6 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Dynamite (July 5 - Review)

Kenny Omega is the best sports-oriented storyteller ever, and proved it on Dynamite last night.

By Michael Sidgwick /

AEW

Over on Collision, Tony Khan has booked a very good (if predictable) tournament.

Advertisement

The more languid pace on the Saturday show has allowed its various threads to resonate. Powerhouse Hobbs is a potentially excellent finalist; He stalked Dustin Rhodes menacingly and overcame his indomitable spirit last Saturday. In a great touch, Juice Robinson put up a fair fight against Ricky Starks, ensuring that the Owen has a slightly different tenor to the usual carny trappings of AEW television, in a match that was far more dramatic than it had any right to be.

CM Punk worked a great fight with Satoshi Kojima at Forbidden Door, a pissy war in which the cocky prick only narrowly escaped, and was even better at the commentary table last week. Samoa Joe Vs. Roderick Strong was already a beautiful, hard-hitting main event, with one of the better babyface comebacks in recent memory, but Punk elevated it.

Advertisement

Joe felt like an insurmountable force through Punk's narration. In the magic of suspended disbelief, Punk made it feel like Joe was still in his prime, that he couldn't be defeated. The other semi-final is hard to predict, at least, and the elegant simplicity has vastly improved upon last year's inaugural tournament.

How did the Blind Eliminator, launched on Dynamite last night, fare in comparison...?

Advertisement

Downs...

3. The Acclaimed Do Acclaimed Things To Diminishing Returns

AEW

The Acclaimed's feud with QTV was very gently advanced in an inoffensive segment.

Advertisement

The Acclaimed won another woefully predictable trios match that somehow everybody cared about. This unit is so over that they're already playing a greatest hits set, and they only turned less than a year ago. It wasn't particularly ambitious or mind-blowing telly, but it was loud and fun enough. Then, Harley Cameron interrupted the celebrations and threatened to drop a music video next week in a bid to prove that she is the best musician in AEW (she can sing well, but as a heel, she won't).

Remember when the rankings system existed to prove who the best wrestler is in AEW?

Advertisement

These matches are genuinely worthless. With the old framework in place, the Acclaimed would have earned #1 contender status to the House of Black weeks ago.

It no longer exists, and now, because their wins don't matter, they must contend with QT Marshall penning Jillian Hall-style material, which is a more brutal prospect than any picture you might have seen of Jon Moxley this week.

Advertisement

2. The Blind Eliminator Tournament, Much Like AEW Itself, Is Uneven

AEW

A quick word on those brackets: even for a conceit as fundamentally silly as the Blind Eliminator, which basically enables and excuses very fake-feeling contrivance, Tony Khan might have taken the piss. It all exists to drive the MJF Vs. Adam Cole programme and advance some midcard fare underneath. That's fine.

Advertisement

But pairing together another set of rivals, Keith Lee and Swerve Strickland, was a bit much (super match aside). Worse is that two semi-established tag teams were "drawn", in Darby Allin and Orange Cassidy and Sammy Guevara and Daniel Garcia. This isn't just too convenient; it's uninspired. Isn't the point of the tournament to indulge bullsh*t?

Nobody is taking it seriously as a serious box office attraction. Why not go dafter? Might as well go all in. Have Nick Jackson and Brody King together. Screw it, why not.

Advertisement

Khan actually threatened to do something supremely dumb and fun, by pairing Daddy Magic with the Butcher, but didn't air their pre-match promo. That wasn't just a missed opportunity. That was a scandal. Why put these specific acts together if not to exploit their majestic '80s Survivor Series promo dynamic? And doesn't Matt Hardy have enough to do? Was entering the tournament in his contract or Ethan Page's contract or whichever contract he's under this week?

Big Bill and Brian Cage. That's more like it.

Advertisement

The issue is that there's less like it.

1. More Of More Of The Same

AEW

Why are the Outcasts allowed to station themselves at ringside every single week?

Advertisement

The contrivance is becoming woeful, particularly since they are hardly the only outfit to interfere relentlessly in AEW matches. If Tony Khan is running a sports-oriented meritocracy as a babyface promoter, why is this ceaseless carny activity left unchecked? Why hasn't he revoked their presumed manager's license?

To enable f*ck finishes to drag this redundant stuff out, thus avoiding the need to commit time to the division. That's the answer.

