7 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE Raw (9 Sept - Results & Review)
Wyatt Sick6 ride high, Jey Uso main events, Hitman returns, Punk/Drew III booked.
Start strong, finish strong. That’s a mantra that works well in sports, and it’s also true for wrestling programs. Monday Night Raw this week was no exception to that rule.
Raw kicked off with a tremendously fun, chaotic eight-person brawl as the Wyatt Sick6 and American Made concluded their rivalry in a street fight, then finished with a frenetic four-way to earn a shot at the Intercontinental Championship.
Everything between those two matches, however, was either pretty good, decent, or meh. The Calgary faithful had a couple of really nice hometown hero moments, though one of them felt a bit underwhelming considering the magnitude of the appearance and what could have been. Bron Breakker and the Judgment Day had good nights, with the IC champ flexing his muscles and making his presence known throughout the program. The women’s tag title match was a marked improvement from previous efforts, but it still underperformed.
Overall, Raw managed to hit a few really high notes, deliver some decent supporting segments, and avoid any truly dismal moments. Throw in a better second effort from new Raw play-by-play man Joe Tessitore (whose debut last week was solid, if unspectacular) and you have the makings of a pretty decent show: not blow-away great, but an enjoyable watch.
Let’s get to it…
Downs…
3. Background Stupidity
They were only onscreen for about 15 seconds Monday night, but Alpha Academy could not have looked more ridiculous if they tried.
Drew McIntyre was walking backstage when he happened by Otis, Maxxine Dupri, and Akira Tozawa, who were inexplicably fawning over a WWE Legacy title for the Calgary Flames, held perfectly so the camera could catch it as McIntyre walked by. Otis made a goofy face as Tozawa did the same, and Drew just shook his head and kept walking, looking like he couldn’t believe these goobers exist in the same universe as he does.
For Alpha Academy, the trio just had a really good showing in the six-person tag match last week against American Made, and they had rightly earned praise as being more than just a cannon-fodder comedy act.
Seven days later, they were right back to looking like jokes, hocking WWE merchandise in the most embarrassing manner during the show. At least when New Day would plug merchandise, it either would take place as an obvious commercial, or it would be done tongue-in-cheek, with a wink at the camera that they’re making money selling items.
2. Perfect Booking, Or Trope Booking For Legends?
The announcement that Bret Hart would appear on this week’s Raw, emanating from Calgary, sent fans into speculation mode about how the Hitman would be utilized on the WWE show he helped make famous.
In the end, Hart ended up partaking in a time-honored WWE tradition of bringing out a legend to a massive pop, then immediately having current superstars overshadow them and talk as if they weren’t even in the ring for much of the segment.
Monday night, this involved Gunther coming out and feigning praise for the Hitman before delivering a killer line that Bret was “a close second” to his favorite wrestler of all time: Bill Goldberg. This drew out fellow Canadian Sami Zayn to defend Hart and to try to goad Gunther into a World Heavyweight Championship match.
To his credit, Bret got to get involved a bit more when Gunther declined and left, calling the champion a coward, which clearly got under the Ring General’s skin, triggering a brawl with Sami. But overall, this was pretty average for a Bret Hart appearance, his first since Clash at the Castle in 2022, which is disappointing. Perhaps this would have felt a bit more meaningful if they had leaned on Bret and Sami’s previous interactions - Hart introduced Zayn for his first Raw match several years ago - or had them build rapport before Gunther came out.
As it turned out, Gunther and Sami could have delivered the same promos without Bret there, talking about the Hitman in the abstract, and it would have mostly worked. Bret fans should be ecstatic to see the Hitman in Calgary – and the home of Canadian Stampede – one more time, but beyond that, he felt like more of a plot device than one of the biggest stars in wrestling history.
1. Better, But…
The Women’s Tag Team Championship match easily was the weakest link on the Bash in Berlin card last month, so Monday night’s rematch didn’t exactly have a high bar to clear.
Still, the match once again felt like it was a paint-by-numbers performance, moving from one segment or series of moves to another. It almost looked like things were going to completely fall off the rails seconds into the match when Bianca Belair and Alba Fyre had a pretty noticeable miscommunication in the middle of the ring, leading to them standing there for what seemed like an eternity, but they managed to get back on track.
