4 Ups & 3 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (Nov 15)

Welcome home, Mr. Deadman.

By Andy H Murray /

WWE.com

Though not as heavily promoted as 2012's Raw 1000, WWE did a good job building-up to last night's 900th episode of SmackDown. It didn't just serve as the last stop before Survivor Series, but a stage for The Undertaker's long-awaited comeback, and a huge Intercontinental Title rematch between Dolph Ziggler and The Miz.

Advertisement

By the time it finished, SmackDown wasn't the historic show that WWE had built it up to be, but it succeeded on a number of levels. There were some missteps (looking at you, tag teams), sure, but The Undertaker's return delivered, as did Miz vs. Ziggler, and SD's women were successfully able to ward off their Raw invaders.

Both shows did a great job in building Survivor Series as an important pay-per-view this week, even if their teams' transformations were too sudden to be believable. SmackDown's stars were beating the tar out of each other last week, but now? They've forgotten all about their differences, and Survivor Series will be focused on competition rather than infighting.

Advertisement

This was one of the better go-home shows that WWE have produced this year, but definitely not one you'll be telling your grandchildren about in 30 years. Here are 4 ups and 3 downs from last night's WWE SmackDown.

Downs...

3. Losing Sami vs. Dolph

WWE.com

The Miz and Dolph Ziggler kicked-off SmackDown with a solid match for the Intercontinental Championship. It didn't quite reach the heights of their No Mercy barn-burner, but how could it? They went for close to 20 minutes, Maryse pushed her husband to reverse Dolph's roll-up, and just like that, we have a brand new Intercontinental Championships.

Advertisement

The match was too good to be a Down, but the consequences most certainly weren't. Miz's last IC run was fantastic, and as vital in rebuilding himself as one of SmackDown's biggest heels as the infamous Talking Smack rant, but we just lost Dolph Ziggler vs. Sami Zayn at Survivor Series, and that sucks.

On a pay-per-view highlighted by Brock Lesnar vs. an old man and three multi-man matches that'll likely be full of shenanigans, Ziggler vs. Zayn had show-stealing potential. They're two of the best wrestlers in the company, and if given enough time, it was hard to imagine them not blowing the roof off. WWE have deprived us of this by switching the title last night, and that's a shame.

Advertisement

Sami and Miz will probably have a fun match themselves, but it won't be the same, despite Miz's improvements since the Draft. Boo and indeed hiss, SmackDown.

2. 12 Pointless Minutes

WWE.com

Survivor Series' 10-on-10 tag team elimination contest felt like the PPV's least important match from the moment it was announced, and recent weeks have done little to change that. It was the same situation again last night, and while SmackDown's tag teams were given ample time to impress, they did absolutely nothing with it.

Advertisement

King Booker returned for a quick backstage segment as Heath Slater & Rhyno attempted to rally the troops for Sunday, and the bulk of SD's teams came together for a big 8-on-8 match later on. It screamed of the producers struggling to fill airtime, and after 12 relatively pointless minutes, American Alpha hit Grand Amplitude on a nondescript Headbanger to take the win.

Perhaps it's unfair to criticise the Survivor Series competitors too strongly - they were competing against one of the most unimpressive 8-man groups (the Headbangers, Vaudevillains, Spirit Squad, and Ascension) ever assembled, after all. Still, the tag teams are heading into the PPV with next to no heat. They'll likely put on a decent show in the end, but SD's 10-man team had a great opportunity to warm-up an incredibly cold PPV match last night, and they blew it.

Advertisement

1. Suddenly, We're All Friends Again

WWE.com

The past few weeks have been rife with infighting. Raw and SmackDown's teams have both struggled to get on the same page ahead of Survivor Series, and it was strongly implied that whichever team found even the slightest shred of cohesion would prevail. Regardless of this, and in spite of the authority figures' protests, both brands have been a warzone, and the wrestlers looked happier to squabble amongst themselves than set their differences aside.

Advertisement

Things took a sharp U-turn last night, however. The Usos celebrated with American Alpha like they hadn't spent most of October trying to tear Chad Gable's knee apart, and when Raw's females attacked Nikki Bella, Carmella suddenly forgot all about their bitter rivalry. In the end, SmackDown's women put on a united front to ward the Raw invaders off, and though the men bickered, The Undertaker appeared to scare them into submission.

After weeks of gnashing at each other's throats, fans are now expected to believe that SD's Survivor Series teams are all best mates all of a sudden. It was too much, too fast, but depressingly typical of WWE's impatience and short-termism.

Advertisement

Both Raw and SmackDown had the opportunity to tell a slower, more logical tale of their teams gradually finding cohesion over a longer timescale. Instead, they chose to cram everything into their respective go-home shows. A disappointing shortcut, and a real missed opportunity.

Ups...

4. Opening With A Match

WWE.com

It's an unwritten rule that every major WWE television show must open with a lengthy talking segment. The days of The Authority boring the audience into submission with the same droning, 30-minute promo are gone, fortunately, but the structure persists through the New Era, and it's not going away anytime soon.

