8 Best Options For Dethroning Samoa Joe As NXT Champion
Who will follow in the footsteps of Joe, Balor, Owens, Zayn et al?
It is one of the weird quirks of modern professional wrestling, but whenever an individual wins a championship thoughts immediately turn to who will defeat them. We may not like it, but it is true. When Zack Ryder won the Intercontinental Championship at WrestleMania 32 and the dust had cleared on appreciating the moment, the next question to be asked was 'who will beat him?'
Sometimes, it is easy to imagine a plethora of individuals dethroning the incumbent champion. Well, NXT is not such a place right now. The two singles champions on the show are almost the dictionary definition of wrestling dominance. Asuka hasn't lost since arriving in NXT at the end of last year and, with the exception of Bayley, it is difficult to imagine anyone coming close to her, let alone beating her.
The current NXT Champion is Samoa Joe, and he is equally dominant. Sure, he has tasted defeat a couple of times, but with his defeat of Finn Balor at TakeOver: The End, he has built a new aura of invincibility around him. Samoa Joe has been a dominant champion in the past, and Samoa Joe could be about to become a dominant champion once more.
Still, someone has to beat him for the title, right? He can't hold it until the day he dies can he? Of course not, and here are the eight men that could eventually vanquish Joe.
8. Tye Dillinger
News coming out of the latest set of NXT tapings suggests that the company aren't planning on running with him any time soon, but the unexpected popularity of Tye Dillinger could be an avenue for NXT to explore in the future. Dillinger has slipped into the 'lose to new stars in their debut match' role, but the love afforded to him at TakeOver: The End... suggests that role may no longer be the best option for the brand.
The NXT audience loves Dillinger. His entire character revolves around his love of the number 10, and that seems to be enough for the Full Sail faithful. It is incredibly simple to get behind after all, and Dillinger really gives his all to the gimmick. He has also spent a huge amount of time in WWE developmental, being a part of OVW and FCW between 2006 and 2009 before returning to NXT in 2013.
It would take a bit of work when it comes to rehabilitation, but you are pretty much guaranteeing a huge moment if Tye Dillinger eventually becomes the man to defeat Samoa Joe for the NXT Championship. The very thought of the vignettes in the build-up are enough to excite.
Heck, why not have Tye Dillinger win the NXT Championship in a Last Man Standing match. Imagine the crowd as the referee gets closer to that magical number 10? It would be a thing of beauty.
7. Bo Dallas
Not the most obvious choice on the planet, but stranger things have happened. Dallas was the 3rd ever NXT Champion, defeating Big E. Langston for the prize thanks to an exposed turnbuckle and his unwavering BOlief. Dallas was champion for an age, before dropping the strap to Neville in a ladder match at NXT arRIVAL.
Dallas commands a certain amount of love down in Full Sail, and Dallas finding an underhand way to defeat Joe would go down much better in NXT than on the main roster. If anything, Dallas cheating his way back to the top of the NXT mountain would not only be a good story to tell over the autumn and winter, but it would also provide Samoa Joe with a way out of the brand.
The brand split suggests that NXT could slowly come to resemble developmental once again, and this is definitely a good thing. In order for the new generation of NXT superstars to succeed, they may very well need to BOlieve.
It never gets old.
6. Andrade 'Cien' Almos
It has come as a big surprise to many that the former La Sombra isn't taking part in the WWE Cruiserweight Classic, as many felt that the tournament itself was to act as the launching pad for the now-rechristened Andrade 'Cien' Almos in WWE and NXT. The full list of CWC competitors has been announced, but Almos is nowhere to be seen.
So with that avenue forgotten, it seems that NXT proper is going to be where Almos establishes himself for the time being. He made his debut at TakeOver: The End... by defeating Tye Dillinger, and although the crowd was fairly split (thanks in no small part to their love for The Perfect 10) Almos' ability more than won them over.
Andrade Almos is simply too good at this whole professional wrestling thing to be missing from any discussion when it comes to the NXT Championship. Whether as a face or a heel, he'll find himself in and around the top of the mountain sooner rather than later.
