10 Wrestlers WWE Regret Releasing
Vince McMahon still rues the days he let these guys walk out of his company.
WWE's talent roster is in a constant state of flux, and while the company currently have over 200 individual performers on their books, their acquisition efforts never sleep. There are only a certain amount of spots available, however, and when a group of new wrestlers join the company, others inevitably have to make way.
The promotion purged dozens of competitors in 2016, and this year's spree of releases has already begun with the likes of Simon Gotch and Jack Swagger. There'll be countless others before the end of the year, but while the bulk of WWE's roster cuts seem logical at the time, Vince McMahon doesn't always get it right - and countless WWE castoffs have gone on to prove that the decision to part ways was a huge error on the company's behalf.
WWE isn't always the promised land it's made out to be, as proven by the names herein. While a number returned to WWE later in their careers, each of their releases coincided with a big upturn for the performer themselves, their new employers, or in some cases, both...
10. CJ Parker
He might seem like an odd inclusion for those who don’t keep up with NJPW, but former NXT jobber CJ Parker has soared since his WWE release in 2015. Initially joining Japan’s top promotion as a trainee, Parker became Juice Robinson, and has since reached a level of stardom he could only have dreamed of in WWE.
Juice initially stood out for all the wrong reasons, but has improved leaps and bounds throughout 2016, and built a big following among NJPW’s fanbase. This culminated with a huge IWGP Intercontinental Title shot against one of the company’s biggest stars in Tetsuya Naito recently, and while Robinson was defeated in his first main event, his performance was close to flawless.
Robinson’s Japanese success demonstrates just how quickly a wrestler can improve when his employers put a little faith in him. His eco-warrior gimmick was always a heat magnet in NXT, but CJ Parker rarely won, and was primarily used as a victim for the likes of Kevin Owens and Baron Corbin.
A shame, as his time with NJPW shows that Parker could have at least been a solid midcard player had WWE put more effort into his development.
9. Slate Randall
Slate Randall accomplished very little in WWE's developmental system. An occasional dark match worker throughout the 2000s, the 11-year veteran eventually signed for WWE in May 2013, and was assigned to the Performance Center. He failed to make a single televised NXT appearance prior to his release in August 2014, however, and soon shuffled back to the independent circuit.
Six months later, Randall signed for TNA, and was reborn as Eli Drake. Impact finally gave him the opportunity to showcase the full breadth of his talents, particularly on the microphone. By early 2016, Drake was rightly regarded as one of the most charismatic wrestlers outside of WWE, with his regular 'Fact of Life' talk show segment putting him over as one of his promotion's most detestable heels.
Drake is a relatively average wrestler, but his elite talking ability makes it extremely surprising WWE released him in the first place. There's a strong chance he'll end up back in the company before the end of the year, however: reports of WWE's revived interest in Drake first surfaced in December 2016, and have persisted ever since, suggesting the company now realise the mistake they made in letting him go.
8. Gail Kim
WWE have released Gail Kim on two separate occasions. The first was in 2004, when Kim was told that management wanted to take the women’s division in a new direction, and she was let go as a cost-cutting measure. She returned in 2008 and spent three more years with the company, but was let go when her contract expired in 2011, and hasn’t been seen since.
The first release is baffling, given the state of women’s wrestling at the time. Outside of WWE, Kim played a vital role in establishing the TNA Knockouts Division, and eventually worked her way into the company’s Hall of Fame. She’s widely regarded as one of the best women’s wrestlers of her generation, and had she stuck around, Gail could have been instrumental in raising the WWE Divas’ pre-Revolution standards - and occupying a Mickie James-esque vanguard role on the opposing brand.
The second was more justifiable. Frustrated with her role, Gail asked for her release, but WWE refused to let her go. Thus, she was made to sit-out the remainder of her deal before eventually departing in regrettable fashion, and vowing to never sign with WWE again. Kim technically left of her own accord, but it stemmed from the company alienating somebody who should have been a standard-bearer.
7. Shelton Benjamin
Looking back on it today, Shelton Benjamin’s 2010 WWE release was entirely pointless. ‘The Gold Standard’ was never going to be WWE Championship material, but he was one of the most athletic wrestlers in the world in his prime. When motivated, Benjamin was an outstanding human highlight reel, an exciting midcard presence, and somebody who all but guaranteed a great match when paired with the right opponent.
Shelton joined Ring Of Honor after leaving WWE, then transitioned to Japan, where he developed a slower, more methodical style of wrestling. WWE tried to bring him back for the brand split in 2016, but the medical exam revealed a torn rotator cuff, and having only recently been cleared to compete again, Benjamin has found himself back on the independent circuit.
WWE’s 2016 approach shows that they probably realise that releasing Benjamin was a mistake in the first place. Even at 41 years old, he’d still make a great roster addition in 2017, and if WWE have a spot to fill on Raw or SmackDown, they could do a lot worse than bringing Shelton back and rectifying what has proven to be an ill-advised 2010 release.
6. Mickie James
Mickie James' story is very similar to Gail Kim's, but while the chances of Kim ever rejoining WWE are incredibly slim, Mickie made a full-time return to the company in January. She has since slotted into a comfortable gatekeeper's role on Monday Night Raw, and will likely continue at that level for the rest of her career.
Like Gail, Mickie was a fantastic women's wrestler at a time when WWE weren't exactly known for making the most of the division. She engaged in a number of memorable stories throughout her run (particularly with Trish Stratus from 2005-06), established herself as one of the company's best female workers, and scored an impressive six Women's/Divas Championships in the process. Like most of her peers, however, James was often let down by poor creative direction throughout her tenure, with the "Piggie James" angle particularly egregious.
