12 Match Star Ratings For AEW Revolution 2022

AEW Revolution 2022 was a long, rewarding, and very, very special show. Mostly.

By Michael Sidgwick /

The build to Revolution was tremendous.

Advertisement

CM Punk Vs. MJF told an instant classic of a programme. It was an incredible recreation of a traditional good guy versus bad guy tale before an ingenious twist perfected it with stunning, modern emotional depth. Chris Jericho leaned hard into a sports entertainer megastar persona to create an ideal contrast with Eddie Kingston's realest man in wrestling. Jon Moxley and Bryan Danielson meanwhile sold fans on a brutal technical fight, and it's only the first chapter of a compelling saga.

These three programmes were so white-hot that Hangman Page Vs. Adam Cole felt cold, in comparison - until the last stretch, during which Page cut an awesome babyface promo and Cole displayed his defensive brilliance in a banger trios match on the go-home Dynamite. The Face of the Revolution Ladder match and its qualifying matches promised a fun, unique take on the genre norm: three hoss giants catching dives and f*cking up puny pukes.

Even the lesser attractions, like Jade Cargill Vs. Tay Conti, were advanced with impeccable sh*t-talking. The Tornado Trios match was convoluted midcard soup stewed to get more names on the card, but that was the exception.

As for the show itself...?

12. BUY-IN: Kris Statlander Vs. Leyla Hirsch

Snug, vicious, really quite well done.

Advertisement

Statlander displayed her formidable power game by effortlessly throwing Hirsch down to her thigh with a tilt-a-whirl backbreaker; Hirsch fired back by punishing Statlander's athletic handstand flourish by sweeping her with a kick as fierce and it was perfectly timed. She launched into a step-assisted missile dropkick to compound the damage applied to the arm, which she targeted by the ropes with a visible, camera-friendly relish.

Statlander's selling was strong. She struggled to ascend the ropes after hitting a desperation scoop slam, and Hirsch capitalised by crotching her. In a fortuitous botch, Hirsch collapsed when attempting a springboard, allowing Statlander to drop her with a body slam. Whether this was the plan or a quality spot of improvisation, the match didn't fall apart. The strikes were so full-on - the sound engineered was fantastic - that the crowd echoed with strong boo/yay chants before Statlander resumed the advantage with more wicked, unique, back-focused offence.

A protracted sequence atop the turnbuckle was more awkward than suspenseful, but the resulting near-fall from the avalanche Glam Slam/Big Bang Theory combo was excellent.

Statlander lost after Hirsch used a surplus turnbuckle located under the ring.

Cheap finish to a rich match.

Star Rating: ★★★¼

11. BUY-IN: HOOK Vs. QT Marshall

HOOK rules.

Advertisement

HOOK shows why he rules in the first two seconds of his matches, which rule.

His penetration step was a blur, following which he picked QT Marshall's leg and shoved him to the mat instantly. In a matter of seconds, HOOK got over, again, as an athletic prodigy with a better grasp of his badass character than entire generations of professional wrestlers.

He makes larger opposition look helpless by dominating them on the mat, positions into which they find themselves with an awesome sudden impact, but QT played his part here too. The man is a terrific, vastly underrated bumper. The snap, the flummoxed expression, the distance he travels hurtling himself out of the ring: he's a near-perfect prelim heel.

QT used his experience to outwit HOOK by the ropes and rake his eye, but the pompous ass got trapped with a shoulder-capture suplex when attempting a big boot. He went after the eye again, and again, his being a marvellous d*ckhead allowed HOOK the opening to choke him out with the Red Rum after QT gloated and vaulted over nothing but dead air.

Star Rating: ★★★½

10. BUY-IN: Death Triangle Vs. The House Of Black

You're not likely to see a pre-show match as fantastic as this.

Advertisement

PAC and Malakai Black's frantic stalemate gave way to the first in-ring glimpse of Buddy Matthews in AEW, which was immensely auspicious. He looked like he was carrying too much muscle against Kazuchika Okada in November; here, he sprinted across the ring and looked like a video game monster in a perfectly timed early sequence with Penta that ended in another slithering stalemate and a just ridiculously impossible-looking kip-up.

The huge and hugely endearing Eric Redbeard and Brody King's hoss battle was fantastic, and spirited - they weren't out of place amongst their dynamo partners and complemented the style without detracting from the blistering pace - but PAC and Matthews, holy sh*t. Their lightning fast sequences and the pelting blows within it were just exceptional state-of-the-art pro wrestling. Proper face-melting stuff, and that's before the match even approached the stretch.

