7 Mistakes WWE Will Probably Make With The Draft This Week
We still remember the last time...
This Tuesday marks the first live episode of Smackdown, and that means it's time for the WWE Draft! Once again, the company will be divided up across Raw and Smackdown lines, with each show being run as a separate promotion, and it all starts this week.
This could be a chance for WWE to really give its programming a shot in the arm. Raw has been stale for a long, long time, while Smackdown's ratings are so weak that the USA Network were the ones to actually press the idea of making the show live. In a perfect world, WWE would take this opportunity to let both shows evolve, grow their own feel, and become must-watch wrestling television.
Unfortunately, as we've seen before - including during the first split, which lasted from 2002 to 2011 - the company tends to be its own worst enemy in this scenario. There's a very "WWE" way of doing things that Vince McMahon is loath to abandon, and as a result, fans experience a lot more disappointment and frustration than they should have to.
This draft could be the beginning of something great - but we've all seen too much to actually believe that. Odds are that it's all doomed from the get-go.
Here are seven mistakes WWE will make with the draft this week...
7. Triple H Becomes Raw General Manager
Before the rosters are split on Smackdown, Raw will answer the question as to who will run each brand.
Last week, Stephanie and Shane McMahon were appointed the Commissioners of Raw and Smackdown, respectively, but Vince McMahon told both of his children that this week they would have to appoint General Managers to run "day-to-day operations".
The Smackdown General Manager is rumoured to be Daniel Bryan (WWE accidentally let the news slip on the company's app), but where does that leave Raw? Sadly, there's no more logical step than for Stephanie McMahon to appoint her husband, Triple H, as the show's General Manager.
As The Authority, the two ran Raw for years, and there's no kayfabe reason why Stephanie wouldn't return to that status quo when given the chance.
Triple H has been off camera since WrestleMania, but rumours have popped up about him competing at SummerSlam. With that show just about a month away, he'll have to return soon if he's participating. That's even more reason to believe the tired Authority unit is coming back.
6. NXT Gets Gutted
On Sunday evening, WWE.com released a list of rules for the draft. Amongst them was the revelation that six stars from the NXT brand will become part of the WWE roster.
It could be worse, to be honest - many feared that NXT would be unrecognisable after the draft. Nevertheless, six stars is a lot for a brand with an active roster of less than thirty, and it's likely going to be the most valuable stars who are poached.
NXT has already basically written Finn Balor and American Alpha off of TV, so it's a safe bet that they'll be three of the six. As for the remaining three, it's hard to imagine neither Samoa Joe nor Shinsuke Nakamura being taken, but both are invaluable to the company's men's division.
The same can be said for Bayley and Nia Jax in the women's division, and again, odds are that one will go. Other picks could be names such as Austin Aries, Hideo Itami, Tye Dillinger, Alexa Bliss, and Andrade "Cien" Almas.
It's not a bad thing that these stars are getting called up - that's what development is ultimately for. The problem is that an exodus this large and with nobody waiting to immediately replace the promoted stars could really hurt NXT.
5. Tag Teams Get Split Up
The most puzzling rule for the WWE draft regards the status of tag teams. According to WWE.com, "Tag teams count as one pick unless a Commissioner/General Manager specifically only wants one member of the team​". So basically, teams can't be split... unless they are.
Given that there have been teases on TV that teams will be split up, it's a safe bet that at least a couple of units will be forced to go their separate ways. The problem is that it's completely unnecessary to break up any of the current tag teams, and WWE will be doing it just for the sake of a swerve in the moment.
During the first draft, WWE split up tag teams, but the men involved ultimately floundered and the teams were reunited. Today, it'll be much the same - nobody wants to see an Aiden English or Konnor singles run, and it won't work.
The only team whose members could make it on their own are The New Day, and being as how they're the most successful act in the company, the time is not right to split them up.
4. Roman Reigns Is Picked Too Soon...
One man who won't be on Raw or Smackdown this week is Roman Reigns. The three-time WWE Champion was suspended just after Money in the Bank, and he won't be eligible to return until Thursday. That means that he'll make his main-event match at Battleground, but he won't be there for the draft.
