8 Reasons WWE Is Wrong To Ditch Single-Brand PPVs
Is the company rolling back the brand split already?
It has been less than two years since WWE reinstated the brand split in July 2016, dividing its enormous roster in half and making its superstars exclusive to either Raw or SmackDown Live! This was an exciting move for fans who were nostalgic for the previous divided days of the noughties, brought about by WWE's acquisition of WCW and the subsequently enlarged roster.
The current brand split has faced criticism from fans for the sheer number of pay-per-view events on offer. There have been periods of time where there have been PPV shows every fortnight. In 2017, WWE put on 16 big shows, equivalent to almost one every three weeks, with only four of them featuring performers from both brands. Fans were fatigued and, as a result, the company announced a lighter schedule of PPV shows. The company has now added that all of these shows will be dual-branded, starting after WrestleMania, featuring performers from Mondays and Tuesdays.
The move to dual-branded events marked the first nail in the coffin of the original brand split and it's hard not to feel like the same may well be true this time around. WWE is torpedoing its brand extension with this move and they are making a huge mistake in doing so.
8. Value Of The WWE Network Free Month
One of the big draws of the WWE Network is its 30-day free trial. The announce teams on both shows are consistently handed lengthy scripts promoting the 'free month' on television, geared around the PPV events new subscribers will receive free of charge. During the early days of the brand split, this was a formidable offering, with new subscribers often able to receive as many as three pay-per-views for free.
The number of events has now been decreased and, in the era of dual-branded shows, it is almost certainly staying that way. The free month is therefore considerably less attractive. If new subscribers purchase the network in the 48 hours prior to WrestleMania, they will just about squeeze in access to the subsequent Backlash event but, after that, there's more than a month between just about every show on the calendar.
Hardcore wrestling fans will already be WWE Network subscribers. However, the casual fans the company needs to bring in for the Network to be a financial success will be far more likely to sign up if they believe they are getting more bang for their buck, particularly if they haven't had to part with a buck yet.
7. Midcard Feuds
The first casualty of dual-branded pay-per-view events will be meaningful midcard feuds getting the chance to shine on a big stage. If the brand split remains in place, the WWE roster will be battling over a significantly diminished amount of airtime on PPV shows.
There are nine championships currently up for grabs on the main roster and so, if all of them are contested for, that fills up a three hour show to an uncomfortable degree and even leaves the epic length of a four hour event looking slightly over-stretched.
The best wrestling feuds are those built on personal issues rather than the simple notion of trying to win a championship. Those feuds are particularly relevant and important for the likes of Bray Wyatt, Tye Dillinger and Baron Corbin, who are treated as major performers but often spend time outside of any of the title pictures. If these wrestlers do not get the chance to work on pay-per-views, it becomes much harder for fans to buy into them as future main eventers when the company decides to give them a push.
Brand split logic dictates that a thinner roster means everyone gets time in the spotlight. That doesn't hold up when that spotlight becomes smaller and more crowded.
6. Showcase Matches For Everyone
There's a world of difference between a TV wrestling match and a pay-per-view bout. On television, the focus is on keeping people's attention on the screen and trying to ensure they come back next week for the new episode. That is not true of PPVs, which are directed towards showcasing the best of in-ring action, rather than any of the backstage accoutrements.
Any WWE performer with aspirations of ascending to a meaningful position within the company will first have to prove themselves on the PPV stage. If they are not able to work a full-blooded match and tell a story within those confines, they are not going to succeed in WWE.
Without the space afforded by single-branded PPVs, it's going to be tough for these superstars to find their opportunity. There's going to be very little room outside of the title pictures and that doesn't leave a chance for the likes of Tye Dillinger, or even the hugely popular Rusev, to work a 10-15 minute match on a big stage.
In this crowded landscape, WWE's only option to give somebody a PPV bout is to push them into a title match, which is not always the best way to get a star over.
5. Keeping Superstars Apart
The entire purpose of the brand split is to make the most of the strength and depth of WWE's talent roster. By keeping certain main event performers separate for extended periods of time, it allows for fresh matches when the rosters are shuffled and can increase the star wattage of upper midcarders who are able to ascend to the main event scene by virtue of the shallower pool of contenders.
