10 WWE Wrestlers DOOMED Without Vince McMahon
Triple H replacing Vince McMahon as WWE's creative lead is good news for some & bad for others...
Paul 'Triple H' Levesque assuming WWE's lead creative role bodes well for dozens of ultra-talented wrestlers who have spent years suffering for not fitting the previous incumbent's antiquated megastar model.
Should Levesque's main roster vision reflect the black and gold blueprint he once drew for WWE's future, Ricochet, Ciampa, Finn Balor, and others may soar. While it's unlikely that Triple H will completely eschew bigger wrestlers with proven main event track records and the glass ceiling for smaller uber-workers hasn't yet shattered, it has at least risen. A Levesque-penned main roster should be more of a meritocracy.
Vince McMahon's late-career star-making processes bordered on farcical. It's no coincidence that the WWE full-time with the most Superstar presence is Roman Reigns, who, alongside Paul Heyman, has a degree of creative freedom. Elsewhere, the roster is littered with first-class performers let down by suboptimal presentation and the burnt-out husks of main event flops.
The airport test is dead - and those who best fit Vince's rigid, dated ideals stand to suffer from WWE's executive switch-up. For every wrestler that moves up the card, there's one that will tumble down.
And it starts close to home...
10. Shane McMahon
Shane McMahon overstepped WWE's boundaries to such a degree that Vince felt compelled to cut his own son loose following Royal Rumble 2022, where even the neutered version of Shane's heavy-handed creative approach saw him go toe-to-toe with former MMA fighter Riddle, eliminate Kevin Owens, and draw Brock Lesnar's ire.
Fightful Select reported on 25 July that Vince claimed Shane would "never get another pop in this company as long as I'm around." The source noted, however, that they felt this was a heat-of-the-moment remark, and may not have held firm.
It wouldn't have. Vince is tempestuous, rash, and prone to changing his mind at the drop of a hat. He would have let Shane back through Titan Towers' door, 100%. Triple H and Stephanie, however?
A "divide" exists between Shane and Stephanie, who became co-WWE CEO after her dad resigned in disgrace. PWTorch reported last month that no reconciliation is on the horizon, seemingly ruling Shane out of a prominent WWE role. Meanwhile, rumours of heat between brothers-in-law Shane and Triple H go back years.
The days of hotshotted Shane O'Mac comebacks are numbered. The 52-year-old glory-hound's potato fists are on ice.
9. Veer Mahaan
The former Indus Sher man was likely screwed before Vince McMahon's departure, having faded from prominence following his Raw squashing spree earlier this year. That his endless pre-debut vignettes started airing without a clear plan for Mahaan's push rang alarm bells in 2021. Now, over a month has passed since Veer last wrestled on Raw, suggesting the company has lost interest.
Rey and Dominik Mysterio have moved on from the big man despite receiving multiple one-sided shellackings from him. It can be inferred, from his lack of direction, that McMahon had no plans for Veer beyond getting another large, burly bruiser on television. Now, his best bet may be a return to NXT, where former partner Sanga still lurks.
Though relatively convincing in his squashes, Mahaan has not yet demonstrated that he has what it takes to prosper on a Triple H-penned show. That Indus Sher was binned so soon after debuting on Hunter's black and gold brand adds further fuel. Unless the 33-year-old boasts a skillset not yet explored on television, he may be due a rethink - and a repackaging.
8. Charlotte Flair
"Doomed" is admittedly excessive here. Charlotte Flair will still be pushed on WWE television despite Vince's resignation, as she should be. Although her performances have dipped in recent years, Flair is amongst the most over-criticised wrestlers in the world, which is a consequence of her nonstop monster push.
That nonstop monster push is what's really doomed. Given the sheer volume of talent at Triple H's disposal (now bolstered by Iyo Sky and Dakota Kai's main roster arrivals), the days of the entire women's division revolving around Flair are done. She will be positioned as a more complimentary player going forward, slotting into different roles as and when required, rather than commanding the spotlight endlessly.
Flair has been a cornerstone of her division since the Divas era gave way and carries herself like a star befitting her legendary surname. 2022 bouts with Ronda Rousey and Naomi prove her bell-to-bell value, too. Triple H and WWE would be insane to downsize her completely, but Charlotte won't feel so indomitable anymore.
7. Von Wagner
Triple H's quiet WWE demotion preceded NXT black and gold's transformation into NXT 2.0: a gimmick-heavy show painted in the broadest strokes, populated primarily by the younger, greener athletes who'd replaced Levesque's experienced cast collected from the indie scene.
This change was to facilitate a smoother transition from developmental to the main roster. A sound theory: the closer the two products were to each other, the easier it should be to adapt. Triple H's creative ascent raised big developmental questions, however. If the main roster is to be painted in Levesque's image, what becomes of NXT 2.0, which was rebuilt in Vince's?
The answer appears to be a hybrid, for now. If so, some of the cartoon-gimmicked rookies fast-tracked through NXT 2.0 will have to give way.
Von Wagner boasts impressive size and power but has now been on television for 11 months without marrying these attributes to the menace demanded by his heel role. A lumbering green giant who routinely loses himself on the microphone, despite his pairing with Mr. Stone, he, like many of his roster mates, isn't TV ready and would benefit from a longer Performance Center stint before re-emerging.
6. Reggie
The 24/7 Title division was conspicuous by its absence on Triple H's first Raw.
Bad comedy skits and Benny Hill chases featuring Reggie, R-Truth, Tamina, and Akira Tozawa were nowhere to be found on a show that otherwise felt like a Vince McMahon broadcast. Whether or not anything should be read into this is debatable, however. While the 25 July Raw was technically helmed by Levesque, swooping creative changes six days before SummerSlam were never likely.