After Brody King chopped PAC so hard that Excalibur let out a giddy squeal, Penta summoned "This is awesome" chants with a fabulous Canadian Destroyer - following which this trios banger broke down in the best possible way: apron Fear Factors, killer jumping knees, hoss colossus piledrivers...

For a silly programme plagued by its own lore, every man involved did such an exquisite job of registering their own presence and selling the danger of their opponents. There was as much cool body language as movez dopamine in this outrageous clash.

Star Rating: ★★★★

9. Chris Jericho Vs. Eddie Kingston

In their big verbal showdown on Dynamite a couple of weeks ago, Eddie Kingston demanded that Chris Jericho show him the Chris Jericho that earned the respect of Genichiro Tenryu.

Advertisement

As if to reiterate that plea, Kingston rocked Jericho right on the crown of the head with a disgusting (awesome) half-and-half suplex. This was the very first move of the match. What a tone it set, Christ. In a ghoulishly physical, super-intense puro-influenced war, the best Chris Jericho match since 2019, Jericho spent the remainder of it punishing Kingston for doubting who he was. The fans were in the line of fire too; this was Jericho responding to growing whispers that he had become redundant, in the wake of the aggressive roster expansion, by entering a killer, selfless effort that could not have done more to accomplish the objective. Jericho was in such outstanding form and radiated such star power that it really felt like Kingston had won the big one.

The struggle to get there made everything feel earned. When he wasn't executing a genuine '90s-tier version of his top rope hurricanrana, he was cutting off and blasting Kingston with Codebreakers and monster suplexes, one of which, a true Kobashi special, was launched from the apron to the outside.

This was Kingston's match, and Jericho was immense in making it feel authentic, fusing his underrated brawling skill with King's Road bombs. Kingston selling his eye injury and disbelief at the finish was just sublime, too.

What a tremendous bit of business.

Star Rating: ★★★★½

8. Jurassic Express Vs. ReDRagon Vs. Young Bucks - AEW World Tag Title Three-Way Match

The expected story played out, but in such a fun way.

Advertisement

The Young Bucks and ReDRagon couldn't maintain the agreement struck prior to the match to help one another in it. They broke up pins at a one count, crucially. Jungle Boy was never treated like somebody who could have conceivably been pinned several times just to advance the story with cheap near-falls. It was the central theme of the match, and it was a stupendous Kyle O'Reilly comedy vehicle. His disingenuous, oblivious "I forgot!" line reading was outstanding in the early phase of the match, which - being a Young Bucks match on pay-per-view - was at the **** level before it even got going.

Jungle Boy was on superb form eating sh*t, Nick Jackson made his case for being the best wrestler on the planet, and Luchasaurus was determined to prove that he was more than an endearing hot tag gimmick. ReDRagon meanwhile were on lethal form, countering Jungle Boy's signature offence with killer strikes and submissions. They added a new dimension to the Bucks' high-octane multi-man where Jungle Boy, with his immense creativity, blew everybody in the arena away with various, mind-blowing modifications of his best sh*t.

Ultimately, these matches are as difficult to construct as they easy to pop for - and those pops rose in volume with every deliriously inventive sequence. Every spot was arrived at organically, too, even by Bucks standards. The spats between the Bucks and ReDRagon helped, when Luchasaurus landed his massive popper dives on an unaware and vulnerable mass of bodies, but in general this was so heady and seamless.

A spectacular spot-fest legitimised by martial arts brutality and lightened by a wicked sense of humour, this was breathless stuff.

Star Rating: ★★★★¾

7. Face Of The Revolution Ladder Match

Uneven is the most accurate word.

Advertisement

Even by the standards of the multi-man ladder match, the prolonged selling on the outside was glaring at various points. The lack of flow and gripping immersion was also felt when the three absolute units sprawled out by the commentary table to set up the spot in which Keith Lee and Powerhouse Hobbs were taken out by Wardlow via table wreckage carnage. There were two perfectly serviceable, working ladders in the ring. Cool as the spot was, it was a dumb decision to stray from the field. It wasn't - Wardlow ended up grabbing the brass ring - but the decision made the match feel more fake than it had to. Cool, but inelegant.

The match was elegant elsewhere.

Orange Cassidy furthered his secret smartest man on the roster gimmick by lulling the giants into positions in which they acted as either human ladders or the platform for a ladder bridge. This took ingenuity and very impressive athleticism to execute. Keith Lee was almost too powerful, not that it wasn't awesome; when he yeeted Orange Cassidy over the top rope, he almost overshot it.

