CM Punk: Every WrestleMania Match Ranked Worst To Best

Remembering and ranking the Best in the World at WrestleMania.

By Ash Jacob /

Now that some time has passed, CM Punk's contribution to WWE seems like only a blip. Just seven and a half years and he was done, but the impact he made in that time was colossal to say the least.

Advertisement

From 2006 to 2014, Punk worked solidly and rose from indie misfit to, well, an indie misfit who was the most cheered wrestling superstar on the planet. However, even though he became the centre of the WWE universe, he never reached the undisputed main event spot at WrestleMania, despite carrying the WWE title into the Show of Shows in 2012.

That doesn't mean to say that CM Punk didn't have his share of Mania moments. Showcasing him as the lovable hardcore daredevil of his ECW years, to the menacing Straight Edge Society Messiah, to the New Nexus Leader, to the bona fide Best in the World, the many faces of Punk all found a way to shine on the Grandest Stage. That dream main event championship match may have only come agonisingly close, but his antics at the Showcase of the Immortals were memorable regardless.

Here's a rundown of the worst to best.

7. Money In The Bank Ladder Match - WrestleMania 25 (2009)

This was the third and final Money In the Bank ladder match for CM Punk, as a bump up the roster and a well-needed change in his persona was imminent. By now, the Straight Edge Superstar was comfortably entrenched in the WrestleMania ladder format, and therefore didn't have a great deal to prove.

Advertisement

That's not to say that this contest didn't have some highlights. In a lot of ways, it was one of the most inventive and impressive ladder matches on the pay per view to date, but this is only when collating the efforts of every superstar involved. For better examples of CM Punk taking to the ladder under the WrestleMania banner, you need to travel back a year or so.

An additional awkward bump at the hands of Christian, further prevents this from being his proudest moment.

There is little doubt that Punk grabbing the briefcase for the second year running was a gift to the fans, but at the same time, he was clearly ready to move on. Fortunately, Chick Magnet Punk was bound for singles competition from here on out.

6. Money In The Bank Ladder Match- WrestleMania 24 (2008)

Jump one year back, and we got a much hungrier performance from the Straight Edge Superstar. He was still carving his niche, and was at the less established side of proving himself to be a main event player. His night at WrestleMania 24 in 2008 was important, but by no means the best.

Advertisement

There's no real black cloud to hang above this one. The match contained some mind-blowing performances, as was generally the case with WrestleMania Money In The Bank ladder contests. Ultimately, the show was rightfully stolen by the likes of Shelton Benjamin and John Morrison, as their crazy antics outshone the other contenders. Amidst this, Punk mainly played the part of opportunist.

The plus side was that it paid off for him. CM Punk grabbing that briefcase and earning a solid victory was a real significant point in his career, arguably more so than that of 2009's MITB match. All was good on that front, but in terms of performance, better examples are to be found in other matches of the same type.

5. CM Punk Vs Randy Orton - WrestleMania 27 (2011)

It's forgivable to forget that CM Punk was once the leader of Nexus. This event took place only three months before he dropped the pipebomb to end all pipebombs, and reinvented his character from head to toe. After that, came the Summer of Punk... and you know the rest.

Advertisement

Still, this was fun looking back. In his grudge match against Randy Orton, Punk showed off all of his crafty skills, and proved to have some solid chemistry with the Viper. As a technical exhibition, this was all top dollar, with Orton and Punk putting in some great effort to make it work. However, there was little real significance to the storyline, and that made the whole thing hard to invest in.

CM Punk's closing turnbuckle dive, hijacked by an RKO, was at least an excellent finish. Perhaps in a parallel universe, this was a WrestleMania main event, and therefore could have gone the extra mile. It certainly had that level of potential. The match delivered on its every promise, but was ultimately a stopping point for better things in the future.

4. Money In The Bank Ladder Match - WrestleMania 23 (2007)

2007 saw CM Punk's first appearance at WrestleMania, and it was one hell of a show.

