10 WWE Stars That The Internet Is Wrong To Hate

How do you like them now?

By Lewis Howse /

The Internet Wrestling Community, or IWC for short, is a catch-all term used to describe a group of people who write articles and commentaries about wrestling and post them online. The IWC is credited (and criticised) for breaking keyfabe and reporting on and exposing many of the backstage goings-on in the wrestling business. Whilst the playing field is a lot more open these days with the advent of blogging and such, during the Monday Night Wars fans would go to a select few people for the latest wrestling news. People such as Dave Meltzer, Wade Keller and Scott Keith would keep fans clued-in about what was going on while also reviewing shows and dishing out star ratings. Inevitably, there were certain wrestlers who came in for more criticism than others due to backstage incidents or perceived politicking. When news of these reached fans, those fans took to blogs to further pillory said wrestler. Somebody would read a news item on a website, go to a forum, start a thread and then, usually, others would join in to attack that wrestler or wrestlers. A wrestler could be a huge babyface on television and with the casual audience but, with the IWC, their reputation would be mud. But was it always justified? Did the wrestler's deserve this lynching or was it a case of internet fans thinking they knew more than they actually did?

10. The Big Show

Why The Internet Hates Him: The Big Show has been in WWE since 1999. Save for a brief period between late 2006 and early 2008 when he left to convalesce from various injuries, Show has been a fixture on WWE television for fifteen years. That's a run that very few wrestlers get to enjoy. With Show and the IWC it's mainly a case of familiarity breeding content. Show has been around so much that fans are simply starting to get sick of him. Plus, he's forty three years old, moves a lot slower than he used to and rarely has a 'great' match. Seeing Big Show and Kane, two men with a combined age of ninety beating the likes of promising talents like Dolph Ziggler and Daniel Bryan irks many keyboard warriors. Show won the second annual Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal at WrestleMania 31, an honour that many felt should go to a younger talent with a long career ahead of them, like it did at WrestleMania XXX when Cesaro won it (last eliminating Show). Instead of being phased out, it seems that WWE are determined to push the ageing Show as strong as ever. Why They're Wrong: The Big Show is a WWE legend, a man who has seen and done it all in his fifteen years with the company. He is a veteran who deserves respect, given the amount of time he has put in. Plus, while travelling and wrestling a full schedule may be hard for 'normal' people, it is ten times harder for a giant like Show. Paul Wight is a locker room leader, somebody whom WWE needs to keep others in line backstage. Besides, Show still has a role to play on the show. He will always be an impressive sight and, for a man of his size, he can still move around very well. Look at the gusto with which he bounces around for a Roman Reigns spear. That is probably why Show has stuck around so long. He is financially set for life but clearly loves the business and wants to give back. He probably should be phased down over the coming months and years but Show is a valuable resource to WWE and the fans should respect that.

9. Rey Mysterio

Why The Internet Hates Him: Mysterio was an internet darling before the internet was really a thing. When he was revolutionising junior heavyweight wrestling in the early-to-mid nineties the magazines and so-called 'dirtsheets' raved about him. That love intensified when he began tearing it up on a weekly basis in WCW. Then Rey finally arrived in WWE in 2002 and things were still good for a few years, despite a few comments that he had lost a step or two since his leaner WCW days. Fans really started to turn on Rey following the death of his close friend Eddie Guerrero in 2005. Rey was the recipient of a major push in a storyline that included some uncomfortable moments referencing the late Guerrero. Since fans couldn't vent their frustrations at Vince McMahon or the creative team, poor Rey became the target of their vitriol. As well as the Eddiesploitation, fans had grown tired with Rey's babyface act and kid-friendly style. He was broken down and past-his-prime they said. Mysterio received some decidedly Cena-esque reactions during the final year of his WWE career. Post-WWE, Mysterio has incurred more wrath for his involvement in the in-ring accident that caused the death of Perro Aguayo Jr in Mexico. Why They're Wrong: Come on, this is Rey Mysterio we're talking about here. This is a guy who has put on countless classic matches and entertained fans for over twenty years, despite numerous major surgeries. The master of the 619 has fought through the pain to put on a show more so than any other. Should Rey be ashamed for his involvement in the Eddie Guerrero exploitation angles of 2006? Possibly, but it's not like Rey, who up to his feud with Eddie had been viewed as a midcarder only, had anywhere near the kind of clout to reject it. If Rey had said no, odds are they would have found somebody else to do it. Rey definitely didn't want to purposefully insult the memory of his dead friend. Had Rey become a little stale and repetitive by the end of his WWE tenure? Maybe. But he was still one of the most consistently entertaining guys on the roster and you knew you'd get a good match out of him. As for the Perro Aguayo Jr stuff, if anyone thinks that Rey is in any way responsible for that, they couldn't be more wrong.

