5 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Dynamite (June 28 - Review)
Jon Moxley and Eddie Kingston's tension boils over, Blood & Guts is ON and Sting is nuts. Again.
In spite of its main event not quite living up to expectations (which were, to be absolutely fair, the highest any could possibly be for a wrestling match), Forbidden Door was a positively-received pay-per-view for AEW, reflecting the broader uptick in opinions of the television show since May's Double Or Nothing.
What it didn't really leave much room for was the traditional fallout or table-setting required for a big post-show Dynamite. Forbidden Door both was and wasn't folded into storylines, making it equal parts special attraction and important checkpoint on the never-ending road. It subsequently made the vibe going into Wednesday's Dynamite a little confused, and that wasn't altered by an extremely strange card.
A rematch of an iconic match sets just as big an expectation as a rematch of a terrible one, and this show effectively tried to deliver both with the opener and headliner respectively. Between them, incidents and accidents and hints and accusations were expected from various key players in promos and angles, but would the latest Canadian crowd still have the energy from a weekend well spent?
Let’s light the fuse…
Downs…
5. MJF & Adam Cole Have Chemistry, But...
Are AEW failing to learn from their mistakes with the current MJF/Adam Cole storyline?
It's nothing new for the 'Salt Of The Earth'. His feuds are typically paced this way - a light and fluffy early offering obscures the devastating switch sociopathic finale, but the MJF character is such a scumbag that a lot of time needs to be spent on the babyfaces and audience growing to enjoy the bond before he rips it away. That they already exhibited chemistry in their first segment together last week set the stall out well too.
This week, the inherent flaw in the booking strategy was all too clear. Adam Cole told Roderick Strong on camera that he was wise to all of this nonsense and playing the long game, even laughing off that the AEW Champion would never even see this because he doesn't watch the show. Fine, but he's young, online and plugged in. He will get wind of this and could even mention it as reason for him snapping on Cole down the road, but that makes the babyface the arrogant and ignorant schmuck rather than the heel.
The two aren't going to win the Blind Eliminator tournament, but it might be wise to get on with wrestling in it. The magic of all of this lies there, not within copy-of-a-copy backstage vignettes.
4. Orange Cassidy, Keith Lee & Vikingo Vs The Jericho Appreciation Society
One of those cute AEW television matches where the arrangement is less about the contest and more to do with all the narrative moving pieces, this was unforgivably dull and heatless considering the diversity and dynamism talent involved.
If you happened not to see this match, a friend who's also a fan might point you in the direction of the awesome moment Daniel Garcia attempted to do his dance on Keith Lee's back. They won't sit you down for the entire 15 minutes wrapped around it. Not if they're a real friend anyway.
Miscommunications here and there on the babyface side could actually be waved away as part of the lack of chemistry between them - Orange Cassidy picked his partners because they happened to be stood next to him in the locker room - but by the end, a poor advert for the trios division in general was only really beneficial for keeping Cassidy and Garcia together and revealing that Keith Lee had reverted back to black hair ahead of his Blind Eliminator reunion with Swerve Strickland against the International Champion and Darby Allin.
It's admirable to seek to achieve all of that from a single semi-impromptu match, but when the bell-to-bell is lost or neglected, the failure feels less noble.
3. We Heard From Jungle Boy Jack Perry...
...and we might need a while to come to terms with it.
First, the positives; Perry aping the appearance of Christian Cage when he explained his own heel turn was a very nice aesthetic touch. Detailed enough to make first responders feel smart but broad enough for everybody to spot, this builds investment from all corners of the audience. Referring to Hamilton as "Toronto" felt like an accident but it got great heat as he barrelled on with his point, and when he ran for the hills away from Hook it was as if he wasn't going to stop until the car he dove into had crossed back over the US border.
And more's the point, who was driving the car?
The meat of the segment was weak, though. Too weak. He's a sunglasses-inside sex haver, and it's all our fault that he's...happier now? He buried the FTW Title while trying to pepper in his aspirations to win it. He's not letting people here Baltimora's Tarzan Boy anymore, even though when there was a connection with the fans it was forged in iron by that. What are we doing here? Who knows or cares - that's the insta-heel tropey fare that has plagued television wrestling forever.
The character and company have earned their let-it-play-out privileges, but this wasn't the strongest start.
2. Hangman Page & The Young Bucks Vs The Dark Order
Was the dynamic in this match doomed by the vignettes that came before it, or did Hangman Page's crumbling kinship with the dilapidated Dark Order over the last several months do the damage?
Earlier in the show, they accepted an open challenge extended by The Hung Bucks having been left on read for long enough by the former AEW Champion. Not for the first time, he looked somewhere between angry and upset and yeah yeah yeah people are complex and Hangman Page is AEW's totem because of it, but sometimes wrestling needs it kept simple, stupid, and the reasons were laid bare when the bell rang.
Drawn into the fight by Evil Uno, it was tough to receive Page as the hero of this mini-story because The Bucks were d*ckheads throughout and The Dark Order are so utterly pathetic at this point that it scanned as schoolyard bullying. The work was crisp and flawless but the live crowd didn't seem to know which way to support it beyond gasps and claps at all of the usual. The babyfaces (?) got the win, but is Hangman okay with it?
Bluntly, who gives a sh*t at this point? Page and Omega 2019-2021, this isn't. Speaking of which...
1. Bored & Guts
All Elite Wrestling finally paid an overdue penalty on Wednesday's Dynamite, and one can wonder if they knew it was coming.
Following The Elite's victory over The Dark Order, The Blackpool Combat Club launched in with the weapons-assisted beatdown, Evil Uno and the lads left them to it, and Jon Moxley called for Blood & Guts on July 19th. The crowd went mild.
