10 WWE Careers That Flatlined After WrestleMania
Those talents whose WWE career nose-dived after WrestleMania.
Since its inception in 1985, WrestleMania has so often been utilised as the place where genuine superstars are made.
With a major win or a whole-hearted performance on the Grandest Stage of Them All, a talent can take their stock to an entirely new level as they cement themselves as a serious player within the world of WWE.
Think Bret Hart at WrestleMania VIII, think Steve Austin at WrestleMania 13, think Edge at WrestleMania 22, think Bianca Belair at WrestleMania 37. All four of those contests cemented the names involved as stars who were on their way to becoming mainstays of the main event scene.
While Hart, Austin, Edge, and Belair all flourished at and after those respective 'Manias, there have been plenty of other wrestlers whose careers have plummeted in the aftermath of the Showcase of the Immortals. Some of those stars have managed to eventually bounce back in WWE or found success in other promotions, but others have struggled to ever get their career back on track following a WrestleMania outing.
To be specific, this is only about a talent's time in WWE. With that in mind, here, then, are ten such wrestlers whose time with the market leader was only on a downward slope once WrestleMania was in the rear-view mirror.
10. Crush - WrestleMania X
Brian Adams had so many of the attributes that will forever get Vince McMahon tight in the pants. As in, he was a big, powerful fella with a great look and who would pass the famed airport test.
The fact that McMahon made Crush the third member of the iconic Demolition should indicate how strongly the talent was thought of, and even as 'Kona' Crush it looked as if the powerhouse was being groomed to be a main event player.
In an actually nicely done heel turn, late '93 saw Crush return to TV with his Tribal Hawaiian heel persona. There, he immediately targeted Randy Savage, claiming Savage was responsible for a back injury the star had suffered when trying to slam Yokozuna earlier in the year. The logic was, Savage encouraged Crush to slam Yoko, and thus the Macho Man was to blame for the injury suffered by the former Demolition man.
This issue culminated at WrestleMania X, where Crush and Savage did battle in a slightly bizarre Falls Count Anywhere 60 Second Count contest. For all the world, it seemed as if Crush would get the win here, giving him a huge win on a huge stage against a huge legend of the industry.
Instead, Macho Man won that bout, and Crush would spend the rest of the year working squash matches on WWF Superstars and Wrestling Challenge.
An early '95 arrest and subsequent jail stint did Brian Adams no favours, and his return in 1996 and roles in the Nation of Domination and Disciples of Apocalypse likewise did nothing for the big man.
9. Tazz - WrestleMania 2000
2000 started oh so well for Tazz, with the Human Suplex Machine making his surprise WWE debut at that year's Royal Rumble, where he clinically choked out the then-undefeated Kurt Angle. Sure, he'd needlessly had an extra Z added to his long-time moniker, but having Tazz arrive in such a manner surely boded well for the Red Hook native's WWE future.
Bafflingly, that spectacular debut meant nothing, and Tazz found himself in a 15-man Battle Royal for the Hardcore Championship at WrestleMania 2000.
While Tazz would get another brief run with the ECW World Title shortly after 'Mania, his WWE career was far less successful. As in, Tazz found himself feuding with Jim Ross and Jerry Lawler by the summer, and saw out the year as a mainstay of Jakked and Sunday Night Heat.
Injuries were the key factor in Tazz bringing an end to his in-ring career in 2002, but it's fair to say WWE creative didn't particularly help out the one-time Tazmaniac by having him feud with a couple of announcers shortly after his first WrestleMania appearance. Even worse, Tazz actually lost to the then-51-year-old Jerry Lawler at SummerSlam 2000 in the pair's first match-up.
8. Jack Swagger - WrestleMania 29
Things were looking up for Jack Swagger when he returned to WWE TV in 2013. After eight months away from action, the North Dakota native caused quite the stir when he turned up sporting longer hair, a beard, and soon with Zeb Coulter as his manager.
With a serious, aggressive edge to him, Swagger won the titular match at that year's Elimination Chamber PPV in order to earn himself a shot against Alberto Del Rio and the World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania 29. While he'd previously held Big Gold himself, this felt like an entirely new Jack Swagger, a more interesting Jack Swagger, and a more believable Jack Swagger.
Of course, the All-American American would come up short against Del Rio at 'Mania, and he soon went from WrestleMania World Title challenger to one half of a tag team. Sure, the pairing of Swagger and Cesaro was a fun one, but it represented a major step backwards for Jack when considering where he was positioned at the Showcase of the Immortals.
