10 Wrestlers WWE Should Have Pushed More

With the benefit of hindsight...

By John Cunningham /

Picture this: You hit the weights, you bust your hump at wrestling school, you’re bruised from the bumps and running the ropes, you work and travel and hone your craft, you hit the big leagues but that mythical brass ring doesn’t quite find you.

For every mega star the WWE has produced, the next 50 or so fall under the above. Near every wrestler has been dead set on grabbing a World title and a main event push at some point in their career. While many are ill-fitting for such responsibilities, others are frustratingly perfect for a mountaintop they never get to climb.

A litany of fan favourites, workhorses and prodigious talents have failed to completely ascend the sports entertainment mountain over the years. The reasons have ranged from the petty and the political to just plain bad luck. In more recent times, many would argue WWE's inexplicable need to meddle with winning formulas is a key cause.

Advertisement

Like, say, changing a beloved indie king and all round ring general's name to that of either the coffee guy from Friends or a Nazi, depending on who one asks...

10. Zack Ryder

Zack Ryder was a pioneer of self-promotion and using social media to get oneself over during the late noughties to early 2010s period. His YouTube channel turned him, a mere jobber on the barely watched WWE reboot of ECW, into a beloved fan favourite.

Advertisement

As 2011 rolled in, it was clear fans wanted to see 'The Long Island Iced-Z' enjoy a well-deserved bump up the card. Initially, it appeared WWE had taken the 'We Want Ryder' chants seriously. They gradually repackaged him as a fiery underdog and did away with the ludicrous one-leg-in-tights-one-leg-bare attire.

His US title win over Dolph Ziggler at TLC 2011 seemingly solidified Ryder as a star with a high ceiling. Many were asking if Ryder could one day become a true superstar in the promotion.

Nope.

Ryder became a hapless pawn in John Cena's career-worst feud against Kane in early 2012. Ryder lost his US belt and watched on as his "girlfriend" Eve Torres made out with (the then-married) Cena.

The former Edgehead then went from low to low, including a chumpifying low blow from Torres at WrestleMania XXVIII. Bar a miraculous Intercontinental Title win at WrestleMania XXXII (which ended the next night), Ryder was buried into oblivion for the rest of his WWE run.

His rebirth as the obsequious "ex-WWE star" Matt Cardona in GCW and IMPACT has proven how entertaining he can be. Given his charisma, phenomenal conditioning and zero issues doing business, the mind boggles at to why WWE threw him under a bus.

9. Curt Hennig

Considering he went by the name Mr Perfect, anything less than the main event looks like a bust. Everyone from Bret Hart to Hulk Hogan to Brock Lesnar has praised Curt Hennig and his near superhuman abilities in all areas of pro wrestling.

Advertisement

The AWA main eventer jumped ship to the burgeoning WWF in 1988. Impressed by Hennig's all-round talent and heel promo chops, McMahon and co. repackaged him as Mr Perfect, an obnoxious super athlete. The son of Larry 'The Axe' Hennig quickly got under WWF fans' skin with his overwhelming arrogance, amusing sports-based vignettes and undefeated streak.

Despite endless rumours of a full-on main event push, Hennig never won the big one in the WWF. Beyond infamously destroying Hulk Hogan's WWF Championship during their 1989-1990 feud, Hennig rarely got all that near to the top of the mountain.

Instead, he had his winning streak shattered by Brutus 'The Barber' Beefcake before moving into the Intercontinental Championship picture. Given his talent, track record as a main event champ in AWA and crowd heat, Hennig could've been a perfect top heel titleholder for the WWF. He would've been the total package as an arch villain for babyfaces like Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior to try and take down.

While his run leading up to his unfortunate back injury in 1991 was hugely entertaining, it was never allowed to reach the peak it should have.

8. Christian

There's just something off about Christian's appearance, at least, that is, according to Vince McMahon. At one point in the early 2000s, McMahon apparently even considered censoring Edge's brother's face for reasons presumably only he knew. Needless to say, Christian rarely got the superstar treatment during his WWE tenures.

Advertisement

Bar a brief 2004 push derailed by injury and a fun feud with John Cena in '05, Christian's singles run after splitting from Edge in '01 was strictly midcard. His subsequent work in TNA, however, proved just how good he could be on top. As both a babyface and heel, Christian Cage delivered the goods with action-packed matches, heated feuds and first class promos.

It was a stark departure from the jobber to the stars he'd become in his final months with WWE. Carrying himself with poise and confidence, the leader of The Christian Coalition became TNA's top heel through late '06 and '07 and was a consistent highlight of every show he was on.

