THIS Was The Most Genius Wrestling Angle In Modern History

Drunk on inspiration.

By Michael Sidgwick /

Lee South/AEW

All Elite Wrestling was founded on the very first day of 2019 to jubilant expectation.

Advertisement

On the very last day of 2019, it faced, if not a crisis, then certainly its biggest challenge ahead of the unopposed Homecoming New Year's Day show.

The moving, massive-feeling spectacle that was Double Or Nothing, with its superb stylistic in-ring range, informed a level of hype that saw AEW Dynamite race ahead in the so-called Wednesday Night War. Those first six weeks of Dynamite were widely and lavishly praised for an instant mastery of episodic television: match quality was high; match selection was purposeful; the angles were white-hot, and several new faces got over within their perfect balance; Cody and Chris Jericho sold the living sh*t out of Full Gear with some of the greatest promo work witnessed on U.S. TV in nearly two decades; the Inner Circle Vs. The Elite feud was a superb umbrella programme that created a sense of cohesion between and across each show.

Advertisement

AEW Dynamite was a vibrant, molten show not without niggling issues - but as a big picture extravaganza, it was an artful blockbuster. And then Full Gear happened.

An incredible pay-per-view, AEW took an age to reset after it. The first glimpses of the next big World Title programme, Chris Jericho Vs. Jon Moxley, materialised as functional, silent show-downs and expositional, long promo segments not unlike that presented by WWE. Cody Vs. MJF spluttered into existence with two botched and mystifying segments, and while it made far more sense in retrospect, the execution of the Butcher and the Blade's debut was worrying, as well as piss-poor. AEW was meant to be the intelligent pro wrestling company with its finger on the pulse. How did they not sense the inevitable anti-climax?

Advertisement

CONT'D...(1 of 6)

AEW

The iconically awful Nightmare Collective was total vanity nepotism amateur hour. The Dark Order - genuinely, an inspired gimmick concept within the win/loss rankings framework that is only just connecting - resolutely failed to connect back then with its overtly cartoonish presentation. Certain matches - like Private Party Vs. Santana and Ortiz - made grimly clear the gulf in standards and pressure between a small indie and the nationally televised stage. At best, the praise directed towards the Women's division was faint and condescending: They're trying something with Kris Statlander, and while the gimmick is rubbish, the work is good!

Advertisement

For an apparent downfall, at its best, Dynamite remained a very good pro wrestling television show in December. The Young Bucks brought the match quality, even when ravaged by the flu. MJF cut a wicked promo on Cody to finally throw a match on that tinderbox. Kenny Omega and Hangman Page, in the very first beat of their storyline, demonstrated an expert level of organic, subtle in-ring acting to open up a mystery.

But even the fanatical base couldn't reconcile that product with the vision for and name of 'All Elite Wrestling'. There was a White Album-esque derangement to it all - an unfocused creative tension that yielded stunning wrestling and indulgent bullsh*t alike.

Advertisement

If Dynamite was too good a show to jump the shark, the events of December 18 hardly felt like it. It was a show so infamous in its poor reception that the words "Corpus Christi" are seared into the memory.

CONT'D...(2 of 6)

Advertisement
Twitter (@AEWrestling)

At the climax of a fabulous Young Bucks Vs. SCU sprint, the Dark Order entered the ring. Evil Uno reached into the throat of Matt Jackson, with palpably fake blood over his hands, and said, reading the room about as well as the competition AEW were so quick to banter off, "You'll never doubt us again". Kenny Omega, Cody and Dustin Rhodes appeared to make the save. All were battered - by enhancement talents in cheap masks trained to work punches by Shane McMahon - in what was a suitable, humiliating visual metaphor for how far this closing segment literally missed the mark. In the case of Omega, it was closer to Steve Austin taking a kicking from the Brood than it wasn't.

Advertisement

AEW President Tony Khan, in a series of since-deleted tweets summarised by Voices of Wrestling, provided a fascinating glimpse into a creative restructuring process over the Christmas period. After much "soul-searching," Khan took full editorial control of the booking. He remained receptive to ideas, in what continued to be a collaboration, but tethered everything together and demanded final say.

The Homecoming show was massive.

