Now that this season of Tough enough has drawn to a close and the winners have been chosen its time to take a critical look at the show and evaluate what changes could be made to improve it for future seasons. As a concept, Tough Enough is a good enough idea and when it initially aired on MTV it was an interesting show that gave viewers a small glimpse of the hard work and sacrifice it takes to become a WWE performer. The show has now existed through several different channels and variations and this past season was possibly the least entertaining of them all. The mix between the taped and live formats took a while for WWE to adjust to, and it often felt like there was too much going on. There were even several production errors like having contestants in the bottom three make their final pleas after voting had already closed. In order to truly get the most out of Tough Enough, WWE has to decide if its more valuable to them as a TV show designed to attract and entertain viewers, or as a vehicle with the intent to discover and create the next wave of WWE superstars. Either way, there are some definite improvements that could be made to tighten up the show as a whole. Let's talk about them
8. Lose The Non-Wrestling Related Challenges
This season like the ones before it featured an abundance of athletic challenges that had absolutely nothing to do with professional wrestling. This may appeal to the viewers who arent wrestling fans, but ratings numbers would suggest that there arent too many of those actually watching Tough Enough. Theres no reason the audience needs to see these contestants swim through creeks or pretend to be firemen. You can toss out the platitudes about learning to work together and performing under extreme pressure and call these what they are; run-of-the-mill reality competition show stunts that weve all seen hundreds of times on other shows. They add nothing to the proceedings and dont help us determine who might become the next WWE superstar. Going forward, every challenge that the competitors face should be strictly wrestling-based. The promo battles and the like are fine, but if you want to hook more wrestling fans stop with the pointless games and get back to basics.
7. Bring Back Stone Cold
This isn't meant as a knock against Chris Jericho. In fact, he did a fine job as the host of the live portion of Tough Enough. Alongside Renee Young, Jericho would use his unique charisma to ask questions and hold the microphone while people answered them. It's a job that needed doing and Chris Jericho was good at it. But, come on, we all miss Steve Austin. Apparently the reason he wasn't on this season was due to scheduling conflicts, and if that's the case it's in WWE's best interests to work around his schedule before beginning the next installment. The best thing about the prior season was Stone Cold's tough, no bullsh*t demeanor. His incredulous reactions at some of the actions of the contestants were awesome, and we'll never forget his mystified response to Cameron naming Melina vs. Alicia Fox as her favorite match of all-time. As a wrestling fan himself, Austin was personally offended. Bring him back as host, make him one of the judges - you could easily replace Daniel Bryan since he was so soft-spoken and uninvolved - or just have him show up and talk sh*t while reaming people out over sucking at some aspect of wrestling. Just bring back Stone Cold in some capacity, OK?
6. Make Fans Part Of The Casting
For those who've seen it you'll likely agree that the WWE Network-exclusive Tough Enough casting special was the best part of this past season. Seeing hundreds of people spend the weekend running drills and facing eliminations, all while the cameras rolled so we could watch them break, flake out or have their dreams ripped away until there were only the finalists remaining was undeniably compelling TV. Who can forget the emotional plight of U.S. veteran Mike Hayes trying to will himself to overcome the handicap of a prosthetic leg, only to fall short and have to exit the competition because his body couldn't keep up with his heart? We need more of that. Those chosen to make it into the barracks were hand-picked by WWE, and while some of their choices seemed a bit questionable they obviously had their reasons. If you're going to put the power to grant people contracts with your company (worth a quarter of a million dollars) into the hands of your fans, how about going all the way and let the fans choose who makes it to the show? Since the casting special was so great, do another one of those but this time make it a two-parter. Again, you keep it on the Network, and after the first special airs those who subscribe to the Network are given a special code in an email to vote for who they think should make it onto the show. Then the following week on another exclusive special you announce the winners. This works positively in two different areas: you allow your fans to choose the people they are most interested in watching therefore hopefully ensuring that they'll follow along as the season progresses, and you give another perk to the customers who subscribe to the Network. Win-win.
