The Undertaker: Every Reinvention Ranked Worst To Best

From the Phenom to the American Badass, via MMA, Big Evil and the Ministry of Darkness.

By Karl Keely /

There is no one in the history of professional wrestling who can match the Undertaker for longevity at the top of one company.

Advertisement

For 30 years, 'Taker was a headline act in WWE, clashing with the biggest names of multiple generations. Hulk Hogan, Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels, Mick Foley, Steve Austin, The Rock, Triple H, Ric Flair, John Cena, Brock Lesnar, CM Punk; all had classic battles with the Deadman. No one can claim this level of consistency and success with one promotion.

One of the keys to the Phenom's unparalleled success was his ability to reinvent and tweak his character, preventing it from ever becoming too stale. Upon signing with the WWF in late-1990 after an uninspiring run in WCW as 'Mean' Mark Callous, nobody could have predicted that the real-life Mark Calaway would still be a headline act in 2020. His constant adjustments to his costume, in-ring style or storyline motives kept him fresh and at the top of the industry even if they did not always change the character for the better.

From his very first reinvention from 'Mean' Mark to the zombie-like Deadman at Survivor Series 1990, the Undertaker made sure to never stick with one presentation for too long, creating a long and storied career that fully deserves its place as the headline inductee into the 2022 WWE Hall of Fame.

10. Purple Glove Undertaker

For over three years following his debut, the Undertaker did little to change his gimmick or in-ring style but remained one of the most popular stars in the WWF. Overcome by injuries and needing a break, he disappeared after Royal Rumble 1994. In his absence, another person whom manager Ted DiBiase claimed to be the Undertaker began appearing on television in the original grey gloves and boots of the Phenom. Paul Bearer would soon announce that his Undertaker would return to face the imposter at SummerSlam.

Advertisement

If anyone was in doubt as to how fans would distinguish between the two, they found their answer when Paul Bearer introduced an Undertaker who had swapped grey for purple. He shortly destroyed the fake Undertaker and would continue to sport the purple and black colour scheme for the next two years.

Only a minor change in colour design, Purple Glove Undertaker saw no changes in 'Taker's in-ring style which stayed slow and pondering until his 1996 feud with Mankind. Other than distinguishing the Undertaker from his imposter, this changed little in the character.

9. Ministry of Darkness Undertaker

Still one of the WWF's top stars as the Attitude Era propelled the company ahead of WCW, the Undertaker became a bad guy again in the latter half of 1998 for the first time in nearly seven years. Reuniting with Paul Bearer, he became the leader of a cult, recruiting many of 'Taker's real life friends to create the Ministry of Darkness, a collection of mostly renamed disciples who did the Undertaker's evil bidding.

Advertisement

Often appearing in robes and on a throne, this Undertaker spoke in tongues, tried to marry a young Stephanie McMahon and crucified people on a symbol. With jet black hair and a double-pointed goatee, it was the most demonic version of the Undertaker character although it often crossed the line into absurdity and sometimes went too far down the route of bad taste.

By this time 'Taker was suffering from a multitude of injuries endured as a result of working hard to bring the WWF back to the top of the business, and the quality of his matches with frequent opponents The Rock and Stone Cold Steve Austin decreased with each month.

Ministry of Darkness Undertaker would earn a third WWF Championship for the Phenom but necessitated an abrupt change in character when he would return from a lengthy injury layoff.

8. Mohawk Undertaker

By the early-2010s, Undertaker ceased to be a full-time performer for WWE. With his WrestleMania undefeated streak growing in legend, he became a key part of the biggest show of the year, often reappearing in January to start his feud for that year's show before disappearing for most of the following twelve months. Each return would bring a slight tweak to his attire or persona, but the most arresting was his appearance against Triple H at WrestleMania 28.

Advertisement

The pair had battled the previous year as HHH looked to do what his best friend Shawn Michaels couldn't and end the streak, but had failed. A rematch was set, this time billed as an 'End of an Era' and inside the Hell In A Cell. Anticipation was high for the encounter as the two legends faced off. 'Taker then surprised everyone by removing his hood in dramatic fashion, revealing a shaved mohawk in place of his customary long locks.