Advertisement

In a very rare strategic misfire - WWE is, if nothing else, exceptional at being cunning - they didn't run an NXT show on New Year's Day. That night's Dynamite ran unopposed. After a defeat to NXT in the overall viewership ratings and, for the first time, the 18-49 demo on December 18, this represented a major opportunity to both reclaim a divided audience and restore its image. The fake blood and hokey presentation of December 18 was only a surface issue; the angle lowered the Elite to the Dark Order's painfully midcard level, which was the opposite of its intention. This followed several high-profile defeats suffered by Cody, Omega, the Young Bucks and Hangman Page. To many, the talent that was so bright with star power that they made AEW remotely viable in the first instance were no longer stars.

CONT'D...(3 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

This needed addressing, and in this reactive, insta-take culture of a war, the momentum shifts in which fluctuated wildly, across November and December, AEW ideally needed to address it in two hours of television. AEW needed to somehow rehabilitate the auras of four stars in two hours.

Advertisement

The Homecoming show required not just a big, positive headline, but a deft series of masterstrokes. It wasn't enough to book the various members to win what amounted to exhibition matches on a show with a feel-good vibe. AEW serves a more knowing audience with a limited capacity for transparent carny booking. They'd have seen the strings. And besides, this wasn't a spot show. This was episodic television. It functions, every week, to make you watch the next episode. There are no happy endings in episodic television - it is rule - and yet Tony Khan had to book a happy ending.

He did, one that doubled as an intriguing episodic story beat, in the cleverest, best, and most effective show-long angle of the modern era.

Advertisement

The Homecoming show, filmed in front of a packed and beautifully unusual Daily's Place, started with a melodramatic video that asked the exact same question of the audience that the audience had asked of AEW: Are the Elite still Elite?

CONT'D...(4 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW/Lee South

This was crucial. Instantly, AEW put an arm around its audience.

Advertisement

The booking was in sync with them. It was at once reassuring and dramatic, striking the perfect balance of tone. No drama is boring, but genuine anxiety is miserable. AEW had targeted the exact root of the problem, and aimed to correct it while casting doubt over whether they would.

In the first match, Cody defeated Darby Allin in a tremendously worked, closely-contested styles clash that built impeccably on their previous encounter at Fyter Fest. Cody won, to strengthen him ahead of his match with MJF. In an inspired bit of booking, one that informed a fantastic programme and virtually guaranteed a ratings victory on the respective Dynamite shows, MJF set out his horrifying list of stipulations that Cody had to meet in order to face him at Revolution. He couldn't touch him, he had to defeat the massive Wardlow in a steel cage, and he had to take ten straps of a whip.

Advertisement

To answer the question posed in the cold open, Cody was still Elite - but was mere weeks away from a segment that would challenge his aura, only this time in the careful fiction of the story.

In the main event, Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks faced PAC, Fénix and Pentagon, Jr. This was an incredibly inspired match because it was guaranteed to be a pulsating exhibition of the Elite's talent - a glorious reminder of how great they are. And it was: Kenny Omega, in a very challenging position, had to put himself over as the best wrestler on the planet. With a viciousness precise even by the standards of his explosive physical timing, he went ballistic, smashing the sh*t out of the future Death Triangle in a stunning performance in which he played, and played convincingly, the role of clutch player. Omega starred in a total banger emblematic of both AEW and the stable it was named after. The idea was that, by restoring the vision of AEW, AEW fans would restore their faith.

Advertisement

But that's not all it had to be.

CONT'D...(5 of 6)

Advertisement
AEW

This match had to drop a hook, and it did; the drunken Hangman Page, on commentary, was a slurring, aloof delight. He was piss funny in the role, and in the sort of infinitesimal comedic touch for which he has become known, he was introduced, in '90s sitcom intro fashion, "caught" off-guard with a big, dumb, beaming smile on his face. This was a lowkey crucial touch. It was designed to amuse the audience, and get Page over with them as a relatable figure. After the match, he was beckoned to ringside by the Elite, but he waved them away. He wasn't considered good enough for the match, so why bother?

Advertisement

The show went off the air with the Elite fraying the very second they had become whole. Instantly, the seed was planted for the civil war saga that enraptured fans ahead of and at Revolution - a brand new and textured conflict realised with a banger of a wrestling match and a meme-able still image. The finger was on the pulse, and the blood was pumping.

That title may read as hyperbolic, but it isn't. If anything, "effective" sells it short; on the strength of the reception of the Homecoming show, the anticipation it drove ahead of Revolution, and its big demo number, AEW and TNT struck a renegotiated deal. AEW secured its medium-term future via a very lucrative rights fee.

Advertisement

An artistic triumph and a huge, money-drawing angle, this proved that the future of professional wrestling need not look bleak, homogenised nor monopolised.