6 Ups And 5 Downs From Last Night’s WWE Raw (April 6th)

We've got our main event for Extreme Rules. Excited?

By Brad Hamilton /

We're officially one week removed from the two biggest and most important shows of the year: WrestleMania 31 and the subsequent Monday Night Raw. While Mania was, by all accounts a very-good-to-fantastic show, the next night's Raw started off extremely strong but sputtered to a disappointing ending after a weak third hour. The highlight of the show was Brock Lesnar going on a rampage, destroying announcers and cameramen in his quest to get his hands on Seth Rollins and was suspended indefinitely in order to write him off TV for a while, reportedly until SummerSlam. The main event was more of the same, with Rollins, Kane and Big Show squaring off against Randy Orton, Ryback and Roman Reigns, who - at least as far as the crowd in San Jose was concerned - wasn't granted any modicum of respect for the beating he withstood at the hands of Lesnar the night before. So where do we go from here? We open with the in-ring promo that has become standard fare at this point, in fact it's impossible to remember the last time Raw kicked off with anything other than someone standing in the squared circle yammering for 15 or more minutes. It's the curse of unimaginative and repetitive booking that we've been plagued with for years. We're begging for some variety in the layout of the shows. So did things pick up from there or did we continue down the same tired path that WrestleMania 31 briefly deviated from? Let's get to the ups and downs.

DOWNS...

5. Randy Orton vs. Kane

Is there any other possible combination of wrestlers less interesting in 2015 than Randy Orton and Kane? When The Director of Operations announced than Orton would be facing him in a singles match, the audience collectively groaned at the redundancy €“ not just of the match itself but for WWE once again dipping into the dried up well of having The Authority book the babyfaces in punishment matches. When Orton is motivated he's one of the best workers in the business, but when he isn't he can be as dull as they come. The Apex Predator seems to be inspired and is clearly headed toward a title shot vs. Rollins at Extreme Rules, but there's better ways to get him ready for that than being unable to pin Kane. The bout itself was mercifully short and ended in a disqualification victory for The Viper so at least we weren€™t subjected to a lengthy matchup between the two, but this trope of having The Authority place guys in matches as punishment needs to end now. These are wrestlers. How is making them wrestle a bad thing? It€™s their job!

4. A Rift In The Authority

Is there anyone who wants to see a Business Casual Kane face turn? At this point in his career the best thing for Kane is to play a much more reduced role, stop being used in main events and elevate younger talent. But with the dissension developing among the members of The Authority in Triple H and Stephanie's absence, it feels like WWE are planting seeds toward a babyface run for The Devil's Favorite Director. If that leads to any kind of feud between Seth Rollins and Kane it's a lose-lose scenario for the new champ as well as the fans. The last thing Seth needs halting his momentum is getting tied up in a feud with a heatkiller like Kane. After all, we saw how well that worked out having The Big Red Machine as Daniel Bryan's first challenger after winning the WWE title at WrestleMania 30. Dissolving The Authority - as least in its current form - is a fine idea, but hopefully if and when it happens it won't lead to The AuthorityPowers Explode! There's far too many guys on the roster who should be getting those important roles.

3. #GiveDivasLessChances

Now that AJ Lee has walked away from WWE, it's obvious the company has inserted Naomi into her spot in the feud between Paige and The Bellas. At the midway point of the show we got a tag match between the four ladies that featured nearly as many botches as actual wrestling maneuvers. While Brie has never been a good worker, Nikki has shown definite improvement, however not much of that was on display in this match. The bout was mostly used as a plot device to tease a split between the twins. If this were to happen, there doesn't seem to be a preferable outcome for the feud. After all, they've already ran this once before with Brie as the face and it died such a miserable death that they aborted the angle, turned Brie back heel and aligned her with Nikki once again with no explanation whatsoever. Conversely, Nikki is such an awesome natural heel - both on Raw and Total Divas - that any attempt to make her the face between the sisters would likely be met with even more disinterest. Honestly the best thing for the Bellas is to keep them together doing exactly what they're doing, soaking up boos as the mean girls of the WWE who the fans want to see taught a lesson. No one is buying either of these girls as faces, unless you stick Brie with Bryan again which would be a terrible move for the Intercontinental champ/ As far as Naomi goes, she's definitely looked better than she did in this match and had several rough patches, but I guess when the girl's entire offense is based on bumping her *ss around like a Nicki Minaj stage show we shouldn't expect all that much.

