10 Wrestlers Triple H Couldn't Get Over
It was game over for these men.
Triple H is not exactly the most selfless man in the history of the wrestling business. That much is pretty widely acknowledged. But the man has been pretty giving when it has come time to do some key jobs throughout his career. Being in a program with him usually has made his opponent feel like a bigger deal, even if they didn't go over on him.
For a period of time (from the the late ‘90s to early 2000s), he was the best heel in the business, and was delivering great matches on a weekly basis. Much like his longtime friend Ric Flair, he knew how to take quite the bump, and would make his opponent look like gold. It seemed he could work with anyone, as he helped bring the careers of quite a few wrestlers to new levels like Chris Jericho, The Rock, Batista, Kurt Angle and even (quite briefly) Taka Michinoku!
However, Hunter doesn’t quite have the golden touch. As good as he’s been as a face and a heel, he just didn’t gel with some wrestlers, especially as his career dragged on. While he was still a big star in the eyes of the fans, some opponents didn’t get a rub from working a program with him, no matter how hard he tried.
From green monsters, to promising rookies, here are 10 wrestlers that Triple H just couldn’t get over.
10. Scott Steiner
In early 2003, Triple H was given the unenviable task of attempting to get Scott Steiner over...as a babyface. Now when Big Poppa Pump first came into the company, fans treated him like a star, but WWE strangely fought the current. They decided not to cast him as a heel, which is what shot him to the main event in WCW.
Upon signing with the Raw brand, The Big Bad Booty Daddy set his sights on Triple H. The two argued over their ridiculous physiques, they had an arm wrestling contest and Hunter got stripped down to some uncomfortably tiny undies. Now that's a feud! Well, things weren’t going so hot, but it was ten times worse once they got in the ring.
Steiner had major foot problems at that point in his career; basically he was unable to lift one of his feet in the air. That was an impossible problem to work around. Triple H sure tried, though, and had to do all the work in their matches. It was abysmal. At Royal Rumble and No Way Out 2003, they put on two of the worst matches of that year, which basically consisted of Steiner doing nothing but belly-to-belly suplexes.
After that feud ran its course, Steiner was sent to the mid-card and never recovered. The two tried to make something happen, but there was just too much working against them. Perhaps in 2000 with both guys healthy, and with the heel/face roles reversed, they could have had a fantastic feud, but in 2003, it was an all-out dud.
9. The Spirit Squad
Perhaps two guys beating up five on multiple occasions is not the best way to book a feud. But such was the case of The Spirit Squad vs. Shawn Michaels and Triple H.
Now to get the rookies over, they needed solid in-ring veterans to work with. There weren’t too many choices better than the DX members at the time, so it potentially could have been beneficial to their careers. Instead, it was the end of the group, and 3 out of the 5 Squad member's careers in a WWE ring.
At Vengeance 2006, the two sides faced off with Hunter and his good buddy HBK, with the cheerleaders taking the loss. A few week’s later at Saturday Night’s Main Event, we got the rematch with the same results. That was pretty much it. There was some talent in the group (most notably the future Dolph Ziggler), but there wasn’t enough give-and-take to make things look equal. Sharing that big spotlight for the young talent was actually a big detriment to their act.
The Squad started out as obnoxious heels who had a lot of heat, but somehow left even more comically inept than when they began.
8. Carlito
Carlito Caribbean Cool came into WWE with a lot of potential. He was given slick, Razor Ramon like vignettes to precede his arrival, and in his very first match he captured the US Title.
Along the way, though, his career started to stutter. Perhaps a feud with Triple H could have got things back on track. Or perhaps, it would sink it to new lows and eventually lead to his departure.
In 2007, Carlito and Hunter engaged in a feud and soon battled it out at Unforgiven. Lucky for Carlito he could NOT be DQ’d. He could have done anything he wanted and not lost. Bringing 40 of his closest family and friends to the ring to help fight alongside him would have been perfectly legal. It was an easy victory...except Hunter won. He didn’t just win, he absolutely destroyed Carlito. For some reason, the two had a rematch on Raw a few weeks later...which seemed really, really unnecessary. Not surprisingly Hunter won that one too.
