Every NXT TakeOver Main Event In History: Ranked
Which match gets the honour of being the best of an amazing bunch?
Since its debut in 2014, NXT Takeover has gone on to be one of the most must-watch wrestling in the world.
When tuning in, fans just know that they are likely going to be entertained for the entire broadcast. This is because the cards are often expertly built, delivering bang after banger leading to a crescendo of wrestling excellence in the main event.
There has been a total of thirty-six Takeovers to date and every single one of them have been finished with an outstanding match. This is what made this list perhaps the hardest that this writer has ever embarked on writing. Having to sort through all thirty-six of these matches and somehow picking the worst and best out of a simply amazing bunch is certainly as hard a task as any. However, one thing is clear: that every single one of these matches deserves to be rewatched and appreciated.
Each one sharing crazy athleticism, dramatic storytelling and stiff strikes, yet each unique in their own way, constantly one-upping the ones that came before them.
As fans, all we can do is sit back and admire the fact that in the last seven years, NXT has produced thirty-six of some of the best matches in modern wrestling history...
36. Karrion Kross Vs. Keith Lee – Takeover XXX
Now don’t get this wrong, this is far from a bad match. The decision on which match to put last on this list was a difficult one. That’s because there has fortunately never been a bad Takeover main event. Pretty hard to pick the ‘worst’ out of a consistently fantastic bunch.
While Karrion Kross has proved a worthy successor of Keith Lee, it’s always risky to have a star so young in his company tenure to dethrone such an over champion who is equally young in his title run. While both men tried their best to outshine one another and make the match good enough to be worthy of the brand's 30th main event, it was largely forgettable. A great chunk of the match was slow, clunky and rife with rest holds, broken up with sporadic sequences of the speed and agility both big men are known for.
With the ability that we know they both have, it’s a shame the pair never got to the level of intensity and showstopping energy that they could have, otherwise they wouldn’t be at the bottom of this list.
35. Kevin Owens Vs. Sami Zayn – Takeover: Unstoppable
While the match was another chapter in the bitterly intense rivalry between Owens and Zayn, it was also the only Takeover Main event to end in a no contest.
At least with the original, there was a firm conclusion. The bell never actually rung to end this contest, instead, Samoa Joe made his much-awaited debut and in the ensuing chaos, Owens just tucked his tail between his legs and ran off. This heavily detracted from the match itself, even a repeat of a referee stoppage verdict would have benefited the affair.
The match before this confounding finish, however, was as good as any Owens and Zayn contest. Heavily personal and hard-hitting, but for the most part, simply a rehash of their far superior Takeover: Rival match. Running thirteen minutes exactly, making it the shortest main event in Takeover history, Owens, just like the prior contest, dominated, before a spirited Zayn comeback. Which of course was followed by more Owens domination, resulting in both the refs and doctors intervening.
Not bad by any means, but far from the heights that Takeover soon began to reach.
34. Samoa Joe Vs. Finn Balor – Takeover: The End
Another match that would surprise many to be this low on the list.
Being Finn Balor’s final NXT appearance, until his eventual 2019 return, you would think that Joe and Balor would go all out to make the last instalment of their trilogy the best of all. Unfortunately, it was the weakest of the three. Not a bad match whatsoever, it was merely just a combination of the two matches we’d already seen at the prior two Takeover events, just slapped inside a steel cage to try and freshen things up a bit.
The same intensity and the same move pieces, just with a few slams into the cage thrown in here and there for good measure. Just really much of the same as what we had already seen many times before. The only real high spot being the avalanche Muscle Buster that finished off the affair and sent Balor packing to the main roster.
Being the only time ‘The Demon’ has recorded a loss, it was a strong affair of course, but due to its repetitiveness, it is not as high as other main events.
33. Tyson Kidd Vs. Adrian Neville – Takeover
The very first Takeover main event was far from the worst.
Enjoyable, yet almost forgotten by many fans, this match was just pure, straight wrestling. No big over the top spots, apart from a couple of high flying dives, the 21-minute affair mostly consisted of wonderfully technical mat wrestling. Kidd got to show off all the wrestling prowess he had learnt being the product of the famous Hart Dungeon training school, while Neville got to prove to audiences that he isn’t just a high flyer, but is also one of the most talented grapplers on any roster that he is placed on.
The two men had instant chemistry and told a simple story very well. Commentator William Regal put it simply, Tyson Kidd was a desperate man who knew that this match was his last chance to make a mark in the WWE. Make that mark he did, as he and Neville proceeded to set a precedent for all future Takeover main events preceding it. Kidd brought out all the stops, applying almost every submission he could think of, even busting out the very rarely seen Dungeon Lock, which surely popped the old school fans. In the end, it wasn’t enough as the always impressive Red Arrow brought an end to the first-ever Takeover.
Many more fantastic main events followed. 32 more, that topped it to be exact.
32. Samoa Joe Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura – Takeover: Toronto
There is going to be a clear theme in this list, in the sense that the sequels will rarely surpass the originals. This is the case with the Samoa Joe/Shinsuke Nakamura saga.
It could be argued that their second encounter was a tad more physical than the first, but there isn’t denying that the match played out very similarly to the first. Just like Joe’s cage match with Balor, it was very much the same sequences and same set-up, just with a bit more effort put into the moves. The only major difference was the added element of Joe targeting Nakamura’s leg to weaken the Kinsasha. Yes, this was an effective move that brought the crowd into the match more, however, it was immediately all undone when Nakamura didn’t overcome this in a huge, rallying comeback. Instead, Joe hit a Muscle Buster and just like that the match was over.
