Ranking 2016's WWE PPV Endings From Worst To Best

A year of strong pay-per-views, but a mixed bag of endings.

By Andy H Murray /

For all WWE's problems this year, 2016 has been crammed solid pay-per-views. Few of WWE's major events set the world on fire, but only SummerSlam, WrestleMania, and a handful of others can be considered disappointments. Battleground, Money In The Bank, and Backlash were all excellent, and if you were to draw a line of best fit, 2016's PPVs would likely sit between "good" and "very good" on the quality scale.

Advertisement

Despite this, 2016 hasn't been a great year for PPV endings. WWE's big shows have brought some great action, but it's hard not to feel disheartened when said action is followed by a disappointing conclusion. Take the Royal Rumble as an example: it was legitimately one of the year's best shows, but what's the only thing people still talk about? Triple H, the McMahons, and the closing scene.

The ending is the most important part of any wrestling show, and what the fans will remember most. It's vitally important to make the live fans feel like they've had their money's worth, and stop the audience at home from thinking they've wasted their time. WWE's booking practises often get in the way of this, however, and it's been a particularly prevalent problem in 2016.

Still, it's not all bad, and the past 12 months have served up some genuinely euphoric show endings. With WWE's pay-per-view schedule over and done with for the year, here are all of 2016's PPV endings ranked from best to worst.

16. WrestleMania 32 - Roman Reigns Over All

A more obvious pick for 2016's worst pay-per-view ending you will not find: Roman Reigns' title celebration at WrestleMania 32 will go down as one of the flattest closing scenes in Mania history.

Advertisement

Roman's Mania coronation felt like an inevitability from the moment Triple H threw him out of the 2016 Royal Rumble, and his eventual victory was a perfect storm of of blandness. The main event was a 27-minuter that felt at least twice that long, and it came at the end of a sluggish, overlong pay-per-view. They tried to go for the slow-building, "epic match" formula, and they failed miserably.

16 months after facing universal rejection as the 2015 Royal Rumble winner, Reigns' WrestleMania moment was in the bag. Nobody asked for it, nobody wanted it, yet WWE swam against the tide regardless, and it resulted in a deflating end to the biggest show of the year.

If WWE officials were expecting a hero's reception for Reigns' victory, they were greatly mistaken. Half the audience headed for the exit as Reigns hoisted his newly won WWE Championship overhead, and the rest only stuck around to jeer the man. Kevin Dunn & co. did their best to mute the boos, but anyone paying attention could recognise the vitriol that showered him.

It's a shame that Roman Reigns' first big 'Mania moment ended this way. The guy's a lot better than some give him credit for, and it's not his fault that he's been asked to play a character that downplays his strengths and highlights his weaknesses. Still, WrestleMania 32 is part of Reigns' legacy now, and nothing can change that.

15. Fastlane - An Unwanted Face-Off

WWE's main event scene was stuck in a Roman Reigns/Triple H-induced rut by the time Fastlane came around. The company made it blatantly obvious that Triple H would win the Royal Rumble and effectively set-up a WrestleMania main event with Reigns. Not for the first time, WWE were attempting to re-tell the textbook spirited babyface vs. evil authority figure story that had brought them so much success during Austin vs. McMahon, and it flopped.

Advertisement

Many fans had already accepted WrestleMania's fate at this point, but for everyone else, Fastlane was the point of no return. The grim confirmation came when Reigns defeated Dean Ambrose and Brock Lesnar in a number one contender's match to seal his spot in the Mania main event, and while the match itself was pretty exciting, few wanted Reigns to triumph, particularly over such popular opposition.

But it happened, and as Reigns celebrated, a suit-clad Triple H strolled out with the WWE Championship in-hand. The duo started each other down inside the ring, before eventually turning towards the WrestleMania 32 banner plastered high inside the arena. The foreshadowing was over: the main event that nobody wanted was finally official, and Fastlane's final scene is a perfect microcosm not only of Reigns' lack of popularity, but the problems that plague Raw's main event scene to date.

14. Payback - The McMahons Take Centre Stage

It's never good when the McMahon family hog the spotlight, but that's exactly what happened at Payback. Shane, Stephanie, and Vince engaged in a horrendously overlong in-ring segment earlier in the evening, but things got worse in the main event. Much, much worse.