Although he would shortly grow his hair back, the reveal was stark and terrifying, adding another level of intensity to his character and performance. That it seemed to make the Undertaker look younger than he had in recent appearances was another positive, making Mohawk Undertaker a brief but memorable reinvention.

7. Phantom of the Opera Undertaker

A prime example of Undertaker's impeccable ability to adapt to any environment or circumstance came in October 1995. Mabel had been enjoying a run as a main event heel, but was developing a habit of injuring the stars he faced. He did the same to the Undertaker, smashing the Deadman's orbital bone in a match. With the autumn of 1995 being a low point in WWF history, the company could not afford for 'Taker to take too much time off.

Advertisement

As a result, he returned at Survivor Series with a protective mask. Revealing the Phantom of the Opera-like covering before his elimination match against Mabel and his team, the threatening face piece only added to the character's mystique, terrifying his opponents.

Sporting the mask for only a couple of months, there was a sense of disappointment when he removed the mask following the 1996 Royal Rumble. That event had seen him take on Bret Hart for the WWF Championship in the longest and most intriguing bout of 'Taker's career so far, a sign of the higher in-ring quality shortly to come from the Phenom.

Although Phantom of the Opera Undertaker lasted only a brief time, it is fondly remembered; a sign of Undertaker's ability to take any situation and make it a success.

6. Return of the Deadman Undertaker

Taking time off over the winter of 2003-4, the Undertaker returned at WrestleMania XX with old manager Paul Bearer in tow to face his storyline brother Kane. The event was notable as it saw a much-anticipated return to his Phenom character after four years as the motorcycle-riding American Badass and Big Evil.

Advertisement

He entered Madison Square Garden to the bells and organ of the classic version, with druids lighting the way, much as they had done in his previous WrestleMania match against Kane six years earlier. Back in a long leather coat for his entrance, his hat was now much more of a cowboy style, demonstrating a hangover from his American Badass days. Appearance-wise, it was a subtle yet welcome update of the traditional Undertaker character fans had been longing for.

One element of this return to the old days was the revival of the classic Undertaker vs. Large and Strange Monster trope. Characters such as Heidenreich were created to be larger than life opponents for the Undertaker to destroy. As with the original run of similar foes in the early '90s, this led to poor matches from an in-ring standpoint, as well as incredulous storylines that undid some of the good work 'Taker had done in rebuilding his reputation as Big Evil.

This return to the Deadman started well but soon ran out of steam, ultimately making it a disappointment.

5. American Badass Undertaker

This was the most dramatic of the Undertaker's reinventions. Returning to the WWF in May 2000 after an eight month absence, 'Taker kept his name but changed everything else about his character. No longer an undead zombie, he was a motorcycle-riding, denim-wearing Texan. His return in the closing moments of Judgment Day 2000 was wholly unexpected, his hair back to its natural colour, sporting a bandana and sunglasses and minus the classic Undertaker theme music.

Advertisement

'Taker's mystical powers had disappeared; he spoke like a regular man, letting his native Texan accent take over, and he had feuds that involved his real life wife of the time. It added layers of humanity to the ice cold Phenom of the previous decade. Although the overblown insanity of his Ministry of Darkness incarnation needed correcting, this was such an abrupt change that it resulted in the character losing some of its unparalleled mystique.

Yet to return to his physical condition of 1997, the American Badass often did not deliver in the ring. In addition, it was during this period that Undertaker easily defeated rising stars such as Kurt Angle and Rikishi, as well as decimating any member of the WCW Invasion he encountered. Such annihilations seemed more acceptable when portraying the supernatural Deadman, but as a supposedly regular American, these hammerings became frustrating.

Certainly a memorable change due to its boldness, the decreasing match quality and demolition of exciting talent put this reinvention squarely in the middle rank.

4. The American Deadman Undertaker

The Undertaker's move into cinematic wrestling with his Boneyard Match against AJ Styles at WrestleMania 36 to date seems to have been his final match. Fittingly, he unveiled another new interpretation of his character for this last ride. Although he may have only used this version of the Undertaker in one match - and one without fans to experience it - it was full of meaning for those who had followed his progress over the previous thirty years.

