10 Wrestling Books That Proved Seriously Controversial

These books divided the opinions of fans and wrestlers alike.

By Adrian Bishop /

Though less frequent these days, for a time around the turn of the millennium it became common for wrestlers to produce a book detailing their lives, with the efforts that followed comprising various qualities, to say the least.

Advertisement

The massive success of Mick Foley's Have a Nice Day: A Tale of Blood and Sweatsocks, that saw the hardcore legend discuss his life and career, eventually reached number one on the New York Times Best Seller List, and led to a trend of wrestlers detailing their career experiences in literary form.

However, what made Foley's first effort so compelling was his talent as a writer, as he authored the entire book in longhand without the help of a ghostwriter.

Foley's epic debut set a bar that few titles that followed would even come close to matching, with some his contemporaries relying heavily on ghostwriters, and their memoirs often suffering as a result.

The often raw nature of autobiographies, with subjects laying bare their true feelings and opinions, means the books can prove highly controversial and draw the ire of fellow performers and fans alike. That is even truer in an industry famous for keeping its secrets.

10. Steve Williams - How Dr. Death Became Dr. Life

To newer fans, Steve Williams is primarily known for being something of a failed experiment in the WWF. He was brought in by Jim Ross, who was a huge admirer of Williams for his tenure as a collegiate football player at Ross' beloved University of Oklahoma, and for his time competing in All Japan Pro Wrestling.

Advertisement

Unfortunately, Williams was debuted in the ill-fated Brawl for All, and despite his amateur wrestling background making him one of the favourites to win the shoot fighting competition, he would be unceremoniously knocked out by eventual winner Bart Gunn.

After being diagnosed with, and recovering from, throat cancer in 2004, Williams wrote an autobiography chronicling his life in both wrestling and gridiron.

What makes Williams' memoir worthy of a place on this list, is a legendary story told by Luke Gallows, who details being chewed out for ostensibly refusing to take a test on the book by John Laurinaitis.

9. The Rock - The Rock Says...

As previously stated, the success of Mick Foley's first written effort led to a public clamouring for more memoirs from active wrestlers. So, who better to detail the events of their life than the silver-tongued most electrifying man in sports entertainment?

Advertisement

Unfortunately, the formula that Foley had struck gold on was not as simply repeatable as WWE believed. Despite being one of the biggest stars in the history of professional wrestling, The Rock's first attempt at an autobiography certainly did not strike the same chord as his former tag team partner's, perhaps because at this time, his career in the wrestling business had not been nearly as varied and tumultuous as Foley's.

The book veers in an out of kayfabe in a pretty confusing ride, with the second half reading like the ghostwriter stepping aside allowing The Rock to cut an in-character sub-par promo for 100 or so pages

8. Shawn Michaels - Heartbreak And Triumph

It's fair to say that while Shawn Michaels' talents in the ring are pretty universally acclaimed, his exploits behind the curtain during his run as a singles performer in the WWF proved divisive, to say the least.

Advertisement

With that being said, with his redemption arc and return to the company completed, 2005 seemed like the perfect time for HBK to offer some insights on both his incredible career and polarising backstage behaviour in a memoir.

The problem is, while Heartbreak And Triumph certainly isn't full of grammatical errors or outright mistruths as many of its contemporaries on this list, it fails to scratch the surface of Michaels' life in the '90s.

A repeated theme throughout the book is HBK's aversion to taking accountability for his actions, instead repeatedly offering explanations about how infamous incidents of his misbehaviour were mere misunderstandings. Even his admission of his role in the Montreal Screwjob follows the same pattern of pointing fingers and shifting blame.

7. Hulk Hogan - Hollywood Hulk Hogan

Hulk Hogan's reputation as someone who isn't afraid to assert his own importance is a justified one, that is if his writing is anything to go by. Unlike many of the would-be authors on this list, Hogan is something of a prolific writer, with more than one autobiography to his name.

Advertisement

The Hulkster's first literary effort is the one that takes pride of place on this list though and for good reason. The book is written in character, meaning that not a paragraph goes by without repeated superfluous usage of the word "brother", and deserves an award for somehow containing some of the most childish writing to feature on this list.

Despite his unquestionable impact on pop culture, throughout the book, Hogan regularly seems determined only to elevate his status through his writing, and despite the apparent best efforts of its ghostwriter, the book still manages to get basic facts like the year of Andre the Giant's death incorrect.

Hogan's book isn't as much controversial as it is just a waste of time, particularly for someone who really does have a story to tell.

6. Justin Roberts - Best Seat In The House

The most recent entry on this list, Justin Roberts' autobiography provides a perspective on the trials and tribulations of serving as a ring announcer in WWE.

Advertisement

One of the best-written books to feature on this list, Roberts chronicles that toxic backstage culture during his time in the company, and the way that he was treated by his employers and some of his coworkers.