Once the Real Americans disbanded, Swagger became the same old bland, boring Swagger, with him spinning his wheels in forgettable matches and nothing rivalries until he left the company in March 2017.
7. Ivory - WrestleMania X-Seven
Heading into WrestleMania X-Seven, Ivory had held the company's Women's Title for 149 days. Unfortunately for the Right to Censor member, that reign would come to a crushing halt at the hands of Chyna in just two minutes and 38 seconds.
While it's great that Ivory is nowadays a WWE Hall of Famer, there's undoubtedly a sense that she's one of the more underrated female wrestlers in company history. For her time, Ivory was one of those who was far, far ahead of the vast majority of her peers when it came to in-ring work and cutting a promo.
Sadly, 'Mania X-Seven would be Ivory's one and only time in action at the Showcase of the Immortals, and that loss to the Ninth Wonder of the World led to the real-life Lisa Moretti dropping down the card.
In fact, despite remaining with WWE until 2005, the four years following WrestleMania X-Seven saw the talented star involved in nothing of note whatsoever, with Ivory being a brief part of the Alliance, and then serving as a trainer on Tough Enough and in the Ohio Valley Wrestling developmental territory.
6. Jim Neidhart - WrestleMania VII
As a tag team, the Hart Foundation remain one of the greatest tandems to ever lace up a pair of boots. Unfortunately for Jim Neidhart, the Anvil's career hit a major roadblock once the Foundation split after WrestleMania VII.
That particular Granddaddy of Them All saw Neidhart and Bret Hart drop the Tag Team Titles to the Nasty Boys, and soon the real-life brothers-in-law would go their separate ways. There was no betrayal, no screwjob, no rivalry. Instead, it was detailed how the Hart Foundation duo merely wanted to now test themselves as a singles star.
While the Hitman would win the Intercontinental Title from Mr. Perfect at SummerSlam just four months later, things didn't go as well for Big Jim. WrestleMania VII was followed by a couple of months of inactivity for Neidhart, and he'd close the year out back in the tag team ranks, teaming with Owen Hart as the New Foundation.
Despite having some promise, the New Foundation would break up in February '92 when Neidhart was fired for refusing to take a drug test. The powerhouse would then spend two years away from WWE before a brief return in 1994 as part of the phenomenal Owen and Bret feud, and his return in '97 as part of the Hart Foundation faction was great to see, but it's fair to say that Jim Neidhart's career - often down to his own decisions and actions - was an unfortunate disappointment post-WrestleMania VII.
5. King Kong Bundy - WrestleMania 2
To be honest, for a monster heel, the only way is down once you've main evented a WrestleMania with Hulk Hogan.
For King Kong Bundy, he was never going to top the steel cage match which closed out WrestleMania 2. This was at a time when it was all about bringing in oversized heels to put Hogan in peril, only for the Hulkster to eventually overcome the odds and get the big win over these brutes on the big stage.
Bundy was one of many to be put in this position, and he was one of many who was quickly moved back down the card, or even out of the company, once Hulk had got his win.
As for how his career dropped after WrestleMania 2, Bundy was placed in a tag team with with John Studd, before the following year's 'Mania had the giant team with midget wrestlers Little Tokyo and Lord Littlebrook.
Bundy would depart the then-WWF in 1988 and enter semi-retirement, although the New Jersey native would be brought back to the company in 1994 as part of Ted DiBiase's Million Dollar Corporation. And in revisiting the formula that worked so well for Hulkamania, Bundy would become another giant for the Undertaker to topple, losing to the Deadman at WrestleMania XI.
4. Rusev - WrestleMania 31
Oh, Rusev...
After a dominant spell in NXT, the Bulgarian Brute had quite an impressive start to life on the main roster. There, Rusev embarked on a lengthy undefeated streak that saw him capture the United States Title and even be the first person to submit John Cena in 11 years.
Surely, Rusev was a future main event star who would be winning World Championships for years to come. Only, of course, that never happened.
For Rusev, he ran up against Cena on the Grandest Stage of Them All, losing his United States Championship to Big Match John at WrestleMania 31. Looking even more like a total badass, Rusev entered that match in a f**king tank. Still, the nowadays Redeemer didn't have enough firepower to fend off John Cena at that 2015 edition of the Showcase of the Immortals.