Jade Cargill selling a leg “injury” after having the limb worked over for all of 20 seconds was almost laughable. If you’re going to ask a She-Hulk like Jade to have to sell, have the heels really work her over with a Dragon Screw and series of chop blocks, not a couple of kicks at the knee.
Call this an improvement from last Saturday, but still below what one should expect from the largest wrestling company in the world with the best talent signed and a “world-class” Performance Center.
Ups…
7. A Nice Hometown Moment
WWE under Vince McMahon conditioned fans to never expect a truly good, positive moment involving its hometown heroes. If a wrestler was billed from the town where a show emanated, fans grew to expect they’d at best lose or at worst be humiliated.
Since Triple H took the reins, WWE has played into these hometown connections more than ever before, giving fans reason to get excited about seeing their local heroes in action. Alba Fyre and Isla Dawn captured the Women’s Tag Team Championships at Clash at the Castle in their home country of Scotland earlier this summer, for example. Gunther defended his World Heavyweight Championship in Germany (where he now resides) at Bash in Berlin.
With Raw stationed in Calgary, Alberta, Canada Monday night, there was only one person who could be the mystery partner for Zelina Vega and Lyra Valkyria against Pure Fusion Collective: Natalya. Thankfully, WWE didn’t book Nattie to fall victim to a distraction rollup or something silly like that. Instead, Natalya slapped on a Sharpshooter and got the submission victory, giving herself, the fans, and Vega and Valkyria a happy moment by silencing PFC for at least one week.
6. Dominik Steals Another One
The running gag that Domnik Mysterio is out of his league in the ring has long since run its course, and yet he still continues to have matches that fire up fans, with Monday’s contest against Dragon Lee being another loud affair.
Mysterio has improved in the ring, and being in there with someone as skilled as Dragon Lee certainly helped. But Dominik also has gotten good at playing to the fans, egging them on as they chanted for him to shave his mullet, posing whenever possible, and blowing kisses to Liv Morgan after she chop-blocked Dragon Lee, allowing Mysterio to get the win.
It’s frustrating to see someone as insanely talented as Lee lose yet another TV match, but the Mysterio-Morgan connection has played out really well, with Liv paying dividends in Dominik’s ongoing feud with his father and Rey’s chosen luchador successor.
One last note: the open question of why Zelina Vega didn’t accompany the LWO to ringside to counter Morgan was quickly answered moments later when her six-woman tag match began in the next segment. She clearly was backstage preparing for her tag match and couldn’t be ringside with her cohorts.
5. Bron Makes The Rounds
I want and need to see a Bron Breakker vs. Braun Strowman match at some point.
No bread. No water. Just MEAAATTTT. ? #WWERaw pic.twitter.com/yuMa5ZTrOg
Advertisement— PW Chronicle (@_PWChronicle) September 10, 2024
In recent weeks, WWE was pretty blatantly signposting that Jey Uso would be Bron Breakker’s next challenger for the Intercontinental Championship. That’s not necessarily a bad thing, but when you have a 12-man tournament ongoing, it’s not the best idea.
Monday night, Breakker spent Raw going around backstage approaching each of the other three wrestlers competing for the number one contender’s spot. He bantered with each of them, establishing himself as the alpha and taking shots at each man in the event that they won the four-way later that evening.
In doing so, Bron made you want to see him battle Braun Strowman, Pete Dunne or Ilja Dragunov, even though Uso still was the obvious route. And by being omnipresent on Raw, it made Breakker feel even more important, a central figure on this show, with the IC title being a focal point throughout the evening, right up through the main event and to the closing shot of the program.
4. Balor Makes His Case
It’s been said that a heel character works best when they not only believe what they’re saying, but their reasons for doing dastardly things are believable as well.
Take Finn Balor and the rest of the new Judgment Day. The group excommunicated Damian Priest and Rhea Ripley because they were acting like the leaders of the group, bossing the rest of the crew around and taking them for granted. Obviously, there were reasons for that, but there was some truth to all of it.
Monday, Balor tacked onto his case against Priest, recounting how he helped Damian retain his World Heavyweight Championship on multiple occasions, but Finn should have been world champion himself even sooner… if not for Priest. And there’s a good amount of truth in this, dating back to Balor’s rivalry with Seth Rollins last year, where he lost two World Heavyweight Championship matches in part due to Priest wielding his Money in the Bank briefcase.
