13 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW All Out

Chris Jericho makes history on a wild, chaotic AEW pay-per-view.

By Andy H Murray /

AEW

Professional wrestling fandom has become so partisan that the immediate reaction to an AEW pay-per-view is often to label it the best thing ever or a complete and utter disaster. All Out was neither of those things, though that won't stop knees from jerking and hot takes from spewing across the internet.

Advertisement

All Out lacked Double Or Nothing's buzz by the time it came to an end, but perhaps this was inevitable. You can only hold your first pay-per-view once, after all, but while this show lacked a headline-making moment like Jon Moxley's debut, it delivered on the card's promise. This was an exciting night of rich, varied action from a rich, varied roster.

There was no sign of CM Punk or Moxley. It didn't matter, though. Depending on your expectations, anticipated bouts like The Lucha Brothers vs. Young Bucks and PAC vs. Kenny Omega likely delivered or over-delivered. Yes, the show had its flaws, and yes, AEW have a few nuts and bolts to tighten before their televised debut, but they're absolutely moving in the right direction, with All Out a major improvement over Fyter Fest and Fight for the Fallen.

Advertisement

All Out brought the first AEW World Champion, cemented the inaugural Women's Title match, a big tag team debut, and all kinds of chaos between the ropes. Let's break it down.

Downs...

5. The Dark Order Misfire... Again

AEW

The Dark Order have been a fine in-ring tag team for years, but All Elite Wrestling continue to get Evil Uno and Stu Grayson wrong where it matters.

Advertisement

The duo are being let down through presentation and placement. With regards to the former, the gimmick is beyond corny with their Creepers looking more like twisted sex slaves than deadly followers, and their look pure shindie. Placement-wise, they were sent out to die at All Out. Going almost 15 minutes with a fundamentally solid but unremarkable tag match after the chaos of Jimmy Havoc vs. Darby Allin vs. Joey Janella and the much-anticipated PAC vs. Kenny Omega showdown only killed the crowd, and they didn't truly recover until two matches later.

Taken in isolation, Dark Order vs. Best Friends was solid enough. They worked hard and the Grayson/Uno tandem showed enough to suggest they can succeed if they're repackaged, but their current gimmick just isn't it. It has almost been rendered antiquated by Bray Wyatt's resurgence as The Fiend on WWE television. Here's hoping AEW switch it up.

Advertisement

4. Cody: Irresponsible Dog Owner

Advertisement

There's no doubt Cody loves his dog, Pharoah. There's also no doubt that the poor little pooch shouldn't have been anywhere near the stage last night.

You know what dogs hate? Fireworks. So why, then, did Cody and Brandi Rhodes deem it a good idea to try and parade Pharoah on the stage seconds after pyro had gone off a few metres from his face? The pup was absolutely terrified. His tail was stuffed between his legs and all he wanted to do was retreat back down the tunnel, though he was still dragged out regardless.

Advertisement

Don't do this again, please.

3. Jim Ross Vs. The Officials

AEW

While Jim Ross was largely fine throughout All Out, something needs to be done about the way he addresses officials.

Advertisement

JR once again went out of his way to draw attention to a number of refereeing mistakes throughout the pay-per-view. It was most apparent in PAC vs. Kenny Omega, where he pointed out a generous countout attempt, and Riho vs. Hikaru Shida, during which he criticised the official's positioning. This needs to stop.

While refereeing gaffes will be spotted by some viewers, a wrestling broadcaster should never be drawing attention to a botch. Instead, they should be doing everything in their power to talk around it and make the audience think of something else. Ross knows this, of course. He's the greatest wrestling announcer of all time, and your writer is just some shmuck on the internet... but why isn't he applying it?

Advertisement

2. The Mid-Show Lull

Advertisement

There seems to be an unwritten rule amongst wrestling promotions that big pay-per-views cannot run shorter than four hours. All Out came closer to five if you include the Buy In pre-show, and the elongated runtime felt particularly painful during the middle of the show.

The Dark Order vs. Best Friends and Riho vs. Hikaru Shida suffered as a result of this. The crowd weren't totally out of it, but they were significantly less engaged than during the preceding matches. It's a shame, as both bouts featured good work, but trimming was definitely needed.

Advertisement

Why must every match go 12 minutes plus? Yes, it gives the wrestlers a bigger spotlight, but it actively detracts from the viewing experience. At least a couple of All Out's matches could've benefitted from adopting the sprint format to keep the fans from switching off, and while this show wasn't anywhere near as drawn-out as Fight for the Fallen, the lull was still noticeable.

Speaking of which...

Advertisement

1. Overstaying Their Welcome

Advertisement

Chris Jericho vs. Hangman Page was a good professional wrestling match.