8. X-Pac

Why The Internet Hates Him: X-Pac, like Mysterio, was another pre-internet darling in the mid-to-late 90s. He was young, exciting and routinely put on great matches. The consummate underdog, fans loved to get behind X-Pac (then billed as the 1-2-3 Kid) against his much larger opponents. Then fans really started to get behind him as a member of DX version 2.0. Pac, along with Triple H, Billy Gunn, Road Dogg and Chyna were one of the hottest things in the business during a true boom period. When X-Pac split for his DX brethren, fans began to give him a much colder reception. By mid-2001, fans were seriously sick of X-Pac. Not in a 'we don't like you because you're a bad guy' kind of way, more of a 'we don't like you because we're sick of seeing the same old s*** kind of way'. Edge referenced this in a promo when he told the Kliq member that '1998 called and they're sick and tired of you. So feel free to join us in the year 2001 any time you want'. The term was dubbed 'X-Pac Heat' (basically 'go away' heat). The main issue was that he had been doing the same routine for way too long and fans were bored by it. Internet fans also weren't happy with the fact that he was using his backstage connections to improve his spot on the card, such as becoming a member of the 2002 version of the nWo. Why They're Wrong: X-Pac heat is a myth, an allusion. It is a creation of the internet. Sean Waltman is a professional, and a damn good one. Chris Jericho tells a story in his second autobiography about how management told him that if he couldn't have a great match with X-Pac, he pretty much sucked as a worker. So he was a great worker, and richly deserved a spot on the card. Could he have changed up his image and character a little bit more? Sure. He did change things up in 2002, switching to short trunks and making other modifications to his ring style. In the years since, X-Pac has become somebody whom longtime fans wish to see make a special appearance and have another WWE match. Absence makes the heart grow fonder.

7. Kevin Nash

Why The Internet Hates Him: Oh man, you could write a book on the reasons why the internet hates Kevin Nash. The main reason is that he's big. Historically, internet fans have preferred to watch smaller, more athletic wrestlers. Those with high 'workrate'. Kevin Nash definitely does not fall into the category of 'smaller, more athletic' wrestler. He is a giant. A giant with about four moves (that's one less than Cena). The perception amongst internet fans is that Nash has gotten very far despite having little talent. Nash, as Diesel, held the WWF Championship for 358 days in the mid-90s despite the fact that business was bad and there were other, apparently more 'deserving' contenders. Nash also gets a lot of internet hate for his role in the demise of WCW. Many point to the ill-conceived Fingerpoke of Doom incident that Nash was the brains behind along with many other harebrained ideas that accelerated the company's death. He also called internet darlings Eddie Guerrero, Chris Benoit and Dean Malenko the 'vanilla midgets', which didn't endear him to fans in cyberspace. Why They're Wrong: Nash, along with Scott Hall and Hulk Hogan, revolutionised the professional wrestling industry in 1996 with the nWo. It was him (and a select few others, including Eric Bischoff) that really kickstarted the Monday Night Wars. In WCW, Nash had some great matches and was involved in some very memorable moments. He's also really, really funny, as his TNA run demonstrated. His work with Alex Shelly in 'Paparazzi Productions' is some of the funniest stuff in that company's history. Nash has also proved that he can have a great match when the occasion calls for it, having a couple of stunners against Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels and Triple H.

