8 Big Questions About Vince McMahon's XFL Reboot!
Besides simply 'why?'
Just about the last thing any wrestling fan in the world expected to be reading about at the close of 2017, besides perhaps a sensational WWE Universal Title victory for a returning, guitar-swinging Jeff Jarrett, was the revival of the XFL. WWE's attempt to bring Amiga classic Brutal Sports Football to life 16 years ago was, in the words of Vince McMahon himself, a "colossal failure". The thought of it coming back this year seemed as likely as a revival of Nazism. Oh.
WWE's turn as Pete Becker cost them dear. After conquering the wrestling world, they utterly failed to conquer the football world; the ridiculous league closed after just a single season, injuring dozens of budding footballers on its way to boring as many fans as possible. $35 million of that new-found monopoly money went down the tube, with most agreeing never to talk about it again.
Then in January of this year, ESPN broke the silence, running a '30 for 30' feature on the doomed venture. Towards the end of the doc, Vince McMahon grew thick with nostalgia, shockingly claiming he'd someday like to revisit the league. And here we are: it's a realistic possibility.
The biggest question is simply "why". But if this does become a thing, there are a few more which need answering. Like, "no really, why?"
8. Will There Be WWE Crossover?
Part of WWE's plan to boost the XFL's appeal was to have several notable names from their wrestling product cross over from the squared-circle to the, er, rectangled-rectangle. The likes of Jerry Lawler, Jesse Ventura, and Jim Ross - seen here having just the time of his life in a dazzling silver stetson - all put the headset on to provide raucous commentary on the ostensible 'action'. If football fans didn't like it, at least wrestling fans would - and there were a lot of them in 2001.
16 years later, WWE isn't quite so in vogue. Would a rebooted XFL benefit from, for example, Byron Saxton calling the action? (Does anything?) To be a success in 2018, it's entirely possible a new football league would have to be as far removed from the company's primary output as possible. Too bad, Mojo Rawley.
7. A New Set Of Teams?
The Fermi paradox stipulates that, just like there's almost certainly someone out there whose favourite wrestler is Big Josh, so too must there be XFL nostalgics. Unlikely as it sounds, there's probably a small group of devoted folk suffering saudade for the loss of such illustrious teams as the Birmingham Thunderbolts or New York/New Jersey Hitmen. News of the league's possible comeback must have their IRC channel pinging like Jan Owe Waldner.
There's just one problem: the team names are dreadful. And in the case of the Memphis Maniax, borderline offensive.
Though few people gave two sh*ts about the XFL, Michael M. Faenza, president of the National Mental Health Association, was not best pleased with the Tennessee team's monikor. "The name and logo is demeaning to the 54 million Americans who are affected by mental illness each year," he observed, and with good reason. Just look at it.
In 2001, we were still a long way from mental health advocacy being taken seriously by the general public. A lot has changed since then. Perhaps the other teams can stay, but Memphis will need a new alliteration, something less degrading. Plus, the logo was pretty crap.
6. Will It Ditch The Cheerleaders?
The XFL didn't actually mean anything, but you can be fairly sure the 'X' was implied to stand for 'Xtreme (!)'. With the exception of buying underwear, it pretty much always does (and even that depends on your predilections).
Products bearing the word 'xtreme' - sans 'e' - rarely ooze class. The XFL didn't buck this trend, with its target demographic firmly in the 'manly man' bracket. And there's only one thing 'manly men' (supposedly) like, besides fast cars and beer.
So the XFL gave it to them. As far as risqué dance routines go, they were more Sky Strikers than Red Light Cabaret, but their sole purpose was plainly clear.
In 2018, hoying a gang of scantily clad women on the field for no other reason than titillating horny guys won't cut it. Sure, NFL has them, but NFL doesn't have a historic reputation for treating women like objects to be ogled. Sexy cheerleaders were a key selling point of the XFL, so it's a bit of a pickle whether to bring them back or not.
5. Will It Feature The Same Rules?
For a Brit, the rules of American Football are bafflingly and prohibitively complex, unlike say, cricket, a simple game of outdoor jenga involving a wooden ball and a break for tea followed by players getting the runs (that's what happens when sandwiches are left out in the heat). The XFL offered a solution: a 'rules-light' version of gridiron which would encourage fast and exciting play (rugby, in other words).
There's a cliché about plans which name drops the title of a popular Steinback novel. Such was the case here. The XFL changed numerous existing rules which, quite aside from making the game tastier, simply made it more dangerous - resulting in more stoppages. Defenders could make contact with receivers at any point. They were granted greater leniency when coming up against QBs. Full bump and run coverage was permitted. It was all a bit mad.