5. Bobby Roode
It is still somewhat unclear what Bobby Roode's role in NXT is going to be. He'll obviously get that respected star babyface reception when he arrives in Full Sail, but will he continue as a good guy or settle into a role as a top heel on the program? For now we can only speculate, but this writer believes that the latter is by far the best option NXT could make.
Whichever way he goes, Roode is a hyper-credible professional wrestler who has finally arrived in World Wrestling Entertainment, and is likely to be treated as a big deal. It is extremely easy to imagine Roode on top of NXT, adding that championship to the many he won in TNA throughout his 12 years there.
As with a few other top NXT stars, the only thing that will stop this happening is if he is shipped up to the main roster quick smart once RAW and SmackDown go their separate ways.
4. Zack Ryder
Now now, stop sniggering in the back. You have read that title correctly, and yes I do believe Zack Ryder could be the man to defeat Samoa Joe for the NXT Championship. When Ryder was put into the multi-man Intercontinental Championship ladder match at WrestleMania 32, a number of people felt that the ladder had a better chance of winning than Long Island Iced Z.
Well, look how that ended up...
World Wrestling Entertainment loves itself a redemption story. Heck, fiction in general loves the trope. An individual, seemingly down and out, works his way slowly to the top of the mountain, overcoming insurmountable odds and challenges along the way. All of which leads to our hero overcoming his biggest challenge, and finding himself held aloft by his peers.
With the brand split coming, NXT is going to change completely. Someone like Zack Ryder could be perfect as a credible champion of the brand as Performance Center graduates come to work with more experienced heads. Give him that moment, a Rough Ryder to Samoa Joe and an unthinkable victory.
Then have him and Emma turn heel and rule NXT with an Iron Fist.
Woo. Woo. Woo.
3. Shinsuke Nakamura
I feel as though it is somewhat superfluous to attempt to write down a convincing argument as to why Shinsuke Nakamura is a potential option for beating Samoa Joe for the NXT Championship.
Surely the only reasoning required is the fact that he is Shinsuke Nakamura? The King of Strong Style has been the hit of all hits since arriving at NXT TakeOver: Dallas, and the man inspires utter devotion from crowds just by waving his arms in a funny way through his entrance.
Nakamura defeated Austin Aries at TakeOver: The End... to become the de factor #1 contender to the NXT Championship. At this point, the only thing that stops Nakamura winning the strap is being called up to the main roster ahead of the brand split. If Nakamura is still a full-time NXT wrestler come winter, then Shinsuke Nakamura will be (or will have been) the NXT Champion.
He won't be a full-time NXT wrestler come the winter.
2. Hideo Itami
Is Hideo Itami ever going to return from injury? It really feels as though the man has been away for a lifetime. A shoulder injury kept him out of a #1 Contender match at NXT TakeOver: Unstoppable in May 2015, and that was the last we got of him. He may have been the man to dethrone Kevin Owens at the WWE Beast in the East show last summer, but that never came to pass.
In the time he has been away, stars have come and stars have gone. Itami's presence and spotlight has dwindled to not too much, meaning that when (if?) he does eventually return it'll be touch and go whether he is embraced as a returning hero or with mild indifference.
A man of Itami's ability is going to succeed either way, and if the reaction is closer to the former than the latter he could very well be the man to take the NXT Championship away from Samoa Joe. What a return it could yet be.
1. Austin Aries
This is where I see NXT going, and probably sooner rather than later. Austin Aries came into the company at the beginning of the year with a certain amount of fanfare, which quickly became somewhat forgotten when Nakamura turned up. Like a quietly confident jilted lover Aries took this in his stride, but his battle with Nakamura at TakeOver: The End... has set him on a path that should lead to a fully-fledged heel turn.
Samoa Joe is being built as a monster champion, and his showdown with Nakamura is inevitable. What better heel move could be pulled than Aries worming his way into the match, and stealing a pin-fall on a recently Kinshasha'd Joe? Once Aries receives the green light to fully turn heel, we'll start to see the true ability of the man.
Throughout his career, Austin Aries has won a number of major world championships. Aries is unique however, in that he has done this without ever truly being the number one guy in a company, a top level credible champion for bigger stars to work off. This is exactly the role that Aries needs to play in NXT, and exactly the role he will play.