Advertisement

AJ Styles and Roman Reigns were fighting for the WWE Championship. At the midway point, AJ sent Roman (and himself) crashing through an announce table with his springboard forearm, and Reigns couldn't beat the ensuing ten count. Out come Shane McMahon to make a song and dance, and restart the match without count-outs.

Fans might have been able to stomach this one slice of McMahon family nepotism, but a second followed shortly after. Reigns struck Styles with an accidental low blow, so of course Stephanie McMahon had to come out and restart things for a second time.

Reigns eventually won after interference from The Usos and Karl Anderson & Doc Gallows. The overbooking derailed what could've been an excellent match, and after its conclusion, the cameras immediately cut to the McMahon family backstage. Vince praised his kids for both restarts, then set up a rematch for Extreme Rules: something that could easily have been accomplished on Raw the next night, but who are we to deny the McMahons their spotlight? They are the most consistently pushed characters in the company, after all...

13. Clash Of Champions - The Interference That Never Comes

Clash Of Champions established the framework for every Raw-specific pay-per-view that followed: a fun night of action marred by oddball booking choices.

Advertisement

Kevin Owens and Seth Rollins fought for the Universal Championship in the main event. As is usually the case with Owens' title reign, the finish came through interference from both Chris Jericho and Stephanie McMahon, who hit ringside with a fresh referee following an ill-timed bump.

You can argue that Stephanie was just doing her duty as a boss, but would she have done the same if the situation was advantageous to Rollins, not Owens? Given her husband Triple H had only just screwed Rollins out of the title in the first place, this seems unlikely.

It was a terrible finish for Owens, who'd only won the belt thanks to Triple H's double-cross in the first place. Now, in his first big PPV defence, KO had once again profited from the actions of others. The major problem here, however, is that the crowd spent the entirety of the match waiting for a Triple H interference that never came. This put a serious dampener on what should've been an excellent match, and prevented the audience from really getting into it. It's a problem that follows Rollins around to this date, and won't go away until him and The Game finally settle their differences.

12. Roadblock: End Of The Line - Best Friends Get Powerbombed

WWE's final pay-per-view ending of 2016 was another damp squib, and a depressingly bland sign-off for what has been an enjoyable year of WWE PPVs. Not only was Roman Reigns vs. Kevin Owens a painfully pedestrian title match, but, as has become common in Raw's main event scene, it ended in shenanigans.

Advertisement

Chris Jericho came to the ring and attacked Owens, his estranged "best friend," with a Codebreaker. Owens retained by disqualification, and the best friends were apparently back together. Remember when Stephanie restarted the Clash main when Reigns got himself disqualified? There was none of that here, but this continuity flub is just the tip of the iceberg.

Jeri-KO celebrated, and Seth Rollins came to the ring. He Pedigree'd Jericho as Reigns speared Owens, and the signed-off by double-powerbombing both Jericho and Rollins before the show went off the air. The match's finish came off contrived, but this was just as bad, and doomed Raw viewers to at least another month of this messy main event feud's continued existence.

Somehow, Reigns and Rollins are best buddies again. They've gone from "awkward allies with common enemies" to brothers in the space of just a few weeks, and none of it makes sense. More than anything else, this PPV ending highlights the short-termism that has plagued WWE's booking practices throughout the PG Era.

11. No Mercy - Wyatt Family Values

If there's one think WWE absolutely hate these days, it's a clean, fair pay-per-view finish. No Mercy certainly wasn't the worst, but the October show's conclusion undoubtedly left a sour taste in the mouth, and it completely flopped with the crowd.

Advertisement

Bray Wyatt vs. Randy Orton was shunted into the main event spot after the WWE Championship match was repositioned as a show opener. The ending would have come off a whole lot better had the duo wrestled a compelling match, but they didn't, and they lost most of the crowd's attention by the time it came around. The feud had lost most of its steam by this point, and Orton vs. Wyatt was a slow, plodding affair.

The lights eventually cut out just as Orton was preparing for an RKO. They came back on, and there was Luke Harper - a face WWE fans hadn't seen for months. This distracted Orton long enough for Wyatt to down him with Sister Abigail, and pick up a longer overdue pay-per-view victory.

The feud, match, and lukewarm reception to Harper's re-emergence all conspired to make this a disappointing ending to a solid PPV. The Wyatt Family have since recovered their lost steam this year, but No Mercy's conclusion was a real low-point in SmackDown's excellent half-year.

