Every WWE Royal Rumble 'Final Four' - From Worst To Best

It doesn't matter when you enter but where you end up.

By Matt O'Connell /

Too often, the Royal Rumble can seem like a one-man match. Despite being a 30-entrant free-for-all, it's regularly remembered as little more than a setup for the WrestleMania title match main event. The upshot is that the winner of the Royal Rumble is usually pretty easy to call. WWE€™s booking is transparent enough that most savvy viewers can guess who'll be closing out WrestleMania by the time they're halfway through watching Survivor Series. What really makes things interesting in the Rumble, more than the actual winner, are the last three men eliminated. They're the understudies, so to speak: the ones whom WWE didn't choose this year, but COULD have, had things panned out differently. Those three, along with the winner, form the 'final four', representing WWE€™s theoretical top contenders for that year. The very conceit that these four are supposed to be believable as the most bankable stars in the company is what makes them worthy of closer examination. Taking this into account, I've ranked the final four competitors of every Royal Rumble (so far) based on overall star power, strength of their booking, the inclusion of memorable moments and the creation of new stars.

29. 2015 - Kane, Big Show, Rusev & Roman Reigns

It doesn't get any worse than this. Kane and Big Show had nonchalantly eliminated every competitor the fans actually wanted to win, and were verrrrry obviously there only to be sacrificed at the altar of the Roman Reigns main event push. Even without their status as telegraphed Roman-fodder, the sluggish, mid-life crisis versions of Big Show and Kane shouldn't have been anywhere near a WrestleMania main event. When Roman eliminated them both, they decided to beat him up anyway, summoning The Rock to beat THEM up. Only after this unnecessary run-in did Rusev reappear - now a massive babyface - to get dumped by Roman. There was no drama to any of it, and no reason for anyone to actually get behind Roman as a WrestleMania challenger. Worst final four ever.

28. 2014 - CM Punk, Sheamus, Roman Reigns & Batista

In 2014, the role of Roman Reigns was played by Batista. He was the hand-picked winner that literally no one wanted to see, going on to WrestleMania so that he could promote Guardians of the Galaxy with the WWE Title on his shoulder. The fans were 100% behind Daniel Bryan during this match, and when it became apparent that he wasn't actually going to be in it, they turned on the whole thing. CM Punk was spared their wrath, but he was lamely eliminated by Kane and left wrestling forever the next day. That left a triple threat of WWE€™s blandest possible musclemen in Sheamus, Batista and Reigns. The fans sided with Reigns as he was the freshest possible choice, but he couldn't overcome Batista€™s combination of crossover appeal and truly terrible cardiovascular conditioning.

27. 1991 - Davey Boy Smith, Brian Knobbs, Earthquake & Hulk Hogan

Can you think of a lamer, more predictable final four than this? Brian Knobbs never won anything of value by himself until the WCW Hardcore division was a thing, and Davey Boy Smith is the most neutered thing possible: a second babyface to Hulk Hogan. At the very least, Hogan eliminating Earthquake paid off a long-term storyline. Hogan had been €œinjured€ by Earthquake€™s sit-down splash months before, and this match was Hogan€™s triumphant return to form, winning the match by tossing the supposedly immovable Quake. Still, this might as well have had a "best horseshoe mustache wins" stipulation. As a final four, it was rubbish.

26. 2000 - X-Pac, Kane, Big Show & The Rock

This is the beginning of Big Show€™s sad, sad Royal Rumble career. His strategy, which he would bafflingly stick with for years, was simple: saunter in mid-match, impressively press a few jobbers to the floor, then try to dump out a popular babyface in such a way that they could easily grab a front facelock and drag him over the ropes. This match didn't even get that right, as Rock yanked Show over but somehow still landed first, meaning that Show technically should have won the match. The botch was so obvious that they wound up making the main event of WrestleMania a 4-way match with A MCMAHON IN EVERY CORNER because of it. Also, X-Pac was one of the top four contenders to main event WrestleMania. The year 2000, everybody.