2. We Clap Or We Snap

This entire bizarre New Day gimmick has officially gone meta. While it's most likely intentional It's not outside the realm of possibility that Big E, Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods are so far under the radar of Vince and the writers that they're not even aware that the three performers have taken to mocking their own gimmick. The interview with Renee Young was a prime example of this, with Big E over-exaggerating his southern baptist minister's voice and Kofi and Woods putting on fake smiles while dancing their way out of the segment. It's obvious they're building toward a heel turn - as evidenced by the cadence of the clap being changed to accommodate the "New...Day Sucks" chants - but if this was the plan from the start, they've done a terrible job of getting there. Reports were that the the initial angle to turn the three heel was nixed due to timing with the Ferguson protests, but turning them into dancing carcicatures was far more offensive than anything politically charged they would have done. The tag team division is in shambles once again, but maybe breathing new life into three of the most ridiculous - and in the case of Big E, wasted - characters in the WWE will help revive it. Probably not, but we can dream.

1. Reigns Isn't Connecting? Have Him Work With Big Show!

If you sat an outsider who doesn't follow the product down, forced them to watch the last six weeks of WWE programming and then asked them what they thought management's opinion of Roman Reigns was, they'd probably posit that he's just "some guy." In the lead up to the biggest match of his life they had him lose to The Big Show, and in the two matches he's had since losing said biggest match, he's now faced Show in both of them. WWE's fascination with Big Show in 2015 should be studied. Seriously, there should be grants and research committees formed to get to the bottom of why Vince thinks booking this guy so strongly leads to positive returns. They've taken the Goldberg formula - something that was quite successful for Reigns during his run with The Shield - and forgotten it entirely, instead trying to turn him into a Samoan Ricky Morton who sells for 90% of his matches. If they wanted Roman Reigns to get over, he should go in the ring with Big Show, kick his giant *ss from pillar to post for 5 minutes, then superman punch-spear-pin. Instead they continue to make him look unspectacular by accentuating his weaknesses in long matches against heatless veterans who have long overstayed their welcome in main events.

UPS...

6. Seth Rollins Is The Best At Everything

Anyone who heard the audience response to Seth Rollins winning the WWE World Championship at WrestleMania and the hero€™s welcome he received at the start of the following night€™s Raw is well aware that the crowd was happy to see him on top. But as a heel €“ and the best one in the business that€™s an active wrestler €“ his job is to silence those cheers and channel them back into boos. And that€™s exactly what he did at the beginning of Raw. The career path Rollins has taken over the last year, going from the guy many feared would be the odd man out once The Shield disbanded, to being the kayfabe and real future of the WWE has been a remarkable thing to witness. He€™s grown so much as a performer and it was never more evident than in the opening segment. Seth does slimy weasel so well that it€™s impossible not to get caught up in hating him. The way he drew heat from that crowd was brilliant and his jab at Kane for €œ€being there€ at WrestleMania was laugh-out-loud funny. He€™s a master at playing the entitled little brat and throwing tantrums when he doesn€™t get his way, but most importantly, every time he steps inside the ring for a match he delivers in spades. He€™s the perfect heel, and when he eventually turns face he€™ll be an even bigger star. Rollins is absolutely on fire right now and deserves the spot he€™s in.

5. The Challenger That Gravity Forgot

In an staggeringly brilliant piece of booking, Kane thrust Seth Rollins into a match against a challenger unbeknownst to him. As the WWE champ stood in the ring waiting on the reveal of who he would be facing, we got our second appearance of the newly-called up Neville. The former NXT champion garnered a great reaction, including the crowd engaging in an €œNXT€ chant, and proceeded to have an awesome match with Rollins. This was so atypical of WWE€™s normal booking when introducing a new performer, where they normally trade wins for a while and then embark on a losing streak before the company ever decides to push them that it was incredibly fresh and unique. In one match they took a guy who may have struggled to get over without the proper booking and established him as an immediate threat while giving him a high profile platform to showcase to the audience what this remarkable talent is capable of. This was an awesome segment and hopefully a sign of things to come for the standout aerial performer.