10. Royal Rumble - Arise, King Of Kings

The Royal Rumble is supposed to be one of the most exciting events of the wrestling year, but the past few shows have been hugely disappointing. Batista's victory in 2014 was met by universal rejection, as was Roman Reigns in 2015, and this year, WWE showed their hand too early. It was blindingly obvious that Triple H would swoop in and steal Reigns' WWE Championship during the event's titular match, and so it transpired.

Advertisement

Reigns was made to look like Superman throughout the match, and survived a beatdown from the League of Nations that should've kept him sidelined, but didn't. He returned to the ring to "overcome the odds" in typical WWE babyface fashion, and when Triple H's music hit at number 30, he was the only person in the building who was surprised.

WWE tried to build sympathy for Reigns when Triple H, his evil boss, chucked him from the ring, but Reigns' elimination actually garnered one of the year's biggest pops. Hunter might be one of the biggest heels of all-time, but almost everyone becomes a de facto babyface when working with Reigns, and this was proof.

No matter how you dress it up, however, the Royal Rumble concluded with an authority figure as WWE Champion. That's only acceptable from an "anyone but Roman" standpoint, and as The Game celebrated with Stephanie and Vince, the long, bumpy road to WrestleMania was set in stone.

9. Roadblock - Destroyed But Not Defeated

Another pay-per-view, another Triple H title celebration, but Roadblock wasn't quite as hard to swallow as the Royal Rumble. The March PPV was essentially a glorified house show, and while it brought some fun action, it was highly unlikely that anything major would go down. Dean Ambrose was installed as an arbitrary title challenger: everyone knew he didn't have a chance, and that made actually helped the outcome on this occasion.

Advertisement

Ambrose vs. Triple H was no straightforward burial, however. The two worked ridiculously hard, particularly Triple H, and both were made to look strong throughout. Ambrose eventually fell, but he was disallowed a pinfall victory when the referee ruled his foot was under the bottom rope as he scored the 1, 2, 3. He would have been crowned WWE Champion if not for this tiny mistake, and that gave his loss a convenient caveat.

Triple H eventually won with the Pedigree, but he was completely obliterated. Ambrose had beaten the tar out of him, and The Game couldn't even stand as he was declared the winner. He collapsed on the floor outside the ring and crawled up the ramp, selling the damage Dean had done to him, before eventually struggling to his feet. Sure, Roadblock still ended with the title in Triple H's clutches, but this at least put Ambrose's tenacity and effort over.

8. TLC - The Ellsworth Factor

Whether you've enjoyed the James Ellsworth storyline or not, this had to happen sooner or later. Ellsworth is a modern day Colin Delaney, and just as Delaney eventually turned on Tommy Dreamer, Ellsworth was always going to do the same to Dean Ambrose. Doing so in one of the biggest match's of Dean's career amplified the turn's significance, and gave The Lunatic Fringe even more impetus to wreck his former buddy two nights later.

Advertisement

It looked like Ambrose was on his way to victory when Ellsworth struck. Dean had already immobilised Styles and started scaling the ladder, but instead of climbing down the the belt in his hands, Dean went crashing through a stack of tables. Ellsworth's inflated 3-0 record against Styles gave him false confidence, and he knew exactly what he was doing.

WWE had hinted towards Ellsworth's turn in the weeks leading up to Tables, Ladders, and Chairs, and while AJ Styles could have benefited from a stronger means of victory, Ellsworth pushing Ambrose from the ladder worked. Ellsworth's presence in the WWE Title program has been divisive, but TLC set the wheels in the motion for the final chapter: his demolition at Styles' hands on this week's SmackDown. For that, it's at least acceptable.

7. Hell In A Cell - The Queen's Flat Coronation

Hell In A Cell 2016 was a decent pay-per-view, but it should have been so much more. None of the night's three HIAC matches lived up to expectations, with Sasha Banks vs. Charlotte the most disappointing.

Advertisement

This was a historic showdown in a couple of ways. It was the first time two women had ever competed inside the demonic structure, and, more significantly, the first time a women's match had headlined a WWE pay-per-view. For those reasons, Sasha vs. Charlotte earns this relatively high spot on the list, but the finish didn't go over with the crowd at all.

