20 Dream WWE Matches That Only Happened ONCE!

These were WWE's true "Once In A Lifetime" showdowns. They'll NEVER happen again!

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE backed themselves into a corner by proudly boasting that The Rock vs. John Cena at WrestleMania XXVIII would be some "Once In A Lifetime" experience for fans. Buy those tickets and pay-per-views, folks, because you'll never see this again! Then, almost hilariously, Vince McMahon decided to book a rematch at 'Mania 29 the very next year.

Advertisement

People laughed and went along for the ride anyway, because this is pro wrestling and pro wrestling is full of false promises like that. How many wrestlers have "retired", for example? This phoney finality is probably why these one-off dream matches stand out. They truly were "Once In A Lifetime" - WWE never booked them again.

Shocking? Absolutely. Cool? Definitely.

There are a whole bunch of bouts from episodes of free TV too, which really just goes to show how much content WWE has to fill throughout the year. Sometimes, matches that would've been pay-per-view blockbusters happen on Raw to plug a gap. They always have.

One match here sticks out as a possible repeat for the future, but none of the others can ever happen again. One-off time...

20. John Cena vs. Jeff Hardy

When: Raw (2 June 2008)

Advertisement

It's actually surprising that John Cena vs. Jeff Hardy only happened once on TV or pay-per-view. Both were big stars during the 2000-2010 decade, and Hardy was pushed on and off towards the end of that 10 year sprint. One would think that he and Cena might've torn it up in several bouts, but no.

The 2 June 2008 flagship was their only televised battle.

Cena beat Jeff after almost 15 minutes. The match was a number one contendership scrap for WWE Title, and it was probably a given that JC was getting the nod due to his status as a concrete main event star at the time. Still, shocking they'd only do this once.

19. Charlotte Flair vs. Trish Stratus

When: SummerSlam 2019

Advertisement

Nobody saw Trish's latest WWE run coming in 2023. It came totally out of left field, but led to some real gold opposite Becky Lynch. Before that, Stratus wrestled what she presumed was her final match vs. Charlotte Flair at SummerSlam 2019. She left it all in the ring that night.

Both women sparkled, and Trish did the honours for Charlotte in her hometown of Toronto. People in Canada might've been bummed out by that, but this was Stratus attempting to pass the torch. She honestly didn't see more matches coming at the time.

WWE left this as a one-off to suit the soft retirement.

18. Chyna vs. Lita

When: Judgment Day 2001

Advertisement

It's important to state for the record that Chyna vs. Lita certainly wasn't a "dream match" when it happened back in 2001. Women's wrestling was in a very different place, but time has been kind to the legacies of these ladies. Both are now considered trailblazers, and rightly so.

Pity Chyna didn't really want to work this match.

The 'Ninth Wonder' thought she was above wrestling other women at the time, and she wasn't long for the WWF scene anyway. Judgment Day '01 proved to be Chyna's last hurrah in the company. Her match vs. Lita wasn't great, but it's become a treasured gem by some.

17. Batista vs. Roman Reigns

When: 12 May 2014 Raw

Advertisement

There was a smaller window for this match than you might think. Roman Reigns wasn't on the main roster radar during Batista's first run with WWE, and 'Big Dave' only returned for a scatter of select matches in 2014 and 2019. Somehow, Roman and Batista managed to meet up on a random Raw in mid-May 2014.

It left people wanting more.

Various run-ins led to the bout being thrown out. Reigns and Batista would clash on pay-per-view as part of The Shield and Evolution afterwards, but they'd never match up one-on-one again. In other words, that "more" people wanted? They didn't get it.

16. Batista vs. Kurt Angle

When: 20 June 2005 Raw

Advertisement

Score another one-off for 'The Animal'.

This is a little more shocking. Kurt Angle was present in WWE for the first four years of Batista's company career, so one would think they'd end up tangling more than once on TV or pay-per-view. Nope. They got exactly one match on the 20 June 2005 edition of Raw and that was that.

The whole thing lasted two minutes, by the way. Batista won by disqualification, meaning any hopes of seeing Angle chain wrestle his way past Dave's power game were dashed in the blink of an eye. It's a damn shame two guys this talented (and high profile) only wrestled solo for TWO MINUTES.

15. Dusty Rhodes vs. Randy Orton

When: Great American Bash 2007

Advertisement

Here's a match that shows the full range of Randy Orton's longevity.

Randy was already five years deep into his WWE main roster career by the time he clashed with Dusty Rhodes in a 'Texas Bullrope' match at the Great American Bash '07 pay-per-view. Think about this: Orton could realistically wrestle Dusty's son Cody almost 20 years after bashing daddy-o's skull in with a cowbell.

That's insane, but it again speaks to the lengthy career Randy has enjoyed. Back at the Bash, he continued his 'Legend Killer' gimmick by defeating the 'American Dream' in suitably vicious fashion. Then, Rhodes went back to training rookies and Orton moved on to other victims.

