Ranking Every WWE Survivor Series From Worst To Best

Teams of five strive to survive. Teams of four are a bit of a bore.

By Michael Hamflett /

The late changes to this year's Survivor Series were oddly in keeping with the chaos that engulfed the company exactly one year prior.

Advertisement

Kurt Angle's WWE in-ring return was splurged on a Shield substitute appearance a month prior to him wrestling on the event, Triple H bullied his way into entering and winning the Red Vs Blue headliner for Team Raw, and AJ Styles took the SmackDown Live's top title from Jinder Mahal to write him out of the Survivor Series main event with Brock Lesnar and hopefully out of WWE main event consideration forever.

With any luck, a brand new tradition can form from these two back-to-back bananas builds. Survivor Series stuck around on tradition alone for many years, with a number of events failing to maintain the sort of hype one of the 'Big Four' shows ordinarily orchestrates.

Admittedly, the 2016 Brand Split reflected a turning point in how the shows were structured, but how many of those 'Thanksgiving Classics' in the intervening years lived up to the company's prized billing? Furthermore, how many of them were even better than the notoriously fickle Vince McMahon could have expected when he planned to bin the brand altogether? Some of these cards literally saved the show. Some were sorely missing saviours...

31. 2013

The Good: The Shield (and particularly Roman Reigns) looked awesome in a perfunctory elimination opener. CM Punk and Daniel Bryan had a broadly enjoyable match with The Wyatt Family, but their mere placement in such a placeholder belongs elsewhere in this entry...

Advertisement

The Bad: ...because Bryan was categorically the fans choice for any and every company main event, and Punk wasn't far behind him. For either of them to be d*cking about in the semi-main in November 2013 was inexcusable, and enough to accelerate Punk's expedition to the exit. Bryan's path thankfully went elsewhere.

The Ugly: Undeserving of their spots compared to the white hot 'YES!' man, The Big Show and Randy Orton absorbed relentless abuse during their limp and listless main event. A cheap finish did nothing to temper the tempers, particularly after the World Heavyweight Championship match between John Cena and Alberto Del Rio earlier in the night had been so dull too.

30. 1999

The Good: Chris Jericho and Chyna had what was at that point 'The Ninth Wonder Of The World's best ever match, and 'Y2J's best in the company after a troubled started. They'd have better together, but this above-average effort stuck out more on such a chronic card.

Advertisement

The Bad: The Big Show's decimation of the Big Boss Man's (and his own) team was pathetic, even if it made a sliver more sense later in the show. Considering how hot the weekly product was, this entire card is a disaster area. Assembled teams make absolutely no sense, the contests are heatless and the show-long bait-and switch angle sours just about everything else on the card. And speaking of that...

The Ugly: WWE scripting Stone Cold Steve Austin to bounce off a car as a main event write-off on the night was crass and unusually unprofessional. 'The Rattlesnake' wasn't ever destined to compete, but they ploughed on regardless. Big Show's win didn't do much to satiate the irritation.

29. 2010

The Good: Team Mysterio/Team Del Rio Survivor Series is alright, and is one of the only decent things on the card. Natalya and LayCool have an impressive handicap battle over the Divas Championship in something of a lost classic from the doldrums of the division.

Advertisement

The Bad: John Cena's acting in the deathly dull Randy Orton/Wade Barrett main event was absolutely pitiful. His failure to commit to his time as a Nexus prisoner in 2010 was nearly as big a crime as his SummerSlam squashing of them all earlier in the year. Even when they were winning, they were losing - Heath Slater and Justin Gabriel defeated Santino Marella and Vladimir Kozlov that played out to virtual silence.

The Ugly: It's easy to say WWE of today is no different from how it was nearly 20 years ago, but the dross peppered throughout this show speaks to some huge changes over the last decade. Daniel Bryan tries and fails to force something fun out of Ted Dibiase in the opener, John Morrison defeated Sheamus in a Raw midcard match people had to pay for and Keval blew his NXT Season Two title shot in a failed Intercontinental Championship match with Dolph Ziggler.

28. 2008

The Good: There was a bizarre brilliance about seeing Shawn Michaels team with Rey Mysterio, The Great Khali and Cryme Tyme in the opener, whilst the star-heavy Team Orton/Team Batista match later in the show also offered flashes of brilliance from a beleaguered midcard.

Advertisement

The Bad: John Cena's return from injury fed into his squash victory over Chris Jericho but ended 'Y2J's incredible year with a resounding thud. A Divas Survivor Series match saw the eliminations raced through in order to protect the integrity of those than simply couldn't wrestle the standard required.

The Ugly: Triple H and Vladimir Kozlov contested one of the worst matches in the show's history until Edge took the place of the suspiciously-injured Jeff Hardy in the WWE Championship triple threat. 'The Rated-R Superstar' was booked as a cynical opportunist, but he was for the fans a last-gasp life-saver.

27. 2011

The Good: Madison Square Garden looked different than it had in the past, but at least upheld its reputation for superlative atmosphere. A red hot crowd propelled the CM Punk/Alberto Del Rio WWE Title switch beyond itself, and served as a strong platform for the 'Voice Of The Voiceless' to kick off his 434-day reign.

