7 Times WWE Blew It With Jack Swagger

Hit the road, Jack.

By Michael Hamflett /

Another casualty of the John Laurinaitis era of talent development within WWE, Jack Swagger has walked away from the organisation after over a decade within the system and nearly as long as an active member of the main roster.

Advertisement

Cast aside for extended stints during his final years with the promotion, Swagger has looked somewhat of a lost cause for a while now, so despite multiple singles titles runs and healthy spells near the top of the card at different stages of his career, his departure wasn't truly that big of a shock.

His final moment of significance was his own announcement as the first wrestler to cross the divide between Raw and Smackdown in the most recent brand extension, but his failure to capitalise on the move and remotely change his situation seemed to sum up what writers thought of his contributions.

As a favourite of Jim Ross in his younger days and a veteran of all three of WWE's developmental territories en route to the big leagues, huge expectations were placed on 'The All American American', but he was often let down by some disappointing booking and creative roadblocks that his precariously poised character was ill-prepared to counter.

As he presumably ponders his next move away from Vince McMahon's wrestling empire, here are 7 ways WWE blew it with Jack Swagger.

7. United States Champion

If anybody could have benefitted from WWE's disastrous mishandling of Zack Ryder's unlikely ascension, it was Jack Swagger.

Advertisement

Having put the US Title on Ryder at December 2011's TLC pay-per-view in acknowledgment of a year's worth of self-made crowd support for 'Long Island Iced Z', WWE immediately cooled on the Ryder Revolution, subjecting him to months of demeaning booking as if to force fans away from their newest love.

Part of that involved the loss of his treasured United States title to Swagger, in an abridged Raw squash after Ryder was decimated by Kane prior to the contest.

Unfortunately for Jack, he was a winner in name only.

Despite Ryder's lust for the title only one month earlier, in Swagger's hands it returned to being a meaningless prop. Outside of a successful defence against Justin Gabriel in a nothing match at February's Elimination Chamber pay-per-view, Swagger was really more focused on success in the tag ranks with fellow Vicky Guerrero protege (and longstanding former US Champion) Dolph Ziggler.

Swagger would drop the title to Santino Marella in March after two pointless months with the prize, and failure to regain it in months of rematches triggered a 'losing streak' angle, removing him from television altogether.

6. You Don't Know Jack

Originally signing to Raw amongst the basement draftees in the 2016 Brand Extension, Swagger was as insignificant on the red brand as he'd ever been.

Advertisement

A jobber-to-the-jobbers, let alone the stars, Jack was immune to wins, as proven when he laid down for roster-enhancing returnee Jinder Mahal in a tepid match.

Post-match, an interview with Tom Phillips revealed that Swagger's contract on the a-show was expiring, leading to speculation that an angle was forthcoming over his possible defection or outright departure from the company.

WWE weren't keen to let that breathe though, and Swagger abruptly appeared on Smackdown Live! the following night to rescue Apollo Crews from a Baron Corbin beating.

Despite dressing like 1998, the rest of his act was refreshing, as he ran off 'The Lone Wolf' and re-established his amateur and professional credentials, even dropping in a new catchphrase in as he promised to thrive in the blue brand's land of opportunity.

It didn't happen. Controversially defeating Corbin in his debut match, Swagger looked a loser for accepting the tainted victory, and defeat in legitimate contests to Baron on pay-per-view and television saw Jack still on his back.

Quietly disappearing off the main shows again, it would be his last major programme.

5. The Real Americans

Returning from surgery in 2013, Swagger re-aligned with manager Zeb Colter and his new charge Cesaro, forming a 'Real Americans' tag unit that would become a hit in a watered-down tag division.

Advertisement

The duo got over fast, which naturally meant eating plenty of losses in efforts to aid other flagging units.

Continuing unabated, the tandem gradually became indispensable amongst fluffier crews The Usos, Los Matadores and a comedy pairing of Santino Marella and The Great Khali.

Consequently, the pair were given high profile pay-per-view opportunities, including a notable Battleground pay-per-view win over Khali and Marella that saw Cesaro hit the 'Punjabi Playboy' with his giant swing, and a Survivor Series coming together with The Shield for victory over a Rey Mysterio-led group of The Usos and The Rhodes Family.

As momentum built for a Cesaro babyface turn, the team began the head towards their split, but the weak implosion would irrecoverably damage both Swagger and Colter, and do little for 'The Swiss Superman'.

Coming apart during the WrestleMania 30 pre-show after defeat in a tag title match, Swagger suffered the indignity of a Cesaro swing and abandonment by Zeb.

