WWE is the biggest wrestling organisation in the world, of that there can be no doubt. WCW ran it close for a few years in the late 1990's, but ultimately Vince McMahon prevailed. Now, granted, this has led to a little complacency on WWE's part, as Vince has always worked best when he has had major competition or his back was up against the wall. But even when things were going better than they are today (and we needn't worry about WWE going out of business any time soon) they haven't always been successful in everything that they have done. Yes, in life you have to take chances - calculated risks, if you will - but WWE has made some decisions that over the years have made people sit up and, along with Stone Cold Steve Austin, say "What?" We're going to look at ten of the biggest flops in WWF/E history - in and out of the ring - and see if anything could have been done to rescue these creative mishaps. (For reference, we will not be including the Gobbledegooker, Isaac Yankem DDS or Papa Shango's special effects -these are always included in any flops list; this one is intended to be more thought provoking.)
10. ECW
Let's get a few things straight. I was a big fan of Paul Heyman's original incarnation of ECW. No, they didn't always get everything right, but it was awesome for its time. Fast forward to 2006 and Vince McMahon, after a successful ECW One Night Stand PPV the year before, decides to launch ECW as a third brand within WWE. It was given a one hour time slot on the Sci-Fi/Syfy channel and Paul Heyman was given creative control (of sorts). So far, so good..... I remember being in America in July & August2006, and watching a particular episode on August 1st which featured the debut of CM Punk. It also featured a main event of Batista v Big Show getting booed out of the building on live TV. Oh how I laughed......But only for a little while. Vince's ECW was never what Heyman thought it would be. Slowly but surely the brand was diluted and ratings went down. Heyman quit (or was fired, take your pick) after the disastrous December to Dismember PPV and the show eventually became a version of what we now know as NXT - it featured up and coming performers, with a few veterans thrown in for good measure. It was finally taken off the air in early 2010. Could anything have been done to make ECW a viable brand within WWE for the long term? Unfortunately, I don't really think so. As we will see in later pages, if something isn't Vince's idea it eventually is done away with. Many fans were left wondering what could have been. But what's that old expression about rose-tinted spectacles?
9. The WBF
The first time I became aware of the WBF was when I saw Lex Luger being interviewed at WrestleMania VIII. I knew from magazines in 1992 that he had been in WCW, so why was he in the WBF? Long story short - a no-compete clause. But I set about finding out what the WBF was. Anyone who knows anything about Vince McMahon knows that he is a fan of big, muscular wrestlers. But as with so many things, he felt the need to prove himself as more than just a wrestling promoter. So he founded the WBF to compete with the IFBB.. He tried everything to make it successful -Regis Philbin co-hosting the first event, Bobby Heenan commentating, giving each bodybuilder a 'persona' - but to no avail. It lasted less than 18 months from its original inception, folding in July 1992. What could have been done to make it better? Not doing it in he first place. Had Vince concentrated more on his in-ring product then we wouldn't have been left with the dark days of the early 1990's WWF.
8. Rikishi Revealed As The Mystery Driver
Picture the scene - it's 1999. Steve Austin, the hottest wrestler in the WWF is injured and can't wrestle in the scheduled main event of Survivor Series. Do you tell the fans and risk less PPV buys? Since when are promoters 100% honest? So, that's a no. Do you write him out on the Raw the week before, allowing time for the fans to buy into hi replacement in the triple threat match? No, that would also risk the buy rate, so we'll keep on promoting him for the match even though he isn't going to be doing it. I know what we can do! We can have him run down by a car backstage during the event - after the fans have paid for the PPV - and then replace him. not with the then up-and-coming babyface Test (a story for another time) but with Big Show. This will make for intriguing television..... Some fans were into the storyline - until long time mid-carder Rikishi was revealed as the driver. Rikishi? Really? Although the reasons to create the storyline were out of WWF's control - Austin was injured - at least they could have used it to promote the next big thing looking for a shot. Instead it was Rikishi. Even worse, he was later shown to have just been a pawn of HHH's. It was a colossal waste of everyone's time.
7. Razor Ramon & Diesel Mark II
Speaking of colossal wastes of time... This gimmick was brought about after Scott Hall & Kevin Nash left the WWF to join WCW in 1996. Vince decided to show them who was the boss, and that it wasn't the performers who made the personae work but the personae who made the wrestlers - and as he was the creative force in the WWF, he was the star maker! Jim Ross was by now a full blown heel and it was said that he was bringing Razor & Diesel back. Once it was seen that the new Razor (Rick Bognor) and Diesel (Glenn 'Kane' Jacobs) weren't getting over, they were quickly dropped (within 4 months to be exact). In fact, not getting over might be an understatement - the gimmick totally bombed. What could have done to save this? When it was brought to the drawing board it should have been rubbed out! I know Vince McMahon isn't one to take defeat (or in this case defection) sitting down, but he should have just ignored it and concentrated on his own product.
6. Divas Musical Chairs
Some of you will remember the first incarnation of WWE musical chairs. It was in 2004 and the premise was that the winner would receive a title shot of their choice. It was 'saved' - if that is the right term to use - by the charisma and personality of Ric Flair. Although won by Chris Jericho, Flair was the greatest turn in the game, and it went down well with the crowd and achieved cult status amongst fans. Fast forward to November 2013, and on 'Raw is Country' we had a WWE Divas version of musical chairs. A cult segment with the added bonus of attractive women. What could be better, right? Actually many things could be...... This version was designed to cross promote a song. It was a train wreck. It needs to be seen to be believed. They didn't know which way to go around the chairs. They didn't seem to be aware of who was being eliminated when (other than Natalya). JBL, on commentary (no doubt straight from Vince), said "This is the dumbest thing I've ever seen." It broke down at the end into a massive 'brawl' between the women left in the ring. It was just a colossal flop, and a waste of TV time. (Musical chairs was also used on the all female season of NXT, but it was designed to humiliate the women involved.) How could this segment have been saved? By being axed from the Raw script and never seeing the light of day.....