Soon after, Carlito asked for his release from the company as he was unhappy with his push (can you blame him?). Vince McMahon convinced him to stay, which then led to a few unspectacular years for the once promising superstar, before he released anyway. His potential renaissance against Hunter was set-up merely to be squashed into oblivion. It did not get him over.
And that? That wasn’t cool.
7. Test
Now to be fair, creative was the one that really let down Andrew “Test” Martin during his hot angle involving Stephanie McMahon and Triple H. The right way for things to have gone down would have been for him to get that one big win on pay-per-view over the guy who stole his fiancee, and then they could see if he was able to manage as a top star from there.
All he really got out of the entire deal was a match on Raw.
Test was getting over a bit as Steph’s love interest, and Shane McMahon helped raise him up a bit at SummerSlam 1999 in a “Love her or Leave her” match. Test later defeated Hunter in a match on Raw, before finding out that his bride-to-be had secretly married the leader of DX. The McMahon-Helmsley Era was born and Test soon went to war with the group. It was over quickly
Test lost a tag match against Hunter and X-Pac, and the group continued to beat him up in the subsequent weeks. They faced off in various forms, but something wasn’t quite clicking. Fans weren’t exactly clamoring for a big Test/Hunter singles match, even though that was what the storyline called for.
Perhaps it was simply a lack of charisma on Test’s part, and a lack of chemistry between the two that doomed things from proceeding further.
6. Vladamir Kozlov
Before Rusev, and after Nikolai Volkoff, there was Kozlov as the evil Eastern European heel in WWE.
After racking up a series of victories against WWE’s undercard, he set his sights towards Jeff Hardy, Triple H and the WWE Championship. It was a bad mix. Hardy’s high flying style, Hunter’s methodical pace and Kozlov’s inability to wrestle created a lackluster feud that culminated at Survivor Series 2008. Jeff, though, was attacked before the match, so Edge was inserted. But he didn’t get involved until 10 minutes in...so we got a slow, plodding bout of just Hunter and Kozlov.
That was pretty much it for Kozlov’s big push. The following month, he opened up the show at Armageddon against Matt Hardy, while Hunter went into a triple threat main event against Jeff and Edge.
Kozlov just didn’t have anything special enough to make him a main event player, and it really only took one match with Hunter for the company to figure it out.
5. Kane
Before Kane and Hunter battled in 2003, The Big Red Machine had been over at points in his career. But he’d peaked a few years earlier after big angles with The Undertaker and Steve Austin ended. With the brand split in full effect, though, the company needed some players to step up, so Kane was shot back into the main event briefly to work with Hunter. For everyone involved, we wished he hadn’t.
The two already had their go at each other, most notably at WrestleMania XV, and then in 2001 as part of the Two-Man Power Trip storyline. Now both men were at different points in their career. Hunter was rocking it in Evolution, and WWE was attempting to make Kane more human by retconning pieces of his backstory by saying that he had a girlfriend named Katie Vick. Well, longtime fans recall how embarrassingly awful that was (who could forget simulated sex on a dummy inside of a casket for 10 minutes?), and it basically sunk the feud immediately.
Kane and Hunter battled at No Mercy 2002 in a title unification match and then fought two weeks later on Raw in a casket match. On June 23, 2003, Kane lost his mask per the stipulation against Triple H, and then reverted back to a more sinister, unrealistic character. It worked well for him for a bit, more so than his feud with Hunter ever did.
The two apart can be quite good, but together they have been horrifyingly terrible.
4. Kevin Nash
Kevin Nash did well for himself as WWF Champion as Diesel, and then he was crazy over as himself in WCW, but his 2002 WWE homecoming was pretty lackluster.
