10 WWE Wrestlers Who Are Too Broken To EVER Be Fixed
Baszler, Gable, Tozawa: who else has fallen too far down the hill to reach the top?
Being a professional wrestler is a real roll of the dice.
While skill and hard work can pay off, you've also got to be incredibly lucky, have good connections and get on the good side of your superiors, as they hold your career in their hands.
Despite this, a career in WWE shouldn't be so scary, as if things aren't working out, you can always reinvent yourself. The likes of The New Day, Becky Lynch, Roman Reigns and even Stone Cold Steve Austin prove that you don't have to hit it out of the park on your first attempt to find success.
Sadly, that cannot be the case for everyone, as sometimes the damage done to your credibility, booking, and character is enough to stifle your potential and keep you more broken than Matt Hardy in Impact.
The following wrestlers came into the company with a tonne of potential, and while they've each proven themselves to be worthwhile employees, WWE has ruined all chance of a main event push for them. Fans can rest easy knowing that they're making the best money of their career, but sadly, their position in the company is too broken to be fixed...
10. The Viking Raiders
The Viking Raiders, War Machine, War Raiders, The Viking Experience, whatever you want to call them, it's fair to say that their time in WWE is a far cry from the pulse-pounding time they had on the independent circuit.
While that can be said for many performers, it feels particularly painful here, as WWE could have really used them to ignite the tag team division.
During their time in NXT, fans got a taste of the havoc that this powerhouse team could bring to the company. They'd already torn it up in ROH and NJPW, and now they were finding great success on the developmental brand. But, once they made it to the main roster, it didn't take long for creative to start messing with their credibility.
A Raw Tag Team Championship reign aside, this team were completely mishandled. Their introduction was a clear sign of the times to come as audiences were instantly hostile to their absurd renaming as The Viking Experience, and soon their booking followed.
Feuding with Street Profits could have been great for them, but the goofy competitions, dire Backlash scripted match and pilling losses sought to ruin whatever potential they had. Erik and Ivar may have recently found their way back into the title picture, but it seems that the damage may already be too great.
9. Robert Roode
It seems that owning the logest IMPACT World Title reign ever has very little bearing on your reputation in WWE.
It's safe to say that the former Bobby Roode was once one of the most significant prospects in the wrestling world, as his old school in-ring work, great promo skills and experience made him an excellent signee for NXT. But, as the tale so often goes, he's fallen quite far from grace.
When Roode made it onto the main roster - after finding a lot of success down on the golden brand - he started slowly, in a 50/50 booking feud with Dolph Ziggler. It was a stifled start, but a start nonetheless, and he even captured the United States Championship. However, he soon started to fall down a rabbit hole of thrown together tag teams, losses and irrelevancy on the roster.
As of right now, Roode is a former SmackDown Team Champion who seems awfully directionless. While his teaming with Ziggler hasn't been awful, it certainly not the main event push fans were hoping for, and at this point, it seems that management has no faith in pushing him right to the top of the mountain.
8. Drake Maverick
Drake Maverick has a wonderful tale to tell, so long as you stop it at a certain point. The former Rockstar Spud has been through so much in the company, especially within this last year. But, sadly, it seems his best days are behind him.
His time with WWE has been truly up and down as he had a great showing as GM for 205 Live but suffered from some awfully embarrassing angles, with the most infamous being the time Big Show caused him to wet his pants. No one could ever be taken seriously after something like that.
Despite this and his time in the 24/7 Title scene, Maverick eventually became a fan-favourite, as his release due to Covid budget cuts (while still being involved in the interim NXT Cruiserweight Title Tournament) turned him into a red hot babyface. This sudden burst in popularity even led to him being reinstated with the company. That has essentially dissipated now, as he has returned to being an underutilised talent.
Simply put, WWE has let him down too many times and placed him in too many embarrassing scenarios to give him a taste of true glory in the company. He may be a comedy wrestler at heart, but WWE has taken the joke too far.
7. Titus O'Neil
It's impossible not to love Titus O'Neil, even if you're not a fan of his in-ring work. He deserves the respect of his peers and fans, thanks to his genuinely wholesome backstage persona and charity work. But when it comes to his position as a wrestler, he sinks beneath all the embarrassing moments he's been through.
In a change of pace from the other entries on this list, O'Neil's problems haven't come from issues with management but rather his habit of clumsiness. The former member of the Prime Time Players is a walking Tom and Jerry cartoon, as he's constantly falling over or screwing things up in a way that makes it impossible not to giggle at.
His infamous trip and fall at the Greatest Royal Rumble isn't the only mistake he's made - lest we forget the NXT keg carry challenge or his grabbing of Vince McMahon - but it's undoubtedly the most cartoonish. After it happened, there was no way he could be taken seriously as a wrestler again.
Thankfully, O'Neil has a great place in the company as an ambassador and is even a Hall of Famer, but his reputation as an in-ring performer is damaged beyond repair.
6. Akira Tozawa
Akira Tozawa was never going to be a shining star in the land of WWE. The language barrier meant his promos were always short, his small stature caused him to be stuck in the cruiserweight division, and he didn't have a huge amount of star power. But he did offer some intense in-ring energy and an awesome look that made him fearsome and engaging. Naturally, WWE squandered that completely.