However, with Cesaro leaving Zeb for Paul Heyman the following night, the group was completely dissolved, with zero satisfactory follow-up programme left in the offing.

4. His Face Turn

Though his face turn came more through the vigour of an effective heel, Swagger back-doored his way into a golden opportunity when a feud with Rusev allowed his United States rhetoric to be a force for good.

Advertisement

Challenging the 'Bulgarian Brute' in June 2014 for his fiercely anti-American stance, Swagger and Zeb Colter presented one of the first real challenges for both Rusev and Lana as they physically and verbally tore through the WWE midcard.

Necessitated by a long undefeated streak the company was establishing for Rusev, Swagger wound up tasting losing to Rusev on pay-per-view at Battleground and SummerSlam that year, however during that time, he provided the substantial threat to Ru-Ru's reign of terror.

Losing via countout and pass-out respectively, Swagger was kept strong, and had even had Rusev on the verge of submitting through his re-invigorated 'Patriot Lock' ankle submission.

The two would battle on and off for the remainder of the year, with Swagger even pick up a disqualification victory over Rusev on television.

The momentum was again short-lived. Transferring Rusev elsewhere, Swagger was left to flounder, and by the time the two had a significant payoff at December's TLC pay-per-view, the result was academic thanks again to Jack's reduced status.

3. ECW Champion

Arguably the highlight of his entire WWE career, Swagger's ECW Title victory came during a quietly enjoyable spell for the much-maligned C-show, with victory over Matt Hardy for the championship representing real elevation for the 'All American American'.

Advertisement

Swagger was the best talent to emerge from the show's constant stream of average athletes that would randomly appear week after week, and through an undefeated streak, a feud with the show's stalwart Tommy Dreamer, and a legitimately irritating character, Jack was a hit.

Soaring above the other developmental prospects bleeding onto the show, Swagger looked like he belonged as champion, but when his undefeated streak was recklessly abandoned in non-title defeat to Finlay a month after he won the title, his arrogance lost its sparkle somewhat.

That said, he did manage to hold on to the title for over 100 days, until April's Backlash where recent company returnee Christian took his rightful spot atop the brand.

Running before he could walk, Swagger was traded to Monday Night Raw, but was unable to find traction from the off as he had done in ECW's smaller pond.

It was rash follow-up for the young character, and undermined months of great work the company and Swagger himself had done since his debut.

2. We The People

What started as the company's best handling of the Swagger character quickly became the worst, as he'd find out that the worst place to fall from in WWE was the very top.

Advertisement

Returning to television in February 2013 after a hiatus, a more intense Swagger ripped through the midcard, demanding placement in the upcoming Elimination Chamber pay-per-view main event, which would determine who would go to WrestleMania to face defending babyface champion Alberto Del Rio.

Swagger was accompanied by Zeb Colter, in a shocking on-screen return for Dutch Mantell. The two parroted the views of the hard-right Tea Party Movement, with the pair portraying ultra-conservative worrywarts particularly zoning in on immigration as a reason for their discontent.

This played in neatly with Del Rio as champion, and when Swagger surprisingly won the Elimination Chamber, the match was set for the 'Show of Shows'.

WWE aren't all to blame for Jack's eventual defeat in the half-hearted encounter at WrestleMania 29, but their follow-up booking didn't help. Swagger was arrested for driving under the influence and drug possession just weeks before his title shot, which soured management on his likely victory, and undoubtedly skewed their thinking as he lost countless rematches in the aftermath.

1. World Heavyweight Champion

Snaring the Money In The Bank briefcase in a jarring upset at WrestleMania 26, Swagger wouldn't hang around, shockingly cashing in on Chris Jericho four days later on Smackdown to claim his first and only World Title.

Advertisement

It was something nobody could have foreseen, but the hope was that as a newcomer to the fold, Swagger would shine with the title, and an instant main eventer would emerge from the run.

Confusingly though, rather than allowing 'The All American American' to portray the character that had gotten over with crowds enough to give management the backbone to gamble on him in the first place, WWE stripped virtually everything away.

Requesting that Swagger portray a no-nonsense brooding bully, gone was the enthusiastic chest-pounding and press-ups in his entrance and obnoxious grins and growls in his promos. Worst of all, it was replaced with nothing.

Swagger wasn't yet the performer to portray that sort of nuanced character, and by the time gave him back all his necessary tools, the run had lost all steam.

Dropping the title to Rey Mysterio at June's Fatal 4-Way pay-per-view, Swagger was abruptly shunted back down the card after his obligatory rematches, then confusingly allowed to play the old version of himself all over again.

Advertisement