6 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite: New Year's Smash (Dec 27 - Results & Review)
Strong Continental Classic business carries AEW's flagship through to Worlds End.
Dynamite was missing an agonised JR call slamming Samoa Joe for doing business "with The Devil himself", but AEW still managed to hammer home the point as cameras faded to black. On Saturday, Joe challenges MJF for the World Title at Worlds End. Here, he caused Max to lose the ROH Tag-Team Titles and laid him out with the belt.
It worked.
Not everything from Wednesday's flagship did. Some stories feel like they're totally dragging and a real chore, whilst others have resurfaced long past their sell-by-dates. All Elite also decided to reunite two wrestlers for the millionth time - that was a case of diminishing returns, and it rendered another union ultimately pointless.
Back on the plus side, the Continental Classic has been a blessing on company TV recently. Tony Khan will do well to find something else as fun to keep things ticking over on Dynamite, Rampage and Collision in the new year, put it that way. At least the final bout is set, and it has the potential to be a proper scorcher.
Here's all the good and bad from AEW's last major stop pre-Worlds End.
Downs...
4. Still Feels Too Late
AEW announced Keith Lee vs. Swerve Strickland for Worlds End mid-Dynamite, and Excalibur hyped the match as though it's something fans have been waiting on the edge of their seats to see. That's not true. If anything, people were fairly excited for this battle of former tag partners a few years ago.
The ship has sailed.
Lee vs. Swerve could still be a fun addition to the undercard come Saturday, but Tony Khan has honestly stretched the feud out for far too long. Interest and general buzz just isn't that strong for Keith anymore, and Strickland has motored past him onto a higher level on AEW's roster.
Maybe this scrap can rekindle some fire, but it remains to be seen. There's surely no way Lee is beating Swerve heading into 2024 - not after some of the performances Strickland has been putting on in the Continental Classic.
Move on already. Everyone else has.
3. This Didn’t Do Much To Convince
Toni Storm is fighting an uphill battle on the same pay-per-view. Her mission, and she has no choice but to accept it, is to make Riho look like a credible threat to the Women's Title heading into Worlds End. That's tough, because the former champ popped back up out of nowhere to challenge for the gold.
Fans are audibly apathetic.
All Elite tried to present Riho as a physical match for Toni on Dynamite by having the diminutive worker run straight through Storm, Luther and Mariah May with ease. This is clutching at straws. Riho still doesn't have much character to speak of, and the women's game in AEW has moved on since she was leading the charge.
The short scuffle Tony booked on Wednesday did nothing to present the match as particularly must-see. Next to nobody buys the idea of Riho hoisting that strap high above her head at close of business on Saturday, let's be honest about it.
2. Jon Moxley’s Knee?
The commentary team talked fans through Jay White's vicious attack on Jon Moxley's knee during a recap of their Gold League match. That happened before the opening three way to establish a Gold League winner, but it was barely mentioned again. Huh? What a puzzling bit of presentation.
Why highlight the possible knee troubles if they weren't going to be involved in either Moxley's match on Dynamite or the setup for his finale vs. Eddie Kingston at Worlds End? Neither White nor Swerve went after Jon's leg much during the opener, and Kingston didn't even bother mentioning the weakness during his promo.
Weird.
Moxley did do a tiny bit of selling mid-celebration following the triple threat, but that was it. Excalibur, Tazz and Tony Schiavone largely ignored the knee in favour of other things, which rendered it useless as a story beat. Surely Mox's knee should've been the narrative glue?
1. Been Here, Done This!
This again?!
Chris Jericho came to Sammy Guevara's aid when the Don Callis Family unceremoniously dumped him and started kicking lumps out of wrestling's new daddy. Fans popped out of politeness, but there's no way AEW gets a pass for playing this card for the zillionth time over the past few years. That's what it feels like, anyway.
Diminishing returns are a stone cold killer to any wrestling booking, and this is a prime example on All Elite's side. At this point, it's really hard to care about the topsy turvy relationship between Jericho and Guevara. Many fans are numb to their constant fallouts and erm...fall-back-ins.
Worse, this means Sammy's alliance with Callis went nowhere and actually did sod all for him as a character overall. So, he's a babyface because he's a new father? That's it?! This was all terribly rushed, and Guevara lacks the necessary fire to be a likeable underdog babyface anyway.
He's a natural heel.
Ups...
6. Change, Change, Change!
Skye Blue recently morphed into a darker character who was corrupted by Julia Hart's witchy influence, and it seems more change is coming in the women's division. That's not really a bad thing either, 'cause Kris Statlander badly needs something to chew on following a mundane TBS Title reign.
Stokely Hathaway is here to provide a solution.
