2 Ups & 6 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (Aug 15)

Styles says "sorry," Cena wrestles Mahal, and Corbin makes a fatal error.

By Andy H Murray /

WWE.com

Complaining about WWE's shoddy pay-per-view go-home shows is almost moot at this point. The company aren't under pressure to sell PPVs anymore: they already have your Network subscription fee, so why would they bother putting the effort in to make sure their product is as hot as possible heading into the big show? They don't care, and rarely give their audience little reason to do so either.

Advertisement

That being said, last night's pre-SummerSlam SmackDown was particularly shoddy. It had a couple of minor highlights, and therefore wasn't a complete shambles, but it was definitely one of the brand's least enjoyable offerings of the year, and another off night for a show that is rapidly losing steam.

Baron Corbin's Money In The Bank cash-in was the night's biggest talking point. Elsewhere, WWE Champion Jinder Mahal had a stinker of the evening, predictable 50/50 booking ran amok, and even the Fashion Files, so often one of SD's biggest highlights, failed to deliver. A bad night as a whole, and one the performers would do well to put behind them.

Advertisement

Which segments contributed to this week's SmackDown slump, and which ones swam against the tide of negativity? Let's have a look.

Downs…

6. "Fashion Peaks" Runs Out Of Steam

Advertisement

Last night presented the Fashion Files’ weakest instalment in a while. The past couple of Twin Peaks riffs were bags of fun, but WWE have an undying habit of taking something that’s well-received and running it into the ground. This is what’s happening here. The jokes didn’t land as intended, the surrealism is wearing off, and we’re no closer to solving the mystery.

Breezango’s performances were fine, and the segment certainly wasn’t terrible, but it was a clear step down from the usual standard. The real downer, however, is the impenetrable bubble that these two seem to live in. Aside from The Ascension (and The New Day a few weeks ago), these segments never lead to meaningful interaction with other roster members, leaving Breezango on an island of their own on SmackDown. This problem wouldn’t exist if it led to the odd backstage segment or match every now and then, but they never do.

Advertisement

The Fashion Files have been a regular highlight on SmackDown these past few months, but the series’ flaws are really starting to show, and it desperately needs a refresh. Otherwise, they may become a more regular fixture in our ‘Downs’ section.

5. Rusev, Orton, And Repetition

WWE.com

Chad Gable and Rusev had an excellent TV match a few weeks ago. It wasn’t a long affair, but it gave both men a rare opportunity to showcase their raw technical wrestling ability, and both came off well. We got a rematch last night, much to the delight of anyone who saw the first clash, but it ended disappointingly.

Advertisement

Both men were counted out in little over a minute. This is a shame, because SmackDown could’ve used a great one-on-one bout to break up last night’s monotony, but it wasn’t to be. That being said, the real issue comes from the aftermath.

Randy Orton jumped ‘The Bulgarian Brute,’ laying him out with the RKO as revenge for last week’s assault. That’s the format this story has taken thus far: one week, Randy gets the advantage, the next, Rusev bites back. It’s an unoriginal, unengaging way to book a feud, WWE have given us precisely zero reasons to be excited about their eventual match, and if Rusev loses at SummerSlam (let’s be honest - he will), he’s going to look like a major dud.

Advertisement

4. Another PPV Match Given Away On Free TV

WWE.com

In terms of pure action, The Usos vs. The New Day was one of last night’s better in-ring offerings. It wasn’t great, but it was solid enough, with both teams doing pretty much everything they could within the eight minute window, but again, the macro trumps the micro.

Advertisement

WWE have given away a bunch of SummerSlam matches this week. First, it was Finn Balor vs. Bray Wyatt and Akira Tozawa vs. Neville on Raw, and now this. The SmackDown Tag Team Champions weren’t on the line, and The New Day lineup may be slightly different on Sunday, but just like Rusev vs. Orton, this is an exceptionally lazy way to book a feud.

The Usos won, so not only did WWE out their complete lack of imagination, but they managed to make their Tag Team Champions look weak in the process. No amount of solid action can compensate for this.

Advertisement

These two teams are probably going to tear the house down on Sunday, just like they did at Battleground. They’re two of the brand’s hottest acts at the moment, and they deserve better than to fall victim to lazy 50/50 booking, as neither team will benefit from this in the long run.

3. Cena Gets Dragged To Jinder's Level

WWE.com

John Cena is a tremendous big match performer, and a man who’ll always be underrated thanks to the colossal amount of unjust hatred he has received throughout his career. He’s a basic worker, sure, but his track record doesn’t lie. From AJ Styles and Roman Reigns to Daniel Bryan and CM Punk, ‘The Face That Runs The Place’ has had great bouts with a huge variety of opponents, but there’s one major problem with his work.

Advertisement

Cena never drags other wrestlers down, but he rarely elevates them either. Instead, he tends to work exactly to their level, and while it takes an unquestionably high level of skill to match the likes of Styles and Bryan, he has never been one to elevate lesser talent.