Advertisement

Still dubbed arbitrarily as 'ECW's CM Punk', he was out to make not just an impression on behalf of the troubled ECW brand, but also a name for himself. It's no surprise then that he came into his first ever Money In The Bank ladder contest guns blazing.

It started with him taking a seemingly real and brutally-thrown stepper to the head, at the hands of Edge. It then progressed with him wearing a ladder round his neck, which was used to take out multiple opponents, and it concluded with him receiving an RKO off a ladder. His head was bleeding throughout. The Straight Edge Superstar took some amazing bumps and showed off some incredible athleticism.

This new guy proved himself more than capable of competing with the big boys. Punk went on to perform in two more MITB matches at WrestleMania, and scored victories in both. Yet, neither quite possessed the all-out fearlessness contained in this one. As WrestleMania debuts go, CM Punk's was as slick as they come.

3. CM Punk Vs Rey Mysterio - WrestleMania 26 (2010)

WrestleMania 26 saw CM Punk's first outing as a singles competitor (excluding the stable interference from Serena Deeb and Luke Gallows), and the Straight Edge Messiah had zero problems in letting the 2010 'Mania crowd know that he was worth the time.

Advertisement

The match began with a stellar promo, where Punk took to the mic and viciously laid in to the audience and his opponent. With a stunning programme established in the run up to this match, the expectation was high, and all parties delivered. Simple.

One has to be bloody good to keep up with Rey Mysterio, and CM Punk was. The numerous spots and bumps served as infallible proof. Punk struck a balance between harnessing the high-flying wizardry of his Money In The Bank years, and putting forth a character so deep and dark, it would not be forgotten in a hurry. Every move he made during the contest only served to project his villainy further. It was genius.

Whilst the match itself could have benefitted from being a little bit longer, It provided irrefutable evidence that CM Punk was only going to skyrocket in the business.

2. CM Punk Vs Chris Jericho - WrestleMania 28 (2012)

When hitting the grandest stage of them all in 2012, CM Punk was at the apex of his popularity. This was also his one and only WWE title match at WrestleMania.

Advertisement

In full babyface mode, he made a sterling title defence against a contrastingly villainous Chris Jericho, who made things personal by insulting Punk's entire family. What's more, Punk's acting corporate nemesis at the time, John Laurinaitis, promised an instant disqualification and title forfeit, should Punk break any rules during the match.

This resulted in an excellent clean wrestling bout which also contained some great storytelling. Jericho and CM Punk were a perfect fit for each other, not just in terms of wrestling, but chemistry too. Their technical showmanship and charismatic approach to staying in character made this an extremely rewarding treat for the fans. They bounced off of each other with enough skill to provide a goodly amount of wrestling surprises. It was everything it should have been, and more.

The final shot saw Punk victoriously holding his belt. The crowd went wild. It was WrestleMania-worthy on all fronts.

1. CM Punk Vs The Undertaker - WrestleMania 29 (2013)

It's important to remember that this match occurred when CM Punk's injuries were taking a serious toll. Creative differences also played a part in him being less than happy going into this event.

Advertisement

Somehow, none of it stops the match from being amazing, though.

CM Punk's entrance alone exudes the Best in the World at his most brazen, strolling to the ring with Paul Heyman in tow whilst Living Color pumped out a slick live rendition of Cult of Personality. His charisma levels were close to bursting, even before the actual wrestling began.

During the contest, Punk relentlessly injected energy and personality into every blow, bump, and dive, countering The Undertaker's stoic presence with craftiness and rage. Though 'The Phenom's aura was godly, CM Punk came across as his equal, all the way up until the final pin. Whilst it was certain from the get-go that Punk was never going to end The Streak, he did give 'Taker a formidable run for his money; so much so that the match dwarfed The Rock Vs John Cena II main event of the night with little effort...

... and so ended CM Punk's WrestleMania tenure, but it was a bloody good sign-off.

Advertisement