5 Ups And 6 Downs From WWE Survivor Series 2016

Well, at least no one jobbed to a clothesline this year. Oh, and Goldberg!

By Scott Carlson /

WWE.com

Survivor Series is in the books, and fans likely have one question: Who’s next?

Advertisement

Or better yet: Will there be a “next?” Goldberg plowed through Brock Lesnar in the main event of the fall tradition, shocking nearly everyone in the audience and sparking differing opinions and questions galore. Say it was wrong, say it was ill-advised, but you can’t deny that it got people buzzing.

Of course, Survivor Series was built on the three traditional elimination matches purportedly for “brand supremacy.” In the grand scheme of things, Raw won two of the matches, so that makes them the winners, right? Or does winning the men’s match count as two victories? As usual, there were some strange eliminations, and while we’ve nitpicked these before, we’ll try to stay focused on only a few of them.

Advertisement

So was Survivor Series good? It entertained, that’s for sure. Did it top NXT TakeOver: Toronto? That’s something this writer would dispute strenuously. Disagree at your own peril. The bottom line here is that Survivor Series provided good matches, helped set the table for December feuds and delivered a memorable main event, so that’s an overall positive.

So what was the sole survivor, and what jobbed to a clothesline? Let’s get to it…

Advertisement

Downs...

Advertisement

6. Sami The Bridesmaid

WWE.com

Poor Sami Zayn. The man wins a blow-off match with his former best friend and the guy who loses goes on to win the WWE Universal Championship, while Zayn drifts aimlessly and then can’t beat the Miz for the Intercontinental Championship.

That’s a pretty harsh assessment, and it’s not entirely fair to criticize Sami for losing that match, given the circumstances. Miz is on the second leg of his never-ending Honky Tonk Man 2K16 impersonation, which seems to work well for him, but that doesn’t make it any worse to see Zayn fall short again.

Advertisement

If we could safely say that Sami would be off to bigger and better things, then it might be different, but, you know… WWE and all.

Advertisement

5. Too Good To Show Your Colors?

WWE.com

Other critics have pointed out the hypocrisy of certain characters donning brand T-shirts during this Raw vs. SmackDown feud. It’s a strange thing to see guys who march to the beat of their own drum suddenly rah-rahing alongside their teammates simply because of the show where they wrestle.

Advertisement

But even though guys like Bray Wyatt and Roman Reigns at least carried the T-shirt with them, the guy theoretically with the most on the line didn’t bother to wear a T-shirt. SmackDown commissioner Shane McMahon chose to wear his typical custom baseball jersey for the big match. And while it was white with blue writing, it still made him the only member of his team to not have the blue shirt on him at any point.

It’s a small thing, but it’s worth calling Shane out for his team disunity.

Advertisement

4. Catching Some Zzzzz’s…

WWE.com

Some will defend and point out that the crowd was still filing in, but you can’t deny that the two kickoff show matches largely played to the sounds of silence.

Advertisement

And while fans were still settling into their seats, they did come alive for parts of the cruiserweight six-man tag match – specifically, whenever TJ Perkins or Rich Swann was in the ring – so you can’t blame a less-than-full arena. Fans just didn’t care much about the other cruiserweights, and they also were fairly quiet during the Kane/Luke Harper match.

Advertisement

It’s an age-old issue: If you give fans a reason to care and/or get invested in a performer or match, then they’ll react. Look at how popular Heath Slater has become after his trials and tribulations. But why should anyone react to Noam Dar or Drew Gulak? It’s a shame because these wrestlers put on a great performance at the Cruiserweight Classic and can connect with fans, but right now, it’s silence.

3. Kane Wins… Why?

WWE.com

During the Kane/Luke Harper match, the announcers spent a great deal of time talking up how agile Harper was and how he reminded them of Bruiser Brody. They marveled at his athleticism as he hit a suicide dive, slingshot senton and running dropkick.

Advertisement

And then he ate a chokeslam to fall to 49-year-old Kane.

Look, Kane deserves all the respect in the world for his contributions to WWE for the past 20 years. And he shouldn’t be losing every match on his way out the door. But – and this is a constant gripe among fans – you’re never going to make new stars if you’re constantly jobbing out younger wrestlers to aging superstars.

Advertisement

Harper is 13 years younger than Kane. He could easily play the role of a big, agile and dangerous wrestler, much like Kane did 15 years ago. But if he’s going to keep losing matches like this for no discernable reason, then he’ll simply remain stuck in neutral.

Advertisement

2. Way To Show Importance Of Division

WWE.com

Just when it looked like WWE was going to raise the profile of the cruiserweight division by putting it up for grabs in a PPV match, the company went and pulled the rug out from under us.

Advertisement

The WWE Cruiserweight Championship match between Brian Kendrick and Kalisto has more than the title on the line. If SmackDown’s Kalisto won, the entire division would migrate to the blue brand. The two had a solid bout that picked up steam as it went and started pulling the fans into it… only for Baron Corbin to interfere and cause a DQ en route to demolishing Kalisto.