Advertisement

Britt Baker Vs. Ruby Soho itself was unremarkable. One very notable botch undermined the first half, but fans did get up for the drama down the stretch. They were convinced that the belt shot delivered by Soho was the finish. The timing and blocking of the finishing sequence was well done too. For once in this endless loop of a storyline, one as interesting as bus route, the referee couldn't be blamed for missing the chicanery. It was a well-concealed smash and grab.

Pay this thing off the second Jamie Hayter is cleared to compete because it is repetitive and unproductive. Britt Baker hasn't been this lukewarm since she first got over.

Advertisement

This thing was booked in two seconds and will longer just as long in the memory.

Ups...

6. The AEW Creative Freedom Spirit, Embodied

AEW

Darby Allin and Orange Cassidy Vs. Swerve In Out Glory was super-heated and very fun, but that description overlooks just how much thought and creativity went into it.

Advertisement

The structure of the match could not have flattered Keith Lee more. This was yet more evidence that Tony Khan has inherited Paul Heyman's crown as the man who can best accentuate the positives and hide the negatives of his talent.

For ages, Lee could not be budged from his feet. Lee's role amplified the drama and crowd heat. He looked unbeatable throughout, and much doubt was cast over the result when, in an awesome spot, he carried Orange Cassdiy up the ring steps with Darby Allin crushed underneath. Cassidy couldn't even budge Lee with his most convoluted Stundog Millionaire trap yet. This all informed the magic of Darby finally flooring Lee with the code red and the brilliance of Cassidy's tornado DDT to the outside. In a match where it felt like Lee wouldn't bump at all, wildly tumbling out of the ring like it was 2017 again got it over all the more.

Advertisement

Funny, exhilarating, strategic, dramatic, unpredictable; this was several different great matches rolled into one, a dramatic party, and a match that could only exist in AEW and its breathless embrace of creative freedom.

A weird and wonderful match that advanced the Swerve Strickland feud in a very bizarre way, but restored faith in the payoff being great, at least.

Advertisement

Tony Khan booking a Can-They-Co-Exist? tournament and making it good is the epitome of a weird flex, but he did it nonetheless.

5. One Of The Best Segments Of The Year

AEW/Defy

AEW has rarely explored the vignette, and with good reason: far more often than not, with the odd embarrassing misread, the fans know who the new arrival is. After All Out 2021, the surprise debut had peaked, and a talent like Nick Wayne is so special that a special presentation was required.

Advertisement

AEW nailed it. This was perfect.

The context behind the rise of Defy sensation Nick Wayne is as emotional as it is impressive. Bereaved son and precocious teenager who took the indies by storm at just 16 years old, the story and the talent demands a grand introduction. It's better than fiction. AEW has stayed out of its own way, grasped this, and merely adapted it. This is to their immense credit. No other major, with its dojo system or Performance Center, would attempt to tell a story as bold as this.

Advertisement

The first part of Wayne's stirring start to pro wrestling was told by Darby Allin, who trained in Wayne's father's school, helped Wayne grieve and who could well be an opponent of his down the line. AEW further babyfaced one of its top stars and built its next huge babyface prospect with just incredible economy.

On a show that was brimming with wacky tag team combinations to drive various storylines forward, this sobering and very real human interest story was far more emotionally resonant - a reminder of what wrestling should ultimately strive towards.

Advertisement

4. An Intriguing New Direction Develops At The Ideal Time

AEW

The timing of this segment was so good that it's hard to believe that Chris Jericho may well have politicked himself into Blood & Guts with Bryan Danielson injured. Is that why he was drawn together with Don Callis in the narrative?

Advertisement

In any event, story beats flowed into one another quite brilliantly here. Jericho addressed the Edmonton crowd and acknowledged that he has become a perennial loser and is at a career crossroads, and hoped that soaking in the sights of his first territory run might rejuvenate him. What a location in which to cut this promo. Jericho created a great effect of serendipity here.

In another strong use of timing, Don Callis smelled Jericho's lack of confidence in the back and crept out to the ring to take advantage. He asked Jercho to join his family, after which both men took credit for once revitalising the other's career. Callis, who really did have a big say in the transformative Alpha Vs. Omega, said he could repeat the trick. Jericho said maybe, and will mull it over.

Advertisement

One plot hole aside - Kenny Omega brought Don in through the backdoor in storylines, so why Jericho insisted he himself did it is anybody's guess - this was excellent.

3. Good Admin Across The Show

AEW

AEW is often fairly accused of not doing the basics right. Certain main events are under-promoted, certain matches aren't raved about after they happen, certain storyline developments aren't emphasised enough as huge, game-changing deals.

