10 WWE Wrestlers Who Have Been Directionless During The Brand Split

Not everyone has stood to benefit from the Brand Split.

By Graham Matthews /

The announcement of WWE bringing back the Brand Split this summer was met mostly with excitement from fans who had longed to see SmackDown and Raw have their own distinctive rosters again. While it would virtually be cutting the rosters in half, it has granted opportunities for those who have been overlooked for far too long and deserved more television time than they were previously getting.

Advertisement

AJ Styles has perhaps been the biggest beneficiary of the Brand Split so far, quickly capturing the WWE World Championship on the blue brand and becoming the face of Tuesday nights. Likewise, Kevin Owens probably would not be WWE Universal champion right now if there was still only one world title.

However, not every one has been better off because of the Brand Split. In addition to the stars whose status in the company hasn't changed, there are a number of names who are even more directionless than they were six months ago. Of course, not everyone can be prominently pushed at the same time, but for popular fixtures on the SmackDown and Raw rosters to be relegated to Main Event and Superstars without a storyline in sight is simply inexcusable.

Here's hoping these superstars will find their footing on their respective show before more damage is done to their fledgling credibility.

10. Zack Ryder

Zack Ryder flies solo to kick off the list and isn't included with Mojo Rawley because when his Hype Bro tag team partner was drafted to SmackDown Live in July, it was pretty clear he would never get above a certain level. And if it wasn't for Ryder, he likely wouldn't be on the main roster at all.

Advertisement

Ryder, however, was on something of a roll at the start of the summer, winning the main event of Raw on July 4th, beating Sheamus in clean fashion, and contending for the United States Championship at Battleground. Even prior to that point, he had won the Intercontinental Championship in one of the biggest upsets of all-time at WrestleMania 32.

Thus, it appeared he could be a huge beneficiary of the Brand Split, but that has been anything but the case so far. Sure, he and Rawley have scored a few wins in tag team action here and there. But they haven't been in contention for the SmackDown Tag Team Championship at all and likely won't be for a while. The Long Island Iced Z could be a valuable asset to the blue brand's midcard, but instead he has been wasting away in the tag team division.

9. Darren Young

Similar to Zack Ryder, it shouldn't come as too much of a surprise that Darren Young currently calls WWE Superstars home, but given the momentum he had when he initially returned to the ring over the summer, it's baffling more isn't being done with him at the moment.

Advertisement

WWE had a golden opportunity to make Darren Young great again, or just great in general, by pairing him with WWE Hall of Fame Bob Backlund. It was an idea Young pitched to management about a year ago, and although it was finally green lit, they never intended to give the gimmick a chance to succeed.

Young was a serious contender to the Intercontinental Championship at Battleground, but it was all downhill from there when that match fell flat. Putting him a program with Titus O'Neil was the worst thing they could have done, and now he is without direction all together.

Truth be told, it's more of a disgrace Creative has nothing for Backlund more so than Young. That gimmick could have been, and still can be, a great vechile to get Young involved in the midcard, but instead he's being relegated to dark matches and facing Jinder Mahal Friday afternoons on Superstars.

8. Kane

Splitting Kane and Big Show up in the 2016 Draft might have been the smartest thing WWE could have done. While Big Show has wisely been kept off programming, Kane has maintained a presence on the program on Tuesday nights but has yet to engage in anything meaningful.

Advertisement

Kane has appeared on occasion for matches with Bray Wyatt and Baron Corbin, and oddly owns victories over both men, but he doesn't serve much of a purpose at a time where WWE is focused on pushing "New Era" talent.

While The Big Red Monster has never been known for his extraordinary in-ring ability, he has helped several stars get over in recent years, most notably Daniel Bryan. That would be an ideal use of him on SmackDown as opposed to inserting him into random matches with The Wyatt Family where he bores fans to tears more often than not.

His placement on his list does not mean I'm pushing for him to contend for the WWE World Championship against AJ Styles and Dean Ambrose, but if he's going to be around in a regular role, management might as well get all that they can out of him.

7. Baron Corbin

Baron Corbin getting selected by SmackDown Live during the televised portion of the 2016 WWE Draft was a tell-tale sign the powers that be had plans to push him as a top star on the brand, or at least it should have been. He debuted with a ton of momentum by winning the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal at WrestleMania 32, only to be placed in a program with Dolph Ziggler that didn't help or hinder him.

Advertisement

SmackDown is the perfect platform for him to emerge as a monster heel, but that has yet to be the case. He initially teased going after Kane before setting his sights on Jack Swagger. Granted, he beat the former World Heavyweight champion in their No Mercy match, but he is hardly more of a threat coming out of the event.

Corbin and Swagger are set to face off in a rubber match on an upcoming episode of SmackDown Live, but where does The Lone Wolf go from there? Targeting the Intercontinental Championship would a logical move, but that would mean he would have to rekindle his rivalry with Dolph Ziggler and it is far too soon for that.

6. Enzo Amore And Big Cass

There is little question that Enzo Amore and Big Cass were the most anticipated call-ups from NXT on the post-WrestleMania 32 edition of Raw. They wasted no time in making an impact at The Dudley Boyz' expense and quickly became one of the most over acts on the entire roster.

Advertisement

Now, that isn't to say they aren't still beloved by the audience, but they have lost quite a bit of steam as of late. Their short-lived alliance with John Cena was a major endorsement of the duo, but they have accomplished next to nothing since losing to Jeri-KO in their backyard of Brooklyn at SummerSlam. In fact, they weren't even a part of Clash of Champions, and that was a Raw-exclusive event!