4. John Cena Is A Fighting Champion

Fans have been complaining about the senseless devaluing of the secondary titles for years now, with the Intercontinental and US championships being treated as jokes rather than the once prestigious honors they were formerly viewed as. When John Cena and Daniel Bryan left WrestleMania 31 with the two belts around their waists, there was cautious optimism that WWE had plans for those titles other than booking the champ to lose consecutive non-title matches while looking like a jobber dork. We€™re only a week in, but it seems that's exactly what the company has in store, at least as far as Cena and the US belt is concerned. Last week the champ defended the title in a hard fought open challenge vs. fan favorite Dean Ambrose, and this week he continued that with putting it on the line against Stardust. The thought of Cena vs. Stardust in any kind of title match would have been an absurd one no more than a few weeks ago, but with someone else sitting atop the WWE throne, this is exactly what Cena should be doing: Having very good matches with guys in the midcard who€™d never get a chance to work with him otherwise. This is a great opportunity to increase the profile of many of the talents on the roster. More of this, please.

3. No Momentum-Building Vintage Separation

Byron Saxton caught a lot of flak for his performance on commentary last week, from both fans and apparently Vince McMahon, but when you take into account he was thrown out there on his own after what was supposed to be a shocking moment the guy deserved a least a little benefit of the doubt. Saxton is no Jim Ross (no one is), but he€™s not quite as bad as he came off last week. This Raw was blessed by the absence of Michael Cole, still selling the effects of Lesnar€™s F5, and while the three men behind the desk combined aren€™t nearly as experienced as Cole is on his own, it was such a refreshing departure from the usual mind-numbing bombardment of Coleisms. For all its faults, the commentary is one of the most unpleasant aspects of any episode of Raw, as Cole and JBL especially engage in grating banter that detracts from the action rather than emphasizes it. Michael Cole can be good when motivated, and everyone is aware of just how much micromanaging Vince does with the commentary team, but nevertheless he wasn€™t missed on this episode. At all. Saxton isn't great (okay, he's awful), but we could use a few weeks without being subjected to JBL€™s incessant €œWE€™RE HAVING FUN, MAGGLE!€

2. Keeping It Classy In Regards To AJ Lee

Prior to this show, the smart money was on WWE either throwing petty jabs at newly retired diva AJ Lee or ignoring her decision entirely. In fact, I think most fans probably expected some form of disrespect or throwing shade, especially considering the contentious relationship between her husband and the WWE. So the fact that the commentators chose to speak so highly and respectful of her at various points throughout the night €“ early in the show and during the Divas tag match €“ was a nice surprise. They lauded her for her multiple accomplishments while with the company, highlighting her record breaking title reign and JBL even said €œThank you, AJ€ - the Twitter hashtag that made the rounds once the news broke. For a company infamous for burying former employees in childish ways, it was nice to see them take the high road in regards to the most popular female performer since the heydays of Trish Stratus and Lita.

1. The Right Guy Won The Main Event...And Quickly

There wasn't any surprise regarding who was going to pull out the win in the main event triple threat match to determine the #1 contender for Extreme Rules, and there shouldn't have been. Randy Orton and Seth Rollins had a great match on the undercard at WrestleMania 31 and it's going to be exciting seeing what they're capable of when tasked with facing off in the main event. For a company who is allegedly so intent on getting Roman Reigns over, they continue to book him in situations where he comes out on the losing end, ostensibly in an attempt to earn the fans' respect by having him pay his dues? At least he wasn't the one to eat the pin here in this main event - Ryback was, and he's someone who they are (and should be) less-invested in. The match was quick and to the point and included the requisite Authority stooge interference, and despite a dead crowd the victory-claiming RKO drew a nice pop from the crowd. Seeing as Orton's last run as champion drew particularly disappointing numbers it will be interesting to see how well the matches do with his as challenger. Hopefully much better, as a long Seth Rollins reign would be great for the company.