While not everything Triple H books will be super serious and grimdark (Bull Fit, we hardly knew ye), nothing from his booking career thus far suggests he shares his father-in-law's taste for bad, WWE-brand comedy. That he doesn't like the 24/7 Championship is a fair assumption.
This wouldn't bode well for Reggie, who has never been a conventional wrestler on WWE's roster. A Vince-approved project with a fun, flippy skillset from his Cirque du Soleil background, he is synonymous with a division that wore out its welcome within weeks of its 2019 launch and an unproven wrestler in a product whose booking has traditionally emphasised the Sports over the Entertainment, Reggie appears an awkward fit.
5. Ezekiel
The Ezekiel project would have bottomed out within its first few weeks if not for Kevin Owens, who breathed life into a one-note gimmick with his typically watchable performances opposite the former Elias. KO remains one of WWE's most valuable television characters for his ability to elevate lacklustre material - and should be in line for an elevation under Triple H.
Ezekiel, on the other hand, will struggle. His character is a surface-level novelty act that merely flirted with getting over when positioned across from Owens. Now that Kevin has left his orbit (and new foe Seth Rollins has resumed his feud with Riddle), Ezekiel has lost what made people pay attention to him in the first place.
The 34-year-old's previous gimmick, Elias, was neither deep nor complex but stayed over whenever he was regularly given the opportunity to strum his guitar and sing a few verses. But that he found greater success on Vince McMahon's main roster than in Triple H's NXT is another warning sign for a wrestler who must now expand his range.
4. Theory
Triple H and Theory's shared past could be interpreted as a sign that Mr. Money in the Bank will flourish under his former mentor's creative lead. Not only was 'The Game' pivotal in scouting and signing the 24-year-old while he was with Evolve, but he was hands-on in his development in NXT as well - and has publically spoken about wanted to him the former Austin progress.
This was before Vince McMahon adopted Theory as his on-air prodigy and attempted a rocket-strapped push, which is going no better today than when the duo started appearing on television together.
Theory is yet to demonstrate the qualities required of a convincing main-eventer. He is quite good at many things but exceptional at none, coming across as artificial, like he was created in a lab. A good look and expressive midcard charisma aside, he is a long way from the red-hot headlining prospect Vince seemingly saw in him.
A distinct lack of any kind of crowd connection makes Theory's continued high-level push a hard sell going forward. Triple H will not be blind to this. 24 is too young to write a wrestler off for good, but 'The Game' may opt to at least dial Theory's positioning back even further - starting with him dropping the Money in the Bank briefcase.
3. Omos
A big, lumbering stiff of a seven-footer in an era that has largely consigned such wrestlers to the scrapheap, Omos has suffered through improper development, having spent far too little time in developmental and on the house show loop before being hurried over to WWE's main roster (much of which owes to the pandemic-related shutdown).
WWE signed Jordan Omogbehin in 2019. When he entered the Performance Center, it was immediately joked that Vince would push the 7'3" skyscraper as soon as he laid eyes on him. Less than two years later, with only six matches on his resume, this came to pass, as Omos and AJ Styles became Raw Tag Team Champions in the big man's first televised match.
The promotion has kept Omos relevant through the inevitable Styles breakup, his Bobby Lashley feud, and pairing with MVP. Unfortunately, the goliath has demonstrated little improvement between the ropes in these outings. Unconvincing even when executing the most basic of monster tropes, this isn't Omos' fault (he simply hasn't worked enough) but there's currently little use for him beyond a basic enforcer's role.
Wrestling evolved beyond plodding green giants. Vince McMahon, unfortunately, did not.
2. Goldberg
Goldberg has long been WWE's go-to panic option, with Vince McMahon breaking glass and unleashing Bill when faced with an emergency regularly since his successful 2016 comeback.
That initial program opposite Brock Lesnar was as effective as it was bombastic. Unfortunately, the WCW icon's goodwill started eroding shortly afterwards. Super ShowDown 2019 saw him contest one of the most shambolic matches in WWE history opposite The Undertaker. The Dolph Ziggler squash aside, he has since become a nuisance: a part-time interloper heinously positioned in World Title and other high-profile feuds against fan favourites. Yet another modern example of WWE using its past to screw the present.
WWE continues to book Goldberg and others of his ilk in these spots because its current, Vince McMahon-created "stars" cannot draw the same levels of interest. This is something Triple H will likely look to change now that he has the pencil. Whether or not he'll succeed in reviving the spluttering WWE star-making machine is in question, though he'll have absolutely taken stock of the response to recent feuds with Bobby Lashley and Roman Reigns when considering Goldberg.
1. Brock Lesnar
Brock Lesnar vanishing from a post-Vince WWE is unlikely. 'The Beast' is front and centre for the company's Day 1 advertising and proved, at SummerSlam 2022, that he is still pro wrestling's biggest spectacle athlete when in the mood. There's value to having him around, particularly now that he has found new life as a babyface.
The days of Lesnar holding McMahon over a barrel in contract negotiations are likely over, however. For years, Brock has squeezed big-money deal after big-money deal out of the 76-year-old, who perceived him as a star beyond anyone on his full-time roster. And, for a while, he was right. Lesnar was on the short list of wrestlers capable of making a notable difference to ratings and other consumer-driven metrics.
This is no longer the case. At least not to the same degree, announcing Lesnar for a show doesn't guarantee it'll pop anymore, which will factor into Triple H, Stephanie McMahon, and Nick Khan's negotiations the next time Brock enters the room.
Lesnar reportedly proclaimed a variant of "if he's gone, I'm gone" upon learning of Vince's resignation. He returned to the arena after his pre-SmackDown walkout, though this response shows he understands that the future may not be so rosy and gold-lined under the new regime.