What was once set to be an unthinkably violent dream match, humorous gag at Vince McMahon's expense and a grisly exhibition of why The Elite's saga booking worked so well all rolled into one has now become just a match. And not because it's the third one, though the contest being calendar-driven does have echoes of WWE booking Hell In A Cell matches because of the month rather than the match.
For different reasons, the stipulation has missed the mark twice, and this year's build faces a few uphill struggles before the clash itself. Eddie Kington will be working the G1 Climax for New Japan Pro Wrestling so can't feature in the payoff even if he's integral to the run-up. Bryan Danielson's injured and Kenny Omega might be, and even then the feud itself has never felt colder. Consecutive pay-per-view multi-man matches have effectively explored the physicality, but whatever original point of contention once existed between the two sides feels mostly played out. Moxley was bleeding as he called for the match too - has AEW's excess contributed to such things not feeling anywhere near as special four years in?
Kingston and Moxley are the glue, and perhaps that's why the latter chose the date. Did he purposely try and avoid working the 'Mad King' having listened to his better half?
Ups…
5. Jon Moxley Vs Tomohiro Ishii
A worthy sequel to their epic 2019 G1 Climax encounter, the escalating violence and anger in the strikes between Jon Moxley and Tomohiro Ishii brought new meaning to "big fight feel" - this felt big and like a fight alright, but the two men couldn't have cared less about spectacle as they were laying into one another.
The arrival of Claudio Castagnoli and Eddie Kingston to stare daggers at one another on the floor helped the two mirror the same spot from Forbidden Door's ten-man tag, but as chops became forearms and forearms became lariats, the tension built without the simmering Chikara rage needing to boil over.
Boil over it would, but not before Moxley drilled Ishii with the Death Rider to pick up a powerful win in a fun and committed opener. On second watch, it's even easier to see why Blood & Guts drew such a listless response. Moxley's primary concern is Kingston and his secondary one was surviving this. A double cage bloodbath should be third on the agenda, but such is life when you've got that many irons in the fire.
Speaking of which...
4. "Fix This"
Everybody was outstanding in a backstage vignette that continued Jon Moxley and Eddie Kingston's current hostilities, but Renee Paquette's involvement elevated the scene beyond the usual wrestling bluster.
Sick of seeing the pair let their hotheadedness and conflicting motivations get in the way of their obvious bond, she tellingly identified Moxley as the cause and Kingston as the solution. "You need to fix this", she said to 'The Mad King', having previously lost her patience with her husband's bad attitude. Both men were absolutely fantastic delivering their incredibly real-feeling lines, with Moxley yet again showing off his comedic chops when trying to undermine Eddie's longstanding fury with Castagnoli, and Wheeler Yuta chipping in when he wasn't needed.
Wrestling - from the action in the ring to the necessary drama elsewhere - is best when it feels real, and there are still simply no two realer men in the game than Eddie and Jon.
3. Ruby Soho Vs Alexia Nicole
A make good for Britt Baker's illness-related absence, Ruby Soho's easy win over Alexia Nicole was a really fun bit of character-driven business. Soho was cynical and vicious in her destruction of the overmatched Nicole, sending a message to Baker throughout.
Her LockJaw win put a finer point on it, as was the quality promo she cut drawing lines between her start in the company and exactly why her Outcasts turn was entirely justified.
An ultimate negative-into-a-positive situation, the rearranged Owen Hart Tournament match is hotter than it already was, and the justified anger of the heels remains an underrated element of an underrated story.
2. Rampage Reflections
Friday's Rampage hosted a tremendous segment featuring Anthony Bowens rejecting Harley Cameron's advances by informing her that he was gay. A cute gag - the building and literally everybody other than Cameron were mindful of this before he had to make it explicit - the scene ended with a "he's gay" chant from the Chicago crowd that understandably drew an emotional response from many online.
LGBTQIA+ fans shared how tough had it been to grow up with wrestling typically villainising anybody that wasn't straight, and though it's effectively toasting wrestling barely catching up with common decency about three decades late, it was an important milestone all the same.
Wise for AEW to repeat it, and dedicate time to repeating anything that can help deepen its relationship with the fanbase at large. Profiling this rather than leaving it inadvertently hidden away on Rampage does as much for the message as it does the featured performers.
1. Le Sex Gods Vs Sting & Darby Allin
A match that'll mostly only be remembered for Sting taking his life into his own hands with a chaotic ladder and table spot, the party main event featuring Sammy Guevara and 'The Painmaker' Chris Jericho against Darby Allin and Sting more than made up for a Forbidden Door trios effort alongside Minoru Suzuki and Tetsuya Naito that simply didn't cut the mustard.
There, what felt like two nasty misfires resulted in the contest falling apart, and (thankfully) with none of that to contend with here, the match was the loudest and craziest of the night having previously occupied the literal opposite spot.
A bloody Chris Jericho survived a Scorpion Death Drop but lost clean to the Scorpion Deathlock, which obviously had additional connotations in Canada. This'll obviously feed more into the collapse of Jericho's relationship with Guevara, but 'The Spanish God' couldn't do much to help after Sting almost lost his teeth smashing him through a table.
It really was a sight to behold - the 64-year-old flying from a ladder in the ring through Sammy on a table on the floor was as terrifying as it sounds, not least because he was lying across two tables and the second one greeted 'The Icon' mouth-first. A subversion of his relationship with Allin, this was Sting wanting to show his protégé/friend (and in reality, the audience) that he was still down for chaos when it was required.
It'll spark yet more conversations about safety, and they're not not cogent. But in terms of making a memory rather than risking it all for a forgotten pop, this was undeniably successful.