10 Wrestling Gimmicks That Got Out Of Control
Enjoy in moderation.
Wrestling gimmicks, by their very nature, are over the top.
That's often true from the off, but it's also true that even the most vibrant characters can spin out of control to the point of excess or end up being a noose around a wrestler's neck. When this happens, somebody needs to stop, look around them and say, 'Alright, it's time to reel this in a bit'. Of course, the always-on nature of the business means that rarely happens.
No, promotions and workers are more likely to push and push and push, desperately trying to rekindle lost glories or squeeze just one last bit of magic from their creations. That's usually when things go wrong and gimmicks end up being parodies more than natural progressions of a winning idea.
There's a saturation point, even in a biz as wacky as pro wrestling. Fans can only be expected to stomach so much silliness before they're the ones asking to rein things in, not the folks responsible.
Every single gimmick listed here took things too far. By the time they realised, it was probably too late...
10. Goldust
The original Goldust gimmick was brilliant.
Dustin Rhodes' androgynous movie statuette was unique, and it helped reshape WWF culture in the mid-'90s by introducing a character unafraid to confront controversy or make people feel uncomfortable. Within three years of his debut though, Goldust was taking things way too far.
Rhodes repeatedly tried to shock for the sake of it rather than doing his original mannerisms well. By the time he morphed into the green/pink/purple/blue/red/silver/literally any other colour than gold monstrosity that was 'The Artist Formerly Known As' Goldust, that eye-catching controversy was lost.
At one point (as the rumours go), Dustin even wanted breast implants to stun people further, but Vince McMahon wasn't having any of it. It was almost sad to watch a great performer push the envelope to little success, and it's remarkable that somebody so lost in the late-'90s is still smashing it in AEW today.
9. Val Venis
One might argue that a wrestling porn star is already out of control, but Val Venis did have his place in the raunchy 'Attitude' era amidst other cartoonish horn-dogs like The Godfather. Crucially, everybody's favourite grappling pimp (?!) kept things simple.
Venis, meanwhile, did not.
The WWF blatantly ran out of ideas for Val and looked to capitalise on real-world events as a short-term fix to make him relevant. Five years on from sensationalist headlines about John's Bobbitt wife cutting off his willy, the company decided to have Japanese faction Kaientai kidnap a helpless Venis and lop off his money-maker too.
This was obviously a step too far and did nothing for Val as a character. He then revealed that his penis was safely attached and moved on to a fake pregnancy story with Terri Runnels and Goldust instead. Everything just felt so forced, and more than a little crass.
8. Diesel & Razor Ramon
Right, here's the deal: Imagine WWE had debuted a new indy wrestler as "Dean Ambrose" when the real one left the company and showed up in AEW as Jon Moxley. The entire wrestling world would've (rightly) laughed at this, and it's an absurd scenario to even type in 2020.
Back in 1996 though, someone had the bright idea to take the popular Diesel and Razor Ramon characters left behind by Kevin Nash and Scott Hall and pin them on two guys who weren't WCW's new Outsiders. It was ridiculous, and it made both Glenn Jacobs and Rick Bognar look like absolute idiots.
They were cosplay clowns, not cosplay kings.
This stupid move killed both gimmicks for good. How could Nash return as Diesel or Hall return as Razor without somebody bringing up these Halloween store knock offs for a giggle? WWE will never try this sh*t again. Ever.
7. Hell In A Cell
It might be heresy to some, but the first Hell In A Cell match between Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker remains better than the follow-up 'Taker vs. Mankind one at King Of The Ring 1998. The original was a pulsating bruiser of a brawl that mixed drama, fear and psychology to perfection.
Mick Foley knew following it would be impossible if he didn't take some huge risks. That's why he agreed to a scary bump off the top of the cage; the second one, which saw Mick chokeslammed through the Cell, was unplanned. Regardless, both bumps have become iconic, and that HIAC bout is one of the most talked-about matches ever.
It ruined the Cell gimmick forever though.
Fans expected death-defying stunts whenever the cage was lowered, and WWE stopped offering them after a few years of trying to top Mick's spectacular falls. That, along with the lack of blood and the fact it's now an annual pay-per-view, has destroyed HIAC's aura.
6. Finn Bálor's 'Demon'
This admission was the inspiration for this article.
New NXT Champ Finn Bálor told Digital Spy that he grew to lean on his off-shoot 'Demon' gimmick like a crutch whenever he was bereft of ideas. Instead of being a sporadic sensation he could dust off to make major pay-per-view matches more exciting, it became a nuisance that he admits "spun out of control".
It's hard to argue against his point here. The 'Demon' played before diminishing returns the more and more Bálor used it. For proof, just check out the complete lack of excitement surrounding his SummerSlam 2017 match with Bray Wyatt, or even less thrills one year later against Baron Corbin on the same event in 2018.