After the nWo flamed out, and Nash healed from a quadriceps injury, he returned to the company, and soon began feuding with his real life good pal Triple H. Now, at this point in Nash’s career, he was far less mobile than a few years before (and he was never that mobile to begin with), and it just felt like a rerun of what we’d seen in prior years. Fans wanted an increase of Rob Van Dam and Booker T in the main events, and a decrease of Nash.
Still, Hunter and Big Daddy Cool began a feud that felt like it simply would not end. They fought in a six man match at Backlash, then a singles match at Judgment Day and then a finale at Hell in a Cell. It was perhaps the most uninteresting Cell match to that point, even though it turned out better than expected.
Somehow, nine years later Nash returned to the company once again to battle his friend in a ladder match. It seemed like one of WWE’s most reckless ideas ever. Despite both men being legends in their own right, the fans still did not care to see them fight one another. Hopefully, that’s the last we’ve seen of them in a ring wrestling each other.
Perhaps they're due for another round by now, though.
3. Randy Orton
The Legend Killer did end up gaining quite a bit of success over the course of his career, but it was in no thanks due to his feud with The Game.
Randy Orton and Triple H simply do not belong anywhere near each other in a ring. They produced one of the most lackluster WrestleMania events ever together, and years before that they had a rushed feud that killed Orton’s momentum as a babyface, and badly derailed his career for months. That was likely not the goal.
Orton defeated Chris Benoit at SummerSlam 2004, and this did not sit well with Hunter, as he was unable to do so himself in multiple attempts. The following night, the newly crowned champ was kicked out of Evolution. They then battled at Unforgiven a few weeks later and Hunter captured the title once again. The plan was for Orton to chase his old leader, with the hopes that he would become a superstar face in the process.
However, he was unable to win the rematch, and was pretty well sunk as a character. It wasn’t until a heel turn, and a match against The Undertaker at WrestleMania 21, did Orton regain his footing.
While The Viper and Triple H made solid stablemates, they just could never recapture that magic against each other in the ring.
2. The Great Khali
Could anyone really get The Great Khali over? In the summer of 2008, Triple H was the last one to try.
After feuds with The Undertaker and John Cena dried up, Khali was simply not over as a main event heel. If Hunter was able to do it, he could have done the unthinkable, and perhaps it would have been one of his greatest achievements. But, much like The Dead Man and Cena, he was unable to do so.
The two were set off to battle at SummerSlam that year after Khali won a battle to earn the right. The main event for that show was Undertaker vs. Edge, with John Cena vs. Batista slotted with the second most important match. Hunter and Khali went on before them. What proceeded was an incredibly lackluster match, one not deserving for such a high slot on a big pay-per-view, especially with the WWE Title on the line.
The following month at Unforgiven, Triple H defended his title in a triple threat match, and Khali didn’t even make it on the show. They met up a couple of months later in their own triple threat match (involving Kozlov as well). Khali took a Pedigree, and the pinfall, and Hunter marched on.
The end of the feud was the last big push of Khali's career as he soon morphed into a comedy act, which he stayed in for the rest of his time in WWE.
1. Roman Reigns
It seems that everyone on the WWE roster has tried to get Roman Reigns over, but few have tried harder than Triple H.
The two battled it out in an Evolution vs. Shield feud after WrestleMania XXX, with Hunter putting the young team over on multiple occasions. But it was at WrestleMania 32 where it was do or die time for the young star. The match died right out of the gate.
Undertaker vs. Shane McMahon had gone on earlier in the night, and The Rock made his triumphant return in the prior segment. The fans were drained. Hunter and Roman were going to have to pull out something big to make it work. What they produced was a nearly 30 minute match that ranks among the least exciting in the history of Mania main events.
Roman beating up the evil COO, a guy who made life a living hell for the entire roster for the past few years wasn’t enough to get the crowd to cheer him. That's a pretty damning sign.
You have to give Hunter some credit for taking the clean loss, but at that stage in his career, he just couldn’t create a compelling match that could get people excited. And Roman just didn't have the crowd support going into the bout that was going to change anyone's mind.
Currently, they are likely headed for another showdown in the near future. Will this round go any better? No. Probably not. But might as well try...right?