5 Biggest Winners & Losers From WWE Hell In A Cell 2016
Charlotte & Sasha Banks make history, but the queen conquers all.
Hell In A Cell 2016 was a hugely important pay-per-view for WWE’s Raw brand. The Monday night show has constantly struggled to match SmackDown’s high standards since the draft, and their first PPV - September’s Clash Of Champions - left fans bewildered rather than satisfied. Another disappointing show would only compound Raw’s poor fortune, and cement SD’s status as the stronger brand ahead of Survivor Series.
WWE rolled the dice last night. They booked three HIAC matches for a single show, and presented the first all-female main event in WWE PPV history. Though HIAC’s build was not without its problems, WWE had at least created a number of big talking points heading into it.
Did they deliver? To a certain degree. All three Cell matches came off well, though the format remains hampered by WWE’s PG rating. Nonetheless, all six competitors did all they could to make their matches as brutal as uncompromising as the rating allows, and despite some questionable finishes, each match was about as good as fans could’ve hoped.
Charlotte is the new WWE Women’s Champion, and Kevin Owens successfully retained his Universal Championship. The New Day lost, but keep their titles via DQ, while Brian Kendrick is the new Cruiserweight Champion, and Roman Reigns kept his United States strap. There are plenty of big talking points coming out of HIAC and several superstars climbed the ladder. Others? Not so much.
Here are the 5 biggest winners & losers from WWE Hell In A Cell 2016.
5. Losers: Enzo Amore & Big Cass
It’s almost moot to praise Enzo Amore’s promo ability at this point, but Big Cass is quietly improving in his shadow. The duo are rarely anything less than entertaining, and last night saw them deliver a relatively long, drawn-out Toy Story metaphor for “Andy” and “Big Gal.” Lesser teams would’ve died with such material, but Enzo & Cass killed it again, and it set their match off to a hot start.
Sadly, that’s where Enzo & Cass’ good fortune ended. They were soundly defeated by Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows in one of the night’s shortest matches, and they’ve nobody to blame but themselves. Gallows & Anderson used good old-fashioned teamwork to put the Realest Guys in the Room away, and it’s a huge loss for Raw’s most popular team.
They’ve likely got enough momentum to take the loss on the chin, but Enzo & Cass just lost to a team who almost never win. Gallows & Anderson have looked like a couple of hapless geeks since arriving from Japan, and Enzo & Cass have gone from title contenders to midcard also-rans. Their future remains bright, but they need to start winning matches like this.
4. Loser: Dana Brooke
Bayley vs. Dana Brooke has reached Titus O’Neil vs. Darren Young levels of woe. Nothing about the feud has gone over, and from Dana’s botches to last week’s dire arm wrestling contest, it has been miss after miss after miss. The duo have struggled immensely in putting a compelling program together, and they had the PPV’s worst match last night.
Bayley’s entrance aside, the crowd were dead throughout. The former NXT Women’s Champion is a good wrestler, but Brooke is far too incomplete a performer to drag a good match from. They worked a sloppy six-minuter marred by some wholly unconvincing limb work, and Brooke inevitably fell to the Bayley-to-Belly.
The loss puts Dana in an incredibly tough spot. She was put into a feud with one of the division’s best workers, yet still couldn’t put forth a convincing performance. If she can’t succeed with Bayley, then there’s little chance she’ll succeed with an Alicia Fox or Nia Jax, who would be her next logical opponents after falling down the ladder. Dana’s fine in her role as Charlotte’s sidekick, but she’s just not ready to strike out on her own, and would likely benefit from another stint in NXT.
3. Loser: TJ Perkins
The TJ Perkins vs. Brian Kendrick rivalry has gradually deteriorated in quality over the weeks. It started strongly with Kendrick playing the bitter old veteran, but descended to farce when the challenger asked TJP to throw this match on last week’s Raw. It doesn’t help that Perkins has taken to speaking like a human Sega Master System, but WWE have ended their first big Cruiserweight storyline disappointingly.
The duo struggled to capture the crowd’s attention following Kevin Owens vs. Seth Rollins, and while the bulk of the match was technically fine, the ending destroyed Perkins’ momentum. Kendrick feigned injury prior to locking-in the Captain’s Hook, and everybody in the building saw it coming but the champion. Perkins was forced to tap as a result, and Kendrick left Boston with the gold.