14. Goldberg vs. Shawn Michaels

When: 20 October 2003 Raw

Advertisement

Admit it: Fans of a certain vintage would've high-fived one another at the prospect of seeing Shawn Michaels try to pull a decent match out of squash match machine Bill Goldberg during the 'Monday Night Wars'. That seemed improbable due to Shawn's retirement, but his return in 2002 and WCW's demise the prior year made it possible.

WWE eventually booked the showdown in late-October 2003. Was it any use? Meh, not really, but Goldberg's matches were always better on paper than in execution. Michaels did bump around for the powerhouse too, so it wasn't a terrible way to spend six minutes either.

Defo qualifies as a dream match.

13. Brock Lesnar vs. AJ Styles

When: Survivor Series 2017

Advertisement

Brock Lesnar might've said no to a 'Champ vs. Champ' match with Jinder Mahal in late-2017, but he was licking his chops at the thought of hitting suplex after suplex on the much more skilled AJ Styles. To his credit, Styles approached this bout the right way and knew he'd have to let Brock dominate most of it then time his comebacks.

Together, they produced a nifty 15-minute story.

Granted, there was no real need for WWE to return to Brock vs. AJ after Survivor Series. It was always more of an exhibition (the kind announcers could hype the latest video game's "fantasy warfare" element with) and little else. This combo will probably never happen again.

12. Daniel Bryan vs. Brock Lesnar

When: Survivor Series 2018

Advertisement

This one absolutely won't happen again.

AEW's Bryan Danielson is on a slow road to proper retirement (on his terms this time) in 2024, and Brock's WWE future is very-much up in the air. These guys will maybe never be underneath the same roof again let alone inside the same wrestling ring, and that makes Survivor Series 2018 special.

One year on from brutalising AJ, an inspired Lesnar worked his socks off in a fun main event vs. Bryan that ran close to the 20 minute mark. People were real chuffed with this one at the time, especially because Daniel's comeback earlier in the year opened up all sorts of possibilities for more "dream matches" to come.

11. AJ Styles vs. Cody Rhodes

When: Backlash 2024

Advertisement

OK, so this match was super-recent and there is always the threat of more whilst Cody Rhodes and AJ Styles are still actively wrestling on the same roster. Their WWE Title collision at Backlash 2024 over in France did have a one-off vibe to it though; the whole framing heading in teased that this would be AJ's only crack at Cody's gold.

It belongs on the list right now, or at least until there's a sequel.

Cody and Styles played before one of the rowdiest WWE crowds ever in Lyon, and they met that lively audience halfway by producing a scorching effort you really should go back and watch again. Up-to-the-minute bouts rarely get revisited because, well...they've just happened, but you'll enjoy this even more second time around.

10. CM Punk vs. Brock Lesnar

When: SummerSlam 2013

Advertisement

How did this happen once and once only?!

CM Punk bashed heads with legends like The Undertaker, John Cena and even The Rock on multiple occasions during his first 2005-2014 tenure in WWE. He'd only collide with Brock Lesnar once: SummerSlam 2013. Yours truly could've sworn there was a rematch on some 'B' level pay-per-view afterwards, but nah. There wasn't.

Lesnar got the win following a full 25 minutes of sheer drama, and it was back to the drawing board for Punk. He was real p*ssed off with WWE life by that stage anyway, so this was arguably his final top singles showing before leaving the promotion post-Royal Rumble 2014.

Brock currently being on ice means a rematch isn't likely today.

9. Eddie Guerrero vs. Brock Lesnar

When: No Way Out 2004

Advertisement

In many ways, No Way Out 2004 was the precursor to Brock Lesnar's matches vs. AJ Styles, Daniel Bryan and Finn Bálor. Eddie Guerrero was a similarly-athletic type of wrestler to those men, and he was cast in the underdog role before shocking the world with a mega-popular WWE Title win heading into WrestleMania XX.

This, rather unfortunately, would be the only time he and Brock were able to deliver a classic - Lesnar left WWE right after 'Mania, and Eddie's tragic passing the next year meant he was long gone by the time Brock returned for another whirl in 2012. Wrestling fans will always have this pay-per-view gem.

It was a joy to relive when prepping this article.

8. Rob Van Dam vs. Rey Mysterio

When: 7 June 2006 WWE vs. ECW Head To Head

Advertisement

Do you recall WWE's 'Head To Head' show between the main brands and their own version of ECW? Most won't, which might make revisiting Rey Mysterio vs. Rob Van Dam quite the treat. For reference, this was the same episode that had John Cena warring with Sabu and Edge facing Tommy Dreamer.

Rey vs. RVD was better than both despite them being babyfaces who also worked extensively as tag-team partners. That union is perhaps why Mysterio and Van Dam only have this match to look back on as opponents. WWE seemingly weren't keen to make a habit of it.

PPVs of the era missed out big time.

