10 WORST Matches From WWE’s Biggest Gimmick Bouts

What were they thinking?

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

WWE bloody love a gimmick match.

Advertisement

They're not alone - fans like seeing new match types too, especially when they're inventive, fit a certain feud or play into a specific wrestler's strengths. For example, Hell In A Cell was the perfect playground for Mick Foley to bump himself silly back in 1998, and his daredevil antics helped endear the Mankind character to more people than ever before.

A nasty byproduct of Mick's bravery/recklessness (depending on your point of view) was that WWE felt the need to push things more and more afterwards. That, unfortunately, led to a shockingly poor Cell moment less than one year later. It's here on this list along with a regrettable rag-tag bunch of bouts that must be considered the worst in their individual fields.

Advertisement

Everything from Elimination Chamber, Iron Man and Money In The Bank to Royal Rumble, TLC and the little-used Buried Alive gimmick counts. There's even some room for ye olde Survivor Series traditions, and a bit of spotlight for other stips too.

These are the worst matches from WWE's most famous ideas...

Advertisement

10. Elimination Chamber

WWE

The Match: ECW's 'Extreme' Elimination Chamber from December To Dismember 2006.

Advertisement

Why It Was The Worst: Where do you start? This was a pay-per-view so bad that Paul Heyman visibly palmed his own forehead on air. The gimmick was that entrants would exit their individual chambers armed with weapons, but that couldn't win back a live crowd already p*ssed when it was announced that Hardcore Holly was replacing an injured Sabu.

As hard as Bobby Lashley, Holly, CM Punk, RVD, Big Show and Test worked, they couldn't make this an exciting, ECW-inspired spin off on the regular Elimination Chamber formula. Heyman's reported attempts to have either Van Dam or Punk win the thing fell on deaf ears and WWE continued shoving Lashley down everyone's throats instead.

Advertisement

This will never make any 'best of' compilations.

9. Iron Man

WWE.com

The Match: The Miz and John Morrison vs. Shannon Moore and Jimmy Wang Yang on the 8 January 2008 episode of ECW.

Advertisement

Why It Was The Worst: Some of the best 'Iron Man' bouts in WWE history include names like The Rock, Triple H, Brock Lesnar, Sasha Banks and Bayley. By comparison, this 15 minute long attempt on the old ECW show involving Jimmy Wang Yang wasn't going to cut it. The 'Fifteen Minutes Of Fame' gimmick worked for Miz and Morrison, but it shouldn't have been an abbreviated 'Iron Man'.

15 minutes is just too short for anyone to get invested in the stipulation. Both teams ended up drawing 1-1, and nobody really cared. The average ECW main event was anywhere between 10-15 minutes during this era anyway, so nothing made sense.

Advertisement

Booking an 'Iron Man' match that was 45 mins shorter than the best was never going to fly.

8. I Quit

WWE.com

The Match: Bret Hart's match with Bob Backlund at WrestleMania XI.

Advertisement

Why It Was The Worst: The 'I Quit' stipulation is a difficult sell at the best of times due to the momentum-breaking stoppages necessary so referees can hold a microphone up to someone's chops as they either yell, "No", something to that effect or say the magic words that end the match.

At WrestleMania XI, Bret Hart and ageing relic Bob Backlund worked the first ever 'I Quit' match in WWE history, and it was horrible. Bret even named this one as his worst match ever when writing his autobiography, and it's not hard to see why; a disinterested Roddy Piper (who as the guest ref) shouting, "What do ya say?" into the mic every two seconds was almost comical.

Advertisement

Backlund also flubbed the ending by shouting, "Yeah" instead of 'I Quit'. Avoid at all costs.

7. Survivor Series Elimination

WWE.com

The Match: The Bushwhackers and Men On A Mission vs. The Headshrinkers, Bastion Booger and Bam Bam Bigelow at Survivor Series 1993.

Advertisement

Why It Was The Worst: Just look at that accompanying picture - that should be all the evidence anyone needs to declare this Doink The Clown-inspired sh*t show the worst traditional Survivor Series elimination match ever. Need more? How about The Headshrinkers slipping on bananas or the disgusting visual of Booger devouring a turkey carcass?

Also, Doink himself wasn't actually involved.

Advertisement

Luke, Butch, Mabel and Mo simply dolled themselves up to look like the mirthful clown and bizarrely rode scooters around the ring as Bam Bam wondered what he'd done to deserve this nonsense. Lord only knows what Stu Hart (or any other wrestling traditionalist present in the Boston Garden that night) would've thought had he still been sitting around ringside.

6. Casket

WWE Network

The Match: Triple H vs. Mideon and Viscera on the 23 September 1999 episode of SmackDown.

Advertisement

Why It Was The Worst: The Casket bout gimmick can work a treat when The Undertaker is involved and has the right opponent. 'Taker and Shawn Michaels proved that at the 1998 Royal Rumble by putting on a clinic. Nearly two years later, Shawn's bestie Triple H wasn't so lucky.