Perkins came-off like the most gullible man on the planet, and that’s not a good look for a guy who’s supposed to be the division’s leading light. It’s impossible to pull-off such a finish if the whole world knows what’s going to happen, and the crowd literally booed TJP for his foolishness. It once looked like Perkins was being set-up as the man to anchor the Cruiserweight division through its formative months, but he has been dethroned in the most crushing way imaginable.
2. Loser: Sasha Banks
Sasha Banks made history last night, and that’s what prevents her from being branded Hell In A Cell’s biggest loser. She and Charlotte will forever be remembered not only as the first women to ever set foot in the Cell, but the first to headline a WWE PPV. It’s a huge moment in the company’s history, and nobody will ever be able to take it away from them.
That being said, losing the Raw Women’s Championship in her hometown, particularly to such a hated rival, makes last night’s loss absolutely crushing for The Boss. She was always fighting the odds after being powerbombed through an announce table early on, but she sustained too much damage to mount a comeback in the aftermath, and the finish left the crowd deflated.
Banks was fantastic throughout the match. She worked as hard as ever, and deserves respect for having the guts to pull-off the announce table spot after her recent back problems. Her every move had the crowd jumping and screaming, and in terms of her all-round performance, there’s little to complain about.
None of it was enough, though. Sasha’s a two-time Women’s Champion, but both of her reigns lasted less than a month. She has defeated Charlotte a couple of times on television, but on PPV - the biggest stage of them all - Flair holds a clear and decisive advantage. It’s back to the drawing board for Banks, who faces a long, gruelling fight to work back towards contendership.
1. Loser: Seth Rollins
Hell In A Cell is an enclosed structure that should theoretically prevent interference from outside parties. Anyone who’s watched more than one of these matches knows that this isn’t the case, however. The action will spill outside the Cell more often than not, opening the possibility of interference, and creating all kinds of chaos.
Triple H turned on Seth Rollins to cost him the Universal Championship, but it wasn’t The Game who interfered last night. Instead, Chris Jericho ran down to the ring, locked himself in the cage, and helped Kevin Owens to victory despite sustaining a heavy beating. Rollins put up a great fight against the best friends, but he couldn’t overcome the numerical advantage, and fell after being powerbombed through two chairs.
It was one of the night’s best matches. Jericho’s interference diminished it somewhat, but the table spot was fantastic, and Owens and Rollins successfully played to the gimmick’s brutal reputation. PG Era cage matches are generally clean, safe affairs, but nobody can say that here.
The result is another crippling disappointment for Rollins, who was laid-out by Jericho’s Codebreaker after the match. He’s a man with no allies who’s trying to compete against one of wrestling’s most devious partnerships, and he’s struggling. Raw’s double-pin has been nullified, and Rollins went home as HIAC’s biggest loser.
And now click below for the winners...
5. Winner: Brian Kendrick
A despondent, desperate Brian Kendrick spent last week pleading for TJ Perkins to “let him win” at Hell In A Cell, but it wasn’t necessary in the end. Kendrick prevailed through taking advantage of Perkins’ stupidity, and after pushing himself into a “need to win” scenario, the crafty veteran captured WWE gold for the first time in nine years.
The finish begs the question of why WWE chose to go down the “let me win” road in the first place. If Kendrick had the intelligence to spring such a trap then there was simply no need to present him as such a pathetic weakling, but it’s in the books now. He has a dethroned the face of the division, and as Cruiserweight Champion, Kendrick will no doubt continue his career’s Indian Summer with grit, grime, and guile.
It’ll be interesting to see who emerges as his first challenger. Chances are high that WWE will pull the trigger on a Perkins rematch, but there are a couple of other stars waiting in the wings. Rich Swann and Cedric Alexander have shone lately, as has Tony Nese. Either one would make a fine first defence for Kendrick, who might not be the flashiest wrestler in the world, but knows how to get it done between the ropes.
4. Winners: Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows
Nobody needed a victory more than Karl Anderson & Luke Gallows last night. The duo have descended to farce on Raw, and their credibility is at an all-time low. They’ve won a couple of inconsequential television matches here and there, but they’ve regularly been found lacking when the chips are down, and the omens weren’t good heading into last night.
