5 Ups & 2 Downs From HBO's André The Giant Documentary

The tale of a tortured soul who just wanted to be "normal"...

By Jamie Kennedy /

WWE.com

At heart, André Roussimoff was a quiet, well-meaning man who started growing at an abnormal rate in his teens and had dreams almost as big as his body.

Advertisement

That never-ending battle between preferring a more quiet life away from the spotlight and knowing he could never have one helps pin down HBO's examination of André's life and career. There's a sense that André was at odds with himself too. Dreaming big from a young age, the Frenchman wanted to "be somebody", but he could never get to grips with constantly being in the public eye.

Talking heads as varied as Vince McMahon, Hulk Hogan, Tim White and Jerry Lawler (along with a bunch of wrestling historians/journalists fascinated with The Giant) all do a great job exploring André's psyche. There's more focus on that personal touch than on André's in-ring exploits, and that makes the film more than a rudimentary pro wrestling documentary.

Advertisement

At the same time though, not everything is rosy. Just like the mountainous subject it studies, the underlying tale of tragedy HBO try to present has flaws...

Downs...

2. One Segment Is At Odds With The Narrative

WWE

HBO's assessment of André boiled down to painting the man as a friendly giant who enjoyed making people happy across the globe. A consistent pattern of André's own unhappiness ran through the doc too, and it's clear he struggled personally whilst keeping a brave face so others could enjoy his work.

Advertisement

That's all well and good, but it just makes a short segment during which The Giant is depicted as a mean bully feel out of place.

Stories from Hulk Hogan about André despising the baby oil Randy Savage would lather his body in are funny, and the same goes for light-hearted banter about the big man putting those who wouldn't play ball with company plans in their place.

Advertisement

As fun as they are, it's then odd to hear Hogan (and others, like Gene Okerlund and McMahon) claim André took great delight in roughing up John Studd. During this segment, André comes across less like a ring general and more like a petty bully who was insecure about Studd's own physical size and wanted to re-assert his own dominance as the WWF's one true giant.

1. Lengthy Tangent On Hulk Hogan's Rise

WWE

There's no denying that Hulk Hogan played an important part in André The Giant's story. As the babyface foil to André's bitter heel in 1987, Hogan was the perfect opponent for WrestleMania III. Most (if not all) watching the doc will already know that, so it's strange that HBO went off on a lengthy Hulk tangent.

Advertisement

In-depth discussion on André's failing health is interrupted so the film makers can go all Hogan fan boy on everyone, and the story turns from focusing solely on The Giant to how Hulkamania was born. That was a mistake.

It was also completely unnecessary.

Advertisement

Hogan is one of the most legendary names in wrestling, and anyone watching the documentary, regular fan or not, will know who he is. There's a little too much time dedicated to how Hulk turned from "Sterling Golden" into the WWF machine's marketing dream.

Ups...

5. The Touching Exploration Of André's Childhood

HBO

Now, the positives.

Advertisement

Even the most ardent André The Giant fans will find something new to see in HBO's film. The opening stretch (after some highlights of André's in-ring career) is a touching look at how one of wrestling's biggest presences started out as a humble child in rural France.

André's siblings get the interview treatment, and their subtitled words lend credibility to the story of trading farm life for the bright lights of Madison Square Garden. This is as far away from WWE hyperbole as you're likely to get. André's brothers, in particular, don't view André like everyone else, because they knew him before he was so famous.

Advertisement

A story about one conversation André shared with his father is special. To the youngster, living on the family farm for the rest of his days was inconceivable, and it's that childlike yearn for something greater/more spectacular that opens up André's real personality.

Albeit brief, this is wonderful stuff.

Advertisement

4. How Well André's Early Career Is Examined

HBO

Learning of André's journey from football to rugby and eventually wrestling is a short experience, but it's one worth hearing. It was rugby that led to a life between the ropes once wrestlers (working out in the same gym as him) told André he'd make money in the pro wrestling biz.

Advertisement

Overall, the early days of The Giant's wrestling career are handled with care, and there's a nice effort put in to show how André grew from shy, oversized teenager to larger-than-life famous athlete. Companies like Grand Prix Wrestling and Maple Leaf Wrestling are mentioned, and there's a cool story about how his André The Giant name was born too.

Once known as Jean Ferré, his name was changed when a Chicago promoter worried fans might think he was being compared to a ferry.

Advertisement

All of this information is packaged up and delivered within 10-15 minutes of air time. That's just enough to get a feel for how André developed as a performer without growing tiresome. If only HBO had shown the same care with Hulk Hogan's retrospective.

3. The Doc's 'Beginner's Guide To Pro Wrestling Feel

WWE.com

Don't know the difference between a wrist lock and a wrist watch? No problem, because HBO's producers made sure to have even the most casual of wrestling fans covered.

Advertisement

The whole documentary has an introductory feel; if someone watching knew absolutely nothing about André's life or career, they'd come away being able to ring off a few remarkable stories or facts about the man without then having to tread through the WWE Network to become industry experts. That's the way it should be.

For an example of this, consider how HBO allow Hulk Hogan to give insight into how André would subtlety sell for opponents by dropping down to one knee. Afterwards, the cameras switch to Jerry Lawler, who handily tells viewers that this is what insiders call selling.

Advertisement

This hand-holding does a masterful job of laying out the basics without making more hardcore wrestling enthusiasts feel like they're having their intelligence insulted. In order to tell André's story to as many people as possible, this was a concession HBO had to make.

2. Refreshing Lack Of WWE Spin

WWE.com

Sure, hearing Vince McMahon talk about "93,000" people in attendance for WrestleMania III lends an unneeded sense of kayfabe to proceedings, as does his claim not to know how tall André really was. Scrape those aside though and there's a curious lack of WWE spin on the film.

Advertisement

"Mean" Gene Okerlund's admission that McMahon and other WWF chiefs told everyone to forget matches André and Hulk Hogan had already wrestled elsewhere is fun, and the same could be said for Hulk's genuine fear that André might not do business at 'Mania III.

Playing devil's advocate, McMahon admits to toying with Hogan himself by insisting he didn't know what The Giant wanted to do on the day.

Advertisement

Okerlund divulging that he secretly didn't think André vs. Hulk would be any good (due to André's health problems) is similarly refreshing. This isn't the usual WWE hype machine telling everybody that the 'Mania III main event was one of the greatest in history, and it's better for that.

1. Insight Into André's Mental Fragility

HBO

As he grew older and further away from childhood, André's mental state became a worry to those who knew him best. Tim White, a WWF referee and the man tasked with handling André on the road, visibly chokes up in the doc when disclosing that The Giant would tell him that he longed to be a "normal man".

Advertisement

Everything, from sitting in chairs at restaurants and bars to climbing into a car and walking through the airport, was a struggle for André. White's sad story of this magnificent mountain of man privately breaking down into tears when he was teased for his appearance is heart-breaking.

To André, every single day was a reminder that he couldn't live a regular existence.

Advertisement

Telling close friends that he ached to live just one day per week as a smaller man, so he could have his own car, visit the cinema or blend into a crowd, shows the increasing mental fragility André battled through in adulthood.

Credit to HBO for uncovering the tragedy of André's size, the one thing that made him money, also being a burden to him personally.

Advertisement

What did you think of HBO's snapshot look at Andre The Giant's life and career? Let us know down in the comments section below!