The 'Demon' became a lazy way to frame Finn's feuds. He'd be up against it as plain old Bálor, then bust out the face paints to roar back at opponents and put them in their place. Rinse and repeat. Rinse and repeat. Rinse. And. Repeat.
5. Oklahoma
Ed Ferrara's Oklahoma was awful to begin with, but it might not be remembered as much had it been a one-off promo on some random Nitro that gave Ed and Vince Russo a laugh. If they'd stopped there, and actually got on with the task of making WCW money (like they were hired to do), then this entry wouldn't exist.
It does, and it won't be kind to Ferrara or Russo.
They needlessly parodied a genuine illness Jim Ross was suffering from. Slaughtering a beloved announcer for having Bell's Palsy was not cool, and they senselessly wasted valuable Monday night airtime on TNT. Then, the pair encroached on the Cruiserweight division's purpose by putting that high-flying belt around OK's waist.
Their power-trip went too far, and nobody stepped up to stop them. Oklahoma was a character so counter-productive that it should always be considered one of the thickest decisions any wrestling writer has ever made. The fact he won a title is painful.
4. Mr. McMahon
The evil, despotic Mr. McMahon persona was wrestling's best heel during the late-'90s.
Whether he was suffering through Steve Austin's rebellion or attempting to rule Raw with an iron fist, McMahon was essential. His matches against Austin, Triple H, Hulk Hogan and others, whilst over-the-top, were some of the most high-profile memories of a generation. Then, things got super-silly.
By 2006, Vince was literally booking himself against "God" on pay-per-view, and he ended up running around with the ECW World Title the following year. These hijinks were in-keeping with McMahon's OTT approach, but they were often watered-down rehashes of his power madness or 'Boss vs. Rebel' successes against Austin.
Bobby Lashley, for example, was not 'Stone Cold', and the whole "God" business opposite Shawn Michaels achieved little other than irking the religious community. It was clear by '06 that fans had tired of McMahon's routine, but he kept trying to out-do himself.
3. 'Loose Cannon' Brian Pillman
Brian Pillman brought a gun to a fist fight.
This writer will always maintain that his handgun angle had no place on WWF television. Yes, it's still talked about today, and sure, it did get fans talking at the time because of how wild it was, but it was never going to be topped. Think of it this way: Pillman vs. Steve Austin in any kind of wrestling match wasn't going to beat Bri trying to shoot his old tag partner.
When things escalate to the point of gun violence, they've generally gone as far as they can go. In movies, nobody says, 'Man, you tried to shoot me - now let's have a dust up with rules!'. All bets are off as soon as bullets fly, but not in the world of pro wrestling.
This gun-related nonsense was Pillman's 'Loose Cannon' gimmick going too far. It was hard for the writers to pen a more memorable twin chapter, and it made most other cartoonish fare on Raw look boring, unrealistic and second-rate.
2. The New World Order
The Four Horsemen worked because it felt like an exclusive club (despite having many incarnations over the years, the group was often small), and The Shield bulldozed though WWE for years because three men made their presentation easy to follow. Meanwhile, the nWo had 62 members between 1996-2002.
Sixty two!
Eric Bischoff's genius takeover storyline started with Scott Hall, Kevin Nash and Hulk Hogan, then quickly started to branch off into other 'B' factions, spin-offs in New Japan and various failed resurrections. Things got silly, and the once-proud gimmick was watered down terribly just a few years into its run.
The phrase "strength in numbers" didn't apply here - the nWo was actually weaker for carting along members like Vincent, Horace Hogan, Brian Adams and other low-to-mid carders. WCW's attempt to branch them off into a separate show also flopped before it really got started.
1. Kane
As a counterpoint to The Undertaker, Kane was stunning.
The initial story was outlandish (a burned younger brother was returning to avenge his dead parents), but it followed a neat sibling vs. sibling formula and gave 'Taker another monster to war with. Unfortunately, WWE tampered with Kane's backstory to the point that it became comical.
He was badly scarred, then he wasn't. He couldn't talk without the aid of a voice box, then he could. The Undertaker had murdered their parents, then he hadn't. Paul Bearer was a family friend, then he was their father. Kane didn't undergo painful burn treatments as a youth, he dated a girl called Katie Vick and killed her by drink-driving.
See? It's too much. WWE even added a splash of necrophilia to the party in 2002 by alleging that Kane had molested Vick's corpse. Then, for better or worse, he was reborn under the mask, formed several 'odd couple' tag-teams, is now mayor of Knox County, Tennessee and... returns as his old self when convenient.
-
What other wrestling gimmicks do you think spun out of control? For more, check out 10 Gimmicks That WWE Dropped Without Explanation and 10 Things You Learn Binge Watching Every WWE Raw From 1996!