Ricky Starks showed off his own creativity and athleticism to deliver a spear between the legs of a ladder, and terrified onlookers by taking a powerbomb on the suspended apparatus. In a killer finishing sequence that put over Wardlow as the fan's choice, he leapt on the suspended ladder with a mind-blowing vertical leap, threw Starks to his doom, and grabbed the brass ring.

Longer and messier than it needed to be, it was wild when it peaked and delivered the result it needed to deliver.

Star Rating: ★★★½

6. Jade Cargill Vs. Tay Conti - AEW TBS Title Match

It didn't go too long, it didn't expose Jade, and yet it never failed to treat Tay Conti as a threat. It was, given the slot and the players involved, as good as it could have been.

Advertisement

It was arguably the worst-worked match on the show. On a few occasions, you could sense that both women were thinking about how to get into position. These moments of hesitation broke the all-important spell of suspension of disbelief. It's a problem with Jade's matches; it will resolve itself in time, but as ever, the sheer star presence she radiates compensated for it. And she was on fire as a personality here; putting herself over as the domineering, arrogant bully, with her Karate Kid taunts, she also dusted off an awesome frog splash on which she put her own, characterful spin.

Her individual repertoire, and it's growing, is so great that will evolve into an even more special performer when she puts it altogether.

The use of seconds and add-ons helped the match from feeling like an inferior version of a wrestling match - it was more of an attraction - and Conti's fire was a tremendous contrast to Jade's cocksure body language.

Star Rating: ★★★

5. CM Punk Vs. MJF - Dog Collar Match

In the strictest definition, CM Punk Vs. MJF, as an end to end presentation, was the greatest cinematic match of all time. The visuals, the sound, the heft, even, by the finish, the shot composition, this transcended wrestling - so much so that, at times, the crowd didn't react to it. The level of detail was almost too rich.

Advertisement

The AFI entrance wasn't just stirring nostalgia. This was CM Punk, as he foreshadowed on Rampage, reminding himself just who the f*ck he is.

The payoff to an instant classic of a programme was incredible. Every beat made sense. MJF targeted Punk's knee after Punk made a rare strategic error by chaining himself up and cracking it against the steps. The injury prevented Punk from executing the Go To Sleep, informing crushing near-misses, where Punk chewed up MJF's hand, knowing full well that MJF would cry out for Wardlow when he couldn't gut it out himself. And cry he did, literally, showing ass like the genius heel he is. Punk was otherwise the smart operator as the elder statesman genius he is; after an early bulldog was thwarted when MJF yanked the chain, Punk rolled it up to prevent a second counter.

In a match pitched in part as a tribute to Roddy Piper, Punk and MJF also invoked the storytelling brilliance of Bret Hart and Mick Foley. This wasn't so much laid out as it was directed, in Bret's seamless vision of building a story in which every beat was as well-linked as the weapon. The thumbtack spots meant as much as they did when Foley used the plunder; the suspense and the catharsis of MJF's GTS slapstick bump were unreal.

It was slow and attritional, a pace that simply doesn't hook a crowd like it used to, sadly, but it worked - eventually - because just look and listen to that finale. In a match with gruesome chain shots and thumbtack bumps, the diamond ring was sold as the most devastating weapon of all.

A nasty, claret-soaked war, it was wonderfully detailed but never in a way that felt cute.

Star Rating: ★★★★¾

4. Dr. Britt Baker Vs. Thunder Rosa - AEW Women's Title Match

Vince Russo's booking philosophy only worked for a short, electrifying period because he missed the point entirely.

Advertisement

The aim isn't to swerve the audience. The aim is to make the audience want something, reassure them that it's going to happen, and then create the most dramatic path to the destination.

Dr. Britt Baker Vs. Thunder Rosa represented the opposite of that extreme.

It was obvious, by the umpteenth interference and visual win, that Rosa would be made to wait. This didn't work; AEW had already relied on the original match without doing enough to build interest in this sequel. The programme was only a saga insofar as length, and this story beat amounted to little more than pissing about. Really, this only served to diminish interest in the switch. It's more than likely going to happen in Texas, and the moment should compensate for this, but the sheer length of the match diminished the overall experience of the pay-per-view. AEW and Tony Khan packed a long storyline build onto an overstuffed show, and the crowd wasn't up for it because the build didn't unfold on the preceding episodes of TV. This was an ironic misfire that will be salvaged by geography.

The work was uneven - a few frightening near-misses on certain bumps created the wrong strain of drama - but Baker and Rosa deserve immense credit for doing enough by the end (and in spite of an overbooked layout) to salvage the match from outright disaster territory.

When they were allowed to just wrestle, this bordered on very good, particularly by the finish, but the sequencing and bullsh*t made their job so much harder than it needed to be.