Advertisement

And that was that. The cruiserweight division’s big PPV moment was turned into an angle for a Corbin/Kalisto feud. That just about sums up WWE’s priorities right there.

1. Nia Jax Taps?

WWE.com

Wait, are you sh*tting us?

Advertisement

An “up” item was being prepared to praise WWE for turning Nia Jax into a monster after she ran through the entire SmackDown roster, one at a time. It was a brilliant move, letting them tag in and then destroy them. Nia double-suplexed Becky Lynch and Alexa Bliss. They were getting Jax over as a force to be reckoned with.

And then Nia tapped out to Becky’s Disarm-Her.

Advertisement

Let that roll around in your head for a minute. Jax is undefeated in WWE. She was being portrayed as a monster who couldn’t just beat up jobbers, but the best wrestlers on SmackDown as well. And she tapped out to an armbar.

No disrespect to Becky, but Nia should have had to have her arm broken before losing her first fall. There were a bunch of different ways they could have eliminated her without having her lose: countout, DQ, even cheating by SmackDown. This was just a dumb, dumb decision.

Advertisement

Ups...

5. Nattie Feigns Ignorance

WWE

Your first inclination might be to blame Carmella after Daniel Bryan found Nikki Bella knocked loopy backstage before the women’s elimination match. Nikki claimed she was attacked from behind and was unable to compete, but despite the fact that she’s been feuding with Carmella for the past few months, it probably wasn’t her.

Advertisement

Enter Natalya, who lost a match to Nikki to be the SmackDown team captain and thus was relegated to being the team’s coach. Nattie was a little too eager to volunteer to take Nikki’s spot in the Survivor Series match, thus getting what she ultimately wanted.

Advertisement

What made this work (and saved it from being a negative) was the fact that the announcers didn’t try to over-explain it or even play dumb. They said nothing and moved on to the fact that Nattie was filling out the team. Leave it to Bryan or someone to learn the truth on SmackDown to kick off that new feud.

4. Setting Up The Next Women’s Title Feud

WWE.com

Sure, there are some gripes about the booking of the women’s Survivor Series match, but WWE did a nice job of turning the page from the “unified Team Raw” to the next night in one fell swoop.

Advertisement

And that swoop came in the form of a Charlotte forearm and beatdown of Bayley, who had just pinned Becky Lynch to win their elimination match. The Raw Women’s Champion proceeded to demolish Bayley, assaulting her on the outside of the ring and throwing her into the barricade repeatedly.

Advertisement

It was a vicious attack that set the table for Bayley to chase her first one-on-one WWE title shot. Fans of Sasha Banks (including this writer) might grumble about her possibly being pushed aside for the time being, but at least this was nicely done, and we know it will make for a good feud.

3. New Day Gets One-Upped

WWE.com

Surprise eliminations can be a great thing in a Survivor Series match. Remember when John Cena was pinned in the 2014 bout, leaving Dolph Ziggler by himself against three men? That one left fans with jaws dropped.

Advertisement

In that vein, it made for a great moment when New Day’s Kofi Kingston, fresh off of mocking Fandango (and Tyler Breeze) for getting eliminated in record time, turned right into an Uso superkick, getting pinned just as quickly and leaving Team Raw without their tag champs and captains.

Advertisement

That elimination led to some strange pairings later, but it certainly turn the tag team elimination match on its head to see the Shining Stars outlast the New Day.

2. Squash City

WWE.com

This is something that fans will debate for some time.

Advertisement

After three years of being absolutely dominant in WWE, Brock Lesnar got knocked off in epic fashion for a man who hadn’t had a professional wrestling match in more than 12 years, Goldberg. And Goldberg didn’t just beat Brock (again), he dominated him by hitting two spears and a Jackhammer to win in short order.

Was this the right decision? Why did they throw away Lesnar’s dominance for someone who was signed to one match? Does this mean Brock is going away for a while? Will Goldberg wrestle more now?

Advertisement

Regardless of which questions you asked, the fact is that if you saw Survivor Series, you were talking about this on Monday. That isn’t always a great reason for doing things in WWE, but in this case, we’ll give them a thumbs-up.

Advertisement

1. Men’s Elimination Match Entertains

WWE.com

We could nitpick the men’s Survivor Series match and probably pull out a handful of ups and downs, but we’re short on time, so let’s just give it an overall thumbs-up for a few things.

Advertisement

First off, kudos to Chris Jericho for telling Dean Ambrose that he still owed him $15,000 for the scarf he destroyed way back before the brand split. Continuity! The bookers figured out a clever way to eliminate both Dean Ambrose and AJ Styles, having each of them cause the other’s loss, setting up their title match in two weeks at TLC. (Less clever was having James Ellsworth cause Braun Strowman’s countout, but at least the Chinless One got put through a table for his troubles.

Advertisement

And a special shout-out to the crowd for continuing the tradition of calling out Roman Reigns whenever he was down on the floor for an extended period of time, chanting “Roman’s sleeping!” and “Wake up Roman!” Hey, if you spend half the Royal Rumble being stretchered out the arena and come back to dominate it, you kind of deserve to be put on blast.