The match felt like it was cut short of its crescendo and the result sucked all the energy that was left out of the crowd, who weren’t happy to see Nakamura’s reign end just 3 months in. Shock results can be successful sometimes, this wasn’t one of those times.
31. Shinsuke Nakamura Vs. Bobby Roode – Takeover: San Antonio
For such an electric lead up to winning the thing, Nakamura had a majorly disappointing NXT Title run.
In what was billed "The biggest money match in NXT history", Roode and Nakamura were treated as one of the biggest dream matches since Rock Vs. Hogan. Yet, it didn’t deliver what was promised.
The match was adequate, nonetheless but seemed to belong on an NXT TV supercard event more than an actual Takeover. The pair played it fairly safe with a cocky heel having his arrogance get the best of him schtick for a majority of the match until the Nakamura knee injury trope was reused from Takeover: Toronto Vs. Samoa Joe. While the injury was played into much heavier than Toronto, the result was still the same in slowing down the match completely. Doing the whole doctor stoppage thing never gets over well with NXT crowds and it didn’t do the match any favours here.
In the process, Nakamura was wrongly humanised and just like his match with Joe, nobody was happy to see Nakamura’s reign end even shorter than last time, no matter how over Roode was at that point.
30. Bobby Roode Vs. Drew McIntyre – Takeover: Brooklyn III
Drew McIntyre’s return to WWE in 2017 was a great story that all wrestling fans could get behind. So it wasn’t a surprise that NXT hot shot him into the title scene just over 4 months after his return. The pairing of McIntyre and Roode didn’t scream Match of The Year, but it didn’t need to. The match was never going to be, and good on WWE for not falsely hyping it up to be, which they do ever so often.
Roode was on the way out and all he needed to do was put on a match that was fitting of setting up McIntyre as the next dominant force of the black and gold brand. This one did its job fairly well. It was an old school style pure wrestling match, with a heel who was too arrogant to realise his title was slipping away and a face who brought a huge amount of fire, completing his redemption arc. It built to a nice finish with a thundering Claymore Kick and an eruption from the Brooklyn crowd.
The post-match debut of Undisputed Era only enhanced the excitement of Brooklyn III’s closure. It was an adequate way to pass the torch to a new generation of NXT talent.
29. Io Shirai Vs. Raquel Gonzalez – Takeover: Stand And Deliver Night 1
With this being just the third Takeover with the women going on last, these two had big shoes to fill. Actually, no, considering how good the first two were, they had HUGE shoes to fill.
While they had no chance of ever filling those shoes, the pair was able to deliver a match worthy of going on last almost 6 years after their predecessors did. Gonzalez was able to complete a career-long character arc of going from a green, rookie jobber, to a dominant force who could credibly topple the star that is Io Shirai.
Granted, all of Gonzalez’s green tendencies weres on show with her multiple missteps throughout the contest. But Shirai, as classy as ever, was able to carry her through the whole thing, making sure her confidence wasn’t shaken and as a result, the match didn’t take a massive hit. Shirai through everything at Gonzalez, which made the young star look like an unbeatable beast by swatting it all off like a fly.
The right move was made at the right time and it was a refreshing change to see NXT get behind one of its homegrown talents for the first time in a long time.
28. Samoa Joe Vs. Finn Balor – Takeover: Dallas
This match could have somehow eclipsed the electrifying match that was Sami Zayn vs. Shinsuke Nakamura earlier on in the night, it only it wasn’t for doctor stoppage.
These two went to war, willing to beat the hell out of each other to win. When Joe got busted open early, the crowd reached an intense climax. The scene of blood gushing down Joe’s face while the two exchanged blows was enough to send them into a frenzy.
You almost started to get the feeling that this was going to be an all-time classic in WWE history. Then the backstage officials started screaming down the earpieces of the referee and the ringside doctors. The crowd was not happy and the match was stopped every time the action started to pick up, making it almost impossible to get invested.
Undeterred, the pair still delivered a match that was intense, physical and hard-hitting in all the right ways. A nice nod to Bret Hart vs. Roddy Piper from WrestleMania VIII with the finish was just the cherry on top that the match needed. Just a shame that due to circumstances beyond anyone’s control, the match was ultimately drained of any showstopping power that it almost had.
27. Samoa Joe Vs. Shinsuke Nakamura – Takeover: Brooklyn II
The stage was set: 'The King of Strong Style’ Vs. 'The Samoan Submission Machine’, WWE’s biggest dream match in a long time. Unfortunately, this one didn’t quite live up to the hype, but it was no fault of the competitors, they rarely ever live up to fans expectations, it’s almost impossible in fact. Was it even the best match on the card? No, hence its low placing on the list.
But these two gave it their absolute all. The match felt epic as the two exchanged blistering chops, knees and strikes, it was hard-hitting wrestling at its finest. Nakamura and Joe proved countless times throughout their almost never-ending saga that they had great chemistry and never fail to put on a fine match. The match delivered a series of outstanding sequences, especially the ending one. With the pair exchanging a series of suplexes and signatures moves, before an electrifying Kinsasha that legitimately broke Joe’s jaw sent the crowd to its fit as Nakamura lifted the NXT Title.
While yes, at times, the match was slow and slightly choreographed, there is no denying that the sheer grandeur of the affair carried the bout to be the best of the pair’s Takeover tussles.