Advertisement

'Taker arrived on a motorcycle ala the American Badass, and sported a leather waistcoat that fit that period of his career more. Yet the cinematic nature of the encounter allowed 'Taker to use the magic and horror of his classic Deadman persona. Shooting fire, destroying druids, and seemingly transporting out of graves, it had all the classic elements of the supernatural Undertaker, albeit in the bodily shape of a 55-year-old tired gunslinger. Due to the recorded nature of the clash, Undertaker did not appear tired or lagging in comparison to a Styles who was at the top of his game, further helping the Phenom have a dignified and satisfactory final encounter.

Encapsulating the different aspects of thirty years of character development, this American Deadman creation allowed for a fitting combination of the best elements of 'Taker's numerous reinventions. If the Boneyard Match does prove to be his final match, this summation of elements from his character's journey was a fitting way to end an unmatched career.

3. Teardrop Undertaker

The Undertaker was reinvigorated in 1996 by his feud with Mick Foley's Mankind character. The pair fought each other for a good portion of 1996, creating some classic matches that were much different to the formulaic and plodding matches 'Taker had taken part in since his debut. Adding new speed and aggression to his in-ring work, he would by the end of the year add a new look as well.

Advertisement

After being buried alive at the October In Your House, Undertaker returned at Survivor Series for one more match with his nemesis. Descending from the rafters at Madison Square Garden with bat wings spread wide, 'Taker had ditched his trademark gloves, boots and hat, instead going for a leather outfit and most noticeably a prominent black teardrop painted on his face.

Indeed, although the teardrop makeup seemed somewhat out of place for such a threatening character, this period of the Undertaker's career saw his greatest in-ring work to date. His clashes with Mankind, Bret Hart and in particular his classic bout with Shawn Michaels in the inaugural Hell In A Cell were excellent and a far cry from the plodding repetition of his early '90s matches with an array of monsters. Combined with excellent storytelling in his feuds with Michaels and Kane, Teardrop Undertaker was one of the character's best periods, redefining what the character and man was capable of.

2. Big Evil Undertaker

Following the WCW/ECW Invasion angle of 2001, the WWF looked to change up its product and tried to arrest their declining numbers. Many wrestlers changed allegiances or gimmicks, defeated WCW stars began to slowly reappear on television, and new stars were being tried out. Prominent amongst the changes was the Undertaker turning heel again. Aligning himself with Vince McMahon, Undertaker did not return completely to his Deadman persona, but added a more demonic side to his American Badass character.

Advertisement

Ruthless and brutal, 'Taker kept his hair short for the first time, adding to the no-nonsense character he was now playing. Destroying Maven after being eliminated from the Royal Rumble, kidnapping Ric Flair's son David in order to get a WrestleMania match with the Nature Boy, and dragging Hulk Hogan through the backstage area tied to his bike, 'Taker's new edge earned him another WWE Championship.

More importantly, after the visible physical issues that had plagued the American Badass and Ministry of Darkness versions of the character, the Undertaker began to get leaner and more agile again. His encounters with Flair, a young Brock Lesnar and memorably a Ladder match against Jeff Hardy were the best he had participated in since the Teardrop Undertaker days of 1997. After a huge section of the fanbase had become disenchanted with him over the previous few years, Big Evil ensured that the Undertaker would remain a popular and respected character, something that had not look guaranteed in the early 2000s.

1. MMA Undertaker

Around the mid-2000s, the Undertaker got into the best shape of his career, and adapted his in-ring style to match his increased athleticism. A big fan of MMA, 'Taker added a triangle choke to his repertoire of finishing moves, and began wearing the padded gloves associated with professional fighters. He also transitioned into regularly wearing a singlet top, showing off his leaner and muscularly defined frame. Still sporting his trademark hat and overcoat on the way to the ring, once the bell rang the Undertaker had reinvented his style again to keep up with new trends.

Advertisement

Having classics with the likes of Kurt Angle, Batista and Shawn Michaels, the change in style and conditioning led to the best in-ring period of 'Taker's career. Looking on the verge of breaking down in the early part of the decade, he was now one of the most consistent workers in the company, and added three more World Titles to his name before the end of the decade as well as establishing the WrestleMania streak as a key part of each year's event.

Updating the Undertaker character cosmetically to maintain the original idea of the Deadman whilst excelling inside the ropes, MMA Undertaker was not the most dramatic reinvention of his career, but the one with greatest overall success.

Advertisement