6. Batista

Why The Internet Hates Him: The internet hates Batista for the same reason they hate Kevin Nash: because he's a big guy. Batista has one of the most impressive physiques in WWE history. Many assumed that was the reason why Batista got the push he got, since Vince historically favours the jacked-up aesthetic for his headliners. Another reason for the Batista hate in 2003 was because he was tied with Triple H, who was probably the internet's number one enemy at that point. He was guilty by association. Adding to that was the fact that he still hadn't found his feet as a worker, meaning his matches were often average or poor. The Batista hate intensified when the big man came back in 2014. The Animal, who was supposed to be a babyface, won the 2014 Royal Rumble match to the annoyance of the fans in attendance (and online) who wanted Daniel Bryan to win and main event 'Mania. Batista became a heel by default. As well as these there were also the allegations of affairs with divas, an apparently cocky attitude and backstage scuffles that had internet fans talking. Why They're Wrong: Batista is a great worker, plain and simple. Although a little shaky in the beginning, he improved tenfold when he began working with the likes of Triple H, Eddie Guerrero, Booker T, Finlay and The Undertaker from 2005 onwards. Batista has had many great matches during his WWE career. People also tend to forget that Batista wasn't pushed heavily from the start and actually had to pay his dues first in OVW and then in a minor role on Smackdown as Reverend D-Von's body guard. Batista only got a big push when the fans started to cheer for him in late 2004. Before that, he was mainly used the 'muscle' in Evolution matches and segments. As for the other stuff? That's really Batista's business, but in interviews he comes across as a genuine, humble person. Not the egomaniacal superstar that the IWC has painted him as in the past.

5. Goldberg

Why The Internet Hates Him: Goldberg may have been a huge fan favourite in WCW but, amongst the internet wrestling community, he's a total villain. The main reason for the IWC hate is because Goldberg was pushed very hard right from the start. Fresh out of the WCW Power Plant, Goldberg embarked on a massive winning streak, destroying his opponents in record time. It was an unprecedented push, but it was one that worked. It accentuated his positives (his look, intensity and power moves) while hiding his weaknesses (the fact he couldn't really work a long match). So, yes, the massive Goldberg was pushed from the start in WCW while internet favourites like Chris Benoit toiled away in the midcard. Some saw that as unfair, especially when Benoit and company could wrestle circles around Goldberg (something Regal actually did during an infamous Nitro match). Then there's his attitude towards wrestling. For Goldberg, wrestling is a business, not a passion. He doesn't need the limelight and will only wrestle if the money is right. His attitude has made him a target backstage with several in the industry labelling him 'hard to work with'. Why They're Wrong: How can you blame Goldberg for accepting a monster push? Was he going to say no when there was big money to be made? At the end of the day, wrestling is a business and Goldberg was a good businessman. He made huge money over a very short period and never has to wrestle again. As for the quality of his matches, Da Man did have one or two crackers with DDP, Scott Steiner and Bret Hart. Goldberg, like Batista, comes across as a decent guy who isn't a mark for the business or himself.

4. Triple H

Why The Internet Hates Him: Triple H was the most hated wrestler amongst the internet fan base between 2002-2005. Triple H had gained a glowing reputation for his performances from late 1999 until his quadriceps tear in May 2001. He really stepped up his game and was many people's picks for Wrestler of the Year for the year 2000. When Triple H came back in January 2002 he had added about forty pounds of solid muscle. The upshot of that was that his body started falling apart at an alarming rate. His performances suffered and he was moving noticeably slower and his movements were more laboured. Okay, let's not sugarcoat it: his matches usually sucked. On top of that, he was being booked as the bada** to end all bada**es while shacking up with the bosses daughter. That rubbed a lot of people the wrong way and led to claims that Triple H was holding others down so that he could hog the limelight for themselves. Why They're Wrong: Well, the internet fans might not be entirely wrong on this one. There was a noticeable drop in match and performance quality during this period and the twenty minute promos were insufferable. But Triple H was trying to establish himself as a locker room leader and a face of the company. He may have had power, but he didn't have that much power. Vince and the head writers were still calling the shots. It was their final decision to push Triple H as strongly as they did. Triple H also had some great matches during that period, particularly in 2004 with Chris Benoit and Shawn Michaels. Triple H still polarises a lot of internet fans but the truth is that he's one of the best in the business. He's started to win the IWC back recently thanks to his reduced role on WWE TV and his involvement with NXT.