Of course, as of last Monday's Raw, it looks like they're headed toward a feud with The Club, but it really is a mystery why they aren't already involved in the WWE Tag Team Championship picture. Especially at a time where The New Day is lacking credible competition. Was it all that necessary for Enzo and Cass to put over The Shining Stars as many times as they did?

5. Bayley

Bayley's move to the main roster from NXT was long overdue, as she could have been on Raw a year ago with the rest of the Four Horsewomen and wouldn't have felt out of place. But it was more important for her to continue to grow as a performer and give back to NXT's women's division.

Advertisement

Her Raw arrival was virtually perfect. She confronted Charlotte one night removed from her Raw Women's Championship victory versus Sasha Banks on the anniversary of when Bayley won the NXT Women's Championship in that same building exactly one year prior, the Barclays Center in Brooklyn.

The crowd came unglued as Bayley was announced by general manager Mick Foley as Team Red's latest acquisition. It was a magical moment that should have led to her getting a one-on-one title opportunity at Clash of Champions (given she beat Charlotte the following week), but instead, it turned into a Triple Threat when Sasha Banks returned and inserted herself back into the picture.

Bayley lost at the event, which was the right move since she shouldn't win the gold until WrestleMania 33 at the earliest, but she has been competing in meaningless matches for the past month. Banks and Charlotte reigniting their rivalry has left Bayley on the outside looking in, potentially headed for a feud with Dana Brooke that could kill time for her.

Regardless, it is slightly disappointing one of the most popular people (male or female) on the Raw roster isn't involved in something more significant at the moment.

4. The Vaudevillians

It was actually somewhat a surprise when The Vaudevillians were brought up from NXT after WrestleMania 32. Both men had been a part of the developmental system for a few years, so it wasn't that they weren't ready for WWE's main stage, but it was always widely assumed by fans that the act just wouldn't work outside of Full Sail University.

Advertisement

The only time Aiden English and Simon Gotch were on the verge of superstardom was when they captured the NXT Tag Team Championship at TakeOver: Brooklyn in August 2015. Beyond that, they have never been able to maintain momentum, though they did a decent job of eliciting heat as heels when they initially arrived in WWE.

The Vaudevillians came close to winning the WWE Tag Team Championship at Extreme Rules but were ultimately unsuccessful. They were never the same following the defeat and have become just another tandem on SmackDown Live, losing every match they have had so far.

There might be hope for them yet if they are repackaged and are made out to be legitimate threats to the twin titles, but they have only been worse off since the Brand Split as of now.

3. Sami Zayn

Sami Zayn, a lot like Bayley, should have been on Raw long before he was officially a member of the main roster, and he likely would have been had he not suffered a shoulder injury in May 2015. Nevertheless, fans were familiar with him when he re-debuted in the Royal Rumble match and again on Raw months later, resuming his rivalry with former friend Kevin Owens.

Advertisement

They traded wins for months and had one of the best feuds of the year, culminating in a phenomenal bout at Battleground. While Owens then went on to team up with Chris Jericho and win the WWE Universal Championship, Zayn was relegated to the Kickoff show at SummerSlam and has been floundering for months.

Zayn was in the midst of an entertaining program with Chris Jericho heading into Clash of Champions before it was abruptly cut short, and now he finds himself directionless yet again. It would be one thing if he wasn't anyone special, but this is the same guy whose entrance music is so catchy that the crowd sings along every time he enters an arena.

It remains to be seen whether his partnership with Neville will be here to stay or not, but he would be better off on SmackDown Live at this point where he might actually be used to his full potential.

2. Apollo Crews

Apollo Crews appeared to be destined for big things when he debuted on Raw the night after WrestleMania 32. Although he had more to accomplish in NXT, it was a sign that management had high hopes for him on the main roster. But aside from one win against Sheamus at the Money in the Bank pay-per-view, he was mostly absent from WWE programming.

Advertisement

Thus, he was bound to be one of the biggest beneficiaries of the Brand Split, but when he was selected late in the WWE Draft, that all but confirmed he wasn't going to be a top priority on the blue brand. Granted, he contended for the Intercontinental Championship at SummerSlam, but he fell short of victory versus The Miz twice before fading off into obscurity.

There is still time for him to rebound and make a major impact on Tuesday nights, but so far, his immediate future on SmackDown does not look promising. He should have been a centrepiece on the show coming out of the Draft, but a lack of direction has prevented him from getting to that next level he belongs to be at.

1. Neville

The ankle injury Neville suffered early on in 2016 might have been the best thing for him. It was unfortunate that he would have to miss his first WrestleMania, but his absence would allow him to reinvent himself and his stagnant character upon his return to the ring.

Advertisement

Neville finally resurfaced in late July when he was drafted to the Raw brand. While he would have been better suited on SmackDown, it made sense to put him on a show where he could lead the Cruiserweight division. However, he has yet to join the Cruiserweight ranks and has instead been relegated to competing on Superstars on a near-weekly basis.

Not only has nothing changed with Neville since the start of the year, he is actually receiving less television time, which shouldn't be happening when there are two separate brands. He reigned as NXT champion for nearly a year, and now he can't even land a regular role on Raw.

His apparent pairing with Sami Zayn could be promising given their chemistry and history together, but in all honesty, it is a tremendous waste of both of their talent. On a three hour long show, it's criminal WWE can't find something more meaningful for Neville than throwaway matches with Curtis Axel and Jinder Mahal.

Advertisement