Raw saw Enzo Amore defeat Anderson in just a couple of minutes, and for a while, it looked like another loss was on the cards. Instead, Anderson & Gallows rallied to eliminate Big Cass, isolate Enzo, and walk away with their first WWE PPV victory. There’s a strong chance the rivalry will continue over the coming weeks, but for now, Anderson & Gallows have the babyfaces in their back pockets.
It’d be premature to call this a resurgence, however. Anderson & Gallows have been dealt a great deal of damage throughout their WWE run, and it’ll take more than a single victory to make them feel like genuine threats in the tag division. Beating Enzo & Cass is a great start, though, and dropping the tiresome comedy act and reverting to their no-nonsense, ass-kicking personas is exactly what they needed to do.
3. Winner: Kevin Owens
Kevin Owens wasn’t exactly enthused about the idea of facing Seth Rollins last night. He’d grown increasingly wary of competing inside Hell In A Cell throughout the build-up, and often cited Mick Foley’s “ruined” career as an example he’d rather not follow. Though a tough, uncompromising fighter himself, KO wanted nothing to do with the demonic structure, and he made that perfectly clear.
But he conquered it all last night. Sure, he needed Chris Jericho’s help to seal the deal again, but Owens retained his Universal Championship with a decisive pinfall. He and Seth produced an excellent match that only became convoluted through Jericho’s involvement. They deserve great credit for producing a strong HIAC match in wrestling’s most sanitised time period, and KO’s good fortune continues.
The finish doesn’t exactly leave him looking strong, through. Owens needed Jericho as a human shield to win last night, and it goes down as another blighted victory in a title reign characterised by them. Regardless, Owens remains Raw’s top dog, and if Chris Jericho’s post-match antics are anything to go by, it looks like his biggest rival’s attentions will now be focused elsewhere.
2. Winner: Roman Reigns
Roman Reigns vs. Rusev was a match of two halves. The first was slow, plodding, and boring: filled primarily with lackluster cell wall bumps and colourless brawling, it summoned the worst of WWE’s PG HIAC tropes. Things picked up in the second half, however, and the duo pulled off an excellent closing stretch to end things on a high note.
Rusev’s chain-assisted Accolade provided a savage visual, but it wasn’t enough to put the United States Champion away. Reigns battled out of it, drilled Rusev with a Samoan Drop on the steps, then Speared him for a decisive victory.
The rivalry has been blighted by both competitors’ increasingly confusing face/heel alignment, but they performed a successful blow-off match. When Reigns was standing tall, it felt like a genuine end for one of Raw’s most heated rivalries, and Rusev lost very little in the end. He was presented as a monster throughout, and his mystique remains intact.
Reigns had his share of jeers again last night, but it wasn’t as bad as usual. He’ll likely never win the crowd over, particularly if WWE keep pushing him as a playground bully, but he remains a solid worker, particularly in environments like this. Rusev’s last US Title run restored some much-needed credibility to the belt, and a well-booked Reigns run can take it to the next level.
1. Winner: Charlotte
Nobody shone brighter than Charlotte Flair last night. Her win was poorly-received in Sasha Banks’ hometown, but she won’t care about that. She’s now a three-time Women’s Champion, and in defeating Sasha last night, she has become the undisputed queen of the division, and WWE’s most important female competitor.
The match almost ended before it really got started. Sasha was being loaded onto a stretcher after being thrown through the announce table, but just when Charlotte was about to be announced as the winner, The Boss came back. The match continued in violent, brutal fashion, and the duo put on a war worthy of the HIAC tag.
The finish was botchy. Charlotte made two failed attempts at throwing Banks through a table before ending her with a hurried Natural Selection, but it’s the outcome that’s important. This was Charlotte’s 14th consecutive PPV victory, and should put her rivalry with Sasha to bed for the foreseeable future. She’s back on the throne, and it’ll take a gargantuan effort to depose her.
It’s easy to complain about Banks’ short reign, but Charlotte is likely the best choice to lead the division at this point. Concerns remain over Sasha’s long-term health, and she took a number of big bumps again last night. There are no such concerns with Charlotte, who’s far from perfect, but has improved immensely since arriving on the main roster. She has become one of the most effective heels in the company, and her in ring abilities have never looked sharper.