WWE: 10 Stars Accused Of Not Paying Their Dues

By Forrest Gabitsch /

Wrestling fans love to complain; in our own socially maladjusted way, we're often a lot like fans of actual sports, in our own, socially maladjusted way. Many are armchair grapplers with a million things to say about the product,but only the internet to listen, where online forums, social network feeds, and blog posts abound with homespun wisdom on everything from which Diva we wish we could approach publicly to whether or not the Oklahoma character was just misunderstood. It's a kind of social schizophrenia: we have an audience, even if it is only ourselves. We're kind of like our angry grandfathers in a way, except our telescreens yell back at us. Among the most popular topics is whether or not a given wrestler deserves a spot. Over the years, the industry has seen plenty of stars accused of not paying their dues, not only by so-called "smart" marks, but by journalists and even fellow wrestlers. Here are ten who, fairly or otherwise, have been so judged - some deserve some defence, while others are less easy to back up, but at the end of the day, only wrestlers are really in a position suitable for judging the merits of their peers...

10. David Arquette

Wrestling promotions seek out publicity wherever they can, which is a tradition that predates the WrestleMania model of involving celebrities in the main event. Even before Liberace wrestled Bam Bam Bigelow (that happened, right?), boxers like Jack Dempsey and Muhammad Ali were seen in wrestling rings, bringing with them an air of legitimacy. This pandering for mainstream attention is often met with rolled eyes and shaken heads from a small, easily-irritated portion of the Monday night faithful. What kind of audience are they trying to attract by putting some creature named Snooki in the ring? Why would any wrestling fan want to see a football star in the main event? Most frustrating of all, though, what kind of dope puts the World Heavyweight Championship on the guy from the long distance commercials? Arquette's reign was meant to be a joke, but even he knew that the World Heavyweight Championship, a belt that had graced the waists of legends like Harley Race, Dusty Rhodes and Ric Flair, shouldn't have been treated like a prop in a Carrot Top routine. Keep in mind, though, that Arquette reportedly donated his WCW earnings to Melanie Pillman, widow of the late Brian Pillman, so though he may not have paid his dues as a wrestler, but he did the right thing in the long run.

9. Randy Orton

Randy Orton has faced the double-edged sword of early success like few others, but the odd thing is that he may have fit in better during an earlier time; before gossiping about wrestling became as ubiquitous as the sport itself, being a third-generation wrestler and a member of a stable like Evolution would have been seen as a good thing. Back then, though, a wrestler wouldn't have become World Champion as quickly as Orton did - that's what the Intercontinental and U. S. titles were for. Orton's ring work has improved, personality-wise, though, he's still the equivalent of the glam metal bands that went grunge in the late nineties. His gimmicks, from the legend killer to the world's least-interesting schizophrenic, have done little to excite longtime fans. WWE knows this, and in a meta-fictional twist even a literature professor could love, has aligned Orton, on-screen, with his actual backstage benefactors, the Authority. Orton was the youngest World Champion in wrestling history. The scariest thing about that is that records are meant to be broken, and one day, someone at WWE will have the bright idea of putting the strap on an eighth grader. Get ready for the G-Era.

8. Batista

Power wrestlers make great heels, but can occasionally become fan favourites. The problem with pushing monsters as babyfaces is that it only works when they're facing bigger monsters, the most obvious example being Hulk Hogan vs. Andre the Giant. Dave Batista is a monster, no doubt, and he's also been pushed as a babyface plenty of times, including at the beginning of his recent return. In true monster fashion, he piqued the interest of fans for a few weeks, then started getting boos, right around the time that he won the Royal Rumble. Like Orton, Batista suffers from two huge problems: his performances are dull, and he reminds us of ten years ago, when the WWE really sucked. Batista had an MMA career that earned him a single win - so there you go: one due - but as a wrestler the Animal still has to prove he's more than just another huge dude with power moves. His current contract looks long-term, so hopefully he can try something different soon.

7. The Ultimate Warrior

The Ultimate Warrior had a quick push to the top of the WWF, which could make some see him as the prototype of Batista and Orton. He looked every bit as impressive, in a Reagan-era, "Just Say No" fashion, and his entrance may be the best in wrestling history, from having the most metal theme of the eighties to the fastest trip to the ring. His move-set, however, was limited to haymakers, clotheslines, and a big splash at the end. The idea of a fast-moving power wrestler may have sounded like a good idea on paper, but in practice, the Warrior lacked focus. His microphone work was equally perplexing, full of stream-of-consciousness rants about fuelling rocketships, ritual suicide by lawnmower, and sharing carbon dioxide with someone named Ho Kogan. In retrospect, the Warrior was as weird as the eighties itself. If you were there, though, you could feel it, dude. Stories about Warrior's unprofessional attitude abound: his refusal to budge on contractual demands ultimately led to his holding Vince McMahon up for more money at Summerslam 91. The most damning tale €“ and fans will really hope it isn't true €“ was his telling an enthusiastic fan that the a championship belt was "just more f-cking luggage." The Ultimate Warrior will enter the WWE Hall Of Fame this year, a well-deserved honour for one of the greatest stars of his era. He may not be the nicest guy in the world, but you probably wouldn't be either if a multi-billion dollar corporation's success rested on whether or not fans liked you. That, plus having space aliens in your head, would probably drive you to wear neon streamers and face-paint, too.