'Y2J' showed surprising agility early on, throwing his body around on a couple of athletic spots, then demonstrating remarkable timing as he got his knees up for Page's dive to the outside. His early dominance led to dramatic comebacks and near-falls from Hangman before Jericho was busted open, flipping the dynamic completely, with the smoke and mirrors kept to a minimum following the shenanigan-fuelled bouts earlier in the show.

Advertisement

But it was just too d*mn long.

While the crowd revelled in Jericho's presence early on, this faded as the long show and frequently meandering work tired them out. 10 minutes should've been shaved from the main event's 26. At this age, a half-gassed 'Y2J' can't keep a crowd hooked for such a length of time, and it's both a shame and a surprise that AEW didn't learn this after his Double Or Nothing match with Kenny Omega.

Advertisement

Not every pay-per-view main event needs to be a long, drawn-out "epic." Jericho vs. Page is proof of that.

Ups...

13. Nyla Rose Triumphs In Imperfect Casino Battle Royale

AEW

Your writer toyed with the idea of throwing All Out's Casino Battle Royale on the Downs side of this column. It had plenty of problems, with the production team missing several big moments, the third group of wrestlers botching their cue to come down, a handful of noticable in-ring flubs, and the performers frequently failing to space their spots out.

Advertisement

Ultimately, though, there was enough good about the clash to warrant the Up. Just. Britt Baker charging out of the ring to Thesz Press rival Bea Priestley on the ramp got a great reaction, and Prestley's involvement in the finish keeps their grudge alive. Nyla Rose looked awesome and is an intriguing winner who can now claim revenge against Riho for that Fyter Fest pinfall. The Joker, Mercedes Martinez, was incredible and should be signed immediately. The Librarians weren't awful for the first time ever, with Peter Avalon placing books on the floor to prevent Leva Bates' elimination. F*ckin' ODB was there. The list goes on.

The volume of mistakes means there are plenty of lessons to be learned for future Casino Battle Royales, though this columnist was satisfied with the whole.

Advertisement

12. No Alex Marvez

AEW

All Out was the first AEW pay-per-view to not feature Alex Marvex as the announce team's third man. The show was much stronger for it.

Advertisement

The malfunction Marvez is ill-suited to pro-wrestling commentary for a multitude of reasons, all of which have been covered in detail on this site (and hosts of others) since AEW's debut. For that reason, we shan't dive into them here. Goldenboy, on the other hand, is a huge upgrade, despite his lack of direct wrestling experience. His flow, cadence, and timing are all spot on, and while he lacks Excalibur's insight, this will come with experience.

Keeping Marvez around to maintain a "real sport" feel makes sense, given his NFL experience. Tony Schiavone, Jim Ross, and Excalibur is a far stronger TV team anyway.

Advertisement

11. Cunning Riho Strikes Again

Advertisement

Fyter Fest saw Riho score a major victory as she used guile and ring smarts to roll Nyla Rose up for a shock pinfall victory. At All Out, she repeated this feat, defeating the impressive Hikaru Shida in a match that largely revolved around her being dominated by her larger opponent.

Shida's work on top was as strong as Riho's defensive chops. Bludgeoned and thrown around, the Kenny Omega-affiliated prospect looked overmatched, but she was never truly out of the match. Her counters, cradles, and roll-ups came through underdog spirit and intelligence. She wasn't trying to "steal one," but play a smart game by frustrating Shida with comebacks and hope spots, trusting her body not to give up on her will, and it all paid off by the end.

Advertisement

The bout's muted crowd reactions prevent it from finishing higher up our list. Regardless, the size discrepancy gave Riho and Shida and easy David vs. Goliath story that they executed well, and the victor is getting over as the women's division's premiere underdog babyface.

10. Gifs At The Ready

Advertisement

While the Private Party vs. Angelico and Jack Evans brought little to the table in terms of story and psychology, it delivered as a spot-filled Buy In sugar rush that scratched an itch for anyone seeking all-out action, though old-school fans may have had a torrid time with it.

Marq Quen and Isiah Kassidy are raw and incomplete, but exhilarating. Their personalities come through in every single movement, from their entrance to the final bell, and watching them, there's no wonder that The Young Bucks have hand-picked them for stardom. Private Party are very reminiscent of a younger version of Matt and Nick Jackson, particularly in terms of fluidity and understanding of each other.

Advertisement

A blitzkrieg closing stretch saw Private Party emerge victorious when both Angelico and Evans were downed with poison 'ranas, before Quen and Kassidy hit their top-rope Hurricanrana/Cutter finisher on Angelico for the three-count. Afterwards, Angelico and Evans turned heel, beating Private Party down to give their team a much-needed wrinkle having gone 0-3 as an AEW tag team.