Mickie was let go by WWE in April 2010, and signed for TNA shortly after. She played a significant role in the Knockouts Division, winning the championship three times before her eventual departure. Beth Phoenix was struck by a career-threatening knee injury one month later, leaving SmackDown's women's roster extremely shorthanded, and the company full of regret (according to the Wrestling Observer).
5. Derrick Bateman
Derrick Bateman accomplished next to nothing in WWE. A competitor in NXT’s third season, Bateman’s most notable angle came through a love triangle with Maxine and Johnny Curtis in 2011, but he was shunted back to developmental in the aftermath. There, Bateman treaded water until May 2013, when he was eventually let go.
Three months later, Bateman, like so many WWE castoffs before him, joined TNA. It was the making of him was a professional wrestler, and as Ethan Carter III, his career went through the roof. Starting life as a snobby, entitled heel, EC3 eventually became Impact’s franchise player, winning the company’s World Heavyweight Championship on two separate occasions, and establishing himself as one of the sport’s most charismatic competitors.
EC3 would be a perfect fit for WWE’s current programming. His microphone and character skills are second to none, and he’s good enough to hold his own with anybody between the ropes. Carter’s tale is proof that nobody really knows how much potential a wrestler has until they’re given a chance to shine, and his ongoing success must be a source of regret for Vince McMahon & co.
4. Alundra Blayze
Along with the likes of Bull Nakano and Bertha Faye, Alundra Blayze was part of WWE's attempts at reviving their women's division in the 1990s. She was highly successful, notching three Women's Championship reigns during her run with the company, and featuring at the heart of most of the division's key storylines. 1995 was a difficult year for her, however, and after winning the title for the final time in October, Blayze was let go in December.
WWE's ongoing financial troubles were cited as the reason, and Alundra was cast into the wilderness. Frustrated, she decided to sign for WCW just a few days later, and made her first Monday Nitro appearance on 18 December. Through technically stripped of her title, Blayze took the actual belt with her and tossed it into a trashcan on live television, stating, "that's what I think of the (WWF) Women's Championship."
Eric Bischoff was giddy, but WWE, predictably, were not. They didn't publicly acknowledge the stunt, but Blayze was blacklisted from the company for 20 years, and WWE didn't reinstate the title until 1998.
Their stance later softened, and Alundra was eventually inducted into the Hall Of Fame in 2015, but the company could have avoided much humiliation had they not disbanded the women's division.
3. Christian
A former World Heavyweight, Intercontinental, and nine-time Tag Team Champion, Christian is one of WWE’s most decorated modern superstars. He’s a future Hall-of-Famer, and if there’s any logic to the company’s selection process, he’ll be inducted within the next couple of years.
Despite all his success, Christian’s WWE career wasn’t quite as glorious as it should have been. Like his partner Edge, he was the total package of charisma, mic skills, and wrestling ability, but he was never able to ascend to the same heights, and was let go from the company in 2005.
Christian signed with TNA, and soon became one of the company’s franchise players. He finally started fulfilling his main event potential without the WWE machine behind him, regularly headlined pay-per-views, and became a two-time TNA Heavyweight Champion. Simply put, Christian actively enhanced TNA’s product by appearing on their shows, and it soon became apparent that his WWE release was a huge mistake.
He eventually returned to WWE, and while Christian has two World Heavyweight Title reigns to his name, both were disappointing. Had WWE retained him in 2005, Christian could have become just as important to the company as Edge was. Instead, he’ll forever live in his former tag partner’s shadow.
2. Kenny Omega
It took him a long time to reach the top, but Kenny Omega is rightly regarded as one of the best wrestlers in the world at the moment. Nobody outside WWE has more buzz than Omega, and while he declined the opportunity to rejoin the company at the start of the year, there’s a decent chance he’ll do a U-turn when his NJPW contract expires in 2018, following in AJ Styles’ footsteps as a top-level WWE star.
Omega was only under WWE contract for a brief period of time, and left the company’s Deep South Wrestling developmental territory in 2006. He was highly critical of the standard of training he’d received during his run with the company, particularly from Bob Holly and Bill DeMott, leading to him eventually requesting his release, and rejoining the independent ranks.
There's no way WWE could have been expected to foresee Omega's meteoric rise, particularly in the last couple of years, and there's a strong chance he wouldn't have developed in the same way had he stayed in the company's rigid developmental system. In hindsight, however, WWE still let a future megastar slip through their fingers, whether they realised it at the time or not.
1. Hulk Hogan
Had Hulk Hogan not signed for WCW in 1994, there’s a strong chance the Monday Night Wars would never have happened. His heel turn and subsequent union with Kevin Nash and Scott Hall as the New World Order was vital in turning the tides in WCW’s favour and securing 84 weeks of consecutive ratings dominance. They were the catalyst, and while Hogan remains a controversial and divisive WCW figure, his turn was perfectly executed.
WWE initially released Hogan in 1993. His superhero babyface act had run its course, and by the time he robbed Yokozuna of the WWE Championship at King of the Ring, much of the audience were sick of him. Vince McMahon reportedly told Hogan that he wanted to push younger, more dynamic wrestlers ahead of him, and decided it wasn't worth matching Ted Turner's giant contract offer to retain 'The Hulkster.'
In retrospect, it would have been worth keeping hold of Hulk just to spite the competition. WWE were in deep trouble as WCW surged ahead of them, and much of this could have been avoided had Hogan not defected. They eventually won the war, and Hogan returned to the company, but while retaining Hulk would have likely created its own set of problems, much hardship could have been avoided if he wasn't let go.