Despite not being the biggest star in his own right, Roberts' book holds its own alongside the wrestlers' accounts of their storied careers by being much franker and matter-of-fact about events that took place, without needing to seem like he is trying to stay on good terms with anyone.

Roberts also details his relationship with the late Connor Michalek, a young WWE fan suffering from terminal cancer. Roberts explains his belief that WWE used their philanthropy towards Michalek primarily as a method of getting positive PR, and accused the company of cutting his close relationship with the deceased child out of their revised version of events.

5. Chyna - If They Only Knew

The tumultuous life of Joanie Laurer following her release from the WWE in 2001 has been well documented.

Advertisement

After Chyna became one of the biggest stars in the Attitude Era for her unprecedented size and charisma, her life post wrestling before her untimely death in 2016 is one of the most tragic tales to befall the sport in recent years.

Prior to her release from the WWE, Chyna co-authored a book on her career, that paints a pretty depressing picture of the now-Hall of Famer's life, particularly in retrospect. Chyna details her various failures before venturing into the squared circle, all in a rather depressing manner as she discusses her fear of fading into obscurity.

The title also drew some controversy due to some of Chyna's disdainful comments about those working outside of the wrestling business, including referring to actress Sarah Jessica Parker as "hospital-bed thin".

4. Vince Russo - Forgiven

As controversial a character as they come in wrestling, it shouldn't be particularly surprising that Vince Russo's 2005 autobiography found its way onto this list. Russo is a seminal figure in the transition period wrestling went through in the late '90s and deserves credit for some of his work as a writer, but the New Yorker's disdain for convention in wrestling has always made him a contentious figure inside the industry.

Advertisement

The book takes the form of a kind of therapy, wherein Russo reflects on a particularly vitriolic manuscript he had written before converting to Christianity and discusses how he now feels differently on some of his decisions.

However, much like Shawn Michaels, Russo repeatedly appears incapable of admitting responsibility for his actions throughout his memoir and instead often doubles down on some of his most controversial decisions, including the making the Oklahoma character mock Jim Ross' Bell's palsy on television.

3. Jackie Pallo - You Grunt, I'll Groan

For those that weren't already aware, a professional wrestling boom was taking place in Britain concurrent to the rise of the WWF in America, though, for the most part, the sport was presented in an entirely different and unique way with weight classes and bouts divided into boxing-like rounds.

Advertisement

Despite this, it is worth noting that by the 1980s the viewing audience in the UK was already aware of the predetermined nature of the bouts.

So when Jackie Pallo, an established in-ring attraction in the British scene, famed for his rivalry with Mick McManus wrote a tell-all autobiography in 1986, he wasn't exactly pulling back the curtain to the viewing audience. However, that doesn't mean that the memoir didn't get some serious heat among his colleagues, many of whom felt that Pallo had exposed the business.

Pallo also stated his growing contempt for the state of the wrestling in the UK at that time, feeling that Shirley 'Big Daddy' Crabtree and his promoter brother Max were killing the art by incorporating too many American influences.

2. Ric Flair - To Be The Man

Unlike many of the books on this list, Ric Flair's ghostwritten autobiography isn't poorly written, nor is it a boring read. In fact, To Be the Man is a fascinating tale of one of wrestling's most storied performers and unlike many of the WWE-produced titles on this list, does not hold back in discussing some of the debauchery surrounding Flair's younger life.

Advertisement

However, To Be the Man earned its place on this list for Flair's penchant for taking shots at his fellow athletes, including a tirade claiming that Bret Hart was too formulaic in his wrestling and that he was not a draw during his time as WWF Champion in the '90s.

Most famously, Flair referred to Mick Foley as a "glorified stuntman" and compared Foley's ability as a worker to the likes of Brutus Beefcake and the Ultimate Warrior.

The feud between the two men would spill over backstage at RAW in 2004 where Flair reportedly punched Foley after Foley had refused to shake Flair's hand due to his comments.

1. Diana Hart - Under The Mat

Unquestionably the most controversial book featured on this list, Diana Hart's 2001 memoir Under The Mat was so contentious that legal action was pursued by Owen Hart's widow in response to the claims made about her family throughout.

Advertisement

As the youngest daughter of Stu Hart and ex-wife of Davey Boy Smith, Diana had certainly spent enough time around the wrestling industry to warrant writing a book on her experiences, but the resulting work serves only to highlight the divisions that existed within wrestling's most famous family following the tragic death of Owen.

The book not only contains a litany of grammatical errors but also has been criticised for including a fictionalised version of events that have been rubbished by those involved.

Diana has disowned the book in recent years and claimed that she wishes it had never been written, but the damage is already done. The title ultimately offers more of an insight into the motivations of Diana herself at that time, rather than a serious account of the family.

Advertisement