It's difficult to keep this pretence going when all of these stars are together in the same building once a month. WWE has already proven itself incapable of resisting brand-on-brand battles, despite billing Survivor Series as the one night a year when the shows collide. The company pitted Raw's Brock Lesnar against Smackdown's Randy Orton at Summerslam 2016, just weeks after the split, and brought in the blue brand's AJ Styles as a replacement opponent for Finn Balor at the Raw-exclusive TLC last year.
With the temptation of a dual-branded show, WWE's chances of keeping the rosters distinct are diminished even further. It won't be long until there's a match pitting the brands against each other on every show, by which time Survivor Series is essentially redundant.
4. Room For The Women
The most laudable thing WWE has done in recent years is display enormous pride in its women's division. Many of the best female athletes in the world are employed by WWE and the 'Women's Evolution' has proven to be something far more valid and valuable than a PR-friendly slogan. WWE's women have competed in a Royal Rumble, a Money in the Bank ladder match and a Hell in a Cell bout, while the notion of women appearing in the main event segment of a show is no longer novel.
At this Sunday's Raw-exclusive event Elimination Chamber, there are set to be at least three major segments involving the brand's women. Six of the top contenders will battle for the Women's Championship inside the eponymous structure for the first time ever, while Nia Jax will fight the undefeated Asuka and megastar Ronda Rousey will formally sign her Raw contract.
It's difficult to imagine any pay-per-view featuring as many as three women's segments if there are two brands' worth of men to pack on to a show. WWE simply does not prioritise its female stars in that way and it's entirely possible that women's matches may once again be cut for time and shunted into graveyard slots.
3. Bloated Shows
WrestleMania is the most significant wrestling show of the year. It's a huge event that fans of sports entertainment all over the world flock to enjoy. However, it's incredibly long. According to the timings on WWE Network, WrestleMania 33 last year was 310 minutes long, with a further 119 minutes for the pre-show. That's more than seven hours of wrestling content in one evening.
It would be false to suggest that every dual-branded PPV event will have a length to rival WrestleMania, but they're certainly getting longer. Dave Meltzer has reported WWE anticipating the majority of these events will be five hours long, including a one hour kick-off show. That's a lot of energy to ask of an audience for a disposable event like a Battleground or a Backlash.
With its five hours of main roster television per week, plus 205 Live, NXT and Mixed Match Challenge to name but a few, WWE is asking its hardcore fans to consume a mind-boggling amount of content. The addition of a five hour pay-per-view Sunday every month might be the straw that breaks the back of even the most fanatical camel.
2. Value Of The Big Four
For years, WWE has marketed Royal Rumble, WrestleMania, SummerSlam and Survivor Series as its 'Big Four' PPV events. Since the brand split was brought into force, these four shows have been the only occasions where superstars can mix, with the exception of AJ Styles at last year's TLC. This lends a gravitas and importance to these shows - particularly true of Survivor Series, which had lost its shine before the split.
These shows will inevitably be less special once every PPV event is dual-branded. The crucial hook that made these events spectacular has been taken away and it's now likely the only factor separating SummerSlam and Survivor Series from every other event on the calendar will be an extra hour of bloat on the running time.
WWE has scored a major own goal with this, undoing the increased buzz around its big events that itself created when it split the roster in half. Ironically, by decreasing the number of PPVs it airs every year, WWE has managed to make the ones it does have less special. It would be funny if it wasn't so sad.
1. Keep The Brand Split Real
There's simply no reason to have a brand split, unless the brands are going to be truly separate.
It sounds like a simple argument, but it's an idea that WWE has lost sight of with this decision regarding its pay-per-view events. The brand split will only remain in place for as long as it remains exciting to watch both shows, knowing the performers and rivalries will be completely different to the other brand.
It's going to be impossible for WWE to maintain the appeal of separate rosters if they gather together once a month for a PPV. There will be countless segments in which superstars from different shows meet backstage for a cheap pop, telegraphing future rivalries and removing the electricity of seeing two people clash for the first time when the rosters are shuffled and they're placed together.
A brand split only works if the two shows operate essentially as if they are different organisations, rather than a mere distinction of corporate branding. By merging the red and blue rosters for every single PPV event, WWE has smashed the foundations of the split and, soon, the whole edifice is bound to come tumbling down.