With that loss, the bloom was off the rose for Rusev. The mystique was gone, the dominance was over, and Rusev quickly became just another guy on the roster.
Before you knew it, Rusev was involved in a bizarre love triangle - or should that be quadrilateral? - with Lana, Summer Rae and Dolph Ziggler, and then he was dumped into the League of Nations. While Rusev Day was admittedly a whole bunch of fun, Rusev's career was on a downward spiral after that WrestleMania 31 loss.
Still, at least Miro is now in AEW, where he'll surely be used as a top tier player, right... ?
3. Lex Luger - WrestleMania X
Truth be told, the wheels were well and truly falling off for Lex Luger following the events of SummerSlam '93, but the Total Package's WWE career was totally doomed once WrestleMania X was said and done.
Of course, 1993 had seen Luger become a flag-wearing, baby-kissing, all-smiling good guy after slamming Mr. Fuji's Yokozuna on the USS Intrepid. Having spent the summer touring the country in his Lex Express, the former Narcissist went up against Yoko for the WWF Title at the aforementioned SummerSlam. Bizarrely, Lex had a huge celebration just for beating Yokozuna by count-out, and that made him look like a bit of an idiot.
With Luger and Bret Hart co-winning the 1994 Royal Rumble, each man had their shot at the WWF Championship at WrestleMania X. That called for Bret to wrestle his brother Owen in a magical 'Mania opener, and the main event of the show would pit the Hitman against the winner of Luger vs. Yokozuna.
There, Lex would once again come up short, losing to the monstrous heel by DQ.
In having Bret Hart close out WrestleMania X on the shoulders of his peers as he held the WWF Title aloft, that signalled the end of the Lex Luger experiment. Rather than being the second coming of Hulk Hogan, brother, Luger instead dropped down the card, embarking on feuds with Crush and Tatanka before settling into the incredibly bland Allied Powers tag team with Davey Boy Smith.
Lex would famously return to WCW in September 1995, following a year of unforgettable dross post-'Mania X.
2. Ted DiBiase Jr. - WrestleMania XXVI
Here in 2023, it's crazy to think back to a time when Ted DiBiase Jr. was viewed as the breakout star of Legacy, with many believing that the group was to be used as a launching pad to superstardom for the son of the Million Dollar Man.
When Legacy imploded at WrestleMania XXVI, it seemed a given that Ted Jr. would be the one to emerge victorious over Randy Orton and Cody Rhodes. After all, Randy was a made man who didn't need the win here, and Cody Rhodes? Pfft, he didn't have a chance of becoming as big of a star as Ted DiBiase Jr. would become...
Oh, how hindsight is a wonderful thing.
Despite having a great physique, being solid in the ring, and having some charisma to him, things just never fully came together for the third-generation DiBiase. When looking at why it never happened for Ted Jr., being the one to lose that 'Mania match - taking an RKO from Orton before being pinned 1-2-3 - certainly plays a part.
With Legacy formally splitting, Ted soon found himself rehashing his old man's gimmick for a modernised version of the Million Dollar Man, complete with the Million Dollar Championship. Unfortunately for DiBiase Jr., this would be the only piece of gold he'd hold for the rest of his WWE run before that came to an end in 2013.
1. Bart Gunn - WrestleMania XV
For poor Bart Gunn, he was absolutely set up to fail at WrestleMania XV.
Having shocked WWE management by winning the infamous Brawl for All, Gunn's prize was a boxing match against legendary knockout artist Butterbean at the 1999 edition of the Showcase of the Immortals.
Of course, Butterbean is someone whose professional boxing record nowadays features a stagger 58 knockout victories. While Bart had shown his own knockout power against Bob Holly, Steve Williams, the Godfather and Bradshaw during the Brawl for All, putting him up against Butterbean was never going to end well for the former Smoking Gunn.
Many have claimed that Gunn was paired up with Butterbean as punishment for winning a tournament WWE never intended for him to win, with the company instead presuming that Steve Williams would win the tourney and then move into a feud with 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin. When Bart sparked out Dr. Death, that put an immediate halt to such plans.
Regardless of whether the Butterbean bout was indeed punishment or not, the result was Bart Gunn being KO'd after just 35 seconds.
In terms of the impact this 'Mania outing had for the WWE career of Bart Gunn, it would bring it to an immediate halt, with Bart soon departing the promotion and returning to All Japan Pro Wrestling.