s focus seems to be on pushing Reigns as opposed to pushing a number of talents at once. Ultimately Goldberg€™s push failed because they forgot to get fresh opponents to the top of the card at the same time as him and after he€™d blown through the established main event scene there was no one credible left to fight and the cycles of repetition and stagnation that were already driving off their fan-base sucked him up as well. Reigns currently faces the same problems in WWE; and he hasn€™t had the same amount of time as Bill Goldberg to develop.

1. Political Minefields

WCW was notorious for backstage politics affecting their onscreen brand; people were pushed based on their relationships with bigger stars or the opinion that these bigger stars (who had the ear of the decision makers or often were the decision makers themselves). Kevin Nash while booking WCW was said to be fed up with the complaining of €œBenoit and the rest of the Vanilla Midgets€ (insider slang for small, boring wrestlers) about their spot; while Hulk Hogan would go on his friend Bubba the Love Sponge€™s radio show and bury talent. On one occasion he said that Billy Kidman €œwouldn€™t be able to headline a wrestling show at a flea market€ and in another appearance he slagged off most of the roster and said that nobody under forty could draw. Bret Hart tried to get several ideas for feuds off of the ground only to find the likes of Nash and Hogan blocking him at every turn; despite being one of the most revered wrestlers of his generation and being potentially the hottest property in wresting when he arrived in the company off of the back of the Montreal Screw Job. You had to be a very savvy political operator to get by in WCW and have the ear of one of the top stars just to stay afloat; let alone progress up the card. Today€™s WWE operates in a different world; but it is no less of a political minefield. Wrestlers are encouraged to do media interviews and maintain a social media presence through platforms such as Twitter; yet are then berated and punished for speaking their mind about issues. Many believe a key factor in the fall down the card in recent times of men like Dolph Ziggler and Cesaro had more to do with comments made in press interviews than anything else (though recent events may indicate that Dolph has righted the ship and is on the rise again); and stories do the rounds of the main event talent trying to derail rising talent just as Hogan and Nash did. If rumors are to be believed; the likes of John Cena and Randy Orton do just as much as Hogan and Nash did to derail talent. They just go about it in different ways; with Cena not putting over Bray Wyatt cleanly during their feud (which derailed the massive momentum The Wyatt Family had) and Orton reportedly being on a go slow during his house show run with Roman Reigns. But what about having the ear of those in power and higher up the card? Well, that still exists in the modern WWE; Sheamus and Batista have benefited from their relationship with Triple H over the years, Funaki and Zack Ryder have stayed employed based off of their friendships with top stars (Shawn Michaels and John Cena respectively; Funaki was only released once Michaels retired), the Rhodes brothers paid for their father Dusty going off script and getting in Stephanie McMahon€™s face during a segment and you get the feeling that WWE would€™ve done more to reach out to and bring back CM Punk if it wasn€™t for Triple H feeling slighted by Punk not being overly enamored with the idea of their proposed Wrestlemania match. Then there€™s also the matter of the President of the company, Vince McMahon himself, going on his friends podcast and saying his roster lacked the drive to become stars; sound familiar to anyone?