This list has already briefly mentioned the Backlash match between Street Profits and Viking Raiders, but it was more than those teams involved as the pre-filmed sequence also acted as the debut of a new look in Tozawa. Gone were the days of catchy colours and kickpads, and instead came a ninja outfit.
Seeing this stern and serious performer given such a stereotyped gimmick was harrowing, and it was only made worse by his insertion into comedy angles. Nowadays, it's hard to look at this performer and remember him as an effervescent star from Dragongate, as he's more akin to a cartoon character than a serious wrestler.
5. Ricochet
WWE may not always push their high flying stars to the moon, but they're often willing to give them a big spotlight. Thus, you'd think it'd be a no brainer to give this wrestler a massive push as he flies higher than most performers the company has ever seen. Still, they've invested precious little in raising his stock, and it seems to be too little too late.
Ricochet has been wowing WWE audiences since 2018 and was making a name for himself on the indie circuit for years before then. You would think WWE must have been foaming at the mouth with him at first, not only because of his fantastic skill but also because he was essentially a real-life superhero, but they certainly haven't shown it.
As of right now, he has been in booking limbo for so long that it's hard to remember any time that he was on top. While he has occasionally found himself in midcard storylines stories, it's always clear that he's just being used as an extra body.
The years of losses, being lost in the shuffle, and lack of faith from management has proven that WWE is not the place for Ricochet, and there's nothing they can do to change that.
4. Chad Gable
The term "workhorse" gets thrown around quite often in the world of professional wrestling. The likes of Dean Malenko, William Regal, Cesaro and more have all been considered sublime in-ring performers who were never given the attention they deserved, and one name who easily slots in with them is Chad Gable.
The fantastic Chad feels like a true rebrith of the legendary Kurt Angle, not just because of their similar gimmicks and move-sets but also thanks to his strong charisma and energetic promos. You'd think this would lead to WWE taking Gable seriously, but if he wanted respect from the McMahons, he should probably find a way to grow an inch or two.
WWE has repeatedly ruined Gable's character and even publicly mocked him. Some of the most egregious crimes include breaking up the impeccable American Alpha, having him lose to Baron Corbin in the King of the Ring Tournament, giving him a tonne of losses, and worst of all, his infamous rebranding to Shorty G.
While Gable has outlived these terrible moments, he's not doing any better as the head of the Alpha Academy, and it seems that no amount of change will fix that.
3. Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE can put a crown on him as much as they like, but it isn't going to undo the dreadful booking choices that have caused this once legendary performer to feel like another missed opportunity. Those unfamiliar with The King Of Strong Style before his NXT debut must have been blown away at first by this hard-hitting wrestler who's bursting at the seams with charisma. But those who see him now might not understand the hype.
It's tough to pinpoint exactly where things started to go wrong for Nakamura, as his main roster opening feud with Ziggler certainly was a poor start, but he'd been showing signs of slowing in NXT for some time before. All that's certain is that his career took a nosedive after his loss to AJ Styles at WrestleMania 34.
After this defeat, he soon faded into the background mulling around in the tag team division and finding little success. Even after his sudden popularity resurgence in the infancy of 2021, it's clear that he's suffered too many high profile losses and spent too much time out of the spotlight to feel like the true King of Strong Style.
2. Shayna Baszler
Shayna Baszler is a perfect example of the mismanagement that NXT stars go through. She started her WWE career as a dominant champion with both a figurative and literal stranglehold over the NXT women's division. But now, her booking seems to get worse and worse, and it's hard for fans to sit through.
After making it through the developmental brand, Shayna seemed poised to display the same threat level as before. Instead of treating her like the monster fighter she was, WWE paired her up with Nia Jax and gave her a lacklustre tag team title reign which made her a side character in the year that should have belonged to her. Still, it has only gotten worse since then.
Baszler's booking as of late feels like a total nightmare, and not because of the deliberately spooky antics of Alexa Bliss. Seeing the former no-nonsense performer partake in one of the most ridiculous matches of 2021 - essentially playing magic make belief with Bliss - at Hell in a Cell was a point of no return for the Queen of Spades.
It's almost unfathomable how broken this star is, and sadly there's precious little that can be done to save her.
1. Bray Wyatt
The introduction to this list talked about how valuable a tool reinvention can be. By changing their character and carving out a new direction for themselves, wrestlers can completely shift their careers. Bray Wyatt, however, proves that this means nothing if the company refuses to change their stubborn booking patterns and ruin you again and again.
After shedding the skin of Husky Harris, the real-life Windham Rotunda became the infamous Bray Wyatt, a cult leader with some supernatural powers. Despite his great promos and in-ring work, he was repeatedly buried under losses and cheap supernatural booking. So Wyatt took it upon himself to reinvent, creating the Firefly Fun House and debuting The Fiend character.
This alteration looked set to make him a star and bring him back to the potential laden early days of the character, but again WWE booked him to keep losing, focussed way too much on gimmick matches and botched him completely.
While Bray has come back from poor booking time and time again, it feels like he's done now, as the dreadful direction of his character and broken connection with Alexa Bliss feels like the final nail in the coffin. WWE fans can simply no longer get behind this wrestler, as they know it will lead nowhere.