3. John Cena

Why The Internet Hates Him: It's not just the internet that hates John Cena. Clearly a large portion of the adult male audience cannot stand the man. But the Cena hate is particularly strong online. Cena has poked fun at the internet backlash by wearing a t-shirt that said 'If Cena Wins We Complain Online'. Internet fans hate Cena because he is the face of the company, a face that is targeted primarily towards children. He is a walking merchandise machine, spouting off tired catchphrases and making juvenile poop jokes. He has been doing essentially the same thing on WWE TV for ten years now. His act is tired, plain and simple. His recent foray into the United States Championship division, while it could be seen as a demotion, is the most interesting Cena has been in a long time. Of course Cena triumphed over Rusev, as he always does. Cena's constant winning is also a major gripe amongst internet fans. Why They're Wrong: Is Cena the best wrestler of all time? No, he's not. Has he been involved in many genuinely classic matches? Yes, he has. Should Cena have been pushed that strongly for as long as he has? Why not? He draws houses, increases ratings and shifts merchandise. That's the bottom line in WWE. Nobody works harder than John Cena, save for Vince McMahon himself. He makes more personal appearances, works more dates and does more Make-A-Wishes than anyone on the roster. While the internet fans would love to see Cena turn heel, it's not going to happen because he loves to put smiles on kids faces. And there's nothing wrong with that.

2. JBL

Why The Internet Hates Him: JBL has been accused of being a bully in the past. There have been many incidences of JBL throwing his weight around and hazing other wrestlers. For internet fans who read up on these incidences, it has made JBL a major villain in their eyes. JBL is a jock and, in the early 2000s, was a locker room leader. A good friend of power players like The Undertaker and Vince McMahon, JBL could essentially do what he wanted without fear or reprisals. He wasn't going to get fired, being as well connected as he was. So he did what he wanted and people either liked it or they quit. That's exactly what Palmer Cannon did in 2006 when he left the company midway through a tour of Europe, fed up with JBL's ribbing and abuse. Chad Wicks (one half of the instantly-forgettable The Dicks tag team) also left the company due to an incident stemming from JBL's ribbing. Rene Dupree has claimed that JBL called him a 'French fa****' ever day that he wrestled on Smackdown and then there was the incident with the Blue Meanie... Another reason that the internet community hates JBL is that his matches are generally of the punch/kick variety and that he was promoted to main eventer at the expense of the beloved Eddie Guerrero in 2004. Fans didn't thank the former APA man had the goods to headline. Why They're Wrong: What people sometimes fail to acknowledge about JBL's push and WWE Championship win in 2004 is that it was requested by his friend Eddie because Latino Heat was cracking under the pressure. JBL proved that he was headline material over the next year and did an admirable job on top. As for the hazing/bullying, well, there's really no excuse for it. JBL has admitted to hazing The Miz and others in the past and, while not apologising for it, has definitely mellowed over the years. These days the Raw announcer can be found climbing mountains in aid of charity and trying to make kids lives better in Bermuda.

1. Hardcore Holly

Why The Internet Hates Him: Similar to JBL, Bob 'Hardcore' Holly developed a reputation as being a bully. The reputation mainly stems from an incident on the second season of MTV's Tough Enough which aired in early 2003. Holly appeared to beat up eventual winner Matt Cappotelli during an impromptu six man tag match. Cornering the rookie, Holly unloaded with a series of full-on kicks and punches to his face. At the end of the match Cappotelli has a black eye and a bloody lip. Holly also incurred the IWC's wrath in late 2004 when he decided to shoot on Rene Rupree during a tag team match, potatoing him with several legit punches and smashing him in the back of the head with a chair. The incident stemmed from an unpaid parking ticket that Dupree had gotten in a rental car registered in Bob's name. Holly had anger issues, people said. He was a jerk, someone who took liberties in the ring. He was excessively stiff with new guys like Randy Orton in 2002. The Holly hate was so bad that, when Brock Lesnar accidentally dropped him on his head and broke his neck in 2002, people blamed Holly for sandbagging The Next Big Thing. Why They're Wrong: Did Holly work stiff? Absolutely. Did he worked excessively stiff on occasion? More than likely. Was the only person to work that stiff at that time? Absolutely not. Eddie Guerrero, Chris Jericho, Chris Benoit, Kurt Angle, JBL and others worked as stiff, if not more stiff than Holly. Ditto Rob Van Dam. As for the Capotelli and Dupree incidences? Holly maintains that he was in the right during both. Apparently the cameras didn't show Capotelli and his fellow trainees goofing around and not paying Holly requisite respect. Holly was as rough with him as he was with anyone else, not more so. With Dupree, Holly could have lost his license and been put in jail over it, since there was a warrant out for his arrest. It cost Holly a lot of money and, according to him, Dupree refused to apologise. Holly gave him fair warning that they were going to have a fight. Was it right? Debatable, but it's not as cut-and-dry as the IWC seems to believe.