10 WWE PPVs That Aren’t As Good As You Remember
Great matches? Sure. Great cards? Not so much.
Nostalgia is the single most powerful sensation one can feel when revisiting old footage on the WWE Network.
It can cloud things too - spend an evening trawling back down memory lane and you'll surely get that fuzzy, warm and content feeling, but one fan's old faves will be another's trash. Someone out there will view cards you've got so much affection for like gigantic snorefests that are only good for a match or two before moving on.
How dare they, right? Don't they know that every single bout on these shows should be treasured as a classic example of wrestling done right? When the nostalgia goggles are off, you'll see that isn't true. In fact, there are some cherished pay-per-view events from WWE history that don't hold up well at all when viewed from start to finish in 2020.
That's not to say these shows don't have merit, memorable matches or magic moments. They do, although that magic maybe isn't as abundant throughout the entirety of the broadcast as you remember, and that can come as a real shock to those who'd staunchly defend them...
10. ECW One Night Stand 2005
What You Remember: E-C-DUB! E-C-DUB! The chants, the atmosphere and the power of the original ECW were back in force for a night nobody could ever forget. This was Extreme done right, and it expertly married the majesty of Paul Heyman's original vision with superior WWE production.
Reality: Some will throw a tantrum over this one's inclusion, but it just doesn't hold up as well as one might expect 15 years on. There are a surprisingly lack of truly excellent matches, and they're all shorter than they seemed at the time (only two went longer than 10 minutes - hardly damning, but that definitely hurt the epic feel).
As much as the atmosphere, setting and production ruled, the in-ring action didn't. It was kinda' like a running commentary on ECW's strengths and weaknesses, actually. The original was hardly renowned for world class wrestling, and it relied heavily on crowd participation.
Interesting, but flawed.
9. King Of The Ring 2000
What You Remember: The WWF could do no wrong in 2000, and they delivered once again with a thumping King Of The Ring card that crowned Kurt Angle, featured the usual 'Attitude' razzmatazz and ended with a popular World Title change.
Oh yes, this was another winner for the fed.
Reality: Only it wasn't.
The bloom had come off the tournament rose long before 2000. KOTR was capable of producing big moments, but this was another example of the promotion's flat approach to tourneys. It didn't help that they booked that Hardcore Title 'Evening Gown' match too. Try watching that around non-fans!
Again, there's a startling lack of essential matches to feast one's eyes on. Even Jim Ross admitted on his 'Grilling JR' podcast that KOTR 2000 was nowhere near as good as he recalled when revisiting it for a quick recap.
8. Royal Rumble 1999
What You Remember: Austin vs. McMahon pinning down the titular Rumble, a super-violent 'I Quit' war between The Rock and Mankind, and heaps more of that winning 'Attitude' formula. The 1999 Rumble also starred Chyna as the first woman in history to enter the 30-person fray.
Reality: Everyone knew Austin vs. McMahon would dominate the Rumble; that wasn't a big problem due to the feud's electric feel, but it did stomp on the notion that "anyone can win". Outside of those two (and maybe a few credible stars like Triple H and Kane), there was a shocking lack of star power in the match.
The undercard, WWF Title bruiser aside, wasn't exactly a thrill ride either.
Big Boss Man vs. Road Dogg, Ken Shamrock vs. Billy Gunn, X-Pac vs. Gangrel and Sable vs. Luna Vachon all felt more Sunday Night Heat than 'Road To WrestleMania' pay-per-view quality. If you do revisit this one, skip everything but the 'I Quit' and final few minutes of the Rumble.
7. WrestleMania XIV
What You Remember: The Undertaker's first meeting with scorched brother Kane, Steve Austin's ascent to the summit of the industry, Mike Tyson socking Shawn Michaels post-title loss and more. It was WrestleMania XIV, and the WWF deemed it "The Greatest PPV Attraction Of All Time".
Reality: 'Mania XIV is only worth firing up on the Network to see Austin's win and Tyson's punch.
The high-flying Taka Michinoku vs. Aguila fare is something WCW were doing better with their Cruiserweight division, and other bouts like Triple H vs. Owen Hart, The Rock vs. Ken Shamrock and the Tag-Team Title 'Dumpster' match were average at best.
'Taker vs. Kane, at 17 minutes, was also a little too long. It was more build and spectacle than in-ring classic, to be fair, but shouldn't get a pass just because of that. When viewed in full, this WrestleMania just lacks so much grandeur and matches worth returning to.
6. Royal Rumble 1996
What You Remember: Following a dreadful 1995, the WWF started 1996 with a bang and Shawn Michaels' second consecutive Royal Rumble win. Elsewhere, The Undertaker and Bret Hart met in the main event, rising star Ahmed Johnson got to shine and bizarre newcomer Goldust creeped the hell out of Razor Ramon.
Reality: Literally nobody other than Michaels, the imposing Vader or maybe Owen Hart had a hope in hell of winning the Rumble. Drafted in hacks like Doug Gilbert, Dory Funk Jr, and The Squat Team filled space without much meaning, and it didn't help that Duke Droese was already penned in as a wobbly final entrant.