He was handed Mideon and Viscera instead.

Advertisement

This coffin-based crap was part of an ongoing storyline that saw Vince McMahon put Trips in five different gimmick matches on the same night. The worst was this Casket effort with a bumbling duo who were never going to offer much resistance.

It took three minutes for Mideon to roll into the box. Yeah.

Advertisement

5. Buried Alive

WWE.com

The Match: The Undertaker vs. Kane at Bragging Rights 2010.

Advertisement

Why It Was The Worst: WWE has only promoted five of these dirt nap matches since introducing the gimmick in 1996, and The Undertaker has been involved in them all. His bouts with Mankind, Steve Austin (despite their weird lack of chemistry) and Vince McMahon all offered some excitement.

Bragging Rights 2010 did not.

Advertisement

Brotherly battles between 'Taker and Kane were a bit played out by this point, and not even the involvement of Nexus could save things. On that note, why were Wade Barrett and the gang helping Kane anyway? They failed to breathe some life into a dull, plodding brawl that played before a bored audience.

Side note: If you fancy a refreshing surprise, then check out 'Taker and Big Show vs. The Rock and Mankind from the 9 September 1999 SmackDown. That was an all-action 'Buried Alive' battle.

Advertisement

4. TLC

WWE

The Match: Roman Reigns vs. Sheamus at TLC 2015.

Advertisement

Why It Was The Worst: WWE's TLC gimmick hasn't resulted in many bad matches. Sheamus vs. Roman Reigns at the 2015 pay-per-view was hardly awful either, but it was living proof that a mutinous live crowd can spoil even the most inoffensive main events.

This was peak Roman bashing from an audience who delighted themselves by rebelling against WWE's wishes (that they cheer Reigns) and thus ruined the match completely. Both guys worked hard even though they were up against folks who wanted them to fail, but they couldn't offset the boos whenever Roman got on top.

Advertisement

If you're ever going to revisit this headliner, do so on mute. The Boston crowd trolled WWE big time here, and they killed the match dead from minute one. It was almost impossible to enjoy all those bumps when they were backed by such indifference.

3. Money In The Bank

WWE.com

The Match: The first ever Women's Money In The Bank match at MITB 2017.

Advertisement

Why It Was The Worst: WWE's women have produced some incredible moments over the past five years or so, but the first ever Money In The Bank match to involve the ladies wasn't one of them. The fact it ended with a man hauling down the briefcase says it all; booking James Ellsworth to win on behalf of Carmella sucked.

Sucked.

Advertisement

'Mella, Becky Lynch, Charlotte Flair, Natalya and Tamina all worked tirelessly to produce a match that could go down in history as something special. They took big risks and seemed up for it on the night. Then, WWE let them down badly with one of the most frustrating finishes in recent memory.

That conclusion took a dump all over what should've been a historic occasion for WWE's women, and it washed away all of their hard work.

Advertisement

2. Royal Rumble

WWE.com

The Match: WWE's first pay-per-view style trip to Saudi Arabia for the Greatest Royal Rumble in 2018.

Advertisement

Why It Was The Worst: Longtime fans found it really challenging to stomach WWE's declaration that some exhibition-style 50-man variation would be the "Greatest Royal Rumble" yet. As it turned out, those fears were warranted when the company rolled into Saudi Arabia and produced a glorified house show main event.

Nobody should forget that Braun Strowman's new green belt was barely referenced again when everyone returned home to the United States. It was almost like this "Greatest" Rumble hadn't mattered at all. Imagine that! Those who opted out of the event beforehand had been the smart ones - they didn't have to sit through a show that smudged the history of one of WWE's best ever gimmick bouts.

Advertisement

Seeing The Great Khali walk out as the 45th entrant in a 50-man match was almost too much to take as well.

1. Hell In A Cell

WWE.com

The Match: The Undertaker vs. Big Boss Man at WrestleMania XV.

Advertisement

Why It Was The Worst: If you've ever watched even a few minutes from this painful match, then you'll know exactly why this one tops the list as the worst WWE gimmick bout of all time. Yep, it's not just the worst Hell In A Cell match, but arguably the worst ever generally. The Undertaker vs. Big Boss Man at 'Mania XV was just that bad.

The finish tried to be shocking for the sake of it too.

Advertisement

Nothing went right. Boss Man's handcuffs broke (what kind of law man has cuffs that break?), the crowd weren't into it once they realised that neither man was going to take a Foley bump and the image of Boss Man being hanged was 'Attitude' era excess personified.

People complain about what HIAC has become nowadays, but not even WWE's worst attempt today could top this.

Advertisement

What do you think are the worst matches from these stipulations? For more like this, check out 10 WWE PPVs That Aren’t As Good As You Remember and 22 Craziest Moments From WWE Extreme Rules 2020!