Advertisement

Last night, AEW felt slightly less rushed and chaotic. Eddie Kingston's career highlight was recapped - he won a title from KENTA, realising a dream of winning NJPW gold in Korakuen hall - as was Jon Moxley's reaction to it. Moreover, Collision was hyped up as a big show. This was a necessity - last Saturday's number was disastrous in context, given that it was in range of far cheaper re-run material that once occupied the time slot - but it should become the norm. Last week's Dynamite was recapped (not to an extent that insulted the intelligence) to make it feel like it mattered more.

It's the oddest thing - AEW is often so good that it should flex its muscles more on occasion - and hopefully, last night was the first sign of a strange trend getting reversed.

Advertisement

2. The Adventures Of MJF And Adam Cole

AEW

The trouble with MJF's run in 2023 is that it is simultaneously well-performed and very entertaining, but not as strong as his programme with CM Punk last year.

Advertisement

Early in the show, a skit was broadcast in which MJF and Cole spotted one another in the gym. MJF also spotted a rotund fellow (Puf) and ripped the piss out of him, mercilessly, and Cole quietly agreed that it was funny even if it's not on to admit that these days. This involuntary bonding was very funny, but the production was jarring and not likely to appease the critics who question this WWE-adjacent direction. The music cues, close-ups...this was filmed and edited. The camera was acknowledged, but the scene was still too staged.

AEW is usually tighter with this sort of thing: couldn't they have framed it as though MJF's personal trainer had to film everything to track his progress?

Advertisement

Anything to hide the fact that this was a comedy skit, in keeping with AEW's approach (if that can still be written in the present tense). Contrived or no, this MJF Vs. Adam Cole double act is a hit in the building. Their match opposite Daddy Magic and the Butcher was fun, if jarring, given that the World champion was in it. MJF as ironic babyface asking for his cooler peer's help drew laughter from the crowd. In the post-match, MJF wished Adam Cole a happy birthday, set off some streamers and brought out an amusingly small, almost cruel cake. Cole sensed that MJF was going to put his face in it and beat him to it. Both men are playing a game, to what end is unclear.

MJF is trying to make Cole feel small, literally and figuratively, but what's Cole doing? Is he trying to make MJF feel like an idiot in order to get the psychological advantage?

Advertisement

MJF is brilliant at navigating material both lightweight and serious. Is the problem here that fans have seen too much of the former in recent months? MJF's character is brilliant. He's Joffrey Baratheon if he grew up. He will at some point reveal the darker side within, and his desperate attempts to get over with Cole hint at the horrible, broken little monster within, but this is the second consecutive feud in which he's done the cake-in-the-face gag. This, while great on its own low-stakes terms, is entertaining - but it isn't the Punk programme.

Wouldn't it be better if he was locked in serious business with Eddie Kingston?

Advertisement

1. A Cracking TV Main Event

AEW

Kenny Omega Vs. Wheeler YUTA was a fabulous TV main event that recognised the genre in which it was worked.

Advertisement

It didn't go too long, had no designs on being epic, and recognised that Omega is above YUTA's level. It wasn't too ambitious, but it extracted drama from the dynamic in multiple, excellent ways.

Nobody is better at the worked botch than Kenny Omega. He is so good at it, in fact, that it was easy to forget YUTA's pre-match promo in the moment. YUTA flashed his teeth and, like the weasel his character is, relished the chance to work his "broken" opponent. Very early in the match, Omega attempted his You Can't Escape fireman's carry into a moonsault. He was off balance and landed on his ass and not his feet, or so it seemed. He sold his neck throughout, and YUTA targeted it from that moment forward, but the way in which Omega crumpled and seemed hugely upset with himself made it feel like a real botch in the moment. There is nobody better at telling sports-oriented stories, and continuity, than Kenny Omega.

Advertisement

This was how the drama was created and parity was established. It wasn't an exciting back-and-forth for the sake of it, purely because that is de rigueur in modern wrestling. With convincing, breathless timing, Omega kicked out of the seatbelt pin because YUTA, whose inexperience is a key element of his character, did not hook the leg. It was a typically heart-pounding 2.9 on the part of Omega. This dynamic, of wounded wrestling God versus precocious but raw technician, created drama without taking the piss or undermining Omega's star aura. This was an outstanding bit of business that delivered the trademark Omega palpitations by the finish.

Could have done without the Dark Order turning up for the usual Elite Vs. Blackpool Combat Club post-match brawl, though. That feud already feels under-baked as a personal issue without diluting it to accommodate yet more internal strife within the Elite.

Advertisement