5 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Rampage (Aug 20)
CM Punk finally becomes All Elite; Darby Allin shines; AEW misses two open goals?
"With a tear in my eye".
CM Punk might as well have ripped off Ric Flair's iconic promo line on the second AEW Rampage. The Chicago native cut an almost overwhelmed figure during his first All Elite appearance, but he quickly regained his composure to get right down to business and set up a huge match for All Out on 5 September.
The wrestling world looked on as Punk dismissed his entire WWE run by saying he'd "retired from pro wrestling" when he left Ring Of Honor in 2005. Now, a full 16 years on, Punk definitively said, "I'm back". Boy is he ever - his sit-down speech mimicked the memorable pipe bomb from 2011 too. That happened on WWE TV, so nobody can really ignore the success Punk had there.
This was his moment though.
Elsewhere, Rampage's sophomore effort did some nice business in the tag-team division but largely sagged in the ring. That's not something anyone can sling at AEW normally. Tony Khan did reveal during recent media scrums that this week's show would toss the expected format, at least.
It was worth it...
Downs...
2. Too Good For A Squash
First though, the negatives.
Anyone who has watched Kiera Hogan in Impact Wrestling will know she has skills. So, with that in mind, it was a bit weird to see her debut as a lowly jobber to Jade Cargill on Rampage. The booking here was especially strange due to AEW's well-known relationship with Impact, and the fact that Hogan just finished up there.
That told this fan that Kiera would be taken seriously by Tony Khan and crew. There's time for that yet, but...this felt like a missed opportunity. Despite her smaller stature, Kiera could've believably gone toe-to-toe with Cargill. Instead, this might've been any faceless "local talent" in there, and that sucks.
Being fair, AEW hardcores who didn't watch a ton of Impact and thus don't know much about Hogan won't be too bothered by this. Something about it just didn't feel right though - Cargill didn't gain much by squashing Kiera, and now a promising new face in the women's division looks like a loser.
1. A Lacklustre Main Event
Daniel Garcia and his 2point0 buddies ambushed Jon Moxley on Dynamite to set up this Rampage headliner. Sadly for all involved, even the hot angle and fiery pre-match exchange (handled by Mark Henry) couldn't convince anyone watching that this was a deserving main event.
Indeed, it wasn't as grand as the spot likely deserved.
2point0 didn't come across as important or really all-that-threatening, which was another missed opportunity. Plus, the post-match beating was very house show. Eddie Kingston, Sting and Darby Allin joined Mox in cleaning house and sending the heels scampering to safety. One was almost expecting a Hulk Hogan-esque pose routine afterwards.
On the plus side, Garcia tried to out-wrestle the obviously-more-dangerous Mox. Then, Jon schooled the newcomer by tapping him out. That aside though, this was barely there and didn't really close the show the required bang.
Ups...
5. Jurassic Express Advances
Luchasaurus and Jungle Boy are arguably the only team left in the Eliminator tourney who are worthy enough to challenge The Young Bucks come All Out. Therefore, Jurassic Express beating Private Party made sense on Rampage; The Varsity Blonds and Lucha Bros will battle it out on Dynamite to earn the other spot in the final.
Regardless of who wins, the Express must roll on.
Sometimes, the popular result is the right result, and this was evidence of that. It was a balls-to-the-wall spotfest at times, but the live crowd in Chicago ate it up, and everyone knows that's Party's deal by now anyway. The most important thing was always going to be that JB and Luchasaurus came out on top.
They did, then the pair stared down 'dem Jackson boys on the stage. People can question the purpose of this tournament when everyone can see the winners coming, but it's not a duff way to build new challengers up. Express have more credibility if they keep racking up wins.
4. JR
Good ol' JR gets a lot of sh*t for his commentary these days. Sometimes, it's unfair. Other times, he comes across as out of touch and possibly not a great fit for All Elite's often-rapid in-ring style. Then, like he did here, Jim Ross reminds everyone why he is who he is.
It's important to give props when they're due.
Ross was way more tolerable than Chris Jericho was last week. Some folks seem to think that wrestling comms are all about yelling your way through absolutely everything or making smart-arsed comments to put yourself over. Jericho didn't do that constantly, but he was grating as part of an over-staffed four man booth last week.
JR's presence made Rampage smoother. He even popped the rest of the team when they were hyping matches for All Out and he said, "Hey, is that the night CM Punk wrestles Darby Allin?". That was slick. Jim helped ease the workload for Excalibur, and he made that four man dynamic slightly less frantic.
3. Getting Right Down To Business
Why wait?
That was AEW's mantra on this week's Rampage. They could've stuck to usual formats for wrestling and had CM Punk come out right at the end. Nah, screw that. Tony Khan opened Rampage with an emotional Punk, and that was smart. Most people were literally there to live that moment.
There was a refreshing lack of pretence heading into Punk's debut too. AEW didn't attempt to divert attention or tease that they were going to pull some other stunt. Khan was upfront and honest (without just coming out and saying, 'CM Punk will be on Rampage') with the media, and that helped the anticipation build and build.
This was a promotional debut done right, basically. Worst kept secret or not, it was exactly what AEW's audience yearned to see, and the company didn't disappoint. F*ck bait and switch tactics. Pro wrestling is about entertaining people and making them happy sometimes.
2. Pop (For) Punk
So happy they cry.
There were several shots of crying fans in the stands at Rampage. None of these were shoehorned in for the sake of it, and they definitely fit the emotion of the moment. The thunderous, sustained pop that Punk received even knocked him off his feet.
OK, so he always did that thing where he goes down on his knees, but the guy was legitimately floored by the love raining down on him. He got legit choked up - you could see it written all over his face. That's the unique kind of emotion that pro wrestling does better than most other forms of entertainment. People bitch, but many adore the men and women who sacrifice so much for them, and that came across here.
The United Center was a giddy place on Friday night. That pop might be one of the loudest (and longest) in industry history. Good, it should've been. AEW were giving so many fans back someone they feared they'd never see perform in wrestling circles ever again.
What a moment.
1. CM Punk’s First Target
Of course, AEW is more about the future of the biz than the past. Nostalgia is powerful, but CM Punk wasn't only here to reminisce about the past and tearfully address why he'd walked away from WWE in 2014. No, Punk was also there to do business and hype up a pay-per-view match with Darby Allin.
The skateboarding daredevil is a stunning first opponent for AEW's new comeback king. He's a rebellious soul like Punk, and he's also clearly a young star who will someday take his place atop the mountain as AEW World Champion. This, fellow fans, is what AEW should be about: Darby and other young stars rivalling already-established top names.
Nobody needed a retread of Punk vs. Jericho, or something similar, immediately. Put it that way.
Working with Punk can take Allin to that next level. He's received a nice rub from Sting, and can now look glorious (whether in victory or defeat) alongside the hottest free agent signing in years at All Out. Wednesday's Dynamite promises more build towards their match, and nobody associated with AEW can wait.
What did you think of this week's AEW Rampage? For more like this, check out 4 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Rampage (Aug 13) and WWE SummerSlam 2021: 10 Things That Must Happen!