9. Oh Hey There, LAX

FiteTV

F*ck yeah, it's Ortiz and Santana... though they obviously won't be able to call themselves LAX in AEW. Impact Wrestling own that trademark.

Advertisement

Regardless, the duo made their presence felt after the chaotic Lucha Brothers vs. Young Bucks ladder match, walking down in all-black attire and John F. Kennedy/Bill Clinton masks, nailing their Street Sweeper finisher to stand tall. A strong, crowd-popping arrival, and it's great to see them go with AEW over WWE and Vince McMahon's hatred of tag wrestling.

With LAX, the Bucks, Lucha Bros., Private Party, Best Friends, A Boy and his Dinosaur, and more, AEW's tag division looks incredible. It seems like the promotion are going all in on their promise to focus more on this aspect of their product than their nearest competitors. The upcoming title tournament should be incredible and after already highlighting many an AEW pay-per-view, LAX's arrival ensures that particular trend will continue.

Advertisement

8. Janela Gets Corny

Advertisement

When looking for plunder beneath the ring, noted Jim Cornette target Joey Janela pulled out a tennis racket and glared at it with disbelief before turning his expression sour, throwing it to the side.

"Who on Earth would use that?!", Excalibur questioned on commentary.

Advertisement

A fun, chuckle-worthy way to get back at the hard-trolling, stuck-in-the-past pundit, though perhaps Cornette is the real winner here: Janela just gave him weeks worth of podcast material.

7. Pockets Full

Advertisement

Speaking of Cornette bait, here's Orange Cassidy!

'Freshly Squeezed' showed up after the Dark Order vs. Best Friends, with the Creepers carrying Trent? away from the ring. The lights cut out. Cue: the predictable big pop, and the noise only increased when they flashed back on, revealing the denim-clad Cassidy in the ring.

Advertisement

Rather than peppering Creepers with slow-motion kicks, Orange went for his awesome, hands-in-pockets suicide dive, taking the whole pile of Baby Craters out. The sunglasses stayed on. Then, he got back inside, kipped up... and the sunglasses stayed on. What's his secret?!

Chuck Taylor and Beretta embraced The King of Slow Style after, hinting at a new alliance. Anyone averse to Cassidy's comedic styles probably coughed up a hairball, but hey, your writer popped hard.

Advertisement

6. Pure Pantomime

AEW

While a clear notch or two below Cody's epic Double Or Nothing clash with brother Dustin Rhodes, 'The American Nightmare's' showdown with Shawn Spears was a strong, pantomime-driven bout laid out by a man who has mastered this style since AEW's formation.

Advertisement

Cody and Spears worked a bout perfectly suited to their strengths. It started hot, with Rhodes leaping out of the ring to attack the former Tye Dillinger before dropping Tully Blanchard with a single punch. A fired-up crowd-brawling sequence commenced before Cody and Spears left the rabid fans to return to the ring, with all kinds of shenanigans commencing thereafter.

Blanchard was phenomenal here. Full of life, he was clearly relishing his return to televised performing and was heavily involved throughout, whether he was distracting Earl Hebner or handing Spears a belt behind the ref's back. Said belt saw Cody briefly transform into Tomohiro Ishii as he defiantly rose through Shawn's whipping shots. This drew another big pop, though not the match's biggest: that belonged to Arn Anderson.

Advertisement

A sensational interference saw the former Horseman march down to the ring, sending the building into raptures as he nailed a perfect Spinebuster on Spears. His stomp to the backstage area prompting a disbelieving Blanchard to do the same. Moments later, Tully fell to a chair-assisted Disaster Kick.

This bout got the night's loudest crowd reactions up to that point for a reason: the sublime build on the Road to All Out YouTube series. Professional wrestling need not be complicated.

Advertisement

5. Cracker Barrel Chaos

AEW

Though Jimmy Havoc made for a curious winner, his three-way dance with Joey Janela and Darby Allin delivered on the promised anarchy.

Advertisement

This thing was batshit. Beginning with Janela and Allin ganging up on Havoc, they soon had him bound helplessly at ringside, having taped his thumbtack-filled mouth shut. A sick spot to start, and things only got crazier from thereon. Havoc stapled Janela's skull. He grabbed a sheet of paper and cut between 'The Bad Boy's' fingers, then his mouth. Joey hit a Brainbuster onto a chair. Then, that crazy bastard missed a full-on, unprotected Moonsault from the top rope to the floor. This prompted Havoc to get the actual Cracker Barrels involved, with a couple of them breaking - most notably when Allin hit a Coffin Drop onto the ring steps outside.