Star Rating: ★★¾

3. Bryan Danielson Vs. Jon Moxley

Jon Moxley Vs. Bryan Danielson played out to a subdued, spent crowd that wasn't up for all of it, but really, this probably would have happened had they opened the main card.

Advertisement

This was not mainstream, arena-sized professional wrestling. On some, very strict level, you could even describe it as a failure. It didn't work for this specific audience. That's a harsh way of analysing the match. Certainly, it was a bit self-indulgent. It was very much the match that Jon Moxley and Bryan Danielson, handed a plain sheet of paper, a razor, and 20 minutes, wanted to have. It wasn't a crowd-pleaser.

It was however f*cking incredible.

Moxley's winded selling was as unique as it was authentic. Danielson targeted his abdomen with one eye cast towards a longer runtime. Mox responded by attempting to bludgeon Danielson to death. Low on bumping, this was an intricate grappling match so brutal that it bordered on unsettling. The physical intimacy of the struggle lost the upper deck but informed the most powerful explosions; Mox's King Kong lariat almost took Danielson's head off in one incredible sequence all the better for the slow-burn. The storytelling was tremendous if, again, a bit understated for the major arena.

After both men attempted suicide dives, they exploded into a hockey fight in an unspoken agreement, almost. They don't dive. They should stop diving. They should show each other violence. They did, and in doing so, reflecting the build and foreshadowing the finish, they literally bled together. Gore as foreshadowing. Artful, brutal, ridiculously accomplished.

The crowd was mostly excellent, but they were swine for this.

Star Rating: ★★★★½

2. Sting, Darby Allin & Sammy Guevara Vs. Matt Hardy, Andrade & Isiah Kassidy - Tornado Trios Match

God, what a blast this was.

Advertisement

It was perfectly sequenced after three long, attritional singles matches. Tony Khan is the booker of the year already, and this match will have a lot to do with it. A lot of people thought this was a match too far on a loaded card; in reality, it was what a loaded card needed. It was shallow popcorn entertainment positioned at a time when the crowd needed to be seized by the throat and thrown into an atmosphere of exhilaration, anxiety and fun.

It was so great for what it was that it even made sense of the otherwise low-rent AHFO gimmick. The various underlings swarmed around the arena when the heels were in deep sh*t to assist with two stunt set-ups that otherwise would have dragged the all-action lunacy down.

Those two stunts were just absurd in the best way. Sammy Guevara destroyed Isiah Kassidy with a Spanish fly off an entrance tunnel and through a table, where Sting - Sting! - executed a balcony dive on Andrade through three tables. One outrageous spot, one magical spot, no laborious downtime.

Between the two demented stunts, Andrade el Idolo furthered his case as the umpteenth prospective TNT Champion on this stupidly deep roster. He worked phenomenally well with Darby Allin - Khan's award will be rescinded if he doesn't run that back as a singles match - and modified his deadlift one-armed powerbomb deal into the buckle.

Even Jose the Assistant took a crazy bump trapped in a trash can in a match that rendered the physical sensation of fatigue impossible.

Star Rating: ★★★★

1. Hangman Page Vs. Adam Cole - AEW World Title Match

As a story, this wasn't too ambitious or unfamiliar. Nor, as a result, was it special.

Advertisement

But in terms of execution, this simple tale of a cunning defensive wrestler countering the bombs of an explosive powerhouse was world class. Everything was right on the f*cking button.

Hangman Page killed Adam Cole with his best shots early. He rattled Cole's head with a brutal, full-on dropkick executed as he propelled himself through the ropes. The collision detection was meaty as f*ck. Everything Page struck - a vicious apron powerbomb in particular - looked like utter death.

Which made Cole's cut-offs all the more impressive.

There can be no doubting his star power now. After last night, that discourse - not all of which was debated in bad faith - seems wild. He effectively drew fans into the match and sold them on the switch with his flawless counter game. As best exemplified by a highlight reel superkick counter to the moonsault, which was millimetre perfect, the smaller Cole convincingly regained the momentum several times throughout. He was in tremendous form; a backstabber reversal to a pop-up powerbomb attempt was another memorable escape.

This dynamic informed several heart-pounding near-falls, as did the sheer physicality behind the signature moves. They went really, really hard to pop an exhausted crowd, and in the end, the babyface prevailed - but Cole was operating on such an awesome level that, much like in NXT, he felt like the fan's choice.

Pulsating and dramatic, structurally, it was nothing you've not seen.

In execution, it was something of which few other talents are capable.

Star Rating: ★★★★½

Advertisement