25. 1990 - Hercules, Rick Rude, Mr. Perfect & Hulk Hogan

Oh no! Can even Hulk Hogan manage to hold off the combined might of a Latino guy cosplaying a Greek demigod and diabolical Minnesotan besties Mr. Perfect and Rick Rude? Spoiler: he can, and the outcome isn't exactly in doubt. The Holy Hulkster saw that the Rumble had the potential to be more than your basic battle royal, and asked the eternal question: why not Hulk Hogan? This was back before the Rumble actually had stakes, and literally just allowed the announcers to have a "Hulk Hogan literally beat 29 men at once" talking point.

24. 1988 - Dino Bravo, One Man Gang, Don Muraco & Jim Duggan

Ah, the first-ever Royal Rumble. There were only twenty entrants, absolutely no prize was on the line, and it was won by a brain-damaged man who loves lumber. Looking back, it's pretty amazing that it became a yearly thing. Since the first Rumble had no stakes, it's no real shock that it didn't boast unimpeachable star power. Still, all four guys were bonafide upper midcarders, and the right guy won in Hacksaw. Don't get me wrong, I never got the guy, but he has always, always been over. *crosses eyes* USA, tough guy!

23. 1989 - Akeem, Rick Martel, Ted DiBiase & Big John Studd

The second Rumble was pretty similar to the first in terms of star power and booking. I mean, right down to One Man Gang/Akeem in the final four. At the very least, it also included Ted DiBiase, arguably the promotion€™s top heel at the time, Rick Martel fresh from an AWA Championship run, and a returning Big John Studd. The finish was poetic: the newly virtuous Studd squared off with DiBiase, who had purchased the #30 spot outright. DiBiase was also the partner of Studd€™s blood rival André the Giant, who had memorably bested him at WrestleMania I to the tune of $15,000. André had also won the last high-profile match Studd had been in (at WrestleMania II), so his elimination of DiBiase here was a satisfying payoff, as well as his career highlight.

22. 1999 - Big Boss Man, D€™Lo Brown, Steve Austin & Vince McMahon

The 1999 Rumble was all about the Austin/McMahon beef, and kind of justifiably so. It was by far the biggest story the promotion had going, and Austin had already done a traditional babyface Rumble win the year prior. Still, it caused the entire roster to take a backseat to the boss-as-entrant storyline, and McMahon€™s win was super predictable. Granted, it was the first time WWE played the €œah, but this guy was just hiding€ card at a Rumble, what were we supposed to think? That D€™Lo Brown was gonna have the Nation of Domination explode a year too late? That Big Boss Man was finally going to get that WrestleMania main event no one was clamouring for? Come on!

21. 1994 - Shawn Michaels, Fatu, Bret Hart & Lex Luger

Although all four of these guys are (or will be) Hall of Famers, only Bret Hart was in peak form during this period. Shawn Michaels was still in his midcard proto-Ziggler phase, Luger was twisting in the wind as Hulk Hogan II, and Fatu hadn't even purchased his first thong yet. I mean, I hope he hadn't... This Rumble is most famous for its unique finish, wherein Hart and Luger tumbled over the ropes together and were declared co-winners. It may seem like a cop-out, but it was actually a very elegant solution to the thorny issue of replacing Hogan as top face. He was still everyone's top choice, but if he couldn't get it together by WrestleMania, they could just give the big moment to Bret. One wonders where that kind of booking flexibility has gone, no?

20. 2013 - Dolph Ziggler, Sheamus, Ryback & John Cena

This final four sure was a mixed bag. Dolph Ziggler and Ryback had never been close to a WrestleMania main event before, while Sheamus and Cena are the poster boys for disappointing WWE status quo. Worse, Cena had killed all the drama in the match by promising he'd challenge The Rock at WrestleMania, like, four minutes after the previous WrestleMania ended. Seriously, what were we supposed to think after Cena lost to Rocky at WrestleMania 28? That the guy whose entire career is based on getting his wins back was going to let The Rock vs. Dolph Ziggler happen? The last guy in the match with Cena was Ryback, just coming off his intial Goldbergian winning streak and main event feud with CM Punk. That at least gave him some shred of believability in challenging Cena, but his loss here ultimately played into his image as a choke artist, which still plagues him today.