6. Lex Luger

Lex Luger spent a year in NWA Florida before his WCW debut in 1987; he was quickly spotlighted in an angle with the Four Horsemen, then won the United States Championship a few months later. Like the Ultimate Warrior, Luger would soon rise in the ranks, becoming WCW's champion, after which he feuded with Simmons and held on to the title, but disagreements with WCW brass led to Luger's refusal to appear for the latter months of his contract. He eventually lost the title to Sting, then joined the WWF. After a motorcycle accident, Luger bounced back as the Narcissist in 1993, and when Hulk Hogan left for WCW, Luger became the babyface All-American. His main event push could have begun here, but the WWF was already putting its weight behind Bret "The Hitman" Hart, and Luger never became a champion in the WWF, though you always had this feeling that he would. He was certainly on television enough. Luger's rise to megastar status happened even more quickly than the Ultimate Warrior's, so it's arguable that he didn't quite pay his dues, especially when compared to other top stars of his era. Since his debut, though, he's made himself a part of the wrestling landscape. He's not a Sting or a Hogan, but he never really had to be.

5. The Rock

"Ro-cky sucks! Ro-cky sucks!" The Attitude Era's most ubiquitous catch phrase came not from the human T-shirt factory himself, but from legions of unimpressed fans. In a cycle that would become even more familiar during the PG Era, Dwayne Johnson, debuting as the babyface Rocky Maivia, was met with a collective yawn. Early accusations of an easy ride weren't without some merit. Johnson was coming off a short run in the Canadian Football League before his father, Rocky Johnson, reluctantly began to train him to become a wrestler. WWE stalwart Pat Patterson soon took over from there, and young Johnson had a brief run in the USWA before his WWF debut in 1996. The WWF did their damnedest to push Rocky Maivia, but it wasn't until he adopted the cocky, brash persona of The Rock that the fans began to bite. Like Ric Flair, Scott Hall, and Steve Austin before him, The Rock proved that bad guys were more fun to watch, and maybe he didn't quite pay his dues before his first Intercontinental Championship reign, but his work since then has given WWE some of its best times, something even the smartest mark must acknowledge.

4. Brock Lesnar

Brock Lesnar was known far and wide as the real deal, but then came Wrestlemania XX. The Madison Square Garden crowd had learned that Lesnar would be leaving for the NFL, and booed and jeered for the entirety of the match. (To be fair, they were also booing his opponent, Bill Goldberg, for similar reasons.) The match went on, but it was easy to see how the crowd's indifference was leading to similar feelings from Lesnar. Lesnar's football career came and went quickly, but his MMA days are a whole other story. He lost his first UFC bout to Frank Mir, but quickly came back with wins over Mir, Randy Couture, and Heath Herring. A battle with diverticulitis and a loss to Alistair Overeem forced Lesnar to quit MMA, but his days in the ring were far from over. Lesnar's WWE return had an immediate impact, with an attack on John Cena at the end of Monday Night Raw. It was 2012, ten years after Lesnar's debut, and he had once again become the talk of the wrestling world. He may not be much of an entertainer, but he's still a hell of a wrestler.

3. John Cena

Remember the brand extension? That was that weird experiment when WWE pretended that Raw and Smackdown were separate products: it was WWE's way of pretending that there was still competition between wrestling promotions, long after its purchase of WCW. The funny thing is, it kind of worked. Just ask John Cena, who had bounced between the two shows for several years, becoming United States Champion and adopting a hip-hop gimmick in the process. When he was drafted back to Raw in 2005, he was brought in to face Attitude Era heels like Kurt Angle and Triple-H, and was booed mercilessly for his efforts. Night after night, a wrestler who had been with the company for three years was treated by fans like he was a lucky jobber. Cena has stayed with WWE for twelve years, most of them as its top star, recently elevating younger talents like CM Punk, Daniel Bryan, and Bray Wyatt into top stars. He's also delivered more Make-A-Wish Foundation requests than any other celebrity (no matter what Justin Bieber says).

2. Goldberg

Goldberg was the best thing WCW had going for them at the time. With increased competition from the WWF and its breakout star, "Stone Cold" Steve Austin, WCW was willing to catch lightning wherever it could. Goldberg became Nitro's only new guy who ever got a solid push. Like John Cena a few years later, he soon faced a backlash. There were rumours that his undefeated streak numbers had been inflated, as if such a thing were unheard of in a fake sport. After WCW was bought by the WWF, Goldberg attempted a comeback, resulting in the aforementioned sad affair at Wrestlemania XX, his career ending with a stunner from special guest referee Austin. It was yet another dig at WCW, long after the company's death. Goldberg had no indie work or even an NWA territory in which to develop his craft. Had he paid his dues the way someone like Austin had, he probably would have had a more lasting impact on the industry.

1. Mr. T

Mr. T is credited with helping bring Wrestlemania, and wrestling in general, to a broader audience, which is precisely why the WWE is honouring him this year by putting him in the Hall of Fame. Fans seem to remember him fondly, but his in-ring contemporaries, however, feel otherwise. "Rowdy" Roddy Piper has been T's most vocal detractor, with the barbs beginning in 1985, making their real life feud one of the longest in wrestling history. Piper's accusation €“ that T was just an actor, and never paid his dues as a wrestler like the other boys had €“ has cast a shadow over the otherwise grand achievement that was the first Wrestlemania. By the end of their boxing match a year later, fans were chanting Piper's name. It was an Austin 3:16 moment about ten years early. Mr. T may not have paid his work with the WWF helped bring wrestling to the masses, a feat far more impressive than any TV or movie career. He wasn't a wrestler, but he's an indispensable part of the sport's history. Which other WWE stars deserve to be included on this list? Share your own picks below in the comments thread.