When rumours surfaced of a 2009 return to WWE, fans were elated. What followed was hugely disappointing. Christian languished in ECW for years and, beyond two painfully brief runs (one was just two days) with the World Heavyweight Championship in 2011, never got anywhere near the top of the card.

Considering his versatile character work, sound in-ring psychology, technical prowess and consistent crowd connection, Christian was criminally wasted by WWE across two lengthy spells with the promotion.

7. Charlie Haas

Charlie Haas seemingly had all the tools to be a somebody in WWE. He had a respectable collegiate wrestling background, was in good shape and, as his work in 2008 revealed, could be absolutely hilarious.

Advertisement

His tag team with Shelton Benjamin and work with Kurt Angle during The Ruthless Aggression Era was great. Many saw both him and Benjamin as future singles stars. 2004's Draft Lottery split the pair up, providing a glimmer of hope that that stardom prediction was about to pan out.

For Haas, it actually meant pottering about in a goofy love triangle angle with Jackie Gayda and Dawn Marie. From there, the Seton Hall University standout didn't even find himself in midcard purgatory so much as dark match hell, a scary place from which many fade away.

An '07 reunion with Shelton Benjamin offered a fleeting hope before it was quietly forgotten in November. In 2008, Haas started getting over quickly with an incredibly silly impressionist gimmick. While rumours abounded that it was given to him as some kind of backstage political punishment, the former WWE Tag Team Champion revealed some serious comedic chops.

Audiences got a good laugh out of his spoofing of other wrestlers. While the gimmick didn't scream main event, it had plenty left in the tank when it was unceremoniously dropped in 2009. Haas spent the rest of his time in WWE looking at the lights. It's hard to even say just how high his ceiling was given he was barely allowed off the ground.

6. Rob Van Dam

Mr Monday Night (or Tuesday depending on the year) was a dependable crowd-pleaser for decades. His flashy blend of strong style, martial arts-based offence with reckless high flying was endlessly entertaining. Unfortunately, working a dangerous pace is, well, dangerous and, upon joining the WWF in '01, RVD was frequently in the dog house for busting people open the hard way.

Advertisement

In the safer-worked years that followed, the longtime fan favourite often lacked much mic time and mostly hopped between midcard title scenes. Upon returning from a career-threatening knee injury in '06, WWE finally committed to giving him a WWE (and ECW) Championship run... for 22 days.

While a lengthy title reign was never on the cards, it was cut shorter still owing to the mountainous portion of drugs police found in his and Sabu's car one night. RVD was never a World champion in WWE again and left the following year.

While the setback that dwindled his main event run is on him, it's plain as day that Rob Van Dam could've entered the main event scene all the way back in 2002. Capable of great character work when given the actual time and space for it, RVD was horribly under-utilised throughout his initial WWE run.

5. Shelton Benjamin

One of the finest all-round athletes in professional wrestling history, Shelton Benjamin is arguably the greatest Money In The Bank ladder match performer ever. The fact he never managed to win the briefcase despite his sterling showings sums up his ultimately disappointing runs in WWE perfectly.

Advertisement

After splitting from tag partner Charlie Haas in 2004, Benjamin's solo work on RAW got off to a good start with surprise pinfall victories over Triple H and Ric Flair. What stood out the most was how convincing Benjamin was a threat to two of the best to ever do it. Between his legit athlete credibility, technical prowess and explosive intensity, he looked like a top dog in waiting. He netted the Intercontinental Championship before the year was over and had gotten increasingly over with fans.

While Benjamin wasn't exactly The Rock on the microphone, he had a down-to-earth charm that made him easy to root for as a hard-grafting, slightly old-fashioned babyface. His main event potential was showcased further in 2005 with blistering bouts against Shawn Michaels and Kurt Angle. Given his hard-hitting, crisp offence, audience connection and explosively scary high risk gimmick match work, Benjamin was a main event-calibre wrestler.

As much of a crowdpleaser as he was, it became clear the top brass didn't see Benjamin as a potential headliner. In the years after his acclaimed first IC title run, the former NCAA All American remained strictly midcard, drifting through some ill-advised heel personas and secondary title runs.

4. Dolph Ziggler

As the late noughties rolled in, WWE became more and more guilty of a bizarre booking issue. When it came to potential new stars, the promotion would often start pushing them, stop completely and then, with less crowd interest, resume said push. Rinse and repeat.

Advertisement

There have been few bigger victims of this counter-productive practise than Dolph Ziggler. 'The Showoff' was seemingly tailor made to be a heel main eventer. He has some legit athlete cred thanks to his collegiate wrestling days and is a superb athlete who bumps and sells masterfully. He is also incredibly smug and annoying on the mic. The multi-time Intercontinental Champion likely could've been a great top champion who could make babyfaces look good in both victory and defeat.