Finn made his argument to Priest, which then gave way to a Judgment Day beatdown on Damian, and then on Rhea when she tried to make the save, leaving the Terror Twins laid out before Jey Uso could intervene.
Tying in that year-old grudge was a smart move, giving Finn some justification for his actions and their feud a bit more depth. The Judgment Day assault was a reminder of how they operate and to put the Terror Twins on the defensive, which is probably the best play for the undersized Morgan and Balor.
3. Hell In A Cell Confirmed
After Drew McIntyre demolished CM Punk last week and sent him off bloodied on a stretcher to a hospital, the odds there would be a face-to-face follow-up this week hovered right around “nil”.
But a smug McIntyre managed to focus his aggression on an unlikely target Monday night: one of his best friends, Wade Barrett. Drew preened about how he was justified in attacking Punk last week because the Second City Saint had boasted that he was done with McIntyre after winning one match by touching four corners and thought he was entitled to challenge for the world title.
With Punk still on the sidelines, McIntyre then turned his attention to Barrett, threatening to drop him if the announcer ever tried to interfere in his business again. Drew has now sunk to the depths of alienating everyone around him because he is so completely consumed with destroying Punk.
But have no fear, Raw GM Adam Pearce turned up to refocus Drew and inform him that their little feud would continue… for one more match. He announced the expected Hell in a Cell for Bad Blood, which now feels earned given the progression of the rivalry and where things stand right now with a battered Punk out of action and a smug McIntyre wanting to move on.
If the strap match and beating last week are any indication, this cell match should be the high point of the feud.
2. Four-Way Closes Strong
WWE multi-man matches have a controlled chaos formula that tends to work pretty well when the wrestlers are synced up and on their game. Raw’s main event was a great example of the pieces falling right into place.
Braun Strowman, Jey Uso, Pete Dunne and Ilja Dragunov put on a highly entertaining match, trading off and unloading on each other in every permutation of the foursome. Being the biggest physical threat, Braun dominated sections of the match using his brute strength, and then was targeted by the other three to knock him out of the match for a large portion. Jey, Dunne, and Ilja brought their best, battling each other but failing to get the upper hand.
The finishing sequence was pretty good as well, with Bronson Reed returning to flatten Strowman with a Tsunami through the announce desk. Dragunov countered a Bitter End and landed an H-Bomb, but Uso broke up the pin with a superkick and delivered a splash to Dunne to earn his Intercontinental Championship match.
Hard work from everyone and a solid closing to the show. Jey versus Bron Breakker should be a good match, particularly if Uso keeps himself serious and doesn’t play to the “Yeet” chants too much.
1. A Chaotic Conclusion To The Feud
Regardless of your preferences, the Wyatt Sick6 has been an objective success on Raw so far. They’ve overcome a debut that could have pigeonholed them, outlasted what might have been termed “polite applause” due to the Bray Wyatt tragedy, and delivered in the ring multiple times.
Monday, the Wyatts had another really good night in the ring, tangling with American Made in an eight-person street fight that saw all types of plunder brought into the mix. Erick Rowan got to play the role of a hulking big man (who else can rip apart the barricade and use it as a weapon?) while Joe Gacy and Dexter Lumis flew around the ring and ate some rough shots from the Creed Brothers and Chad Gable. Nikki Cross and Ivy Nile had their own little battles, but they managed to mix it up with the men a few times, including Cross German-suplexing Gable.
The craziness finally ended with Lumis pinning Gable to effectively end their months-long feud. One small, nitpicking negative though: although anything goes in a street fight, Uncle Howdy had to get involved to give the Wyatts the edge, despite the group being the babyfaces and Gable’s crew not doing anything more egregious than their opponents.
For American Made, it’s an opportunity to turn the page and become a serious heel stable, knowing they did their best to make the Wyatts look great at every turn. For the Wyatt Sick6, this is where the real test will begin. How will they function within the normal WWE world? Or will they? Will they instead pull other acts into their vortex separate from the Raw universe? Can anyone see Howdy just chatting backstage with Sheamus? This will be an interesting test going forward.