A strong finish saw Havoc take advantage of Janela's injured legs from the foiled Moonsault, superplexing his shins onto the barrel. He followed up by Acid Rainmakering him through the bloody thing, and that was that.

Advertisement

Hardcore wrestling isn't for everyone, but it will clearly have a place in AEW going forward. This bout showed it can flourish.

4. All Hail Luchasaurus

Advertisement

AEW have a potential star on their hands with Luchasaurus.

Little under two months after stealing the entire show at Fight for the Fallen, the 65-million-year-old beast was it at again. His, Marko Stunt, and Jungle Boy's trios match with SoCal Uncensored was designed to make the former Judas Draven look incredible - and he did. His hot tag saw him obliterate Scorpio Sky, Christopher Daniels, and Frankie Kazarian with all manner of kicks, spinning or otherwise, and his Chokeslam/standing Moonsault on Kaz had the whole building molten. Few things in the promotion are as exciting as watching this guy in full flow at the moment, and AEW would do well to keep highlighting him going forward.

Advertisement

The Luchasaurus praise shouldn't detract from the other wrestlers, though. Jungle Boy played an excellent face-in-peril and his offensive spells were suitably fast-paced, while the pint-sized Stunt's brief flurries were all on point. SCU, meanwhile, worked like the tight, cohesive veteran unit they are, selling the Luchasaurus terror well, before hitting a double Best Meltzer Ever on his tiny children for the victory.

This thing ruled. Checked it out if you like exciting trios action.

Advertisement

3. Dream Match Delivers

AEW

Jon Moxley's staph infection forced AEW to change gears days before All Out. His match with Kenny Omega would've likely been a heated, story-driven brawl informed by previous fights at Double Or Nothing and Fyter Fest, as well as their excellent Road To promos. For many, it was the most-anticipated bout on the card.

Advertisement

Swapping Mox for PAC meant AEW had to promote an exhibition-style dream match instead. This worked out just fine. For the most part, PAC vs. Omega was a dramatic, well-paced, elite-level wrestling match that started with a simple game of oneupmanship, before progressing at a slower rate than many would have expected, given their combined athletic talents.

This wasn't a problem at all. It would've been easy for PAC and Omega to build their match around hyper-athletic cloudbursts of offence, and it was refreshing to see them eschew this approach. The spurts of violence felt meaningful and well-placed. Concussive V-Triggers blasted PAC's skull and a gruesome Moonsault to the outside crushed his shins on the barricade. The finish, too, was sublime, with PAC countering the One Winged Angel into his Brutalizer submission, forcing a referee's stoppage as the 'Best Bout Machine' shockingly folded into the mat.

Advertisement

A botched poisoned 'rana at a prominent late-match spot prevent Omega vs. PAC from finishing higher. It still ruled, though.

2. The Right Choice

AEW

Though some may mourn Hangman Page's All Out main event loss, Chris Jericho was the right guy to go with as AEW's first World Champion.

Advertisement

Fight for the Fallen cooled Page off to a degree that couldn't be recovered on Being the Elite and Road To. A shame, as he's likely the wrestler AEW's future will be built around - but that's another reason why he didn't have to win. Why rush it with Page? He's only 28 years old, is still developing, and should be here for a long, long time. His coronation can wait.

Jericho, meanwhile, is comfortably the biggest mainstream name in the company. Though his athleticism has diminished and the main event was flawed, he's the familiar face that AEW need to lead their product when they debut on TNT next month. Him carrying the belt into those first few tapings should help draw and maintain a bigger audience.

Advertisement

It'll be interesting to see who AEW build as his first challenger, but no more 25-30 minute matches, please.

1. AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!

Advertisement

Matt Jackson, Nick Jackson, Rey Fenix, and Pentagon Jr. might be dead. Their ladder match was out of this world.

Professional wrestling is often at its best when it carries an air of legitimate danger. While watching these four wrestlers risk life and limb with all manner of crazy spots will have left traditionalists aghast, it sold the stakes. These wrestlers were so determined to put each other away that they were willing to use their bodies as weapons in the most extreme ways. This meant dozens of flips, dives, and well-choreographed double-team spots, dozens of which were executed off ladders and through tables - and the crowd lapped everything up.

Advertisement

The match's most dastardly moment saw Matt Jackson yank Pentagon's mask off. This only enhanced the terrifying skeleton ninja's bloodlust, with him and Fenix hitting a double stomp/piledriver onto a ladder bridged from the ring to the barricade. That it didn't break only added to the brutality.

This spot was enough for the Lucha Brothers to claim the victory, with Penta and Fenix scaling the ladders and grabbing the belts in tandem. They killed it and themselves in the biggest match of their careers. Hats off to them for sacrificing their bodies for our entertainment, though taking a few weeks off might be a good idea now.

Advertisement