Ahmed's "shine" was scuffed by a disqualification result, Razor was clearly uncomfortable working with Goldust and the 'Taker vs. Bret headliner wasn't a patch on their later efforts at both SummerSlam 1997 and One Night Only that same year.
Not even HBK's heroics could save this one.
5. Survivor Series 1997
What You Remember: When yours truly was growing up in the 90s, literally everybody dubbed Survivor Series 1997 as a "must buy" VHS. After all, it was the site of an infamous 'Screwjob', featured Steve Austin's return from a serious neck injury and had four matches with that familiar, old-school team-based format.
Reality: Controversy aside, it's also a bad watch.
All four traditional Survivor Series bouts were functional at best and questionable at worst (The Truth Commission vs. The Disciples Of Apocalypse could be used as a torture device), Austin's revenge on Owen Hart was too short to satisfy and the main event is either awkward or boring as f*ck, depending on your point of view, to watch in 2020.
Even if you aren't sick of hearing about how Vince McMahon, Shawn Michaels and others conspired to screw Bret Hart out of the WWF Title before he left for WCW, it's still hard to sit through this event in full. Watch 'Wrestling With Shadows' for some juicy backstage stuff instead.
4. WrestleMania XXV
What You Remember: A bonafide classic between The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels. Face it, that's all anyone really cared about after this show was done, and it's perhaps the only reason WrestleMania XXV would get watched by younger fans intrigued by all the buzz today.
Reality: There's a reason for that.
'Taker vs. Michaels is one of the greatest wrestling matches of all time, and it should be watched at least once by every fan out there. Everything else though? Hmm, maybe not.
'Mania XXV only really has that storming classic to shout about. Watch from beginning to end and you'll see CM Punk getting some boos after winning MITB for a second year running (that ladder match is fun, admittedly), Santino Marella stomping all over the women's division in drag and Mickey Rourke looking like he'd rather be anywhere else.
You'll also see Matt and Jeff Hardy prove why they're better partners than opponents, an unspectacular Triple Threat for the World Title and a main event between Triple H and Randy Orton that ended the card on a low note.
3. SummerSlam 1992
What You Remember: The United Kingdom pines for a SummerSlam 1992 repeat so much that Queen Elizabeth II got "British Bulldog is gonna' win, whether he wants to or not" tattooed on her left thigh (that may not be true*).
Seriously though, the old Wembley Stadium rocked for a night that reaffirmed the WWF's power on an international stage. Plus, how could anyone forget that amazing main event pitting Bret Hart against brother-in-law Davey Boy Smith?
*definitely isn't true.
Reality: Hart vs. Bulldog was literally the only great match on a card littered with stuff that should've been on Wrestling Challenge or Superstars. For every Intercontinental Title main event, there are crappers like Nailz vs. Virgil and Crush vs. Repo Man to sit through.
Randy Savage vs. The Ultimate Warrior did get the live crowd going, but 28 minutes is far too ambitious for any Warrior match, and it was clear that both struggled to repeat their shockingly good 'Mania VII effort.
2. King Of The Ring 1998
What You Remember: Back-to-back big matches like The Undertaker vs. Mankind and Steve Austin vs. Kane made King Of The Ring 1998 a big deal. The card instantly earned a place in the history books because of Mick Foley's stuntman antics and Kane's unexpected title win.
Reality: Just as well, because it had nothing else to offer.
Foley's bumps are genuinely the only reason this card is remembered as fondly as it is. Had he not risked his life to entertain, then KOTR '98 would be 'that show Kane won the title at before Austin regained it on Raw the next night' and that's all. There wasn't a lot of quality sprinkled throughout.
The King Of The Ring tournament itself didn't really get going thanks to bland entrants like Dan Severn and Jeff Jarrett, and it's arguable that The Rock should've won instead of Ken Shamrock. Yep, this one would be long-forgotten without those dual big bumps from Mick.
The New Midnight Express challenging for the Tag Titles though. There was that.
1. WrestleMania X8
What You Remember: 'Icon vs. Icon' - The Rock vs. Hollywood Hulk Hogan for ultimate bragging rights. Elsewhere, Triple H would finally fend off Chris Jericho (alongside Stephanie McMahon) and become Undisputed WWF Champion after returning from injury.
As if that wasn't enough, Steve Austin wrestled Scott Hall, Ric Flair battled The Undertaker, Kurt Angle fought Kane, Edge faced Booker T and more.
Reality: Hulk vs. Rock is the only match worth watching more than once here, although there's maybe a shout for 'Taker vs. Flair too if you haven't seen it in years.
WrestleMania X8 is given unfair prestige by some in the pro wrestling community because of the red hot atmosphere inside Toronto's SkyDome and due to that 'Icon vs. Icon' billing. Outside of that stunning showdown, the card had little to shout about.
A frustrated Austin didn't want to work with Hall, Edge and Booker T warred over a fictional shampoo commercial and the headliner between Triple H and Jericho shouldn't have been in that spot ahead of Hulk and Rocky.
A total letdown, in retrospect.
What other WWE pay-per-views aren't as good now as they were back then? For more, check out 22 Craziest Moments From WWE Extreme Rules 2020 and 10 Things We Learned From Eric Bischoff's Podcast On Returning To WWE!