Instead, beyond a brief babyface World title run that was wrecked by Jack Swagger's boot (and that strange episode of Smackdown where he was handed the World Heavyweight Title only to lose it to Edge), Ziggler never reached the top. He has spent most of his career bumping hard and ceiling-staring instead.

While he does a good job of making his opponents look good, it's clear Ziggler was cut out for much more than tagging aimlessly with Robert Roode (someone else who definitely could've done more, incidentally). In 2022, it's clear Ziggler's day in the sun will likely never come. It's an unfortunate waste of a solid all-round talent. Perhaps he was right some of those countless times he said it should've been him.

3. Ernie Ladd

This American football star-turned professional wrestling menace was a colossal heat magnet throughout the '70s. One of the first ever African American heels, the trailblazing Ladd cut to the heart of the matter with brutally insensitive, trash talk-laden promos and antics.

Advertisement

The politically incorrect 'Big Cat' employed a host of astoundingly unlikable character traits to further crank up the crowd's hatred. One such classic was to simply call it quits and leave when an opponent was getting the better of him. Ladd would take the count-out loss over a potential pinfall as the ferocious fans (seriously, the crowds from the good old kayfabe-focused days are just brutal) avalanched him with jeers.

Another common trope from the big man was his recurring issues with incredibly questionable "injuries". His subsequent complaints of the pain he was in, normally just in time for a match-up with a babyface out to humble him, only served to tick viewers off all the more.

While Ernie Ladd was a respectable star during his time in the WWWF, he was never fully given the ball to roll with. Had he been the promotion's top heel, he would've been the perfect nemesis for the wholesome Bob Backlund during his title reign. While the imposing Ladd did work some title bouts with the man who's never eaten marijuana, an extended blood feud never came. Sadly for 'Big Cat', an extended run at the top never came at all.

Given his charisma, hulking presence and explosive, highly influential character work, Ladd deserved more.

2. Razor Ramon

Scott Hall was a hot prospect long before his Cuban gangster days. In the AWA, the future nWo villain was considered the next big thing. While that didn't pan out on account of AWA's slow, painful death and Hall's disdain for cold weather, it was plain as day he was a star to watch.

Advertisement

Inspired by Brian De Palma's 1983 gangster epic Scarface, Hall reinvented himself as Razor Ramon upon joining the WWF in 1992. 'The Bad Guy' was an immediate hit with fans and moved up the card as a cool heel. By '93, the endlessly quotable Ramon (thanks to Al Pacino's Tony Montana character being endlessly quotable) turned babyface and received big reactions everywhere he went.

The much-maligned New Generation Era was in full swing by this point. While legends like Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels lit the ring up, the creative direction of the WWF proved off-putting for many. With childish angles and a lack of larger-than-life personalities, ratings and mainstream appeal fell a long way from the promotion's '80s glory.

Razor Ramon was an exception: a colourful wrestler with some dazzling moves and a solid audience connection. Despite being a prominent character, Ramon was never considered for a proper run on top, even as notably less over wrestlers like his buddy Diesel floundered in the main event scene.

Instead, Ramon was trapped in ludicrous feuds with the likes of Goldust and a diaper-wearing 1-2-3 Kid. To the surprise of no one, Hall eventually jumped ship to WCW.

1. Ken Shamrock

WCW went to great efforts to convince their fans that Goldberg was an unstoppable shooter no one could hang with in the late '90s. For WWF, there was a much easier route to go in producing such a character. Ken Shamrock, an MMA pioneer and the UFC's first real draw, joined the promotion in 1997.

Advertisement

After a decent start and skull-crackingly stiff showdown with Vader, Shamrock spent the rest of his run firmly in the midcard. Despite being a solid talent in the ring with an unsurprisingly menacing exterior, the ankle lock maestro never quite landed the big push Attitude Era icons like Steve Austin, The Rock and Triple H did.

Worse still, the tough guy was set up with doomed to fail storylines like having a hot sister he had to guard from lusty wrestlers. As is nearly always the case with WWF/E angles involving fake siblings, there was a strange incestuous overtone to make it all just that much more frivolous.

By mid-'99, Shamrock had quite understandably had enough of being presented as a goof and went back to MMA. As a heel, he would've been a convincingly murderous brute for Steve Austin to overcome. As a face, he could've been a bad-ass antihero butting heads with Triple H and Mr McMahon. Instead, he was never quite booked to be on the level.

A colossal waste of what could've been a one-of-a-kind character at the time.

Advertisement