Advertisement

The Bad: Perhaps complacent due to the expected success of the main event, the entire show seemed like an afterthought. Boring singles matches aren't augmented by a boring Survivor Series match and the Big Show's World Heavyweight Title match with Mark Henry was the boring of their series too.

The Ugly: The Rock and John Cena's "Never Before. Never Again" union was a passable way to give 'The Great One' a dry run before his WrestleMania 28 match against 'The Champ', but the pair acted as if opponents Miz and R-Truth weren't even out there with them. Reduced to less-than jobber level, Awesome Truth's game effort to get themselves over in the build-up was almost entirely for nought when the bell rang.

26. 2014

The Good: The Team Authority/Team Cena main event had huge drama even if the twist in the middle reeked (more on that later). Sting's debut for the company was mind blowing for longterm fans, especially those blissfully unaware of how the story between him and Triple H would conclude at the following year's WrestleMania. The Miz and Damien Mizdow winning the Tag Team Titles was a great decision for the hugely over act.

Advertisement

The Bad: Nikki Bella beating AJ Lee in 0:33 was great for the heat, but a disappointment considering what they perhaps could have achieved together. Bray Wyatt's boring battle with Dean Ambrose was by then frustratingly typical form from 'The Eater Of Worlds'.

The Ugly: Adam Rose and his Bunny mascot Vs Slator-Gater (Heath Slater and Titus O'Neil) had no place on any wrestling show, let alone the fourth biggest WWE one of the year. Nor did yet another illogical Big Show turn. He'd been repeatedly reduced to tears just a year earlier - this felt like a fire escape for the company so keen to protect John Cena even when he wasn't booked to be on the losing side.

25. 1991

The Good: Ric Flair is in sublime form in the opener, recoiling in horror at having to face any of the babyfaces across the ring from him. His slimy, slithering victory vindicates his canny cowardice. His reptilian actions were perhaps to replace the lack of a King Cobra on the show - Jake Roberts' snake had been banned after sinking its teeth into Randy Savage's arm just days before the show. Uncensored highlights of the incident justified the price of the show alone...

Advertisement

The Bad: ...but not when it became apparent that it was a commercial for the match rather than the location. The company using the event to plug an experimental 'This Tuesday In Texas' mini-pay-per-view was insulting to the paying crowd. That they utilised the hottest angle in the company and the WWE Championship reflects how desperate they were for it to succeed.

The Ugly: Undertaker's WWE Title win over Hulk Hogan is absolutely abysmal, particularly considering the intention to have their rematch just days later. Less than nothing happens before 'Taker cheats to win and the company goes into meltdown to help 'The Hulkster'.

24. 2000

The Good: Typically secure in his role as the industry's true top breakout star by that point, The Rock puts in a world class selfless display to try and salvage something from the reckless Rikishi heel turn. Doing for him what Stone Cold Steve Austin and Triple H couldn't and wouldn't, 'The Great One' lives up to his name yet again in a surprisingly scintillating encounter.

Advertisement

The Bad: Conversely, Austin and Hunter can't. Their lethargic brawl runs and runs without reason until they spill out to the parking lot after 25 minutes for the absurd show-closing visual of 'The Rattlesnake' dropping a trapped Triple H to the ground from a crane. As bad as it sounds.

The Ugly: Kane and Chris Jericho couldn't summon interest in a match that infamously came together after 'Y2J' spilt coffee on 'The Big Red Machine'. The Undertaker looked ridiculous in Godfather's borrowed snakeskin trousers, shamelessly dominating Kurt Angle for the second time that year before an inventive finish spared his blushes in defeat.

23. 2015

The Good: The New Day, King Barrett and Sheamus were hilarious together, and added energy to a contest that ultimately ended up match of the night. So little had any importance on this card, but the heels at least created a reason to care even if the match was otherwise entirely stake-less.

Advertisement

The Bad: WWE were thrown a creative bone when Seth Rollins got injured, but the tournament for the vacant title wasn't half dull. The cash-in became part of a grander plan, but the lack of drama for something so high stakes was notably disconcerting.

The Ugly: The Undertaker yet again confirmed how fast his time had past with the second squash of Bray Wyatt that year. The Brothers Of Destruction bulldozed The Wyatt Family in yet another catastrophic night for 'The Deadman's supposed spiritual successor.

22. 1994

The Good: The Teamsters/Bad Guys opener is one of the best in the show's history, setting a grand stage for the Diesel/Shawn Michaels break-up in a way that also masks 'HBK's broken hand throughout. Kevin Nash looks ready to change the industry as he bulldozes through the babyfaces - it's easy to see why Vince McMahon was so keen.

Advertisement

The Bad: Bret Hart's WWE Championship loss to Bob Backlund isn't for everybody. There's some supreme character work from Owen Hart late in the match, but the laboured approach and lengthy submission stretched patience and believability at time.

The Ugly: Save for an excellent moment in which Jerry Lawler responds to a chicken-fight challenge from Doink and Dink by scaling one of his own miniature 'Kings', the Royal Family/Clowns R Us match is a calamity only McMahon himself could possibly find funny. Truthfully, his laughs on commentary didn't even sound that forced.

Advertisement