Unfortunately, Jinder Mahal falls into that category.

Advertisement

The duo wrestled in last night’s main event, and it stunk. A typical Jinder match, it was basic, plodding, and completely devoid of urgency or energy. WWE once again tried to mask Mahal’s deficiencies by filling it with Singh Brothers-related shenanigans, but the flaws were all too apparent, and it ended in a DQ when Baron Corbin attacked Cena.

A particularly bad match, this served only to further the feud between Cena and ‘The Lone Wolf.’ It did nothing for Mahal, who remains the least impressive WWE Champion in recent memory, and whose reign of error must now come to a sharp halt at SummerSlam.

Advertisement

2. The Script Remains The Same

WWE.com

As if you couldn’t already tell, last night wasn’t good for Jinder Mahal. His contributions presented his act at its absolute worst, and while his main event with Cena was a major clunker, his show-opening in-ring promo was even worse.

Advertisement

‘The Modern Day Maharaja’ didn’t screw up. He didn’t stumble over his words or get distracted by the crowd. His delivery was probably exactly what he intended it to be, but the script was awful. “I love India,” “India loves me,” “you hate me because you’re xenophobes”: singing aside, it was exactly like every other Mahal promo you’ve heard since he became WWE Champion, and the company should’ve just cut and pasted one from a previous week, such was the lack of differentiation.

Shinsuke Nakamura eventually interrupted, to which everyone in the building breathed a sigh of relief. He kept things short, stating that America will celebrate when he takes Jinder’s title, and that was that. The segment came to an end with both men jawing at each other, but it built no excitement for their upcoming clash, and served only to fill time.

Advertisement

1. Baron's Burial

WWE.com

Failed Money In The Bank cash-ins need to happen every now and then. If WWE have every single briefcase-holder successfully take their targeted championship, the format becomes stale and predictable, and loses its intrigue. They’re not a problem in themselves, but the way WWE execute them is absolutely vital, and they did the worst possible job with Baron Corbin last night.

Advertisement

‘The Lone Wolf’ tried to take Jinder Mahal’s WWE Title after his match with Cena, but became distracted by ‘The Face That Runs The Place.’ The bell rung, and Corbin was rolled up by the champ within segments, leaving him humiliated as the show came to a close.

It made Baron look like the biggest geek in the universe. Here’s a guy who has clear deficiencies in the ring, but WWE obviously like a lot, and are trying to build up as some big, nasty bruiser. Every heel needs his comeuppance, but this was far too soon for Corbin’s, and in the end, he leaves looking like a complete loser.

Advertisement

He’s not a perfect performer, but Baron had built considerable momentum in recent months. All of that is now gone, and while you can argue that giving him the MITB briefcase was a mistake in the first place, this was a borderline burial.

Ups…

2. Natalya Builds Some SummerSlam Momentum

WWE.com

There wasn’t much going on within Natalya vs. Becky Lynch last night. It was a relatively listless TV match, the kind of which we see every single week, but in the context of last night’s subpar show, it had enough quality to finish as one of the evening’s biggest plus points.

Advertisement

These two usually work well together, and they produced a solid back and forth affair last night. Becky came close to winning with a top rope leg drop, but it wasn’t to be, as Nattie rolled out of the way, locked in a Sharpshooter, and forced Lynch to tap. Natalya challenges for the SmackDown Women’s Title on Sunday, so this was the right outcome, and she looked strong in victory.

The aftermath saw Nattie apply a second Sharpshooter on Lynch, before Naomi made an inevitable save. Carmella and her Money In The Bank briefcase then made an appearance. She teased the idea of cashing-in at the pay-per-view, and while there’s little to suggest that the title match will be anything better than average, Carmella’s looming presence at least adds some intrigue.

Advertisement

1. An Apology Gone Awry

WWE.com

Last week didn’t go so well for AJ Styles. With Shane McMahon installed as the special guest referee for his match with Kevin Owens, ‘The Phenomenal One’ accidentally booted the SmackDown Commissioner in the head when a brawl broke out. It wasn’t his fault, but he left his boss laying, and with a big title match looming, that’s not a good position to be in.

Advertisement

Styles issued a full apology last night. He hit the ring, called Shane out, and tried to mend fences, but questioned if McMahon would use it against him in Sunday’s match. KO then arrived to stir the pot, stating that there was no way the kick could’ve been an accident, before another fight broke out. The roles were reversed this time, and Owens blasted McMahon with a superkick, leaving all three men on uneasy ground.

The likeliest outcome is that Styles retains the United States Championship, and we get Owens vs. Shane somewhere down the line. Regardless of the predictability, this was a perfectly cromulent segment. The trio were strong on the microphone, and their escalating mind games add intrigue to what should be a solid rematch, particularly if AJ and KO are motivated to top the disappointment of their past two in-ring encounters.

Advertisement