If WWE Was Being Honest About Unhappy Talent
Plans change.
WrestleMania, to its creative detriment, is the endurance festival aimed at talent who have endured the year-long schedule. It is a thank you of sorts; the talents get mainstream exposure, a handsome payday, and the opportunity to perform in front of the largest crowd of the year.
This Kickoff gambit is no longer working; no less than three performers have requested their release in the one and a half weeks following WrestleMania 35. The striking, definitive trend of 2019 is multiplying. The timing is telling; morale is plummeting during what is, historically, a time of celebration and renewed opportunity.
Sasha Banks attempted to walk out over ‘Mania Weekend, feeling let down by WWE’s decision to strip the Boss and Hug Connection of the Women’s Tag Team Titles she effectively dreamt into existence. Luke Harper has astutely followed the successful precedent set by Tye Dillinger; in publicising his desire to leave, he appeared to thank WWE in a heartfelt message. The subtext reveals otherwise. It reads like a challenge: you released Tye, so release me.
Alexander Wolfe was more cryptic in his Twitter missive. Irrespective of where he lands, NXT or the Independent circuit, his “Goodbye #WWE’ sign-off reads like a desperate plea to go somewhere, anywhere, that isn’t a main roster show on which he is conflated with an entry-level Indy talent cosplaying as security. That Miz angle really was something. Wolfe and the rest of SAnitY found themselves right back where they started from, staring both their past and future in the face.
This is a strange subversion of the old “spring cleaning” practise; in 2019, the roster is purging itself. It’s all backwards. This becomes a theme. This all feels inevitable, weirdly, even if it represents a remarkable paradigm shift few saw coming.
CONT'D...(1 of 5)
WWE cannot push every performer at the same time, and every WWE performer—or at least character—in this post-NXT environment is in the orbit of stardom. We are removed from even the old development days, in which a performer exclusively trained by WWE was promoted to the main roster, via vignette, and entered the system equipped with the knowledge that it would take years, if ever, to reach the pinnacle.
Those called up to the main roster have tasted success in NXT, and this success has created an expectation among their fans. Within the narrative infrastructure of the flagship, virtually every character is championship calibre. Many talents are in reality, too, creating an implacable roster that grows in number by the week. This elite roster of talent didn't join WWE to job, but somebody has to. The greed of the raid has forced WWE to regurgitate, and now everybody feels queasy.
It is chronically backwards.
You used to start at the bottom, and work your way up. Under this new framework, talents debut at the top, and race to the bottom. So much else is backwards, too, intensifying the malaise. A talent develops a set of skills with which they alert WWE in the first place; WWE strips away many of these skills via scripted promos and road agent regulation.
When a talent becomes a Champion in WWE, they lose.
Is this reaching its inevitable conclusion? Is WWE itself, once the only destination, the launchpad?
CONT'D...(2 of 5)
That may read as utterly absurd, but the most critically acclaimed singles and tag performers on the planet, Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks—objective draws in an industry that can barely calculate what that means anymore—opted not to sign with WWE earlier this year. The Revival; Tye Dillinger; Mike and Maria Kanellis; The Club; Dean Ambrose: all have officially or allegedly elected to or demanded to leave before this week’s want-away trio scorched social media.
They are all acutely aware that progression is impossible. Investment is futile for fans and talent alike. Beyond WrestleMania 35, which we’ll get to, when did you, as a WWE fan, last share in the triumph of a main roster superstar?
Triumph isn’t in the plan. Or perhaps it was, until the last-minute rewrite, and it’s gone. Vince McMahon just bumped you off the show. So much of what has happened in 2019 feels ancient. Andrade was building momentum, in his firecracker programme with Rey Mysterio, and it’s gone. Chad Gable and Bobby Roode turned heel on the post-WrestleMania RAW, but then Gable moved to SmackDown in the Shake-Up, and it’s gone. EC3 was managed by Drake Maverick on a post-‘Mania SmackDown dark segment, teasing a partnership and an arc, but then Maverick didn’t show up by his side on Monday, and Braun Strowman straight up killed him, and it’s gone. WWE implemented a one-save rule in the tag team division, and it’s gone.
Vince’s increasingly impulsive, inexplicable bullsh*t just adds to the spiralling catastrophe.
WWE has created a gridlock in which every name act, the genetically superior moneyed heel, the extraordinary luchador, the Demon, the heart-on-sleeve babyface, the massively-muscled MMA marine—all wildly different, credential characters are indistinguishable in quality, appeal and purpose.
CONT'D...(3 of 5)
WWE RAW’s tagline used to read Uncut, Uncooked, Uncensored. The more accurate tagline for 2019 is Morbidly Hilarious, and while it is a schadenfreude joy to remain a WWE fan, that’s likely not what Fox paid billions for.
There is a counterargument to all of this, in that long-tenured employ—independent contractors—reached the highest of heights just under a fortnight ago.
But in stark contrast to Seth Rollins, a very rare, consistently protected performer, the New Jersey/shadow of New York triumphs of Becky Lynch and Seth Rollins emerged by accident, essentially. We weren’t meant to receive Becky as a babyface in the summer of 2018. Kofi Kingston was meant to take part in a 10 minute Fatal 4-Way match at WrestleMania 35.
If current trends continue, there is every chance that, in Tampa next year, Becky Lynch will not main event, and Kofi will Experience a pair of Vikings, in addition to the two nearest tag teams on SmackDown. But the Viking Experience are on RAW, you might say. As if that matters. None of this matters. That’s the point.
That’s not cynical; that is projection through precedent. Shinsuke Nakamura went backwards, following WrestleMania 34. Nia Jax went backwards. Jinder Mahal went backwards. Bray Wyatt entered ‘Mania 33 as WWE Champion. Next year: André. There’s always more wood for the dumpster fire.
CONT'D...(4 of 5)
Naomi won the SmackDown Women’s Championship in Orlando. Next year: Moolah. Only, lol, WWE discovered that naming the battle royal attraction after a reviled pimp wasn’t good business practise.
See? Morbidly hilarious.
WWE’s global raid has backfired spectacularly. Aiming to secure a warehouse of ambitious, prime talent, the bloated roster now seeks an escape. WWE’s week-to-week product is so laughably inconsistent that it invites waves of scorn on Twitter. We are in the Meme Era of WWE, and the roster is sick of being the punchline—particularly since their erstwhile colleague Cody, the example to follow, is Being The Elite.
Something needs to change, but it can’t. WWE cannot be honest about all of this. WWE is fundamentally incapable of lasting creative change—remember the December 17 RAW?—and even less capable of or inclined to rip up the new personnel blueprint. The company is too spiteful, too fearful of losing grip on its monopoly. Just listen to the absolute state of Triple H’s Hall of Fame speech. There’s an underlying arrogance to everything, too.
We have reached a point at which acts that debuted in January of this year can now be classed as “long-suffering”.
This sh*t is unsustainable, but WWE will maintain its stronghold. Under these bizarre, oxymoronic conditions, only chaos is possible. It is a strangely, perversely magic time to follow WWE. To perform under its umbrella, through which rain pours ceaselessly like an early morning in New Jersey, seems significantly less magic.
WWE has for years surgically removed any sense of autonomy within its talent. The company has been asking for this for well over a decade. Change is coming.
In WWE, it always is.