Still, anyone who's watched Raw in Roman's absence knows that the company hasn't let a little thing like him not being there stop them from putting him over. Seth Rollins has been crowing about Reigns incessantly over the past few weeks, with the company hoping he'll take some of the heat Reigns is undoubtedly going to have upon his return.
They're doing their best to protect "The Guy", even in absentia.
Part and parcel of that protection is that Reigns is going to get a great pick in the draft. Originally, it was rumored that he'd be the 1A pick, anchoring Raw, and John Cena would be 1B, going to Smackdown. While it is possible that resentment over Reigns's Wellness Policy violation could prevent him from going first overall, odds are cooler heads will prevail and the company will stick with its years-in-the-making plan.
Expect Reigns to be one of the first two men selected.
3. ...Seth Rollins Isn't Picked Soon Enough...
There's nobody in WWE right now with a larger upside than Seth Rollins. Though AJ Styles may be the better worker overall, Rollins is only 30 and has another decade-plus to reign atop the company. His promos, his ring work, and his presentation are all world-class, and he deserves to be the face of WWE.
He's not, though. While it's possible that someday he will be, right now, Rollins's role is to be Roman Reigns's foil, the thorn in "The Guy's" side. WWE squandered all of Rollins's return moment when they refused to turn him face, and they're going to keep shooting themselves in the foot in order to put Reigns over.
That means that Rollins won't get the draft slot that he deserves. "The Architect" should feasibly be the first overall pick in the company, but odds are that Reigns and Cena will both go before he does. That leaves Rollins at #3 at best, lower at worst, and wasted either way.
2. ...And Dean Ambrose Is Completely Screwed
Actually, a correction - it's Dean Ambrose who should feasibly be the #1 overall pick in the draft, because he's currently the WWE Champion. While that could (and likely will) change next week at Battleground, "The Lunatic Fringe" will retain his title in the Seth Rollins match on Raw, and head into Smackdown as champ.
Ambrose has been the odd man out since The Shield split up - he's been Roman Reigns's sidekick, Seth Rollins's victim, and the unpredictable midcarder who's managed to stay popular despite being treated like a joke by the booking team. Now, improbably, Ambrose is WWE Champion. It could be a turning point for him.
Unfortunately, that just doesn't seem likely. WWE Champion or not, Ambrose is clearly not as high a priority for WWE as Reigns and Rollins are, and he's only carrying the title right now because of Reigns's suspension. With Reigns and Rollins believed to be Raw's top face and heel, and Cena and Styles expected to hold the position on Smackdown, Ambrose is out in the cold.
Ultimately, he could be selected as high as fourth overall, but even that spot will be an embarrassment to him, and to the WWE title.
1. Raw Is Dealt The Better Hand
The only reason this draft and split are happening is because USA is unhappy with Smackdown's ratings. It would stand to reason, then, that the highest priority here is making Smackdown more of a must-see show, and on the surface, that's probably how WWE sees it. Unfortunately, history shows that that's going to be harder than it sounds.
Raw is WWE's flagship show. The company says it all the time, and Vince McMahon even said it on Raw last week. McMahon and his team won't do anything to jeopardise the value of the Raw brand in the long run, and given that the ratings for the show have already decreased to 19-year lows, that means that there's really not that much room to play around.
No matter what happens with the draft, Raw is going to be losing talent, so the show's future is shaky.
For that reason, expect Raw to be protected more than one would think - or advise. The red brand's roster is already confirmed to be larger (WWE.com stated that due to the length of the show, Raw will get three picks for every two Smackdown gets), and expect it to be better, too.
Even if John Cena does go to the blue brand, Raw will make up for it with Brock Lesnar, Randy Orton, The New Day, and most of the other stars who could mean ratings success.
Last time, it took nine years before Smackdown was unfeasible as its own brand. How long will it take this time - and how will USA react?