4 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Rampage: Road Rager (June 17)
Sting shocks AEW; Tony Khan takes the p*ss out of his own title rankings.
"IT'S STIIIIIIIIIING!".
Excalibur couldn't wait to do his best Tony Schiavone impression on this week's Rampage. It's 2022 and a full 25 years since he started doing it, but there's still something wonderful about the lights dimming then the Stinger showing up unannounced. AEW got a lot of mileage out of that on Friday night's 'Road Rager' special.
"Special" isn't something one could call most of the 60-minute episode though. The opener was good, and the women's bout had merit, but literally everything else suffered due to poor refereeing or poor presentation. Also, what was up with Tony Khan making a mockery of his own title rankings here?
That was so odd to see, especially as "top ranked contenders" suddenly became important again when hyping Forbidden Door. This is something All Elite must be careful of, because they don't want to sh*t all over the things that help them stand out.
Come for Sting's return, stay for some young workers getting to shine and then shake your head at more of the same annoying problems that blight AEW's booking.
Here's all the good and bad from Rampage.
Downs...
4. Your Point, Caller?
Boy, this was useless.
Max Caster teamed up with Gunn Club to beat Leon Ruff and Bear Country is roughly one minute. The match was a senseless waste of everyone's time, and seemingly only existed so Caster could rap and fans could chant, "Ass Boys" along with the injured Anthony Bowens.
Generally, Tony Khan crams too much into each Rampage episode. This was a classic example of that, and it shouldn't have happened. Would it have killed AEW to give Jade Cargill and Willow Nightingale another few minutes for their match, or maybe stuck another minute or two onto Jon Moxley vs. Dante Martin?
Instead, Ruff and his big buddies were thrown to the wolves. It's strange to see workers like Caster and the Gunns (who typically play cowardly heels during their matches) dominate and squash others anyway. This whole segment was a big ol' miss.
3. Wrecking Their Own Rankings
AEW likes to claim that every win and loss matters in the title rankings picture. So, why did Willow Nightingale get a crack at Jade's TBS Title then? Her own entrance graphic pointed out that she last wrestled for AEW on the 2 May edition of Dark: Elevation against Gia Scott.
Her overall win/loss record for 2022 is also 1-3.
It's great to see Willow get some TV time (she's fab), but come on. Two months on from your last All Elite outing and still getting a shot at a supposedly-prestigious belt with a losing record? Next, Tony will be shoving Ashley D'Amboise from those Dark: Elevation tapings into the title mix too. Why not, eh?!
Handing championship matches out like free sweeties then trying to make a big deal out of Toni Storm being "the top ranked contender" for Thunder Rosa's own title in the same episode is stupid. Consistency is everything when you're leaning on real-sports rankings.
2. Nobody Stands Out
Here's another bitch about the women's scene in AEW.
Why does every babyface challenger around this place need somebody else to run in and save them when things get feisty? Athena took care of Kiera Hogan, but then got roughed up by the dominant Jade Cargill before Kris Statlander rushed out to save her skin.
This was yet another example (in a long line of examples!) of AEW over-booking segments that really don't need it. It's also really worrying that Athena is starting to blend in rather than stand out next to the other women on the roster. This...keeps happening.
Why should anybody believe that Athena is a threat to Cargill when she can't even fight her own battles? Is it worth sacrificing that individual credibility so All Elite can book more thrown-together multi-person tags on future episodes? No, it's not.
1. The Main Event’s Refereeing
Consider this a complement to the whinge about those title rankings.
Bryce Remsburg started count outs then randomly stopped them during the main event between Bobby Fish and Darby Allin. At one point, Bryce even exited the ring to admonish Fish for failing to follow rules he himself was barely bothering to enforce. Wow.
This happened several times in what was clearly presented as a regular match (one with rules, supposedly), and it definitely stood out. Sometimes, Remsburg didn't even count despite Allin and Fish being outside the ring or working spots on the apron. It was all over the place.
Fans shouldn't care if this occurs during a picture-in-picture ad break or not - it shouldn't be happening at all, especially during a TV main event. Bryce is usually a fine ref, so it's weird that he looked like he'd been plucked out of the crowd and asked to officiate here.
Ups...
4. Jade Cargill’s Notable Improvement
AEW's post-match saddled the women with more messy run-in b*llocks, but the actual match between Jade Cargill and Willow Nightingale was perfectly fine. Jade is showing real signs of improvement every time she steps between the ropes, and Willow got enough in to ensure this wasn't a squash.
Good, 'cause Nightingale deserves better than that.
It's probably shouldn't have been a title bout, but that's been covered in the 'Downs'. This was a fun little TV match that didn't overstay its welcome but also gave fans enough of a reason to care about the beaten wrestler. All Elite chiefs can consider that a win all-round.
Jade looks more comfortable in back-and-forth matches than she did a few months back too. That's a sure sign she's improving, and it means her next major pay-per-view collision should be her best yet. Fingers crossed that's against Athena.
3. That Commentary
He's not pictured, but William Regal and Chris Jericho are gold together.
The veteran pair bounced off one another like a comedy double act who just adore taking the p*ss out of their real-life mates. This fan got a big pop out of Regal saying he invented a submission hold Jon Moxley locked in, and the banter that ensued.
When Jericho said, "He'll take credit for it either way. Who you gonna ask? Johnny...Johnny Saint?!", Regal replied: "I've got him on speed dial". It was all so charming and silly, but crucially didn't overwhelm the match between Moxley and Dante Martin one bit.
Regal and Jericho picked their spots, and set about the task of colouring up the commentary without diverting too much attention away from the opener. They enhanced it, which good announcing should always strive to do.
2. Dante Martin’s Performance
Dante Martin is looking more and more like a star-in-the-making against top names like Jon Moxley. His first forays into the ring against AEW's biggest workers were fun, but they felt more like glorified enhancement bouts than anything else. This...this felt a bit different.
The flyer held up his end of the bargain.
AEW's producers did well to pluck some clips of Martin crash-landing onto Mox from the archives, which gave this match some much-needed context. The story that Dante is getting closer to finally scoring a career-changing win over someone the standing of Jon is very welcome indeed.
The promotion will have to pull the trigger on Martin eventually - he's not exactly Eddie Kingston on the mic, but he can talk and will only get better. Besides, he's shown enough in-ring to suggest that the future is incredibly bright.
Check this match out.
1. Sting’s Return
What a cracking moment this was for Rampage.
AEW's third hour can occasionally come across as inconsequential these days, so it's sweet to have a major return to report from Friday night's edition. Sting, who looked rather refreshed after some time off, made his comeback by saving Darby Allin from the clutches of reDRagon.
It's unclear just how much juice this feud still has, but Stinger targeting the team that took him out back in May is logical. Fans were also delighted to see him, and everyone popped big for the lights going down; bonus points to Kyle O'Reilly for selling Sting's sudden appearance like he'd seen a ghost.
Sting and Allin vs. Bobby Fish and O'Reilly should be used exclusively on Rampage going forwards. It'd be wise to give the 'B' show some rivalries fans can't see on Dynamite, after all. For now, just enjoy having the icon back on TV.
What did you think of this week's AEW Rampage? For more wrestling, check out WWE 2K23: 10 Improvements Fans Demand and 10 Gimmicks WWE Cancelled For Being TOO SUCCESSFUL!