5. The Higher Power
Some of the angles on this list started out as intriguing. To cut a long story sort, in late 1998 the Undertaker turned into an evil, power hungry character, which for a short time the WWE tried to say was the gimmick meeting real life, and Mark Callaway had gone mad. The 'Ministry of Darkness' was formed, and he systematically recruiting his followers, or 'Acolytes'. He feuded with Kane and Steve Austin, but alluded to there being a 'Higher Power' that he was working for. This led to many great angles on TV and much speculation amongst fans as to who this new character would be. Would it be a new wrestler to the WWE to feud with Steve Austin? Would it be, as many people thought, Jake 'the snake' Roberts, to play off their King of the Ring match a couple of years before? Whatever the result, at least it would create a fresh new min-event rivalry, right? Wrong. To effectively stick it to fans and show them they didn't know as much as they thought they did, in June 1999 Vince McMahon revealed himself to be the 'Higher Power'. Fans around the world groaned their disapproval. Fans in the arena booed - not because Vince was a 'heel' but because they were expecting a reveal of more thought. Something so promising delivered, in the end, so little.
4. Replacing Jim Ross With John Laurinaitis
At first glance, this might seem like a strange choice, but let me elaborate. For a long time Jim Ross had headed up the WWE recruitment/talent relations. He looked for athletic performers, many with a background in amateur wrestling, who could be viewed as potential WWE main-eventers. Amongst others, he helped recruit Brock Lesnar and Shelton Benjamin. He was also pivotal in the signing of many female performers - and although knowing Vince's preference for attractive women for his Divas division, Ross also stressed the need for athletic prowess and wrestling fundamentals. When John Laurinaitis was hired by the WWE in 2001 after the collapse of WCW, it was always with a view to replacing Ross. He wasn't as thorough in the way he conducted himself in the job as Ross was - although his supporters wold just say he was doing it differently. His way of recruiting? That guy has an awesome body, we'll take him. Can he wrestle? Who knows. Divas? He would literally flick through swimwear catalogues looking for young, beautiful women and contact their agents. Don't believe me? How do you think Kelly Kelly got into the industry? Not all of his hires were awful, but he had a lot more his than misses. Jim Ross did his homework thoroughly, making sure that the individual would be a good fit. Laurinaitis acted on a whim more often than not. For a long time WWE suffered in this aspect of their business. Hopefully their new developmental facility, NXT, will help alleviate the problem.
3. The XFL
Lets see if much of this sounds eerily similar to the WBF. Vince wants to prove he is much more than a wrestling promoter, so he sets about forming a new American Football League. in 2000, along with his partner, NBC, the XFL is born. With less rules, more showbiz and a lot of viewer friendly initiatives, Vince thought he was set to take over the sorts world. How wrong he was. Despite a good first week's viewing figures, it steadily declined. WWE an NBC lost an estimated $35million each. And with Vince giving so much of his time to turning it around, that meant that he had taken his eye of the WWE ball (if you pardon the pun!). Creatively, the WWE was not strong at this time. Coincidence? It must be said, however, that as big as a creative and financial flop as the XFL was it left a couple of positive legacies for the NFL: it popularised 'sky-cam' and produced many players who would play in the NFL, several going on to win a Super Bowl ring.
2. Hornswoggle As Vince's Son
Much like the 'Higher Power' scenario, this angle started off interesting and finished with a fizzle rather than a bang. 2007 was a dark year for wrestling, in many ways. One of the reasons was Vince's 'throw everything at the wall and see what sticks' mentality. In August of 2007, Vince was informed of a paternity suit, alleging that he had fathered a child outside of his marriage to Linda. The build up was that it was a male member of the WWE roster. Then the angle hit a snag.... The internet picked up on the fact that it was scheduled to be Mr.Kennedy (that being Vince's middle name) and that it would elevate Kennedy to the top of the WWE , feuding with Vince then subsequently siding with him. At least this would give us a new name in main-events, and Kennedy would be given the chance to sink or swim at the top of the card. But Vince didn't like that word had got out, so he changed his mind. Which led us to Hornswoggle....... Honestly, Vince, you only cut off your nose to spite your face, as the saying goes. You could have created a potential money storyline, but no. Childish, very childish........
1. WCW Invasion
Probably the biggest flop of them all - and much of the blame must be laid at the feet of Vince McMahon. And yet, it started so promisingly..... When WCW went under in March 2001 Vince bought it with the intention of running it as a separate entity entirely, with its own TV show (the SmackDown slot had been earmarked), talent, announcers, etc. But to start it all off, he had to introduce the WCW wrestlers to his audience. Lance Storm was the first to invade Raw. then we had the likes of Booker T, who debuted by attacking Steve Austin. So far, so good..... Until the now infamous Raw min event of Buff Bagwell and Booker T (complete with the WCW announce team of Scott Hudson and Arn Anderson). It bombed massively. Vince had told his audience for years that WCW sucked, so why would they suddenly want to watch it? The fan in the arena booed the match, making Vince to sharply change tack, turn all WCW heel, combine them with the ECW wrestlers and feud against all of the WWF/E wrestlers. Just like that, 18months of storylines were rushed, leading to the Invasion PPV. The PPV itself drew a phenomenal buy rate (770,000) but that was it for the storyline. By that year's Survivor Series, it was gone. Vince had to prove that his company was best, and that he did - but by flushing a potential of millions of dollars down the drain. It seems that this leopard really can't change its spots.