Sasha was fighting in her hometown, but she almost didn't get out of the starting blocks. She was fastened into a stretcher after going through the announce table early on, and while she eventually returned, this booking decision ground the match to a halt. The action that followed Banks' comeback was strong, but they'd already lost steam by that point.

The finish was just as bad. Charlotte threw Sasha against a table twice, but it just wouldn't break. In the end, she settled for a Natural Selection out of nowhere, the referee counted the pinfall, and that was that. Sasha had lost in her hometown, and the crowd were numb to it.

This should have been one of the best matches of Sasha and Charlotte's feud, but it barely breaks the top five. A huge, huge missed opportunity for both women, and WWE as a whole.

6. SummerSlam - Goodnight, Shane

SummerSlam was 2016's most disappointing pay-per-view. With matches like AJ Styles vs. John Cena and Finn Balor vs. Seth Rollins on deck, it looked like WWE were about to deliver the show of the year, and make-up for WrestleMania's disappointment. There were a few highlights (AJ vs. Cena in particular), but sadly, SummerSlam just didn't deliver.

Advertisement

The main event was a violent brawl between Randy Orton and Brock Lesnar. It was a wholly one-sided affair, and after slicing Orton's forehead open with a series of savage elbows, Lesnar was declared the winner via technical knockout. It didn't do Orton's momentum any good, but it painted Lesnar as a dominant force again, particularly after his limp victory over Dean Ambrose at Mania. Not the most technical match you'll ever see, but an outstanding visual.

The post-match saw the officials tend to the battered, beaten Orton, but they weren't alone. SmackDown Commissioner Shane McMahon joined them in aiding his brand's fallen star, but disaster struck. Lesnar took offence to Shane's presence and downed him with a huge F5, closing SummerSlam on a major talking point that was unfortunately never followed-up on. This could have been the catalyst for a huge inter-brand war heading into Survivor Series, but no: Lesnar got away with a light fine, and the incident was never mentioned again.

In a bubble, however, SummerSlam's conclusion was striking, and something nobody saw coming. For those reasons, it rises above the shower of mediocrity that closed most of WWE's PPVs this year.

5. Backlash - AJ Takes The Gold

Here's where things start getting good, and it'd be remiss not to mention AJ Styles' crowning glory towards the top end of the list. There was nothing particularly big or flashy about Backlash's conclusion, but in the context of his career as a whole, AJ Styles' WWE Title celebration is a highly significant moment.

Advertisement

This was the culmination of 18 years of hard work. Styles was initially passed over by WWE when Vince McMahon bought WCW in 2001, and it was clear he'd have to take the long road to the top despite his prodigious talents. That's exactly what he did, and his 11-year run with TNA not only helped put the company on the map, but established him as one of the best wrestlers on the planet.

Styles headed to NJPW in 2014, and for all the great matches he'd had in TNA, this was where he really started taking over the world. Styles soon became one of the company's most important wrestlers, and one of the most reliable big match performers in the world. World class matches with the likes of Shinsuke Nakamura and Minoru Suzuki secured his place at the top of the wrestling mountain, and he hasn't come down since.

AJ made an electric debut in this year's Royal Rumble, but it took until September for him to capture the gold. Still, his Backlash triumph over Dean Ambrose felt like one of the most deserved WWE Title victories in decades. Styles was playing the heel, but it was hard not to feel thrilled for him after such a long journey.

4. Battleground - A Roster United

Few fans knew what to expect heading into Battleground. Roman Reigns was fresh-off a mandatory 30-day suspension for violating the company's Wellness Policy, but WWE had decided against pulling him from his WWE Championship match with Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins. Would the company golden boy be punished for his transgressions and take the loss, or would he predictably pull through and recapture his lost gold?

Advertisement

The answer was clear: Roman Reigns lost cleanly for the second consecutive pay-per-view, and Ambrose's long overdue title reign endured. Dean let Reigns do the dirty work of taking Rollins out before sneaking into the ring and downing him with Dirty Deeds, and while Reigns escaped the doghouse soon after Battleground, fans were elated to see their chosen hero triumph over the guy WWE had spent months begging them to cheer for.

Battleground came to a close with the entire SmackDown roster pouring out from the backstage area. Ambrose's win ensured that the big belt would be heading to Tuesday nights in the Brand Split, and Raw Commissioner Stephanie McMahon was absolutely fuming. As Battleground went off the air, SmackDown was presented as a united front, and, by default, WWE's top brand heading into a bold new era.