Advertisement

Fortunately, SmackDown broke the habit last night. Okay, so Daniel Bryan and Shane McMahon were out first, but they only hung around for a few seconds. When they were done, The Miz and Dolph Ziggler kicked things off with a tremendous Intercontinental Title match, and after some typical Spirit Squad/Maryse chicanery, Miz is the new IC Champion.

It's a shame to lose Ziggler vs. Sami Zayn at Survivor Series, but there's no better way to open a wrestling show than with, you know... wrestling. Anything that breaks convention must be seen as a good thing in WWE's increasingly formulaic universe, and it helps that Miz and Ziggler had the best match of the night. They set the show off on a high note, and while the rest couldn't quite match their quality, SD made a great start.

Advertisement

This is Miz's sixth Intercontinental Title reign, and the finish means his rivalry with Ziggler will likely rumble on. Few will complain about this: they duo have been warring for months, but they're both putting forth some of the best work of their careers at the moment. There's plenty of gas left in this particular tank, and the IC scene will remain strong for as long as they're involved with it.

3. Kalisto Wins

WWE.com

Appearing on SmackDown for the first time since dinosaurs roamed the Earth, Kalisto scooped a quick win over NXT's Oney Lorcan last night. It wasn't long enough to analyse too deeply, but it did everything it needed to: Kalisto looked great ahead of his Cruiserweight Title match this weekend, and Lorcan wasn't made to look like a schmuck.

Advertisement

This is a perfect use for lesser-known NXT workers like Lorcan. It gives them the opportunity to get comfortable on a bigger stage, where one day they'll hopefully end up, and also allows the crowd to become familiar with them. Billy Kay played a similar role for Dana Brooke back in June, and if SmackDown are to continue with these short enhancement matches, these guys are a stronger option than Raw's faceless local talents.

Kalisto needed a win prior to challenging Brian Kendrick at Survivor Series, and he got it. The former Lucha Dragon should have never been excluded from the Cruiserweight division in the first place, but he's taking the whole roster with him should he win on Sunday. Here's hoping he does: SmackDown could use some fresh faces, and the show's smarter writing team make Tuesday nights a better home for the Cruisers anyway.

Advertisement

2. Chaos! Chaos Everywhere!

WWE.com

Raw closed with a huge chaotic brawl between both brands' men's teams, and SmackDown continued the theme last night, only with the women. Nikki Bella and Carmella were embroiled in a No Mercy rematch when Raw's Charlotte showed up to poison the well. It didn't take long for Nikki to get distracted and strike Charlotte, and when the match was called-off, Raw's women's team invaded.

Advertisement

A fight broke-out, but unlike the men, SD's women were successful in fending-off their Raw rivals. Nia Jax missed a spear and sent herself flying through the barricade, Naomi scored a big dive, and the blue squad stood tall. Lesson of the week: don't invade your opposing brand without expecting to get beaten up for your troubles.

As nonsensical as both sides' premature togetherness is, Raw did an excellent job of building excitement for the men's match, and SmackDown the women's. This segment wasn't quite as heated as its Raw counterpart, but the crowd absolutely lapped it up, and it sent the blue team into Survivor Series on a high note. The Raw team will walk-in as rightful favourites, but if the likes of Becky Lynch and Alexa Bliss can resist the urge to strangle each other mid-match, they might just pull it off.

Advertisement

1. Digging Holes & Taking Souls

WWE.com

Of course The Undertaker's comeback was one of the highlights of the night.

Advertisement

It was obviously good to see Edge (and his marvellous beard) again, but he's on the Network all the time anyway. His appearance was significant, but not as important as The Deadman's, who hadn't been seen on WWE programming since WrestleMania 32.

SmackDown's closing segment kicked-off with a James Ellsworth-centric edition of the Cutting Edge that saw AJ Styles take the brunt of everyone's jokes, and then the gong struck. As announced, The Undertaker emerged to close the show, and in one of the night's biggest surprises, announce his (seemingly) permanent return to the active roster.

Advertisement

In his own words, Taker is no longer a WrestleMania exclusive. He'll be back on a semi-active schedule for the first time in years, and warned SD's wrestlers that if they fall at Survivor Series, they'd have him to answer to.

The Undertaker's appearance raises a lot of questions, but there are a number of strong matches for him on SmackDown's current roster. AJ Styles and John Cena make perfect sense, but there's also Dean Ambrose, or the revitalised Miz and Dolph Ziggler. However often he works, it's great to have him back, and though his career's clearly winding down, Taker won't be stuck for things to do while he's still around.

Advertisement

WWE made a smart move in closing SmackDown 900 with Taker's comeback. It was always going to be the night's biggest talking point, and it closed the show on a high note. Two thumbs up for delivering on the hype, and unexpectedly bringing The Undertaker back on an increased schedule.