4 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE Hell In A Cell 2021

Even Alexa Bliss' spooky magic can't make Rhea Ripley vs. Charlotte Flair satisfying.

By Scott Carlson /

WWE.com

Rating WWE PPVs is a tough deal at times. The wrestlers are almost all top-notch athletes, among the best at their craft, so the matches – if given the opportunity – have a really decent chance of being anywhere from good to great, regardless of how awful the storylines surrounding the matches have been.

Advertisement

So when you watch Hell in a Cell and see several pretty entertaining matches, it’s easy to say, “That was a pretty good PPV, if ultimately meaningless.” But that ignores the abysmal march toward HIAC, with mind-numbing angles that left you confused and frustrated more than anything.

Nothing encapsulated this dichotomy more than the Charlotte Flair/Rhea Ripley women’s title match. The entire feud – which we won’t try to recap in 50 words – has been horrendous. But their match hummed along nicely overall… right up until the end reminded us of the awful storyline and its many glaring problems. What should have been a pure and great rivalry that elevated both superstars has torpedoed interest in both wrestlers in record time.

In the long run, Hell in a Cell 2021 will be remembered as (hopefully) the last WWE PPV during the Pandemic Era, with the company slated to return to live crowds permanently next month. And that will be it. None of these matches will be seen on a “Best of…” compilation. And that really just sums it all up.

Let’s get to it…

Downs…

6. Missing Another Gear

WWE.com

Not every Hell in a Cell match should be 100 KPH straight ahead brutal violence, but the cell match between Bayley and Bianca Belair was lacking in the kind of intensity you’d expect in this sort of bout.

Sure, Bayley and Bianca tried a more methodical approach, building slowly to a climax with Belair overcoming the Rose Plant on a ladder to put the former champ down. But it really felt more like a slow march from one spot or series of spots: using a chair, using the steps, using kendo sticks, using a chair again, and finally using a ladder.

It really is a shame to rate this as a “down”: Bayley and Bianca are class acts, perfectly capable of delivering a PPV classic. But this just felt like it didn’t need the cell. If it had been a straight wrestling match – or even a no-DQ bout without the cell – it would’ve been better.

Advertisement

But as a HIAC match, this didn’t do it.

5. Bumping Roman

WWE.com

Look, it’s partially understandable why WWE bumped the Roman Reigns/Rey Mysterio Hell in a Cell match to SmackDown on Friday night, as the ratings climbed to their highest level in more than a month (which is still down overall for the year).

But that doesn’t mean it escapes criticism in the PPV column, as the match had been advertised and announced in advance, then was moved 48 hours before the event. Had there been a paying crowd, that would have been tantamount to inciting a riot with the fans. But for the viewing public, it just meant we lost what was likely going to be a quality match with the excellent antics of Reigns.

So while the business side understands and might even agree with the decision (given the modest ratings bump), the fan side feels cheated sitting down to watch and review the PPV.

4. Commentary Nosedive

WWE.com

When Pat McAfee debuted on the SmackDown commentary team after WrestleMania, he sounded like a breath of fresh air, a different voice who was nothing like the Byron Saxtons of the world.

But his “performance” at Hell in a Cell was so bad that it harkened back to another commentator who started off strong and quickly faded into a yelling caricature of himself: Matt Stryker. McAfee spent the blue brand’s matches yelling randomly and adding next-to-nothing to the storylines and match progression, which on a two-man announce team is not good at all.

McAfee was bad from the jump, being almost insufferable during the women’s HIAC match (yelling about how he forgets how to tie his own shoes), and just grating on viewers’ nerves throughout the night. It was such a jarringly bad performance – has he been getting worse week-by-week on SmackDown, or was this a sudden thing?

This is made even worse when you remember that WWE cut loose Samoa Joe and Tom Phillips right after Mania. And while they brought Joe back to NXT, he was perfectly capable behind the desk calling matches.

3. Blatant Lying

WWE.com

We all know one of the announcers’ more important jobs (in theory) is to sell viewers on storylines and various angles. So we’ve come to expect a stretching of the truth.

But the announcers just went all-in on some pretty blatant lies when talking about the women’s tag team division and potential challengers Dana Brooke & Mandy Rose. In the span of two minutes, the announcers talked about how the “tag division is heating up” (despite breaking up nearly every functional tag team by releasing wrestlers the past two months), that Mandy & Dana were “making the case” for a tag title match, and that we’ve “seen that success from Dana and Mandy.”

*Ahem*

Let’s just be clear: Mandy and Dana have won exactly two tag team matches in eight months. The two matches? They defeated Naomi and Lana (who was released) in March and last month. Otherwise, they’ve been human punching bags in the women’s division, a joke of sorts as a pair of blonde bombshells who can’t get it done in the ring under any circumstance.

Advertisement

But hey, the announcers told us they were “making the case” for a tag title match… even as Mandy lost to Natalya in the kickoff show match. Wrestling fans might be gullible at times, but we’re not outright stupid.

2. Former Champs Turned Chumps

WWE.com

Shayna Baszler and Nia Jax should be considered future Raw Women’s Championship challengers for Rhea Ripley, contender fodder to power the new champ through the summer and into the fall easily.

Instead, the two former WWE Tag Team Champions were single-handedly possessed and trounced by the diminutive and “spooky” Alexa Bliss. The “match”, as it was, saw Baszler land a series of offensive strikes and submissions on Bliss, only for Alexa to laugh all of it off.