3. Extreme Rules - Seth's Grand Return

As far as 2016's great wrestling moments go, it's hard to top Seth Rollins' return. Sure, WWE dropped the ball by having him play heel the very next night on Raw, but Rollins' unexpected appearance set the wrestling world ablaze.

Advertisement

Roman Reigns had just defeated AJ Styles to retain his WWE Championship. It was an outstanding match, one of the year's very best, and while many fans pined for a Styles title run, few could have been disappointed with the contest. It was Reigns' best individual WWE performance to date, and for Styles, another outstanding match in a year full of them.

The night wasn't over, however, and Reigns' celebration wasn't to last. Seth Rollins emerged to a gigantic pop from the crowd, and as he destroyed the WWE Champion with a Pedigree, there wasn't a fan in the building who wasn't on their feet. The Architect was celebrated like a conquering hero, and in that moment, he seemed like the perfect choice to end Reigns' unwanted title reign.

It was the first time Rollins had been in a WWE ring since injuring his knee in November. He'd never lost the WWE Championship in the first place, and this, coupled with the sympathy gained from missing such a prolonged period of action, looked to set him up as WWE's biggest babyface. It's a shame that the full turn didn't transpire until several months later, but that doesn't detract from Extreme Rules' epic conclusion.

2. Money In The Bank - Ambrose Cashes In

Pure euphoria: that's what WWE delivered at Money In The Bank 2016.

Advertisement

This pay-per-view's conclusion delivered on a number of levels, and Seth Rollins ending Roman Reigns' WWE Championship would have closed the show on a high enough note on its own Rollins was the heel heading into the match, but his popularity endured, and he fought like a babyface throughout. It was an odd dynamic, but it absolutely worked, and his clean victory served as a satisfying conclusion to a great match.

The fun didn't stop there, though. Dean Ambrose had won the Money In The Bank briefcase earlier in the evening, and he wasn't going to wait around before cashing in. As Rollins celebrated with the belt he never truly lost, Ambrose jumped him from behind, smashed him with the briefcase, and the match was made.

Less than ten seconds later, Dean Ambrose was WWE Champion. Fans had been crying out for WWE to pull the trigger on him as the company's top champion for years, and they'd finally received their wish. Nobody saw this move coming, even after Dean's triumph in the ladder match earlier, and that's why it came off so well. Wrestling is nothing without its surprises, and this was one of the year's biggest.

1. Survivor Series - Goldberg Shocks The World

Love it or hate it, no singular event sent more shockwaves rippling through the world of wrestling in 2016 than Brock Lesnar's stunning loss to Goldberg.

Advertisement

Survivor Series was absolutely huge. Goldberg, at the age of 49, had made a perfect return to the company. His family-driven motivations were rock solid, his promos were excellent, and the fans accepted him with open arms. Against all odds, Goldberg immediately became the company's biggest babyface, and his rematch with Brock Lesnar suddenly went from something nobody really wanted to see, to something no self-respecting wrestling fan could miss.

There were so many questions heading into the match. Was Goldberg in fighting shape? Would his ageing body be able to withstand Brock's furious onslaught after 12 years away from the ring? How long would Goldberg be able to fight for, and would the match descend to the drudgery of their WrestleMania XX stall-fest?

Something that seemed absolutely unquestionable, however, was the outcome. It was universally assumed that Lesnar would send Goldberg into permanent retirement with a final loss, then move onto the next big challenge. His victory was a sure thing, and the idea of Goldberg coming in and toppling WWE's prized asset seemed laughable beforehand.

But that's exactly what happened, and Goldberg didn't just beat Lesnar: he destroyed him. Two Spears, a Jackhammer, and 85 seconds were all it took to secure the year's most shocking result, and the rivalry looks set to continue through 2017.

Lesnar just didn't take Goldberg seriously, and he paid dearly for it. Sure, his monstrous aura takes a dent from this, but he'll quickly recover his lost momentum. For now, it establishes Goldberg as a legitimate threat heading into the new year, and keeps the company's hottest feud going. There's a very real chance that Goldberg vs. Lesnar could headline WrestleMania 33, and it's all thanks to Survivor Series' closing events.

Advertisement