5. Open The Voting Earlier
One of the problems this season struggled with was the voting process. The opportunity to vote your favourite on to the next week didn't occur until just moments before the show went off the air, and there were even instances when the contestants facing elimination were asked to plead for their futures AFTER voting had already closed. If you want more people to be able to participate you need to open the voting much earlier in the show. Take a cue from The Voice, which is one of the biggest shows in the world and give people a reason to vote. WWE employs some of the best video package people in the business and we should be getting these on each person in danger of being booted with highlights from their past accomplishments to remind us if we should or shouldn't vote for them.
4. Add Guest Judges
Let's be real here. From a judging standpoint, Hulk Hogan brought absolutely nothing to the show other than his name value, and the same can nearly be said - although to a much lesser extent - of Daniel Bryan. In Hogan's case, he can't stop thinking about himself long enough to properly critique anything anyone else does. And Daniel Bryan's issue is that he's just too nice of a guy to be put into that position, where harsh judgements are often necessary. Paige was pretty great at times but could border on overly-abrasive and sometimes seemed like she had a chip on her shoulder that was weighing her down. The Miz was The Miz, but he has so much charisma that he can get away with it. Plus he brings the added element of having been there and done that. With all the talent on the WWE roster, from current workers to legends, there's no reason we can't get a revolving door of guest judges. It's promo week? Here's guest judge Jake Roberts. This week's challenge was all about selling? The Heartbreak Kid joins the panel. There's so many ways you could go and it would add intrigue tuning in each week to see who would join the other judges.
3. Put Them On The Road
These men and women really don't have any idea what they're in for if they actually make it into the WWE. The grind of the travel, being away from your family 300-plus days a year, the demands of the public, the wear and tear on your body and the politics of the environment are all incredibly taxing. Living in a "barrack" is not. Sure they were put through some grueling workouts, but nothing remotely resembling what a wrestler's life is like. A great idea would be to take each contestant and assign them to their own WWE superstar for a week, where they have to spend the entire seven days shadowing their companion. Stay in the same hotels, ride in the same car, eat at the same restaurants, in and out of bed at the same times. If their wrestler hits the gym at 6:00 AM for a workout before doing a three hour press junket and then catches a flight to the next town for a live event, they have to tag along. Not only will this somewhat prepare them for life in the WWE machine, but it's a safe bet it would make for some great TV. Breaches of etiquette would occur left and right and there's a good chance some of these pairings wouldn't get along at all. Imagine a gym freak like John Cena or Cesaro having to deal with ZZ not wanting to work out?
2. Put The Contestants With NXT
In saying this we don't mean have them train in private at the performance center while guys like Jason Jordan come in and take bumps for them. No, actually put them in the locker room with the men and women that will be their peers should they win the contract. The Tough Enough winners were awarded contracts for $250,000. The details of those deals have been kept close to the vest and there's probably some fine print there, but by all reports that's considerably more than the NXT wrestlers are making, all of whom are obviously more experienced, some having been in the business a decade or longer. How do you reconcile that with your current contracted talent? You can't, really, so you do the next best thing: feed them to the lions. You want to make it to WWE - Tough Enough winner or not - you're going to have to do so through NXT. Coming in green as grass while banking a bigger paycheck is going to earn the winners some resentment, so get that on camera. The NXT talent have scratched and clawed to get to where they are, and some of them will never set foot inside a WWE ring. We want to feel their resentment through our TV screens, and more importantly see how the Tough Enough rookies adapt to it. Will they handle it with grace or crumble under the stress?
1. Give Us A Reason To Care
As mentioned earlier, the team that produces WWE's video packages are the best in the industry. They can take any mundane storyline and with the right music and clip selection get us wholly invested. Did anyone care about the John Cena/Bray Wyatt match before the "My Legacy" video came out? WWE had these contestants who presumably have lives and families outside of this show, but outside of a few phone calls or mentions we rarely got a glimpse of that aspect. Once the number of remaining contenders has been whittled down somewhat, start showing us who these people are. If my vote is going to earn someone a quarter of a million dollars, I want to know as much as possible about the life that I'm supposedly changing for the better. These are just a few ideas to make Tough Enough the success it could be. Do you have any ideas of your own? Share them in the comments.