7. Triple H vs. Daniel Bryan

When: WrestleMania XXX

Advertisement

Technically, Triple H and Daniel Bryan "wrestled" the night after their cracker at WrestleMania XXX. Except they didn't. Not really. That match barely got started before various other wrestlers piled in for a brawl and non-finish, which makes 'Mania XXX unique. It was the sole occasion on which these workhorses squared off.

Bryan Danielson will never forget it.

Trips made him look like the man early in the night before Bryan went on to beat both Randy Orton and Batista to claim WWE immortality. Anyone worried Hunter would steal Daniel's spotlight had nothing to fear. 'The Game' was all in on the 'Yes Movement' by that point.

6. Bret Hart vs. Roddy Piper

When: WrestleMania VIII

Advertisement

Bret Hart and Roddy Piper reportedly avoided backstage trouble by claiming their bloodletting was completely accidental. Vince McMahon let them away with it, but punished Ric Flair and Randy Savage for the same thing later in the night. That's one of the most famous stories fans have taken away from this iconic match-up.

The next time Bret and Roddy shared the ring together physically? WCW in 1998, and that was a tag bout. WrestleMania VIII would never be replicated in a rematch - not in the WWF and not down south in Atlanta later the same decade. That's astonishing.

Something else amazing? Losing to Bret was Roddy's first televised singles clean job since 1986.

5. Dean Ambrose vs. Roman Reigns vs. Seth Rollins

When: Battleground 2016

Advertisement

The fact this three-way happened on a 'B' pay-per-view like Battleground is unacceptable. An implosion of The Shield should've done monster business at WrestleMania or SummerSlam, but it wasn't to be. WWE put Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose out there on a lower-level show instead.

Boo to them.

Anyone thinking this Triple Threat would become a hot ticket on the house show circuit is sorely mistaken too. WWE's creative team never really came back to the idea of all three Shield boys locking horns as rivals again. That's incredible when considering that bouts like Ambrose vs. Rollins and Reigns vs. Seth have been done to death individually.

4. The Rock vs. Eddie Guerrero

When: 22 July 2002 Raw

Advertisement

One to cherish.

That's how people felt when The Rock vs. Eddie Guerrero went down on a hot summer night in 2002, because everyone knew the match wasn't going to be the start of some long-running series. Rocky had already started to move towards Hollywood by 2002, and it was obvious his full-timer days were coming to a close.

Meanwhile, Eddie was just getting warmed up en route to main event stardom.

Seeing Guerrero and The Rock on pay-per-view in 2003 or 2004 (even given Dwayne's part-time schedule) would've been a riot. Fate would decree that this Raw match is the sole offering they'd give together in singles action though. Another one worth going back to check out in retrospect, or if you've never seen it.

3. Shawn Michaels vs. Rob Van Dam

When: 25 November 2002 Raw

Advertisement

Nobody ask RVD to do that impression of HBK.

Rob refuses to do it nowadays, but he didn't always (ahem) see eye-to-eye with Shawn Michaels. That might explain why they'd wrestle exactly one singles bout on TV or pay-per-view in WWE. It fell on an episode of Raw in November 2002 shortly after Shawn had returned to capture the World Heavyweight Title.

RVD won via DQ following approx eight minutes of ridiculously solid wrestling. What should've been an appetiser for more to come was sadly more of an unsatisfying teaser for fans. Van Dam and Michaels did work several tag matches together after this, but they didn't produce any classics.

2. Ric Flair vs. The Undertaker

When: WrestleMania X-8

Advertisement

Being totally honest, The Undertaker and Ric Flair did work a run of brief house shows matches in 1992 before the 'Nature Boy' bolted back to his WCW comfort blanket in early-1993. Do those count? They do, but this combo is included anyway 'cause fans had to wait another decade for them to do anything meaningful in front of the cameras.

'Taker vs. Flair didn't happen on TV/PPV until WrestleMania X-8.

It could be considered a "dream match". Fans were right up for it after seeing a reinvigorated Flair do his thing vs. Vince McMahon at the 2002 Royal Rumble, that's for sure. Ric proved he still had gas in the tank vs. another active legend at 'Mania, and he was off to the races again.

1. Hulk Hogan vs. Shawn Michaels

When: SummerSlam 2005

Advertisement

SummerSlam '05 was meant to be the first leg of a series between Hulk Hogan and Shawn Michaels, but egos clashed and neither side fancied it after the initial match. Shawn's ridiculous over-selling was considered a slap in the face from Hulk, and ol' Terry apparently didn't want to return the favour by losing to HBK in a rematch anyway.

Michaels was probably just glad to be shot of Hulk.

Their main event remains one of the most curious headliners in WWE history though. Hulk's face mid-beatdown when Shawn starts flopping around the place is worth seeing, but it wasn't all a p*sstake. Some moments midway through even hinted at what might've been possible had they been on the same page.

What other dream match scenarios only happened once in WWE? For more wrestling, check out WWE King & Queen Of The Ring 2024: 10 Things That Must Happen and WWE King & Queen Of The Ring 2024: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True! 

Advertisement