Oh, and then she hypnotized Shayna to break a submission, then possessed Jax and got her to slap Reginald. And then she took out Baszler with a flurry, ending with Twisted Bliss to put Shayna down.

Advertisement

Really, we could go on and on about how ridiculous and awful this stuff was, but we’ve been talking about the stupid mystical stuff for so long, we really should state it upfront and leave it as is. Why waste time talking about this idiotic angle other than to call it stupid, give it a huge “down” and then move on with our lives.

1. Despicable Wrestlers Produce Dismal Outcome

WWE.com

Repeatedly, we have trashed the abysmal build behind what should have been a simple, powerful rivalry between Charlotte Flair and Rhea Ripley. WWE has managed to turn what could have been a career-defining feud for Ripley into utter garbage.

Still, Flair and Ripley (as expected) managed to put together a pretty good Raw Women’s Championship match on Sunday night, only for everything to fall apart at the end. After a solid exchange between the two and Rhea’s perseverance being extolled, the champion used the announce table cowl to cause a DQ, seemingly doing it deliberately because she couldn’t put Charlotte down.

And if we had any doubt, the brawl continued afterwards, with Rhea putting Flair down with the Riptide, and then celebrating (despite losing) when the ring announcer declared that she remained champion – which is a total heel move.

Advertisement

So as we’ve asked 100 times, who are we supposed to cheer? Who are we supposed to support? The answer very clearly now is “no one.” We aren’t supposed to support or emotionally connect with either woman. They’ll just have a bad feud with good in-ring work – and even then, that’s not a guarantee.

Ups…

4. Cesaro Shows Some Fire

WWE.com

One of the missing elements (if any) in Cesaro’s game has been that babyface fire that gets fans behind a wrestler. As great as the Swiss Superman is, that’s been something that’s been lacking.

On Sunday, we got to see some of that from Cesaro as he continued to fight back against Seth Rollins. At one point, Seth was tagging Cesaro, only for the Swiss Superman to shake it off and hit a European uppercut repeatedly. His comebacks were well-timed, and his offense was perfectly situated for fans to rally behind.

You’ve got to hope that WWE doesn’t drop the ball for the 87th time with Cesaro, because this likely is his last chance to really make some headway as a singles star, and it would be nice to see the company actually get behind him rather than treat him as a flavor of the month role player.

3. KO, Sami Go To War Again

WWE.com

Almost every time Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn tangle, you’re in for a hard-hitting, brutal battle. It’s almost a guarantee, and Sunday night’s match between the two followed through.

Taken in a vacuum, their Hell in a Cell match was another solid brawl between the two. Owens and Zayn slugged away at each other, hitting their opponent with everything in their arsenal. KO couldn’t maintain his flurries due to breathing problems after suffering two Nigerian Nails on Friday night, giving Sami some openings to get back into the match.

An arm injury further opened the door for Zayn, and eventually, he used that to his advantage and landed a Helluva Kick for the win, finally picking up a win when he needed it.

Advertisement

Hopefully, this won’t turn into the writers keeping this feud going forever. While they’re very good together, the writers have a tendency to beat the proverbial dead horse, and it would be a shame to overdo this rivalry right now.

2. Rollins, Cesaro Dazzle Again

WWE.com

Back at WrestleMania 37, everyone knew that of all the matches on the card, Seth Rollins versus Cesaro was the one that you could count on to be an in-ring master class.

So when you saw the rematch booked for Hell in a Cell, you had to feel like we’d get yet another really good, solid wrestling match. And we certainly did. The two went at each other at a steady pace, never really slowing down. Rollins and Cesaro traded heavy offense, with the Swissman seemingly having Seth’s number. Cesaro looked to have a submission victory within his grasp when Rollins grabbed a small package for the shock victory.

Normally, this column despises 50/50 booking, but Cesaro has had the upper hand for some time in this feud, and Rollins needed to win something if the feud was going to continue.

Advertisement

And let’s face it: This feud is producing good-to-great matches, so why wouldn’t you want to see it carry on? Rollins stole one from a too-aggressive Cesaro, so now we’ll see if the Swiss Superman can regroup and finally put his adversary down… possibly in front of a live crowd.

1. A Brutal Cell War

WWE.com

The final battle between Drew McIntyre and Bobby Lashley needed to be an all-out war, with both men tearing into each other and using everything at their disposal to try to end the other man’s career.

And thankfully, that’s what we got in the Hell in a Cell main event on Sunday night. Lashley and McIntyre attacked each other with various weapons, battering each other with chairs, kendo sticks and ring steps, putting their opponent through tables and brawling all over the cell. They hit all their signature spots and kept fighting until neither had anything left.

It took an x-factor – MVP – to tip the scales, grabbing McIntyre’s foot before a climactic Claymore attempt, which allowed Lashley to grab a desperation rollup for the win. Normally, a rollup would be a disdainful finish, but after a half-hour HIAC match, it’s believable that a wrestler just wouldn’t have enough left eventually (plus Lashley’s pin was a pretty deep one).

Advertisement

Regardless, this feud needed punctuation, and we got it on Sunday night. Drew can’t challenge for the WWE Championship as long as Lashley holds it, so this hopefully means that both men move on to new feuds.