The latter was changed after just the fourth week when it was found to be terrible. As indeed, were a number of other rules - including the 'no ties allowed' stipulation, altered to prevent games overrunning into Saturday Night Live. It was clear the XFL was making it up as it went along, less a sport than an evolving television concept.
It was certainly revolutionary - but it wasn't good. A relaunch would require a serious think about its codex; it needs to be distinct from the NFL, but can't possibility feature the same ill-conceived rulebook as the failed first attempt. After all, who would risk their career playing in it?
4. Will It Be As Violent?
One of the XFL's big selling points - and a major factor in altering the rules in ways described earlier - was that it was super violent, a sort of hybrid between professional football and professional wrestling - but minus the phony outcomes. Promotional material for the nascent league boasted that players would "eat dirt" and be "slammed into the wall" - pretty strong stuff, the sort of angry rhetoric you'd expect from a top heel's promo rather than adverts for a sport.
It was a little distasteful then, but it'd be positively repugnant today in light of what we now know about NFL-related chronic traumatic encephalopathy. Whether Vince and co. care about that or not is another matter; Baron Corbin's recent fallout with company doctor Joseph Maroon over his downplaying of the JAMA study into CTE suggests otherwise.
Even if the company are in willfull denial over the effects of football-related concussions, another season blighted by constant injuries can't be in their purview. But again, altering this facet of the league would be to undermine one of its only real USPs.
3. A New Name?
When it comes to branding, Juliet's famous speech on the irrelevance of a name simply doesn't apply. Just as christening a nursery in Jimmy Savile's honour is a terrible idea, so too is relaunching a football league under a banner bearing the stench of failure. XFL was an unmitigated disaster; it's basically what it's remembered for. Trying to revive a product universally known for its terribleness is a preposterous idea from the get go. At the very least, change the name.
As mentioned previously, time nurtures nostalgia, misplaced or otherwise. Perhaps there's an ironic yearning for the XFL brand these days? An entirely redeveloped league with the same title could just work - and don't think for a second Vince won't be desperate to clear up this enormous blemish on his record - though reports of an alleged 'United Football League' trademark seem to point to other plans. UFL's a good idea, but will it'll always be shorthand for 'XFL2'.
2. Does It Have A TV Deal Already?
What possible reason could Vince McMahon have for entertaining the idea of fishing the XFL out of his attic of failed concepts and dusting it off for another go-around, beyond the obvious one regarding his senses on a one-way trip to the moon? Both his company and NBC reportedly lost $35m of their joint $100m investment in 2001, so it seems positively bananas, heck, positively pineapples to try to bring it back.
This seems to be the way we're headed, which rather suggests McMahon already has something in place for it, such as a lucrative, ad-revenue generating TV deal. Why else would the WWE honcho think the concept is viable? NFL ratings are down, and a gap is opening, but you don't become a billionaire making risky gambles on a hunch. Someone in WWE somewhere must be good with numbers (Tye Dillinger, perhaps), as there's no way the company would openly acknowledge the rumours, affecting their stock in the process, if they didn't have a sense of surety that it won't immediately eat into their capital.
Another suggestion is that it could be original content for the Network, but that plan is almost as barmy as reviving the XFL in the first place. So... maybe.
1. Can It Possibly Succeed?
American football is in decline. The ratings are down, the national anthem protests have blighted it with racial division, and the recent JAMA study has made clearer than ever that it's basically a glorified bloodsport. The NFL as we know it needs to change, and pronto, if it's to survive much further into the current century. A bloodier, more brutal variation just doesn't fly in 2018.
Even if the XFL was watered down to a PG-friendly UFL, as is more likely, it would still struggle to shake the stigma of being devised by a fixer of fake fights. As far as the vast majority of the general populace is concerned, wrestling has been a tawdry irrelevance since the golden era. An ignorant opinion, yes, but it's widespread, and one which delegitimises pretty much any outside venture Vince attempts from the get-go. WWE Studios, The World, even Linda's senate campaign - all suffered for their association with the squared circle.
In his desperation to prove to the world he is more than just a wrestling promoter, so often McMahon ends up drawing attention to the fact its his sole area of success. Those failures rack up, to the point he has a reputation for it. Given the circumstances are even less conducive to a new football league than they were 16 years ago, could an XFL reboot really prosper? A ball is yet to be kicked, but it has to be an emphatic "no".