The slick-talking manager did guest commentary on Stat's match vs. Skye on Wednesday, and Stokely suggested he's the man to bring something extra out of Kris in the long run. That'll be fun to see. The actual match between Blue and Statlander was a blast too - even the annoying pic-in-pic ad interruption couldn't halt their momentum.
Go out of your way to see Skye's insane looking Code Blue off the ropes in the corner too. That was one hell of a finish, one that sells just how menacing the previously-charming Blue has become now she's next to Julia. Good stuff all round here.
5. Exactly What It Needed To Be
Yours truly was a bit worried when short interludes aired teasing a civil sit-down chat between Adam Copeland and Christian Cage, but AEW was bluffing. The old friends-turned-rivals started brawling as soon as Copeland arrived on the scene, and things got so out of control that what looked like the entire ROH roster had to step in.
Honor, and all that eh?
There's a stark contrast between this simple piece of business and the earlier moment between Riho and Toni Storm. Namely, Copeland and Cage have significant history together, and there's a valid reason why they're at one another's throats ahead of Worlds End.
Sometimes, this kind of simple pull-apart is all you need heading into a pay-per-view title match. AEW successfully made Christian look cowardly when confronted, Copeland wild and out of revenge, and they even managed to sell the 'No DQ' stip too.
4. “Pleasure Doing Business With You”
Some wrestling fans might well be critical of AEW's decision to take the ROH Tag Titles off MJF (and Adam Cole, don't forget) on Dynamite, but this writer actually liked what Tony Khan did here. The way Samoa Joe pulled wool over Max's eyes, and left him to battle the numbers disadvantage solo then ambushed him, was pro wrestling 101.
The tweener stuff Joe had been doing is now firmly out the window. He's the villain of this piece, because he screwed MJF over in favour of a payday from The Devil. That reveal better be something pretty special on pay-per-view, but back to TV for a second.
"Pleasure doing business with you" was a winner.
Now, in theory, MJF will be physically and psychologically damaged heading into the World Title showdown on Saturday night. That suits the Samoan veteran, and (again in theory) gives him a better chance of seizing the title.
3. A PPV Quality Opener
What an opener, man.
The triple threat pitting Jon Moxley vs. Jay White vs. Swerve Strickland came across as a big time battle from the off, and it proved to be a top way to open this episode. The fact Swerve didn't take the decisive fall is very encouraging too; here's hope AEW has big, big plans for him in 2024.
Strickland has been on fire lately, and more is clearly coming. Besides, Jay White is a more established star on the upper decks and recently battled for the World Title, so he'll be fine. Personally, this guy would've went all the way and given the win to Swerve, but it is what it is and at least there's a natural story to tell with Mox and Eddie Kingston.
People always know they'll see some really good matches whenever they tune into AEW programming. However, this three way was a cut above even that. It was borderline pay-per-view quality from start to finish, and had stakes to boot.
2. Eddie Fights For His Life!
"...and had stakes to boot".
Eddie Kingston created a problem for himself right at the beginning of the Continental Classic by putting his ROH and New Japan titles up for grabs. A miserable 0-2 start suggested Eddie was out of the running, but AEW told a fab story by having Kingston scratch, bite and claw (and chop) his way back into contention.
On Dynamite, Bryan Danielson went out of his way to elevate Eddie further. Both men told a wonderful story of arrogance (from the much more technical Bryan) and scrappy heart (from Kingston, who refused to let his dreams die). Eddie fought from underneath for most of the match, and the Orlando crowd was with him every step of the way.
There was a majestic moment near the end when Danielson kicked out of the move Kingston had used to beat Andrade El Idolo in the tourney. That sold how much harder the CC gets the deeper you go, which is really smart storytelling and should come in handy for future versions when announcers claim every match matters.
1. Old Friends At It Again
Admittedly, Moxley vs. Kingston wouldn't have been this fan's top pick for the final of the Continental Classic when it kicked off, but it will be one hell of a fight at Worlds End. Tony Khan's tournament has been a celebration of everything that's right about tourney wrestling thus far, and there's no reason to expect the finale to sag.
Jon and Eddie going nose-to-nose on Dynamite was pulsating.
Their ongoing story of mutual respect from old friends/warriors, with a similarly mutual understanding that both will do anything to succeed, works. All Elite didn't try to over-egg the pudding here either. Moxley spoke of knowing he's the dominant wrestler whenever he and Eddie lock horns, and Kingston warned him he's not some "young boy".
Fans opposite the hard cam were visibly hanging on every single word and movement between these two. Look out for some callbacks to their "I Quit" main event from Full Gear 2020 on Saturday as well. Workers like this pair love to reference history, so it's almost a given they'll do so at Worlds End.
What did you think of this week's AEW Dynamite? For more like this, check out 10 AEW Wrestlers Poised To Break Out In 2024 and AEW Worlds End 2023: 10 Nightmares That Could Come True!